Unethical Material in comedy show KHABARDAR
- Thread starter jyvaskyla1
- Start date
ایک مصنوعی دانشور کا اچھا پوسٹ مارٹم ہے
بیچارہ آفتاب اقبال، انگلش زبان اورمغربی اقدار کو انسانیت کی معراج سمجھتا ہے
اسی لئے انگریزی کے الفاظ کی بھی ٹانگیں وغیرہ توڑتا رہتا ہے
لیکن مجال ہے کہ ایک جملہ روانی سے بول سکے
اردو کے کئی الفاظ کی اپنے تئیں اصلاح کروانے کے بعد
ماشا اللہ غلط ہی بولتا ہے
بیچارہ آفتاب اقبال، انگلش زبان اورمغربی اقدار کو انسانیت کی معراج سمجھتا ہے
اسی لئے انگریزی کے الفاظ کی بھی ٹانگیں وغیرہ توڑتا رہتا ہے
لیکن مجال ہے کہ ایک جملہ روانی سے بول سکے
اردو کے کئی الفاظ کی اپنے تئیں اصلاح کروانے کے بعد
ماشا اللہ غلط ہی بولتا ہے
jyvaskyla1
Councller (250+ posts)
rightly said......................
dangerous tears
Senator (1k+ posts)
راو صاحب غصہ جان دیو ۔اگر نہیں پسند پروگرام تو نا دیکھو ۔
jyvaskyla1
Councller (250+ posts)
lolz...does not mean that you allow people to advertise XX movies on media....
Siasi-Expert
Banned
Bhai Tu Piyya Hua Hai? Koi Aesi baat nai ki... bss Criticize karna hota hai ap jaisy logon ko...
Sharam kro yaar!!
Indian Songs b chalte hain aur Pakistani songs b...
Muslim Mashaheer teri soch se b zyada kiya hai.... jab b Mughal ki baat ki to usne Jahangir aur Babar, Abdaali ki b tareef ki..
----
Sharam kro yaar!!
Indian Songs b chalte hain aur Pakistani songs b...
Muslim Mashaheer teri soch se b zyada kiya hai.... jab b Mughal ki baat ki to usne Jahangir aur Babar, Abdaali ki b tareef ki..
----
Siasi-Expert
Banned
mein usko 2010 se follow kar raha hun uska Show waqayi buht funny hota hai..
Woh asal mein unn Comedians ko Awaam ki Jahalat portray kar raha hota hai k Awaam hmari ki soch iss tarah ki hai.
aik sabaq k liye, mene isske interviews b sunnay hain.. usme yeh explain b karta hai yeh baaten
mubarik Shah
Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
in one of his programs there was some discussion about surgical instruments and he was supposed to say word sanitized ..instead he used the term sensitized...
is ko boltay hain angraizee ki bud-hazmi
awan4ever
Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
Although I dont like AftabIqbal and his narcissism but this review did not make much sense either.
AftabIqbal is a pseudo-intellectual wannabe harfan-maula who loves praise and loves to show off how well read, well travelled and aware of pop-culture he is. That is why he likes to talk about cliched stuff over and over again and especially about foreign movies, books and characters.
However to criticize a one or two underhand juggats regarding a scene without overtly expressing anything explicit shouldnt be such a big issue that it required calling him out on social media. The audience has probably watched the movie and are grown ups so if they can watch the movie they can also hear a few jokes on it. If anyone hasnt watched it then they wont really get the context anyway so whats the harm then?
Coming to the issue of doing parodies of historical characters, he doesnt glorify anyone actually like Alexander for example. He calls him Alexander younani and not Alexander the Great and makes fun of him relentlessly. He has praised Raja Porus for bravely defending Punjab against the Greek onslaught. I really dont get how making a parody of Alexander is akin to glorifying him.
Coming to Mughals, they were Muslim rulers but they bent every rule in the book to hold on to power. They were Kings first and muslims second so why should they be revered like saints? Did they act like saints or kings? Why is making fun of Mughals the same as making fun of Islam? Mostly its Akbar and Shahjahan who are made fun of or Muhammad Shah Rangeela. Do you seriously think those guys should be revered as rulers? He has praised Dullah Bhatti for standing against Akbar because Bhatti was the son of the soil while Akbar was an invader.
As far as talking about Caliphs is concerned do you seriously think a comedy show where juggat baazi is the main attraction is the kind of forum for talking about truly revered saints of Islam? A devout man like Junaid Jamshed had to go through hell when something he said got picked up as an insult so imagine what would happen if something is taken out of context in a juggat theatre based show? Its smart of him to leave out sensitive topics from a comedy.
There are many things you can criticize AftabIqbal for but what was said in the review here did not bring any of those things up.
AftabIqbal is a pseudo-intellectual wannabe harfan-maula who loves praise and loves to show off how well read, well travelled and aware of pop-culture he is. That is why he likes to talk about cliched stuff over and over again and especially about foreign movies, books and characters.
However to criticize a one or two underhand juggats regarding a scene without overtly expressing anything explicit shouldnt be such a big issue that it required calling him out on social media. The audience has probably watched the movie and are grown ups so if they can watch the movie they can also hear a few jokes on it. If anyone hasnt watched it then they wont really get the context anyway so whats the harm then?
Coming to the issue of doing parodies of historical characters, he doesnt glorify anyone actually like Alexander for example. He calls him Alexander younani and not Alexander the Great and makes fun of him relentlessly. He has praised Raja Porus for bravely defending Punjab against the Greek onslaught. I really dont get how making a parody of Alexander is akin to glorifying him.
Coming to Mughals, they were Muslim rulers but they bent every rule in the book to hold on to power. They were Kings first and muslims second so why should they be revered like saints? Did they act like saints or kings? Why is making fun of Mughals the same as making fun of Islam? Mostly its Akbar and Shahjahan who are made fun of or Muhammad Shah Rangeela. Do you seriously think those guys should be revered as rulers? He has praised Dullah Bhatti for standing against Akbar because Bhatti was the son of the soil while Akbar was an invader.
As far as talking about Caliphs is concerned do you seriously think a comedy show where juggat baazi is the main attraction is the kind of forum for talking about truly revered saints of Islam? A devout man like Junaid Jamshed had to go through hell when something he said got picked up as an insult so imagine what would happen if something is taken out of context in a juggat theatre based show? Its smart of him to leave out sensitive topics from a comedy.
There are many things you can criticize AftabIqbal for but what was said in the review here did not bring any of those things up.
Raaz
(50k+ posts) بابائے فورم
What a crap this Rao is .....
یہ بیچارہ جیلسی کا مرا ہے
کیوں کہ آفتاب اقبال کا پروگران شاید سب سے بہتر جا رہا ہے
کبھی اس نے ڈاکٹر مبارک علی کی کتابیں پڑھی ہیں جو مغلوں کے بارے میں ہیں
http://www.drmubarakali.org/urdu.html
آپ یہ پڑھیں آپ کو پتہ چل جاۓ گا کہ اصلیت کیا تھی مغلوں کی
جتنی نالج کوئی بندہ اس پروگرام سے حاصل کرتا ہے کوئی اور مزاحیہ پروگرام نہی دے سکتا
http://www.drmubarakali.org/assets/mughol-derbar.pdf
یہ بیچارہ جیلسی کا مرا ہے
کیوں کہ آفتاب اقبال کا پروگران شاید سب سے بہتر جا رہا ہے
کبھی اس نے ڈاکٹر مبارک علی کی کتابیں پڑھی ہیں جو مغلوں کے بارے میں ہیں
http://www.drmubarakali.org/urdu.html
آپ یہ پڑھیں آپ کو پتہ چل جاۓ گا کہ اصلیت کیا تھی مغلوں کی
جتنی نالج کوئی بندہ اس پروگرام سے حاصل کرتا ہے کوئی اور مزاحیہ پروگرام نہی دے سکتا
http://www.drmubarakali.org/assets/mughol-derbar.pdf
Raaz
(50k+ posts) بابائے فورم
اس قوم کو مذھب کے نام پر جتنا مرضی بے وقوف بنا لو بن جائیں گے
لوگ اپنی دشمنی نکلنے کے لئے اسلام کا کہہ کر آگ لگا دیں گے
میں محسوس کر رہا تھا کہ اسوقت سب سے ٹاپ پر پروگرام جا رہا ہے
اب عزیزی جیسے بھانڈوں نے کچھ تو کرنا تھا
خامی ہر ایک میں ہوتی ہے
sensible
Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
I believe Aftab Iqbal's show is better than every other comedy show. All other shows gone beyond moral values. He often praise good muslim rulers like Sher Shah Soori, Tipu sultan and few others.
Regarding other Mughals if they did bad things then I do not see any issue in mentioning those
Regarding other Mughals if they did bad things then I do not see any issue in mentioning those
aamir_uetn
Prime Minister (20k+ posts)
مطلب کوئی ڈرگز بیچنا چاہے تو اس کی دکان داری خراب نہیں کرنی چاہیے کیونکہ وہ بیچارہ چاٹ یا فالودہ تو بیچ نہیں سکتا
