@baba deena
baat lambi hai agar tou wakee samjna chhatay hoo tou kisi real ALIM k pass jao aur agar sirf mayree tarha batay kernay ka shooq hai tou phir muj jaisay INTERNET ALIM b kafee lambi behas ker saktay hain iss baat per .
(agar tumhara BAAP tum say kahay kay bayta yeh yeh kaam ker do tou tum kahoo ABU GEE bayta tou mai app ka hee hon magar mai yeh yeh KAAM nahe karo ga tou kia hayal hai k uss surat mai tum nay koee GUSTAHI kee? and remember k woh still tumhara abu hee hai aur tum uss ko still father he mano gayy so kia haya hai yah koe gustahi ka pehloo hai k nahe?)
GUSTAHI sirf yeh nahe hai k hum NAUZ BILLAH unn ki shan k hillaf koe ALFAAZ keH dey GUSTAHI yeh b hai k unho nay apni ummat k leye jo piaghamaat deye hain woh hum pora karay warna tou mayray bhai ALLAH kay rasool ki gustahi kernay wala tou mayrya hayal say daira islam say hee bahir hoo jata hai aur jo daira islam say bahir hoo jaye usay gustaah nahe kehtay kuch aur kehtay hain)
(SO according to my statement just think about it are we gustahay rasool?)
Why r u confusing the thread or has confused the thread: you mean that:
a) everyone who does not act on the message/messages of Allah given by
Rasool is G="GR",
Whereas read my post again what I have asked? In a society particularly like Pakistan
a person is being declared GR if:
a) says that Rasool is Bashar;
b) says that he does not know unseen;
c) quotes Alamnashra's one verse.
d) objects to certain poetry like "bar do jooli meri, type"
Mine question still is there, that a Kalma reciter, how he can
be a GR? Please bear in mind that your explanation takes a person
near to "Zalim" as per Quran. not "Gustakh".