Star Gazer
Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
Jury is supposed to be a collective body os people for making democratic decisions but we have a one man Jury.
I would like to know from the writer of this thread as to what is percieved to be a Sind Card? Because when some one says card it sounds some special tecnique of getting what you want other than straightforward.
sobia403 said:Very valid and basic question Gazoomartian.
I would like to know from the writer of this thread as to what is percieved to be a Sind Card? Because when some one says card it sounds some special tecnique of getting what you want other than straightforward.
itsnotme90 said:I appreciate Pakpatriot response on this post but what i hav notice on this forum for example members like sobia403 if you explain them 1 then 2 then 3 , 4 , 5, 6,7,8, 9 steps and after 9 you hav to start from zero again to explain them coz they have zero general knowledge and they will deny any thing without any information and after some time same person will come along with new name and new id & they will ask you same questions repeatedly again & again like kids so i will request those people who just jump into any conclusion that plz increase your knowledge and dont make your point of view just a kitchen window.
sobia403 said:Very valid and basic question Gazoomartian.
I would like to know from the writer of this thread as to what is percieved to be a Sind Card? Because when some one says card it sounds some special tecnique of getting what you want other than straightforward.
PakPatriot1 said:sobia403 said:Very valid and basic question Gazoomartian.
I would like to know from the writer of this thread as to what is percieved to be a Sind Card? Because when some one says card it sounds some special tecnique of getting what you want other than straightforward.
@Sobia and Mr. Gazoomartin:
I know you will never agree with me because you have a mind set against MQM, and that mind set does not allow you to think beyond your self imposed imaginations.
Why would I not believe you if you present your point with full conviction? In this case you have done so. In terms of polictics, all imaginations are self imposed....I am not against the MQM just for fun. I used to MQM lover. I was in Karachi in 1986 when first HUGE jalsa happen. But only recently, I viewed the video in which he said: Pakistan was the biggest blunder, if mahajirs come back, please forgive them. He said all this in fornt of enemy audience. It would not be bad if he says in any country, but sepcially in India, which is our sworn enemy, proven in 1971. I have lived thru the days of Sheikh Mujeeb, I KNOW WHAT A GHADDAR is. I moved from East Pakistan in June 1972, 7 months afer humiliating defeat of Pakistan. So please dont tell me how to define Ghaddar.
Anyways, for the sake of the other young audience I want to clearify what is Sindh Card is. I dont know how old sister sobia is, I know I aint no spring chicken no more. :D
This is historical reality that PPP has always been doing it's politics in enterior Sindh on the basis of Sindhi Nationalism. This is not new, it has beeen prevailing from Z.A. Bhutto to now Zardari and Zulfiqar Mirza.
When in 1977, with the help of American aid, a massive movement was launched against Bhutto and PPP the whole Pakistan was involved in that movement except enterior sindh.
And then Bhutto's govt. was ousted by Zia regime and every party on that time distributed "Mithai" in all over Pakistan including Karachi and Hyderabd. Those days these two cities were politically controlled by Jamat -e - Islami and Norrani Mian parties, there was no MQM there.
YES, Shaheed ZAB was a victim of conspiracy but unfortunately he had big mouth (dont no body be offended) to announce: Why cant we have Islamic bomb? So when I heard Altaf's blunder, naturaly my mind thinks he is a ghaddar.
Down the road Bhutto was hung on the gallows and again Mithai was distributed in all over the Pakistan. Mithai distribution was not the right thing to do but people do have right to express their happyness, anger, satisfaction etc, right or wrong
That was the time when Murataza and Shanawaz Bhutto {with the obvious permission of Banazir and Nusrat Bhutto), formed a terrorist organization and named it Alzulfiqar. The members of that Alzulfiqar hijacked a PIA airliner and after killing some passengers, as a ransom, they got released many PPP workers from the jail. Thsy killed many political leaders and rivals of Bhuttos including Ch. Zahoor Illahi in Punjab and Zahoor ul Hasan Bhopali in karachi.
So Murtaza and Shanawaz did commit murders for revenge. I did not know, thanks for informing me
MRD movement against Zia regime was launched and soon it became very popular in enterior sindh because a common Sindhi rightly thought Bhutto was murderd by Zia and Pakistani establishment
Now when the MRD movement getting strength, Sindhi Waderas came into action and started their dirty game to inject the poisonous thoughts against Pakistan, Punjabis and Muhajirs into the minds of common innocent Sindhis.
This technique worked and MRD movement turned to a seperatist movement in enterior sindh. G A Sindh was in full swing on those days in E. Sindh. Well i hope it doesnt happen and things get better, Ameen
That is the Sindh Card means you give us everything otherwise we will break Pakistan.
They could succeeded in their planning but Zia was very smart, he realised the situation and immediately started to take actions to check the out of control situation in Sindh.
Zia knew that in Urban Sindh within Muhajir community there is no roots of Sindh Card, so he might be I am not sure though, formed or just supported MQM and Altaf Hussain. But the overwhelming response MQM and Altaf Hussain got from the people, was not in the imagination of anyone. MQM became popular within no time. It was a sudden change and kind of revolution in Pak politics especially in sindh. May be Zia forme MQM but who became it popular? only people. This is another fact that many MQM haters can not digest easily.
Since then MQM has been acting as the Great Wall of China against Sindhi seperatists, Muhajirs are being victimised from these seperatists time by time.
If only Karachi support them and MQM and Altaf Hussain shake hands with these elements in Sindh, then no one can control the possible anarchy in Sindh, and the end result could be anything- might be break up of Pakistan. But your Traitor Altaf Hussain and his workers, supporters and voters are the main front liners against all of these theories of Sindh Card etc etc.
he is not MY traitor, he is Pak's traitor, just for the record. By the way, I am NOT a MQM hater, I am hater of their policies and actions
I don't want you to believe, (because it will be against your mind set) but this is the fact, until MQM exist in Sindh, no one can seperate Sindh from Pakistan.
Big difference between East Pak and Sind. Sind is jeographically attached to Pak, East Pak wasnt
PERIOD.
such said:
itsnotme90 said:I appreciate Pakpatriot response on this post but what i hav notice on this forum for example members like sobia403 if you explain them 1 then 2 then 3 , 4 , 5, 6,7,8, 9 steps and after 9 you hav to start from zero again to explain them coz they have zero general knowledge and they will deny any thing without any information and after some time same person will come along with new name and new id & they will ask you same questions repeatedly again & again like kids so i will request those people who just jump into any conclusion that plz increase your knowledge and dont make your point of view just a kitchen window.
PakPatriot1 said:itsnotme90 said:I appreciate Pakpatriot response on this post but what i hav notice on this forum for example members like sobia403 if you explain them 1 then 2 then 3 , 4 , 5, 6,7,8, 9 steps and after 9 you hav to start from zero again to explain them coz they have zero general knowledge and they will deny any thing without any information and after some time same person will come along with new name and new id & they will ask you same questions repeatedly again & again like kids so i will request those people who just jump into any conclusion that plz increase your knowledge and dont make your point of view just a kitchen window.
Thanks bro.
My intention always be to address to everyone not people like you mentioned (although I give response to them). I know many youngsters in this forum don't know the facts about Pakistan's political history and their minds are being maligned by these people.
These people are on the internet just to spread hatered. Nothing constructive service for Pakistan can be expected from them.
But I always feel responsible to clearify the facts, no matter who thinks what about me, my party, my leader and my community.
sobia403 said:Thankyou for your kind words and simili, although according to my training and upbringing this is considered inappropriate, your case may be different. But if you are using it as a ploy to push your critiques away it will not work with me although you try your best to derrogate any one who questions your mighty opinions because you people are the heirs to all wisdom handed down from the top brass and that ofcourse now has to be imported from a more developed country,so you have to accept it!!
You have gone to a great length to explain the history of MQM I know that and that was not my question. So what you are saying is that sindh card is used to threaten the federation of Pakistan by sindhi seperatists? and that would be PPP? correct me if I am wrong??
For your information I have only one party: PAKISTAN.
No political affiliations, but always get suspicious when simple questions rattle the people.
sobia403 said:My brother pakpatriot1, if you have been reading my posts on other topics you would have realized that I have been applying the same standards of critisizm to all parties,I do not try to defend one or the other. If you are right in what you say and believe then why should it bother you what other people say. Your 's and your friends answers are always laced with sarcasm directed at the writer and this kind of makes the whole issue less intellectual. Living in Pakistan and being politically involved by now should have taught you to be patient and take crisizm with humor.
Politics is not life or death,it is a way to achieve certain ends.Always keep the fact in mind whoever you defend or critisize that you are being honest in your effort and only you and Allah know that. One may be wrong, that is ok even with the best intentions because then Allah takes over and usually no great harm befalls the members.
May God guide and bless us all.
ps; I will keep pointing out, lets just stick to the leaders and issues.
© Copyrights 2008 - 2025 Siasat.pk - All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy | Disclaimer|