@mehwish_ali:
For the last time PLEASE stop using Sunni sources to back your ulterior agenda! You have no idea what the hell you are saying and on another post I had shown to both you and muntazir that Sunni literature that you guys quote are OUT OF CONTEXT.
There is a difference between "hadith" and "sunnah" and anyone who doesn't know this will make the same errors that people like you make using any hadith as an argument. Every 'amal or qawl of Rasulullah (SAW) CANNOT and SHOULD NOT be taken as definitive hujjah unless he (SAW) specifies it as such. For example, he married more than 4 women at one time. You will find such ahadith in these same books. Similarly, from Sahih Bukhari you will find ahadith that Nabi (SAW) did rafa' yadain in between sajdah (what you shi'ahs do).
However, these kinds of ahadith are NOT the sunnah. Meaning, they are just recorded actions/sayings not taking into account the fact that they were abrogated and these 'amal/aqwaal were replaced by other practices. So its pointless to quote ahadith if you bloody don't even know the usul of these ahadith.
As Sufyan Ath-Thawri (rah) once said: Ahadith are DEATH for everyone except for the 'ulama/faqih. So don't just quote willy nilly. Finally, every hadith book has its
sharh (explanation). One of the best shawarih of Sahih Al-Bukhari was Ibn Hajr Al-'Asqalani (rah). He has dedicated a whole book for explaining each and every hadith of Sahih Al-Bukhari in his monumental
Fath Al-Bari. In that book he has discussed IN DETAIL the matter of who the "khawarij" were. Go and read it.
The "khawarij" came and went. It is pointless to try and use those ahadith NOW to paint other Muslims in a negative light. Those 14 signs that you show of the Khawarij can easily apply to ANY Muslim so its all very subjective. One needs to have proper knowledge of
ilm al-aakhir az-zaman to interpret these eschatological things and put it in its proper context.
Finally, note some of the points like number 11 (kathrat kay saath sar mundwayain gay). Tell me one Taliban who is BALD?? Almost all of them have long flowing, unkempt hair!! Similarly, number 8 (bud paraston ko chorengay): The Taliban were known for destroying the statue of Buddha in Bamiyan and killing Hindus in the war of 1948! 1/3rd of the Kashmir that Pakistan has is because of this same campaign against the Hindus that the Waziri tribes fought against India.
So, please, don't embarrass yourself by quoting Sunni text when you are: (a) A Shi'ah; (b) Have no knowledge of Sunni text; (c) Have this habit of showing your bias so clearly that it almost makes one puke!
@KhanHaripur, @zubair1234, @zhohaq, @watandost
جی نہیں، طالبانی اور القاعدہ کا خارجی ہونا کسی شک و شبہ سے بالاتر ہے۔
یہ خبیث مسلمانوں کی تکفیر کر چکے ہیں۔
یہ خبیث اپنے جنونی نظریات کی بنیاد پر مسلمانوں کو قتل کر چکے ہیں۔
