Is Two Nation Theory valid today?

SINGH KING

Politcal Worker (100+ posts)
zahil hamid has a great impact on minds of some of people of your country and they are living in 15th cebtury and thinking like they will attack india and kill or make hindus , sikhs, christa slave and rule all over the place. The reason you have so many suicide bombers coz u guys can brain washed so quickly but anyways funny post by farnaakhan



Welcome brother. Okay, Pakistan conquered India. Then what? Will you be happy? Next elections Rahul Gandhi will be PM. Then you will do what? Another Pakistan movement.
 

SINGH KING

Politcal Worker (100+ posts)
how you can impose pakistans constitution on 1 billion hindus , sikhs and christs . you are free to think\imagine whatever U want , but its always better to think realistically.vase Dil behlane ke liye Galib yh khyahal acha hai


According to constitution of Pakistan, non-muslim cannot be PM or President!
 

shaheedchoudry

Minister (2k+ posts)
zahil hamid has a great impact on minds of some of people of your country and they are living in 15th cebtury and thinking like they will attack india and kill or make hindus , sikhs, christa slave and rule all over the place. The reason you have so many suicide bombers coz u guys can brain washed so quickly but anyways funny post by farnaakhan
Suicide bombers are brainwashed by non state actors funded by RAW.
 

SINGH KING

Politcal Worker (100+ posts)
So basically you are saying k some of u pakistans people are taking money from RAW US nd from India and killed 35000 people of ur country and killing so many more . So paise ke liye aap kuch vi kar sakte ho




Suicide bombers are brainwashed by non state actors funded by RAW.
 

shaheedchoudry

Minister (2k+ posts)
So basically you are saying k some of u pakistans people are taking money from RAW US nd from India and killed 35000 people of ur country and killing so many more . So paise ke liye aap kuch vi kar sakte ho
Again you r trying be be over smart and not paying attention to the issue. Yes there are some Pakistanis also but many of them are from middle east "jihadists" and some r hindu gurkhas pretending to be muslims. Our army has killed few and checked their under and guess what, they were not circumcised but they were pretending to be muslims.
 

SaadKnight

Senator (1k+ posts)
It is because people did not follow the religion.[/QUOTE

Do you think in Pakistan the people are following religion now ? If not will something similar to what happened 40 years back expected now to prove Two nation theory again?
Its because of such people (that are following religion sincerely in any capacity) that Pakistan still survives. People are coming back to religion, slowly.
But the problem is that the majority wants to see them on TV, and believe that there is religion in Pakistan. People that follow religion do not come on TV very often here. So the TV only shows secular jahalat and fascism, because of which Fools think that Pakistan will divide and the two nation theory will not have any meaning.


But still it is not your fault, may be you want to see a divided Pakistan (but because I do not know your true intentions), I will not put any label on you.
 
Last edited:

Scorpion

Banned
Its not the Question weather two nation theory is valid or not . . . . It has left out to be the only medicine for this ill nation . . . .

You drop this medicine and you loose this Pakistan . . . .
 

chandbibi

Minister (2k+ posts)
The two nation theory or three nation nation theory as it must be called today is valid because the sub-continent stays divided on the basis of religious ideology. It is irrelevant today in the Indian context, because India still has a large muslim population. In Pakistan the two nation theory created an intellectual and adminstrative vacuum, caused by the mass exodus of hindus and sikhs. In addition Pakistan lost its tolerant society. Also Pakistan gained a lot of radical tribal population from its western borders. In 64 years democracy could not take roots in pakistan, unlike its neighbour India. Lack of leadership , wrong policies and intolerance failed to make the two nation theory a success in Pakistan. Yes it exists on paper, but it has lost its meaning. Two nation theory is a great concept, but it should not have come in the way of the development of Pakistan. Losing its human capital has hurt pakistan a lot. What is important for the future and well being of pakistanis is to understand that a well balanced mix of people is required for good governance. That way the fringe groups can be kept under control and the state can go about its business. For this to succeed you have to become secular in your outlook. And this has nothing to do with being a theocracy. Turkey is a fine e.g. Probably same was Jinnah's vision for Pakistan.
 

Mughal1

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
Is two nation theory valid? It is valid or not can only be discussed if we first of all understand what two nation theory is as was explained by its proponents. The two nation theory was thought of, proposed and used by some indian muslims to get a piece of land under muslim jurisdiction so that the quranic rule of law could be implemented in there in order to make it as an exemplary state for the world to see, so that mankind could see and realise what islam and muslims were all about as regard wider humanity.

Two nation theory was not about creating a piece of land to accommodate muslims only. It is for this reason no major indian leader muslim or nonmuslim ever told any people to migrate rather they were told to stay put.

Whatever bloodshed resulted was either due to misunderstanding by people themselves or was caused by misinformation and disinformation amongst communities by the elements that could benefit from such chaos. This in no way could be started by muslims in india because they were a minority in india and in places wherein they lived. Likewise it could not be started by nonmuslims on pakistan side of the border because here nonmuslims were a minority in places wherein they lived.

So creation of pakistan was not about causing animosity between hindus and muslims nor about taking any land from india because the land muslims got for their jurisdiction was the land on which muslims were already living.

The only and only reason for which creation of pakistan was deemed necessary was just a piece of land for muslims to implement islam as it was understood by its founder in order to try and get humanity out of its problems.

http://www.parwez.tv/dowquominazaria.html


The do qomi nazriya had four phases a)get land b)implement islam c)make progress and prosper to become an exemplary country in the world and d)to invite other countries to do the same ie get rid of ignorance, poverty and disease on one hand and become progressive and prosper.

The first phase succeeded and they got pakistan but then ruling elite and mullas took over and here we are after breaking up of half of pakistan. Breaking up is still not a big issue if we could show our bangla deshi brothers by example how to progress and prosper by means of proper islam. Once we both implement islam the 2nd phase of ideology would be complete and then the 3rd phase is working hard for putting the country very high on the world map. After that people would be able to see what we have by following divine rule of law so they may even follow suit all by themselves without our invitation for their own good. After all, all nations follow those who do something that makes them worthy and great.

79 Surah an Nazi'at Ayah 01 To 05
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4TqPVfiWabw&feature=related

79 Surah an Nazi'at Ayah 06 To 26
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hheis2gHcSk&feature=related
 

Doctorplato

Councller (250+ posts)
two nation theory was invalid from the first day. Islam is a concept beyond boundaries. Two nation theory was a british conspiracy to divide india! And they suceeded. The most important casuality in this divide was islam and the most harmed people, the muslims of the sub-continent.
 

only_truths

Minister (2k+ posts)
two nation theory was invalid from the first day. Islam is a concept beyond boundaries. Two nation theory was a british conspiracy to divide india! And they suceeded. The most important casuality in this divide was islam and the most harmed people, the muslims of the sub-continent.

One correction not "the muslims of the sub-continent" but the poor of this sub-continent (of every religion) who have to go through mass migration in all directions.
 

az.ay

Politcal Worker (100+ posts)
To this day, the average Muslims haven't been accepted by the Hindu majority. They are a separate nation beyond doubt.

This Eid Day: Muslim man killed by Hindu mob

Hyderabad_Indian_protesters_10636.jpg


One Muslim man was killed and 10 others were injured during a communal clash in Uttar Pradeshs Kaushambhi district Wednesday, police said.


Violence erupted after Hindus and Muslims in Kokhraj area had an argument over the playing of a loudspeaker.
After hurling abuses at each other, members of the two communities started clashing with stones and sticks, Additional Superintendent of Police M.P. Verma told IANS on telephone from Kaushambhi, some 250 km from Lucknow.

A 42-year-old man Chand Miyan died in the clash, while 10 people from both communities were injured.
No arrests have so far been made in the incident.
Two Circles
 

FaraanKhan

Politcal Worker (100+ posts)
how you can impose pakistans constitution on 1 billion hindus , sikhs and christs . you are free to think\imagine whatever U want , but its always better to think realistically.vase Dil behlane ke liye Galib yh khyahal acha hai
dude! This is the truth, and you will soon face it!