Citizen X
President (40k+ posts)
The zair zabbar was introduced later as Islam spread to non Arab lands and to make it easier for the non Arabs to read. Just like when writing urdu we don't always dot our i's and cross our T's but the reader understandsThe problem with Ghamdi interpretation and other Quranists is that we need sources other than the Quran to interpret what that Quran says. Try reading the first few chapters of the Quran and come back and tell me what you understand.
Even Quran has been changing over time, there are atleast 20 different versions of the Quran. Atleast 7 different ones today that have 10s of millions of people reading each version. The zair zabar harka'at in Quran were invented 100 years after Quran was written. So which Quran are you talking about and how do you know its the real divine one and not the others?
Another issue is that its not just hadith that have messed up things like genocide of Banu Qurayza, Quran also has its own messed up stories of Jins farting and stars are missiles being fired across the sky.
There are still teachers who teach that makki Arabic the one without the zair zabbars, you can even find classes online, so it really isn't a big deal.
As for your other question here is a detailed reply, if you ever get time watch it.
CONVERSING ISLAM - with Hamza Ali Abbasi
Enjoy the videos and music you love, upload original content, and share it all with friends, family, and the world on YouTube.
www.youtube.com