Shame on PTI - Peshawar Bus Rapid Transit project likely to miss March 23 deadline too

Walter

Senator (1k+ posts)
Shame on PTI - This project is already 11 months delayed and now it will be delayed further.


PESHAWAR: The procedural technicalities and frequent design changes are likely to push the completion of the Pakistan Tehreek-i-Insaf government’s flagship Peshawar Bus Rapid Transit project beyond the new deadline, officials claim.

The Peshawar Development Authority, the executing agency, has set March 23 as the new deadline for the launch of the multi-billion rupees bus service, which has been delayed by 11 months.

Work on the BRT has been suspended at six locations due to the procedural technicalities and other hurdles.

Officials blame delay in start of bus service on technicalities, frequent design changes​
According to the original plan, the BRT buses were to ply the track in May 2018.

The government changed the deadline for the project’s completion many times.

The frequent changes to the BRT design has escalated the project’s cost from Rs49 billion to Rs69 billion. The Asian Development Bank is financing the project.

The PDA officials insisted that the meeting of the new deadline greatly depended on two state entities i.e.

Wapda and Pakistan Railways, which were to lay new transmission line on Sonehri Masjid Road in cantonment areas and issue no objection certificate for the installation of heavy girders to complete elevated track over the cantonment railway station, respectively.

A relevant official told Dawn that work on BRT track on the Sonehri Masjid Road had been suspended for four months due to the delay in the shifting of the existing power cables.

He said the power lines passed over the elevated portion of the BRT track and the construction won’t resume until the Wapda relocated them.

“Delay in the removal of electricity lines has delayed civil work for more than three months. The PDA may not meet the new deadline if the Wapda does not finish its work immediately,” he said, adding that the authority had scheduled to start work on Wednesday.

The official said the PDA had been waiting for the Pakistan Railways’ NoC for the installation of girders over the cantonment station to complete the elevated portion of the track.

He said a total of 18 girders would be installed over the railway track.

The official said the NoC request was submitted to the railways two months ago and even the due payment had been made for land acquisition but action on it had yet to be seen.

Sources said the PDA had paid Rs450 million to the Pakistan Railways for acquiring land and using its space at four different locations.

They said the PDA would pay an additional amount of Rs120 million to the railways for putting up the elevated track in Karkhano Market near Hayatabad.

The sources said the PDA purchased around 30 kanals of land from the cantonment board at Aaman Chowk near Gorra Qabristan at the ‘very high’ rate of Rs1.2 billion.

They said Rs300 million had been paid to the board.

The intersection including a public park has already been used for traffic.

Separately, the PDA will pay Rs1.8 billion to the Wapda, Sui Northern Gas Pipelines Limited and Pakistan Telecommunication Company Limited for relocating their installations.

When contacted, Engineer Shah Nawaz, the Pakistan Railways focal person for BRT project, claimed that the PDA didn’t submit girder launching plan and safety certificate to the ministry.

He said the Pakistan Railways had asked the PDA to produce the relevant documents required for the issuance of NoC.

“We are ready to issue the sought-after NoC if the PDA submits the required documents,” he said, adding that the authority had yet to pay Rs120 million for acquiring space in Karkhano Market.

On the other hand, the PDA abandoned its plan to install concrete girders for building 1.7 kilometers elevated track from the Lady Reading Hospital to the cantonment railway station for bicyclists and pedestrians after an inspection team of Asian Development Bank found the structures faulty.

Sources said the ADB team observed that the U-shaped concrete girders were so narrow that they couldn’t accommodate bicyclists and pedestrians and therefore, they should be replaced with steel girders.

The U-shaped concrete girders are to be used for the pedestrians’ movement and overhead bridges in Hayatabad and Chamkani areas. The company has constructed a total of 35 U-shaped girders to be shifted to Hayatabad and other locations.

Published in Dawn, November 28th, 2018

Link: https://www.dawn.com/news/1448069/p...-project-likely-to-miss-march-23-deadline-too
 

3rd_Umpire

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
تیلی" کو رگڑ کر جلانا چاہیئے ۔ ۔ ۔۔"
چھ مہینے میں بس چلانے کی بونگی ماری تھی اُس نے


!!! اتنا بڑا منصوبہ بھلا چھ مہینے میں کیسے پورا ہو سکتا تھا
 
Last edited:

Dr Adam

President (40k+ posts)
Shame on PTI - This project is already 11 months delayed and now it will be delayed further.


PESHAWAR: The procedural technicalities and frequent design changes are likely to push the completion of the Pakistan Tehreek-i-Insaf government’s flagship Peshawar Bus Rapid Transit project beyond the new deadline, officials claim.

The Peshawar Development Authority, the executing agency, has set March 23 as the new deadline for the launch of the multi-billion rupees bus service, which has been delayed by 11 months.

Work on the BRT has been suspended at six locations due to the procedural technicalities and other hurdles.

Officials blame delay in start of bus service on technicalities, frequent design changes​
According to the original plan, the BRT buses were to ply the track in May 2018.

The government changed the deadline for the project’s completion many times.

The frequent changes to the BRT design has escalated the project’s cost from Rs49 billion to Rs69 billion. The Asian Development Bank is financing the project.

The PDA officials insisted that the meeting of the new deadline greatly depended on two state entities i.e.

Wapda and Pakistan Railways, which were to lay new transmission line on Sonehri Masjid Road in cantonment areas and issue no objection certificate for the installation of heavy girders to complete elevated track over the cantonment railway station, respectively.

A relevant official told Dawn that work on BRT track on the Sonehri Masjid Road had been suspended for four months due to the delay in the shifting of the existing power cables.

He said the power lines passed over the elevated portion of the BRT track and the construction won’t resume until the Wapda relocated them.

“Delay in the removal of electricity lines has delayed civil work for more than three months. The PDA may not meet the new deadline if the Wapda does not finish its work immediately,” he said, adding that the authority had scheduled to start work on Wednesday.

The official said the PDA had been waiting for the Pakistan Railways’ NoC for the installation of girders over the cantonment station to complete the elevated portion of the track.

He said a total of 18 girders would be installed over the railway track.

The official said the NoC request was submitted to the railways two months ago and even the due payment had been made for land acquisition but action on it had yet to be seen.

Sources said the PDA had paid Rs450 million to the Pakistan Railways for acquiring land and using its space at four different locations.

They said the PDA would pay an additional amount of Rs120 million to the railways for putting up the elevated track in Karkhano Market near Hayatabad.

The sources said the PDA purchased around 30 kanals of land from the cantonment board at Aaman Chowk near Gorra Qabristan at the ‘very high’ rate of Rs1.2 billion.

They said Rs300 million had been paid to the board.

The intersection including a public park has already been used for traffic.

Separately, the PDA will pay Rs1.8 billion to the Wapda, Sui Northern Gas Pipelines Limited and Pakistan Telecommunication Company Limited for relocating their installations.

When contacted, Engineer Shah Nawaz, the Pakistan Railways focal person for BRT project, claimed that the PDA didn’t submit girder launching plan and safety certificate to the ministry.

He said the Pakistan Railways had asked the PDA to produce the relevant documents required for the issuance of NoC.

“We are ready to issue the sought-after NoC if the PDA submits the required documents,” he said, adding that the authority had yet to pay Rs120 million for acquiring space in Karkhano Market.

On the other hand, the PDA abandoned its plan to install concrete girders for building 1.7 kilometers elevated track from the Lady Reading Hospital to the cantonment railway station for bicyclists and pedestrians after an inspection team of Asian Development Bank found the structures faulty.

Sources said the ADB team observed that the U-shaped concrete girders were so narrow that they couldn’t accommodate bicyclists and pedestrians and therefore, they should be replaced with steel girders.

The U-shaped concrete girders are to be used for the pedestrians’ movement and overhead bridges in Hayatabad and Chamkani areas. The company has constructed a total of 35 U-shaped girders to be shifted to Hayatabad and other locations.

Published in Dawn, November 28th, 2018

Link: https://www.dawn.com/news/1448069/p...-project-likely-to-miss-march-23-deadline-too



Instead, I would put it like this: Shame on Mehmood Khan government....!
 

PakGem

Minister (2k+ posts)
تحریک انصاف کو پنجاب سپیڈ کی طرح پھرتیاں دکھانے کی کوئی ضرورت نہیں، خود جیل میں، بچے ضمانتوں پر، داماد مفرور اور سپورٹر کھوتی کے بچے
 

Aslan

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
Big projects are rarely completed on time due to various complexities.In London the cross rail project has been delayed for a year.UK has very good project managers and engineers but this project is very complex.The project should be done properly,it doesn't matter if it is a little late.
 

hawkkhan

MPA (400+ posts)
Delays in this sort of big projects are normal thing in any corner of the world. Completion date is always ahead of proposal date even you do a small construction of your house.
 

khaaki

Senator (1k+ posts)
Although the credit should be given where and to whom it is due...neefa podri must be commended for completing rwp metro in a record time.
P.S. now that pti is in fed govt it seems kpk and its affairs are kinda put on a back burner...not much coming to.limelight these days.
 

mskhan

Minister (2k+ posts)
Shame on PTI - This project is already 11 months delayed and now it will be delayed further.


PESHAWAR: The procedural technicalities and frequent design changes are likely to push the completion of the Pakistan Tehreek-i-Insaf government’s flagship Peshawar Bus Rapid Transit project beyond the new deadline, officials claim.

The Peshawar Development Authority, the executing agency, has set March 23 as the new deadline for the launch of the multi-billion rupees bus service, which has been delayed by 11 months.

Work on the BRT has been suspended at six locations due to the procedural technicalities and other hurdles.

Officials blame delay in start of bus service on technicalities, frequent design changes​
According to the original plan, the BRT buses were to ply the track in May 2018.

The government changed the deadline for the project’s completion many times.

The frequent changes to the BRT design has escalated the project’s cost from Rs49 billion to Rs69 billion. The Asian Development Bank is financing the project.

The PDA officials insisted that the meeting of the new deadline greatly depended on two state entities i.e.

Wapda and Pakistan Railways, which were to lay new transmission line on Sonehri Masjid Road in cantonment areas and issue no objection certificate for the installation of heavy girders to complete elevated track over the cantonment railway station, respectively.

A relevant official told Dawn that work on BRT track on the Sonehri Masjid Road had been suspended for four months due to the delay in the shifting of the existing power cables.

He said the power lines passed over the elevated portion of the BRT track and the construction won’t resume until the Wapda relocated them.

“Delay in the removal of electricity lines has delayed civil work for more than three months. The PDA may not meet the new deadline if the Wapda does not finish its work immediately,” he said, adding that the authority had scheduled to start work on Wednesday.

The official said the PDA had been waiting for the Pakistan Railways’ NoC for the installation of girders over the cantonment station to complete the elevated portion of the track.

He said a total of 18 girders would be installed over the railway track.

The official said the NoC request was submitted to the railways two months ago and even the due payment had been made for land acquisition but action on it had yet to be seen.

Sources said the PDA had paid Rs450 million to the Pakistan Railways for acquiring land and using its space at four different locations.

They said the PDA would pay an additional amount of Rs120 million to the railways for putting up the elevated track in Karkhano Market near Hayatabad.

The sources said the PDA purchased around 30 kanals of land from the cantonment board at Aaman Chowk near Gorra Qabristan at the ‘very high’ rate of Rs1.2 billion.

They said Rs300 million had been paid to the board.

The intersection including a public park has already been used for traffic.

Separately, the PDA will pay Rs1.8 billion to the Wapda, Sui Northern Gas Pipelines Limited and Pakistan Telecommunication Company Limited for relocating their installations.

When contacted, Engineer Shah Nawaz, the Pakistan Railways focal person for BRT project, claimed that the PDA didn’t submit girder launching plan and safety certificate to the ministry.

He said the Pakistan Railways had asked the PDA to produce the relevant documents required for the issuance of NoC.

“We are ready to issue the sought-after NoC if the PDA submits the required documents,” he said, adding that the authority had yet to pay Rs120 million for acquiring space in Karkhano Market.

On the other hand, the PDA abandoned its plan to install concrete girders for building 1.7 kilometers elevated track from the Lady Reading Hospital to the cantonment railway station for bicyclists and pedestrians after an inspection team of Asian Development Bank found the structures faulty.

Sources said the ADB team observed that the U-shaped concrete girders were so narrow that they couldn’t accommodate bicyclists and pedestrians and therefore, they should be replaced with steel girders.

The U-shaped concrete girders are to be used for the pedestrians’ movement and overhead bridges in Hayatabad and Chamkani areas. The company has constructed a total of 35 U-shaped girders to be shifted to Hayatabad and other locations.

Published in Dawn, November 28th, 2018

Link: https://www.dawn.com/news/1448069/p...-project-likely-to-miss-march-23-deadline-too
Have you looked at the reasons genius. This is a massive project and it needs to be done correctly and properly, nobody is in a fucking hurry. Mega projects take time and they are almost certainly over run, there are a dozen examples of overrun projects in the U.K.
 

Politically1981

MPA (400+ posts)
The problem is that most of us Pakistanis have taken positons in favour of one or the other part and nobody is looking at anything constructively to get an opinion from. Firstly it was a bonker by Pervaiz Khatak to claim they would finish the project in six months. Projects like that take years to complete. Secondly, if you read a full report, the delay is due to reasons beyond control of the construction company. The Wapda and railway need to clear the way for the construction. However due to slow processes and lack of automation, these two departments are failing miserably to complete tasks on time. Let’s be fair to each other, we are all Pakistanis and I am sure most people here want Pakistan a prosperous country.
 

mskhan

Minister (2k+ posts)
Do it once...do it right. There never was a need to give short timelines
They were way too ambitious, it was near impossible in 4 months which was their initial timeline. If they hadn’t given such an ambitious timeline none of these idiots would have been barking now.
 

Politically1981

MPA (400+ posts)
Although the credit should be given where and to whom it is due...neefa podri must be commended for completing rwp metro in a record time.
P.S. now that pti is in fed govt it seems kpk and its affairs are kinda put on a back burner...not much coming to.limelight these days.

The scale of the project is minimum three times more than Lahore metro. It was idiotic to give a timeline. Projects like these should have minimum three years time line.
 

PakGem

Minister (2k+ posts)
bhai but PTI needs to finish projects on time or estimate the time period correctly.

There are clearly a couple of reasons for that,

1. Lacks of Experience of Mega Projects.
2. Elections

It's been a good learning Curve for the PTI and they will do better in the next one.
 

kakajee

Minister (2k+ posts)
The 6 months bongi was an election gimmick and nothing else.

Otherwise everyone knows such a huge project requires atleast 2 years, if not more
 

such bolo

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
جلدی کی ضرورت کیا ہے؟؟
جلدی کا کام شیطان کا ہوتا ہے


چھ مہینے کا ریکارڈ کیوں بنانا تھا؟
جاہل عوام کو جاہل خادم اعلی نے پھدو بنایا ہوا تھا
پرویز خٹک بھی اسی ڈگر پر چل پڑا
ایک دو مہینے اور للو...کوئی بات نہیں...کام پکا کرو بس
 

Sonya Khan

Minister (2k+ posts)
The project needs a good audit ....... If embezzlement found, the guilty should be punished... We think about Pakistan ... We r not like noon leaguers who even defend NS personal property.....
 

kakamana

Minister (2k+ posts)
i wonder why are we justifying these delays? This delay need to be questioned and properly audited about rising cost and its benefits. Already NAB suppose to follow up of awarding BRT peshawar metro project to a blacklisted company
 

Back
Top