Bret Hawk
Senator (1k+ posts)
Re: Last recorded Dua of Dr. Israr
Bhai Hans I usually admire your sense of objectivity, factual argumentation coated with the layers of brevity and sensibility. But I think by terming the great Dr Israr as clown you’ve seriously undermined your objective mindset and I’ve taken a great offense by that repulsive remark of yours. Brother believe me when it comes to difference of opinion despite of immense respect for Dr Israr Marhoom o Maghfoor, I do had some differences as well on some of his thoughts and views in the past (which I do hold some of them till now) and its normal for one to have that margin of liberty to formulate a dissenting and differing opinion on a given subject matter.
In the last section of your post, which I’ve highlighted as well, if I’m not wrong in decoding your hidden message in those lines is that because of his offensive and blunt reasoning against the criminals of Almighty from the House of Israel which in return has resulted (In line with the hard-line rhetoric of many other Muslim clerics of current uni-polar world) in the ruthless backlash from them over the decades against the Muslim states scattered and disunited around the world, who (Israelis) unfortunately also hold the reins of extreme power and influence in Western Europe and Northern American territories in current scenario. Correct me if I’m wrong to interpret this reasoning of yours.
As far as this misconception of declaring himself as a Khalifa of his Caliphate movement and organizations in Pakistan is concerned then I think it’s totally baseless and misconstrued misconception formed by you in this regard as he always maintained himself during his lifespan that he was nothing more than an ordinary worker for the establishment of a Khilafat system in Pakistan in perfect reflection and footings of a perfectly constituted Caliphate (Divine Vice-regency) of the rightly guided first four companions of the great Prophet pbuh after his demise from this world in 632 C.E.
Bhai Hans I usually admire your sense of objectivity, factual argumentation coated with the layers of brevity and sensibility. But I think by terming the great Dr Israr as clown you’ve seriously undermined your objective mindset and I’ve taken a great offense by that repulsive remark of yours. Brother believe me when it comes to difference of opinion despite of immense respect for Dr Israr Marhoom o Maghfoor, I do had some differences as well on some of his thoughts and views in the past (which I do hold some of them till now) and its normal for one to have that margin of liberty to formulate a dissenting and differing opinion on a given subject matter.
In the last section of your post, which I’ve highlighted as well, if I’m not wrong in decoding your hidden message in those lines is that because of his offensive and blunt reasoning against the criminals of Almighty from the House of Israel which in return has resulted (In line with the hard-line rhetoric of many other Muslim clerics of current uni-polar world) in the ruthless backlash from them over the decades against the Muslim states scattered and disunited around the world, who (Israelis) unfortunately also hold the reins of extreme power and influence in Western Europe and Northern American territories in current scenario. Correct me if I’m wrong to interpret this reasoning of yours.
As far as this misconception of declaring himself as a Khalifa of his Caliphate movement and organizations in Pakistan is concerned then I think it’s totally baseless and misconstrued misconception formed by you in this regard as he always maintained himself during his lifespan that he was nothing more than an ordinary worker for the establishment of a Khilafat system in Pakistan in perfect reflection and footings of a perfectly constituted Caliphate (Divine Vice-regency) of the rightly guided first four companions of the great Prophet pbuh after his demise from this world in 632 C.E.
Last edited:
