Dr Imran Shah Incident - The other side of the story

[Anonymous Paki]

https://www.facebook.com/video.php?v=475284359604348

 

[Nightcrawl]

Oh

 

[Nightcrawl]

He should upload on Twitter

 

[Mubashir120]

https://www.facebook.com/video.php?v=1972212979735502

 

[c'estmoi]

Whatever....even if I believe you, there is no justification of a law maker physically assaulting that person. Even in western countries, you are allowed to swear back if someone swears at you but you CANNOT start beating that person up!

 

[Anonymous Paki]

Whatever....even if I believe you, there is no justification of a law maker physically assaulting that person. Even in western countries, you are allowed to swear back if someone swears at you but you CANNOT start beating that person up!

indeed there isn't
thats why he apologized

 

[ImranD]

Imran shah k sath bahut hui hey, mujhey tu ab bechara lagna shuru ho gia hey.

 

[Anonymous Paki]

inshallah :heart

 

[Ahmad2015]

Its clear that this poor guy is forced to say this. No matter what, you can not take the law in your hands. You need to go.

 

[c'estmoi]

indeed there isn't
thats why he apologized

Nope. This is a criminal offense. If we want rule of law, then it should be dealt with accordingly. Remember we are talking about a Law Maker not an ordinary person. Since the police is useless, there should be some action taken against him by the party. Letting this get away with an 'apology' is a very very bad precedent that other will surely wont mind following. Also, remember this guy had no remorse and was putting the blame on the victim in his video message. He only apologized because of social media pressure and show cause notice.

 

[c'estmoi]

Do you think a mpa just went out of his way to get out of his car and beat up some random person for no reason at all?.....I don't think this guy is forced or not but the incident story is probably true.

Yes, the story is probably true and what this MPA should have done was to defuse the situation and call the police if there was a criminal offense by either one of the other guys. Instead, he decided to test his newly gained power.

 

[Citizen X]

He is not the law and he has no right to physically assault someone, regardless of what the other person was saying.

 

[c'estmoi]

If the so called victim doesn't want to pursue the issue.Who are we to do so?......

Actually, he does not have to. The state can do so in these type of cases. Sindh police is saying the same thing. They are 'reviewing' the case.

 

[Citizen X]

If the so called victim doesn't want to pursue the issue.Who are we to do so?......

In such cases Police themselves become the "mudai" or complainant and file an FIR but Sindh Police is useless that won't happen
So I suggested at the very least at least party disciplinary action from the Party in the other thread and people lost their fekin' minds over it.

 

[Anonymous Paki]

Nope. This is a criminal offense. If we want rule of law, then it should be dealt with accordingly. Remember we are talking about a Law Maker not an ordinary person. Since the police is useless, there should be some action taken against him by the party. Letting this get away with an 'apology' is a very very bad precedent that other will surely wont mind following. Also, remember this guy had no remorse and was putting the blame on the victim in his video message. He only apologized because of social media pressure and show cause notice.

Are you retarded?
what country do you live in?
even in west if two parties agree to defuse the situation themselves then the law considers the matter resolved
stop speaking from your ass and making shit up

 

[c'estmoi]

Are you retarded?
what country do you live in?
even in west if two parties agree to defuse the situation themselves then the law considers the matter resolved
stop speaking from your ass and make shit up

I can abuse you better than you can. So watch your language. You have a habit of speaking like this in most of your posts. You should come out of whatever hole you live in. Dont worry about me. I know what I'm talking about.

 

[Anonymous Paki]

I can abuse you better than you can. So watch your language. You have a habit of speaking like this in most of your posts. You should come out of whatever hole you live in. Dont worry about me. I know what I'm talking about.

ok explain, what you are talking about.
you have no clue what you are saying, stop trying to be an intellect. thats all im saying

 

[Adeel]

I have to agree with Anonymous Paki above
I don't know what law you guys are trying to enforce when both parties consider the matter resolved.
If the guy decides to file charges then it is a different matter

 

[kakamuna420]

'zafar' MOLANA us ko na jāniyegā vo ho kaisā hī sāhab-e-fahm-o-zakā
jise aish meñ BARFI na mili jise taish meñ SAMOSA na mila

 

[c'estmoi]

ok explain, what you are talking about.
you have no clue what you are saying, stop trying to be an intellect. thats all im saying

You obviously have no knowledge of the law. Even if the victim decides not to press charges, the state can still do so in its own 'mudiyat'. This is what happens in western countries. Sindh police is useless so it wont happen.