Should Muslim world create a united force and deploy it in Hijaz for defense of Haramain & Sacred Si

[Wadaich]

​

Muslims Should Create a United Armed Forces of Islam

1. Yes

2. No

 

[ASQR1]

Not only to defend Hijaz, but to rid people like Bashar who is killing innocent by the hundred thousand. And destroying Syria. Same for other groups that are killing in Iraq.

But first thing first, send a mission to talk to this Syrian killer to tell him that he must stop now and let Syrians choose their leaders freely.

 

[OnlyPK]

mery muhally me 1 time pr to Azan hoti nhe, Unite kya ho gy :doh::35::rule::smashfreakB:
ksi se agr poochy k ap kon hy to boly ga k mra taluq fhlany maslaq se hy, koi ye ku nhe bolta k me Musalman hu or mra taluq Prophet Muhammad pbuh k din e Islam se hy

 

[PAINDO]

 

[Faizan Syed]

Muslim world ko chaiye ek dosry k mulko me bomb blast na karwaye aman se rahy to kisi b force ki zarurt nahi parhy gi

 

[Jibran Naeem]

yes nice idea

 

[Imran Siddiqi]

mery muhally me 1 time pr to Azan hoti nhe, Unite kya ho gy :doh::35::rule::smashfreakB:
ksi se agr poochy k ap kon hy to boly ga k mra taluq fhlany maslaq se hy, koi ye ku nhe bolta k me Musalman hu or mra taluq Prophet Muhammad pbuh k din e Islam se hy

Baat to saheeh hai Aap ke per Jab koee Prophet Muhammad pbuh ki Shaan me Gustakhi karta hai toh Unite hoatay hain naa

 

[OnlyPK]

Baat to saheeh hai Aap ke per Jab koee Prophet Muhammad pbuh ki Shaan me Gustakhi karta hai toh Unite hoatay hain naa

You are 200% Right.

wsy mjy is bat ke smjh aj tk nhe aye k ye maslaq kis chirya ka naam hy, ksi bndy se poocha jye to wo bolta hy k hm fhlany imam ko follow krty hy, koi kehta hy k hm us imaam ko follow krty hy, me un se sirf 1 seedha sa swal krta hu k jin jin imaaamo ko ap follow krty hy kya apne kbi socha hy k wo Imaam kis ko follow krty hy ..... definitely hr Imaam Prophet Muhammad pbuh ko hi follow krta hy, to ye maslaq beech me kha se aa gya ..... at least mjy is behudgi ke aj tk smjh nhe ayee

 

[Tyrion Lannister]

muslim world and unity; these words do not belong to a single sentence

 

[Mughal1]

Muslims have not prepared themselves to be the army they need to be, why not? For explanation see HERE and HERE.

 

[badmaash kantutta]

Yes, also include Saudi Arabia, Bahrain,kuwait, etc etc.. which have horrible human rights records

Not only to defend Hijaz, but to rid people like Bashar who is killing innocent by the hundred thousand. And destroying Syria. Same for other groups shar are killing in Iraq.

But first thing first, send a mission to talk to this Syrian killer to tell him that he must stop now and let Syrians choose their leaders freely.

 

[ASQR1]

Yes, also include Saudi Arabia, Bahrain,kuwait, etc etc.. which have horrible human rights records������

First thing first, can't equate killings of 400,000 humans with others.

 

[RAJPUT1]

مسلمانوں کو متحدہ قوت سے زیادہ متحد ہونے کی ضرورت ہے

 

[arafay]

No as muslims we believe that Allah protects medina and mecca through angels.

However, i think it is time for muslims to tackle this menace of terrorism because it is attacking the foundations of islam. All muslim countries should declare jihaad against any person or group who helps promote, facilitate and finance terrorism.

the only problem is that out of all the 50+ muslim countries only 3 have decent army - turkey, iran and pakistan. hopefully saudia and iran will unite against the common enemy i.e. terrorists (isis, ttp or any future organization). Maybe muslim countries will unite with Europe against ISIS like they did against the soviets. This situation actually reminds me of a hadith.

"You will make a firm truce with the al-Rum until you and they wage a campaign against an enemy that is attacking them. You will be granted victory and great spoils. Then you will alight in a plain surrounded by hills. There, someone among the Christians shall say: 'The Cross has overcome!' whereupon someone among the Muslims shall say: 'Nay, Allah has overcome!' and shall go and break the cross. The Christians shall kill him, then the Muslims shall take up their arms and the two sides shall fall upon each other. Allah shall grant martyrdom to that group of Muslims. After that the Christians shall say to their leader: 'We shall relieve you of the Arabs,' and they shall gather up for the great battle (al-malhama). They shall come to you under eighty flags, each flag gathering 12,000 troops." [= approx. 1 million]


Narrated with sound chains from Dhu Mikhbar al-Najashi by Abu Dawud, Ahmad, Ibn Majah, Ibn Hibban, and al-Hakim who declared it sahih and al-Dhahabi concurred. See Shaykh Shu`ayb Arna'ut's documentation of this hadith in his edition of Sahih Ibn Hibban (15:101-103 #6708-6709).

many scholars say that the common enemy mentioned in this hadith is russia/soviet union/communism. However, soviet union didnt attack any European or arab country at that time. There was a cold war between capitalism and communism and almost all arab countries were with the US/western europe. Also there was no written agreement or truce done between arabs and usa/europe against soviet union.

 

[Anuj76]

100% like the idea, it should have been started in 1924 after the fall 8f Khafat e Usmania. We given the Jew controlled west tje right to act and behave as our Lord. Right to invade and Kill and destroy Muslim lands with impunity.

It is time to put an END to crusade.

 

[skyplus]

Yes insha allah we will be soon

 

[atensari]

باقی باتیں بعد کی پہلے مسلمان آپس میں اتحاد و اتفاق کریں ایک دوسرے کے خلاف استعمال ہونے کی بجائے باہمی معاملات گفت و شنید سے خود طے کریں

 

[atensari]

@Adeel
@Waseem

نہیں منتخب کرنے والے معزز ممبران پر خاص نظر رکھیں ہو سکے تو ہمیں بھی مطلع فرمائیں

 

[Raaz]

ہمارے ہاں یا نہ کہنے سے کیا فرق پڑتا ہے ؟؟؟
آج مسلمان امریکہ اور روس کی حمایت میں ایک دوسرے کے مخالف ہو چکے ہیں

کون مسلمانوں کو اپنی مرضی سے اپنی ایک پالیسی بھی بنانے دیتا ہے
ضیاء کے زمانے میں اسلامیات کے سلیبس بھی امریکہ سے بن کر آتی تھیں

 

[Raaz]

Baat to saheeh hai Aap ke per Jab koee Prophet Muhammad pbuh ki Shaan me Gustakhi karta hai toh Unite hoatay hain naa

نہی اس وقت بھی اکھٹے نہی ہوتے
کبھی دیکھا ہے ارب ملکوں کے لوگوں یا حکومتوں نے احتجاج کیا ہو

ہمارے فورم پر ایک اہلحدیث ملوی صاحب ہیں - سچ بولو
وہ فرماتے ہیں کہ گستاخی پر احتجاج نہی کرنا چاہے ، کیوں کہ احتجاج کی اسلام میں کوئی گنجایش نہی ہے

بس یار ، اب لوگ مسلمان ہی نہی ہیں تو اکھٹے کیوں ہوں
مسلمان اکھٹے ہوتے کافر نہی