11th Hour - 21st May 2012 - Marvi Memon Vs Waseem Akhter - Formaton of " Muhajir Province " Issue

ReadWrite

Citizen
لعنت الطاف کے چمچوں پر جو جھوٹ اور منافقت کا پلندہ ہیں
ان کو بھی اسی طرح سڑک پر ذلیل کر کے مارنا چاہیے جیسے یہ غریبوں کو بے رحمی سے مارتےہیں - ان کا اور ان کے لیڈر کا انجام قذافی جیسا ہونا چاہیے - اللہ وہ دین سب کو دکھاۓ- آمیں
 

mkamd

MPA (400+ posts)
I do not see much logic in this argument. Province is an administrative issue not ethnic. India has divided several of their provinces. Other countries in the world do it all the time. In Karachi only 60% are Mohajir, remaining 40% are non Mohajir. Real issue is that those funds which are collected in Karachi, 90% of those are spent in Interior Sindh. Having seperate province does not mean that only Mohajir will get benefited. Everyone who lives in Karachi shall have the right. The reason Sindhi politician make it such a big issue and declare it as holy cow because they do not want to loose all the money the get in the name of Interior Sindh. Ironically, despite taking 90% of Sindh budget in the name of Interior for last 60 years, the life of ordinary Sindhi has not changed a bit and all money is taken by big landlords. If Sindhi would treat Karachi as their own city, gave fair share in jobs and developmental fund, then no one would ask for a seperate province today. If you want Karachi to feel like that its part of Sindh then you have to treat them as part of Sindh. Blame that Mohajir do not adopt Sindhi language or culture is unfair. Do Pathan or Punjabi in Sindh adopt Sindhi language or culture? As a matter of fact where Mohajir are fewer in Interior Sindh they have adopted Sindhi language & culture.To be honest the reason we are having this discussion today because for last 60 years we did not become one Pakistani Nation and did not treat each other fairly. Matter of fact is that still majority of Mohajir love & respect Sindhis for what they did for them 60 years ago. Even today if Sindhi leadership starts treating Mohajir as brother there won't be any popular demand for the seperate province.
 

mkamd

MPA (400+ posts)
Where is the evidence? How can we accept alleged blames on some one without any evidence. What if Marvi has personal bias against Mohajirs which has led her to blindly believe this allegation without evidence. If all blames are acceptable without any proof then tommarrow Altaf can say that Nawaz Sharif is behind all this in order to get even with PPP for what they did to him in Punjab. Honestly MQM do not get much from this as these were all powerless politician in Sindh, on the other hand Nawaz can get lot of momentum against PPP by hurting their ally..
 

iukhan

Banned
You be lying if you say that Altaf Hussain of mafia group is not behind this fiasco. Tell the truth you liers. This is your ultimate purpose. Don't be like sheeps. Shahzad Saddique ? A foot soldier and a front end of this ugly Monster.

This Marvi is hypocrite woman so as other n-league, q-league and MQM's politicians as they want to divide Pakhtunkhwa but not Sindh and Punjab because they know how these will effect their vote banks. So I request all Pakhtuns to bring awareness against the division of Pakhtunkhwa (our mother) and realize that we should never vote in the future these parties.
 
Last edited:

Back
Top