Should Karachi be given under Army control for indefinite period ?

[BrotherKantu]

Should you want peace in Karachi, you need to eliminate MQM completely.
MQM is fully responsible for the destruction of this great city Karachi.
Prior to MQM, Karachi was one of the most peaceful city of Paksitan.
We need to eliminate MQM from Pakistan. This is only the solution.

I been once in Karachi before MQM and I LOVED it.

 

[saifsaif]

I think the Afghanies in Karachi are the major problem,they are so rude and JANGLI,they dont have any manners(not pathans) from the day they came in Pakistan we have problem and even they dont recognize the EHSAN of Pakistan,their president is an wrost enemy of Pakistan so please send them back to Afghnistan we will be in peac(INSHAHAALAH).

 

[FaisalKh]

fine... why are u bringing ethnicity here???? i said all illegal immigrants must be kicked out from karachi or the tribal areas.. we are not living under khilafa.. we have our own country.. they shud go their theirs.. or come here using a legal route... just like saudi arabia will kcik any illegal pakistani....

for your suggestion to legalize them.. yes they shud be registered and given legal status and tracked as to what were thet doing for the lively hood before and what is their status now..

Why u have started lobbying against afghanis what afghanis have to do with it... why dont u raise ur voice against MQM PPP and ANP? or u think they are the most pious people of Pakistan? u r only beating about the bushes here....

 

[adnan_younus]

i am giving the root cause of the problem... afghanistan is already ruined be it russia, their own warlords or US... now they are coming in our cities are ruining us... some wher thru suicide bombings and somewhere thru this gun cukture.. zia is responsible for this all...

MQM PPP and ANP are reponsible but who are the elements behind it.. capture all pakistanis who are involved in karachi killing and kick all non pakistanis to their own homeland....

Why u have started lobbying against afghanis what afghanis have to do with it... why dont u raise ur voice against MQM PPP and ANP? or u think they are the most pious people of Pakistan? u r only beating about the bushes here....

 

[crowbar]

Army is required to clean karachi from terrorist who kills on behest of dons living abroad.

 

[FaisalKh]

i am giving the root cause of the problem... afghanistan is already ruined be it russia, their own warlords or US... now they are coming in our cities are ruining us... some wher thru suicide bombings and somewhere thru this gun cukture.. zia is responsible for this all...

MQM PPP and ANP are reponsible but who are the elements behind it.. capture all pakistanis who are involved in karachi killing and kick all non pakistanis to their own homeland....

I dont think there is anything to do with afghanis in current situation... PPP ANP and MQM are solely responsible and why dont u mention India and US's hand in current situation... what would afghanistan get from this but India and US are getting lots from it by destabilizing Pakistan... and thats what we also want capture all those who are involved (Pakistani or non Pakistani) and line them up and shoot them in front of others and set them as an example for others

 

[adnan_younus]

might be.. but who is being used???? if india.. afghanistan is an ally these days.. afghan army is attacking pakistan now at borders...

there is a balance of resources in a city managed by city administration.. if u fill it with refugees who are lawless... the balance will fail.. im a born karachite and these killings are not new to me... the only time i saw peace and prosperity in karachi was during musharrafs era... and only his leadership can bring peace to pakistan again...

I dont think there is anything to do with afghanis in current situation... PPP ANP and MQM are solely responsible and why dont u mention India and US's hand in current situation... what would afghanistan get from this but India and US are getting lots from it by destabilizing Pakistan... and thats what we also want capture all those who are involved (Pakistani or non Pakistani) and line them up and shoot them in front of others and set them as an example for others

 

[FaisalKh]

might be.. but who is being used???? if india.. afghanistan is an ally these days.. afghan army is attacking pakistan now at borders...

there is a balance of resources in a city managed by city administration.. if u fill it with refugees who are lawless... the balance will fail.. im a born karachite and these killings are not new to me... the only time i saw peace and prosperity in karachi was during musharrafs era... and only his leadership can bring peace to pakistan again...

Hahahahaha nd thats what i can only say on ur statement peace during musharraf's time.... before musharraf,there were killing and political clashes in karachi and hyderabad only but during his time it spread to the whole country 12 May incident is one of them... Dont start again plzzz by defending ur leader here as this is not the right time and situation...

 

[adnan_younus]

only 12th may...

the solution of karahci is give administration to the people of karachi... simple.. who ever they are.. give it to them... dont use karachi as ayyashi and kamayee ka adda for lawless people and elite rich...

bring local govt system back.. give the city to the people and watch it excel.....

i used to go to college in 5C... after 14 years i jsut had a though to travelling thur bus from saddar to my place.. there was not a single difference b/w that 5c and 14 years after... every new thing brought be it green buses or metro sabotaged....

give karachi to its people and watch it excel.... simple solution

Hahahahaha nd thats what i can only say on ur statement peace during musharraf's time.... before musharraf,there were killing and political clashes in karachi and hyderabad only but during his time it spread to the whole country 12 May incident is one of them... Dont start again plzzz by defending ur leader here as this is not the right time and situation...

 

[FaisalKh]

only 12th may...

the solution of karahci is give administration to the people of karachi... simple.. who ever they are.. give it to them... dont use karachi as ayyashi and kamayee ka adda for lawless people and elite rich...

bring local govt system back.. give the city to the people and watch it excel.....

i used to go to college in 5C... after 14 years i jsut had a though to travelling thur bus from saddar to my place.. there was not a single difference b/w that 5c and 14 years after... every new thing brought be it green buses or metro sabotaged....

give karachi to its people and watch it excel.... simple solution

Karachi is in the hands of people of Karachi what else do u want? MQM PPP ANP they r inhabitants of Karachi... they did not come from afghanistan, india etc... the only difference among them is that some of the leaders ruling them from abroad... by the way whom u call people of karachi?

 

[fido82]

I think entire Pakistan should be given under Army control.

 

[adnan_younus]

no its not; we dont administer karachi..... only sindh has urban and rural quota as separate.... get local bodies elections.. give local administration.. all big cities in the world has their own police and other development authorities...they dont use provicial police.... if uve liced abroad the concept of councils we have thats what i am talking about...

Karachi is in the hands of people of Karachi what else do u want? MQM PPP ANP they r inhabitants of Karachi... they did not come from afghanistan, india etc... the only difference among them is that some of the leaders ruling them from abroad... by the way whom u call people of karachi?

 

[adnan_younus]

those who are born here or live here premanently and not because their domicle is of toba tek sindh they get priority to an educated man who can run the office betterbut cant just because his domicile is that of karachi... i wanted to be a css officer but cudnt just because of this dreaded quota system... pick polcie officaly from karachi.. pick all departmens jobs from karach.. or atleast do it on merit rather than on quota...

no its not; we dont administer karachi..... only sindh has urban and rural quota as separate.... get local bodies elections.. give local administration.. all big cities in the world has their own police and other development authorities...they dont use provicial police.... if uve liced abroad the concept of councils we have thats what i am talking about...

 

[fido82]

Should you want peace in Karachi, you need to eliminate MQM completely.
MQM is fully responsible for the destruction of this great city Karachi.
Prior to MQM, Karachi was one of the most peaceful city of Paksitan.
We need to eliminate MQM from Pakistan. This is only the solution.

Did you remember in Musharaf period of 5 years. There was not a single killing in 5 years. Just MQM phobia and haters comments.

 

[FaisalKh]

no its not; we dont administer karachi..... only sindh has urban and rural quota as separate.... get local bodies elections.. give local administration.. all big cities in the world has their own police and other development authorities...they dont use provicial police.... if uve liced abroad the concept of councils we have thats what i am talking about...

U r absolutely right local govt interacts directly to the people and they know their problem in better ways i m also in favor of this....

 

[ALI ARYAN]

 

[Star Gazer]

No, a definite no. Police and the civil law enforcement should take care of it.

 

[atensari]

دونوں دہشت گرد تنظیموں کو کالعدم قرار دے کر ان کی سرگرمیوں پر پابندی لگا دی جاۓ​

 

[saeed Hassan]

and naseerullah babar the commander with in 2 week peace in karachi.

 

[FaisalKh]

No, a definite no. Police and the civil law enforcement should take care of it.

If Pakistani police want, they can force an elephant to become a deer :P but the problem is they are under political pressure and they are not allowing them to do their job properly...and they cant open their wings fully same is the case with rangers so only Army is the one and only solution or else people should take arms and protect them and their families...