Abdul Allah
Minister (2k+ posts)
Re: The main contributions of ghulam ahmed parwez to islam and muslims
A Hadith contradicts Quran is not Hadith at all.
is that answer your problem and your thoughts about me??
But if a Hadith explain an Ayat and interpret it
Do i need to believe some GAP interpretations that goes entirely against Hadith??
or let me be more simple
To understand Quran Hadith is the source or someone GAP???
and if GAP goes against hadith and bring a new explanation that did not match with Hadith and even context then???
Imam Shafai,Imam Hanbal , Imam Abu Hanifa all said that if any of their words contradict with Hadith throw it away.
and you believe GAP thoughts that are clearly against hadith.
Simple rule
for me Hadith is the main source to understand Quran not GAP or XYZ
Negate it with solid arguments
You will not like it ... but honestly ... Ghulam Ahmed Pervez point of view is accurate. He does not reject or deny ahadith. He only says that Quran cannot be tested against Hadith (as you do and it is your attitude which has made me think like Pervez sahib). Hadith is to be tested against Quran. If Hadith is in accordance with Quran ... then it is binding part of Shariah and deserves all reverence and taazeem.
But "Hadith" which contradicts Quran is absolutely a false Hadith.
Chain reference in Hadith is Not a "Khokhli baat" if Hadith is not contradictory to Quran. But if Hadith is contradictory to Quran ... then the Chain Reference (how much rich may be) is a khokhli baat. Simple is that...!!!
A Hadith contradicts Quran is not Hadith at all.
is that answer your problem and your thoughts about me??
But if a Hadith explain an Ayat and interpret it
Do i need to believe some GAP interpretations that goes entirely against Hadith??
or let me be more simple
To understand Quran Hadith is the source or someone GAP???
and if GAP goes against hadith and bring a new explanation that did not match with Hadith and even context then???
Imam Shafai,Imam Hanbal , Imam Abu Hanifa all said that if any of their words contradict with Hadith throw it away.
and you believe GAP thoughts that are clearly against hadith.
Simple rule
for me Hadith is the main source to understand Quran not GAP or XYZ
Negate it with solid arguments