Was Jinnah Wrong on the Language Issue?

[aazaad]

I went through all your article as you can see for yourself. British left but the policy of divide and rule remained. Poor, illiterate men always exploited some times in the name of religion , some times in the name of language and some times in the name of caste and creed. It goes back to the leaders of those days. Instead they could ask from central government for better educational system, good governance, better law and order but instead they looking for language so that they could stay in power. Not for the betterment of their fellow muslims but the lust of power. What difference it made to Khyber Pakhtoon Khwah, is the mere labour man son been able to go to school, is the loan of that Widow who lives behind the Jama Masjid Peshawar would not have to pay her loan. Now the jokers are making a new Province in the name of changing lives of poor people or their Castles. No one know.

 

[Aliza]

If i am a father having five sons, Two of them speaks Urdu the other two also understand urdu, but one does not understand urdu. And i want them to be brothers with a strong relationship, unity, harmony and brotherhood and obviously communication does matter for each of them to achieve all this. But the fifth one instead of following the other fours chose to leave. Is it the wise decision for the fifth one? A sane mind would say No way.. Well why don't people look on this side of the picture that Jinnah Rehmatullah Alaeyh wanted this nation to be one! The purpose was to unite them all so they can face the challenges together as we all know unity is the strength but the one Bengali boy was not sane enough. Just imagine if Bangladesh was still part of Pakistan with nukes with them would anyone dare? especially India! Would there be Kashmir issue anymore if India had Pakistan on both of her side with Nukes?
Imaan, Ittehad , Tanzeem this is what Quaid said all his life and if bengalis were so loyal to this motto or respected their leader Quaid then the case would be different. Infact they should be considered traitors who betrayed their leader.
That's all.

Kuch bhi kerlein iss quom ko aisa hi hona tha ab deikhye na iss sawaal ko uthanay ka mutlab hi kia hey??? Pakistan aik mulk hay, uski aik language hay, aur uskay soboon mein rehnay walay log upni upni sobai zubanay boltay hein, humari official lanuage Urdu aur English hi hay! Waisay masala punjaab mein kissi ko hona tu nahein chahye hay kionke jahaan ka Iqbal itna bulund ho wahan urdu ke sub hi chahanay walay hein aur uss bulund Iqbal ke khawaab ka hi ye nateeja mein mulk bana tha, uss bulund IQBAL ki urdu zubaan se chahat ka undaza lagein ke sari dunya mein unki urdu shairi mushoor hay.... Punjabi aik boli hay, magar urdu aik zuban hay...masala ye hay kia humko ye aiteraaz hey ke urdu zuban official honay ki waja se aaj humari qoum iss haal ko pohnchi hay???
Ya aaj sirf aapko ye ahsaas hua ke iss baap ke paanch beitay thay? Bengalis betrayed then as RAJA DAHIR & today as Shaikh Mujeeb-ur-Rehman....or anyone else like Shabnam & Robin Ghosh Rona Laila! Ye jo thread dalnay waley sahib hein inko bhi issi qism ka naam milna chahye ab log naey naey issues buna ker latnay lagay hein upnay nam ke liye...For me as I said earlier in other threads these kind of people are all Munafiq, Traitors of Pakistan, simply ignore them...WHY raise this question at this critical moments of the country?:angry_smile:(thumbsdown)(yapping):doh::crazy:

 

[Aliza]

oh bhai quiad e azam ka peecha choro . unhain gaey hoay 65 saal ho gaey . yeh batao hum logo nay kitna teer mara.

Teer pehlay nahi mara tha abb marein gay munafiqat ka bazaar garam kerkay!:angry_smile:
Arrey hum tu Mulk aur Quom ko aik honay ke paigham ko aam kerna chahtay hein aur ye sholoon ko hawa deinay ka kaam ker rahay hein?:angry_smile:
:doh::doh::doh::doh::doh::doh::doh::doh::doh::doh::doh:

 

[samy99]

It would be better that if Bangali and Urdu both should be official languages . It could be Bi-lingual, nothing wrong with it.

 

[Aliza]

well the outcome does suggest so....but perhaps if we were a bit more tolerant and understanding in the following years, we would have been a bit better off..

Huma behen kuch nahein hona tha sirf humko zaroorat iss baat ki thi aur ab tu shadeed hay ke hum aik quom ho ker ITTEHAAD aur YAQEEN-E-MUHKAM ka daman haath se na chorein, jabke humein bakhoobi undaza ho raha hey ke hum bikhar gaey hein aur humein phir se ikhatta hona hey like "ALL FOR ONE & ONE FOR ALL" theory per amal kerna paraiga!!! Sirf issi mein humari Quom o Mulk ki azadi berqarar rehe gi.(not listening) ignore these kind of sharr!

 

[Aliza]

There should be no official language in a big country . Hindi is not Indian national language too !!

Let state decide their language , just follow english!!

That w as the best thing happened to India :) we sucked all jobs from usa,europe!!:lol::lol::lol:

(clap):lol:
Really you are so right! Hum bhi India ki terhan upna zamir beich ker unkay qadam choomtay tu bahut taraqi ker chukay hotay! Jaisa mein yahan aur Gulf mein upni ankhon se deikh chuki hoon! :angry_smile::angry_smile::lol::lol::lol::lol:(clap)(clap)(clap)(clap)(clap)(clap)(clap)(clap)(clap)(clap)

 

[nuzhatghazali]

اگر اردو کو قومی زبان نہ بناتے تو پھر بنگالی زبان کو قومی زبان بنانا تھا کیونکے اکثریت تو بنگالیوں کی ہی تھی تیسرا نمبر پھر انگریزی کا اتا ہے .ویسے بہتر تو یہ ہی تھا کہ ہندوں کی ہی غلامی کرتے اور ہندی سیکھتے اور ان ہی کے ملک میں رہتے

 

[nuzhatghazali]

Kuch bhi kerlein iss quom ko aisa hi hona tha ab deikhye na iss sawaal ko uthanay ka mutlab hi kia hey??? Pakistan aik mulk hay, uski aik language hay, aur uskay soboon mein rehnay walay log upni upni sobai zubanay boltay hein, humari official lanuage Urdu aur English hi hay! Waisay masala punjaab mein kissi ko hona tu nahein chahye hay kionke jahaan ka Iqbal itna bulund ho wahan urdu ke sub hi chahanay walay hein aur uss bulund Iqbal ke khawaab ka hi ye nateeja mein mulk bana tha, uss bulund IQBAL ki urdu zubaan se chahat ka undaza lagein ke sari dunya mein unki urdu shairi mushoor hay.... Punjabi aik boli hay, magar urdu aik zuban hay...masala ye hay kia humko ye aiteraaz hey ke urdu zuban official honay ki waja se aaj humari qoum iss haal ko pohnchi hay???
Ya aaj sirf aapko ye ahsaas hua ke iss baap ke paanch beitay thay? Bengalis betrayed then as RAJA DAHIR & today as Shaikh Mujeeb-ur-Rehman....or anyone else like Shabnam & Robin Ghosh Rona Laila! Ye jo thread dalnay waley sahib hein inko bhi issi qism ka naam milna chahye ab log naey naey issues buna ker latnay lagay hein upnay nam ke liye...For me as I said earlier in other threads these kind of people are all Munafiq, Traitors of Pakistan, simply ignore them...WHY raise this question at this critical moments of the country?:angry_smile:(thumbsdown)(yapping):doh::crazy:

is sawal keh uthanay ka matlab yeh hay keh qaid-e-azam ko her trh say tanqeed ka nishana bnaya jayay(omg)

 

[Humi]

اگر اردو کو قومی زبان نہ بناتے تو پھر بنگالی زبان کو قومی زبان بنانا تھا کیونکے اکثریت تو بنگالیوں کی ہی تھی تیسرا نمبر پھر انگریزی کا اتا ہے .ویسے بہتر تو یہ ہی تھا کہ ہندوں کی ہی غلامی کرتے اور ہندی سیکھتے اور ان ہی کے ملک میں رہتے

I guess Arabic could have been an option as well...or perhaps majority of us forgot it while we were living in the subcontinent?

 

[indigo]

its called two nation theory.... our languages are different, our culture is different, our borders are different, our social class is difference, our resources are different.... only thing is same is religion.... if that makes a same nation than ... tare zameen par

 

[nuzhatghazali]

I guess Arabic could have been an option as well...or perhaps majority of us forgot it while we were living in the subcontinent?

As a muslim it could be considered to learn arabic , but to adopt as national language no way ..... actually urdu and hindi were the same language only different in writing , that is why urdu got prevalent over other languages. till today it is widely spoken in subcontinent.

 

[Omrkhan]

Quaid was not wrong in making URDU as National language. Since it was allowed to use Bengali language officially.And as for all those racists out there Urdu is now much better spoken by Punjabis than original Urdu speakers.

 

[aneeskhan]

Urdu is the best gift to Asians.
the most common language for communications,All overseas Bengalis speak Urdu very well.
You are any part of Asia it,s the best language to communicate.
In Haram 2nd language is Urdu,you will delight to read "Nahana Mana Hai"in Urdu .
Kiyon Urdu Se Dushmani Karte Ho yaroo,Yeah woh Khoobsoorat Zaban Hai Jo Sab Ko Qareeb Lati Hai.

 

[wahid77]

What you did for own country.

 

[Altaf Lutfi]

True but definitely some one authority on the matter has right for the final say, not a commoner like me. I believe it was theoretically correct decision, given the type of state Quaid had envisioned. Practical application of it in Bengal must had been questionable because Bengali shared values and basics with Hindi and languages in South like Marathi, Tamil, Malayalm or Telgu. Urdu must had been a remote shot.

Interestingly, Swiss example was not taken into consideration where 4 languages go simultaneously as official, because of Swiss demography.

 

[Altaf Lutfi]

As a muslim it could be considered to learn arabic , but to adopt as national language no way ..... actually urdu and hindi were the same language only different in writing , that is why urdu got prevalent over other languages. till today it is widely spoken in subcontinent.

Please correct your notion. Hindi and Urdu are two different languages. Hindi has roots in Sanskrit and has evolved in thousands of years, Urdu is influenced by Turkish, Persian and Arabic for most part and it is relatively new language.. What Indians speak and we understand is Urdu, mixed with Hindi words. Pure Hindi language is not heard in public so often. A common Pakistan easily adopts local languages like Sindhi, Pushto, Balochi or Punjabi but learning Telgu, Tamil or Malayalam is next to impossible only because these Indian local languages are based on Sanskrit values,too.

 

[Umer Baloch]

He shouldn't have declared Urdu as official language. That was the first step leading to discrimination with Bengalis and it ended up as separate nation.