insaf_tiger
Banned
Karachi is much.better since shahid hayat took charge welldone.shahid hayat.. next time you should tell chudry nisar that your problem is that u don't have s... tools which is given to waseem akhtar by ishaq dar .
I think ethnicity should not be the criteria for selection.But its a city highly polarised on lines of ethnicity and if Muhajir/urdu speaking guy can soothe the relations among public/police and bring some law and order , sure. However If the police chief is from MQM then he will sure support them in unfair way which will not be professional.
These extra judicial killings were going on even before he took over. so its not something new.
I am not saying that its right but too much criticism is because of this fact as well. Killing in this fashion is certinaly wrong.
I never defended police action.I am trying to explain the meaning/reasons of this MQM lashing on Police Chief .Ethnicity does have a role to play. If it was an Urdu speaking guy MQM's reaction would have been different. Killings are wrong regardless who is doing it. MQM also has killed policemen.Actually, by defending police action, you are supporting extra judicial killings. Otherwise, critisim in this should be without agar and mugar. Police Cheif should resign.
Why MQM is not in the equation ?I think at this point MQM is not even in this equation. Its about the pleight of people in Karachi. Certainly, police cheif should not have any political affliation. But imported police in Karachi is creating imperfect solutions like MQM or seperate province or even countary. This trend should be changed and better now.