Urdu is a daughter of Sanskrit not the language of Pakistan

Shan ALi AK 27

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
Exactly, they believe in so many myths to feel good.

We don't have any problem with that.

As for reality, Pakistan didn't create on 1947(as if it wasn't on the map before that) but the region was separated in 2 countries. India was formed that day too.
Ironically they still not bashed by so called modern West.
They can rub cow shit on them and it's ok but if a Muslim marry more than one woman (not have to) they have a problem.
It's all hypocritic world my Afridi brother.
 

Shan ALi AK 27

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
what is this... Persianised standard register of the Hindustani language?...just tempering of wording...the word Hind is even given by Persians and then widely used by Arabs...No knowledge..just base less self pleasing ventures of hindians...
Lol I think this scholar's in red shirt career is over after being roasted on siasat dot pk
I am no language expert not sure who is on this forum but this dude is dark roasted LOL
 

atensari

(50k+ posts) بابائے فورم
اردو چودہ اگست انیس سو انتالیس کو معرض وجود میں نہیں آئی تھی۔
 

Aslan

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
Urdu and Hindi share common grammar but the vocabulary is ver different.Urdu contains more than 60% Persian,Arabic and to a lesser extent Turkish words.We need to setup an Urdu academy similar to what the French have.We need to remove all words from Urdu which have Sanskritic/Hindi roots.We can replace them with Arabic,Farsi and Turkish words.
 

HSiddiqui

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
You should have done some research before coming on to this topic my friend.
Urdu has no particular relationship with any language or country, but this word came from Turkey "HORDE" which meant creating the mixture. And Urdu means Army / Mixture of words, Urdu contains Arabic, Persian, Turkish, and more. It had nothing to do with any country but in 1947 it become Pakistan's national language because in 1947 at the time of independence, the majority of Muslims spoke Urdu, and those were the people who migrated in majority to Pakistan, those were the people who looked after Pakistan's affairs. It has everything to do with Pakistan, it is our national language. It was not originally Indian, if you have to talk about the origin or birthplace of Urdu, then it is TURKEY.
 

StarTrooper

MPA (400+ posts)
Urdu and Hindi share common grammar but the vocabulary is ver different.Urdu contains more than 60% Persian,Arabic and to a lesser extent Turkish words.We need to setup an Urdu academy similar to what the French have.We need to remove all words from Urdu which have Sanskritic/Hindi roots.We can replace them with Arabic,Farsi and Turkish words.
Words can be replaced but how you will replace verbs? Urdu can survive by replacing Arabic , Farsi and Turkish words but by replacing Sanskrit it will die
 

arifkarim

Prime Minister (20k+ posts)
اردو چودہ اگست انیس سو انتالیس کو معرض وجود میں نہیں آئی تھی۔
اردو پاکستانی زبان نہیں ہے۔ ہندوستان کے مسلمان اشرافیہ کی زبان ہے
 

Khi

MPA (400+ posts)
Words can be replaced but how you will replace verbs? Urdu can survive by replacing Arabic , Farsi and Turkish words but by replacing Sanskrit it will die
Why is there a need to replace anything? What’s wrong with Urdu being an Indian subcontinent based language?

Our religion islam is not confined to certain parts of the world and our holy prophet never said that people of non-arabic origin have no right to speak their local languages.

At the end of the day most Pakistanis are native people of Indian subcontinent and we should be proud of who & what we are. A 3rd class, dumb and Jahilana mentality like yours has no place in 21st century.
 

Tyrion Lannister

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
Urdu has more arabic and Persian words, way more than sanskirit, kaha se ajate hen chutye. Ab almost sb languages ka root latin aur sanskirit e hai but urde is more related to persian and arabic
 

Khi

MPA (400+ posts)
اردو پاکستانی زبان نہیں ہے۔ ہندوستان کے مسلمان اشرافیہ کی زبان ہے
Pre-independence Hindustan k muslim ashrafiya included all of today’s Pakistani people. Urdu has long been a bridge language of different local muslim populations in all corners of British/Muslim India.
 

pinionated

Minister (2k+ posts)
Urdu has nothing to do with Islam except for the fact that it was developed/used by Muslim conquerors of India as a language so all anti Hindus can commonly communicate among themselves ?