طالبان کے حمائتیوں کے لئے

[Modest]

Wtf? Aren't these people Muslim Afghans now? Are terrorist Taliban justified to kill their fellow Muslim brethren just because they oppose Taliban?

If these pro American puppets attack & kill Taliban then what should Taliban do, present them some flowers?
Don’t be childish, Taliban are the freedom fighters who defeated the terrorist USA & their alliance. Since the fleeing of Americans, why would Taliban not try to capture the whole country from the American puppets.
I am not saying it is right or wrong but think logically. If someone has fought a war for twenty years then they won’t stop until they achieve complete victory.

 

[arifkarim]

It doesnt work like this all the time. The modern US won it's freedom through force. The American civil war one side imposing its agenda on the other through force. Chinese communist party removed Western puppet regimes through force. Taliban are now fighting against those who fight against them and try to suppress them. If Taliban come into power and brutalize Afghan citizens then that would be unacceptable.

Then Taliban fascists are no different than Chinese communist party and US govt that fought the break away Confederate States. China became one party dictatorship while US became two party dictatorship after their civil wars. Afghanistan will become Taliban dictatorship once again after the current civil war. Is this what you want and support?

 

[arifkarim]

why would Taliban not try to capture the whole country from the American puppets.

So Afghan Muslims who do not support terrorist Taliban are American puppets? Can there be no opposition to Taliban rule in Afghanistan without labeling them as someone's puppets?

 

[Modest]

So Afghan Muslims who do not support terrorist Taliban are American puppets? Can there be no opposition to Taliban rule in Afghanistan without labeling them as someone's puppets?

I am not taking about normal afghans, I am taking about the armed pro American afghans who are fighting against Taliban.
Of course there can be opposition to Taliban rule & everyone has the right to choose who they like.
You are calling Taliban (freedom fighters) terrorist but not calling the invaders (America) & their puppets terrorists?

 

[Eigoroll]

Yes, Islam lovers who support Islamic Jihadi terrorist groups like Taliban are fools of course.

People support Taliban for different reasons. Taliban are not perfect. But an Islamophobe's opinion on who Muslims support or not doesn't amount to any thing.

Then Taliban fascists are no different than Chinese communist party and US govt that fought the break away Confederate States. China became one party dictatorship while US became two party dictatorship after their civil wars. Afghanistan will become Taliban dictatorship once again after the current civil war. Is this what you want and support?

You conveniently skipped on how the US won it's freedom. What I and You want doesn't matter. These things are beyond us. If Talibans have spine to fight against the US onslaught for 20 years they would careless about what you want.

 

[arifkarim]

You are calling Taliban (freedom fighters) terrorist but not calling the invaders (America) & their puppets terrorists?

US invaders are gone. Now is the time to build national army consisting of all Afghan fighting groups. But Taliban doesn't want that. They want to end all groups who oppose their rule. How is this fighting freedom?

 

[arifkarim]

People support Taliban for different reasons. Taliban are not perfect. But an Islamophobe's opinion on who Muslims support or not doesn't amount to any thing.


You conveniently skipped on how the US won it's freedom. What I and You want doesn't matter. These things are beyond us. If Talibans have spine to fight against the US onslaught for 20 years they would careless about what you want.

How good is Taliban govt in Afghanistan if they take it by force and no country recognize it including Pakistan?

 

[Modest]

US invaders are gone. Now is the time to build national army consisting of all Afghan fighting groups. But Taliban doesn't want that. They want to end all groups who oppose their rule. How is this fighting freedom?

US invaders are gone but their puppets & proxies are still in place. Taliban are giving pardon to those who lay down their weapons but if some groups are still interested in fighting then Taliban will also continue to do so.
Since the invaders are gone, I want all the groups including Taliban to strike a peace deal & end this fighting.

 

[Eigoroll]

How good is Taliban govt in Afghanistan if they take it by force and no country recognize it including Pakistan?

If this happens, most of the countries will recognize it sooner or later just the way the whole anti-communist West recognized the Communist government in Vietnam which liberated the country from the US. Read history.

 

[arifkarim]

Taliban are giving pardon to those who lay down their weapons

So Taliban wish to dominate Afghanistan like Americans and Russians did.

 

[arifkarim]

If this happens, most of the countries will recognize it sooner or later just the way the whole anti-communist West recognized the Communist government in Vietnam which liberated the country from the US. Read history.

Of course they will. They recognized Iranian Shia govt and North Korea's communist govt too. As for relations with the West, time will tell.

 

[Modest]

So Taliban wish to dominate Afghanistan like Americans and Russians did.

May be, as they defeated the invaders & now they believe it’s their right to dominate & rule Afghanistan.

 

[arifkarim]

May be, as they defeated the invaders & now they believe it’s their right to dominate & rule Afghanistan.

Hahahaha so if Russians or Americans had defeated Taliban, they had the right to rule Afghanistan by force? Hypocrisy exposed. Applying this logic further; Israel has the right to rule Palestinians and India has the right to rule Kashmiris as they have defeated insurgency over there.
That's why I am opposed to bringing democracy by force and bringing Islamic rule by force. Key to rule is vote not force

 

[Modest]

Hahahaha so if Russians or Americans had defeated Taliban, they had the right to rule Afghanistan by force? Hypocrisy exposed. Applying this logic further; Israel has the right to rule Palestinians and India has the right to rule Kashmiris as they have defeated insurgency over there.
That's why I am opposed to bringing democracy by force and bringing Islamic rule by force. Key to rule is vote not force

I thought you were a clever guy but you are really childish. Russia & America were foreign occupation forces & they didn’t have any right to rule Afghanistan. If someone attacks your home & defeat you then do they have the right to occupy your home because they defeated you?
Taliban are Afghanis & they have the right to defend their country against foreign forces. They are the force who won the war while the other groups were sitting in the American lap. Now since they won the war & they were the ones who were ousted from government, they will claim it is their right to rule again.
Israel & India are both illegally occupying foreign land, so they have no right to rule others land. Your logic is so idiotic & foolish.

 

[arifkarim]

Now since they won the war & they were the ones who were ousted from government, they will claim it is their right to rule again.

Through elections not with force. Why can't you understand that, Taliban lover?

 

[Modest]

Through elections not with force. Why can't you understand that, Taliban lover?

I was telling you about what Taliban would be thinking now after defeating the invaders. Why can’t you understand this, invader lover?
I am not saying that Taliban should rule Afghanistan by force.

 

[karachiwala]

اسلام پسند دنیا کی احمق ترین مخلوق ہیں

یہی بات لوگ آپ کیلیئے بھی کہتے ہیں کہ آپ بغیر ڈائریکشن اور بغیر علم کے سب سے بڑے مبصر ہیں​

 

[Saeed Akbar]

تو میں نے کہاں کہا ہے کہ یہ اجتماعی سوچ ہے؟

To phir aap ki soch bilkul ghalat hai.