Khari Baat
Councller (250+ posts)

Last edited by a moderator:
It is not mine "problem" to take guidance only from Quran, rather it isy
dear brother
your problem is to take guidance only from quran and you want to understand it the way you want, and for you
no importance to the and the only teacher of quran our beloved prophet, there is no solution to your problem
More than once this topic had been discussed in a different way. Anyhow once again:
MY CHALLENGE TO ALL ULEMA, LEARNED SCHOLARS AND ANCHORS IS STILL THERE AND
ONCE AGAIN REPEATED HERE:
A) Did the verse No. 3 of Surah Nisa contains the arabic words "Feil Yatamaa" (in Orphans); Yes or No.
b) If there are included these arabic words "Feil Yatamaa" (and they are difinitely), then the first and
foremost condition is of Orphans, is it Yes or NO.
c) is the verse No.3 Surah Nisa is in continuation of Verse No.2, Yes or No?
d) If V.No.3 of Surah Nisa is conditional/restricted with Orphans Yes or No.
e) If V.No.3 is giving a blank permission to believers like this " Oh you believe, marry women of your liking
two, three, or four", Yes or No.
f) Wherein Quran at any other place such kind of permission has been granted? Yes or No.
Why all the Ulema and People are putting cart before horse by only emphasing the afterwards
conditions of "Inshaff, equal treatment, adil etc", why they do not take into account the first and foremost
condition.
PLEASE GET INTO YOUR HEART AND MIND ONE THING, IF NO ORPHANS OR ORPHANS AFFAIRS
ARE INVOLVED, THERE IS NO PERMISSION TO MARRY MORE THAN ONE WOMAN. Or you prove it,
Now please do not bring me often repeated hadiths, sunnah or anything because for me Quran is
foremost what it says is final and over any thing.
PLEASE GET INTO YOUR HEART AND MIND ONE THING, IF NO ORPHANS OR ORPHANS AFFAIRS
ARE INVOLVED, THERE IS NO PERMISSION TO MARRY MORE THAN ONE WOMAN. Or you prove it,
Now please do not bring me often repeated hadiths, sunnah or anything because for me Quran is
foremost what it says is final and over any thing.
It may be your belief that "teacher" may have taught contrary to what is in the Book,
not mine.
hmm right
before i come with detail answer please let me know
as mention in the discussion that Sahaba like Hazrat Ali RA(the one who was grown up by Rasool Allah pbuh himself) married more than once even after Muhammad pbuh.
tell us please that
1) were there any ORPHANS OR ORPHANS AFFAIRS INVOLVED in his multiple marriage? Yes or No
2) if Yes then prove it. or
3) if NO then please tell us that Hazrat Ali RA goes again Quran(nauzbillah). Yes or NO.
please answer the question and do not come with answer this and that.
I am not concerned at all what Ali (rzt) did, but I am really interested to know
what in Quran is written. So you can read Quran yourself and answer Yes or No
to my questions. Did I ask you or all other too much. After all Quran wherein there is
no doubt at all, is available with you?
But you should concern dont you.
Dont you think people living near to Muhammad pbuh will be more aware of Quran and know more what Quran SAYS (as they were able to ask directly and Muhammd pbuh was the teacher of them to explain Quranic Ayath )? think logicaly and carefuly and ANSWER
now let us come toward Quran that What Quran says about that.
Ok tell me please
1) Where Quran STOP man from marrying more than one?
2) in that Ayath we have مِّنَ النِّسَآءِ could you please tell us that did this مِّنَ النِّسَآءِ is talking about women other than فِى الْيَتَٰـمَى or not.
please answer these questions so that we progress in understanding this Ayath.
Read my post No.7
© Copyrights 2008 - 2025 Siasat.pk - All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy | Disclaimer|