To Naeem Moderator, u edited my comment reason no Pak Army bashing, can we ask why???

[rtabasum2]

Why r they holy cows now, u can bash prime Minister, President who is the head of Armed forces, judiciary, police but Army is sacred of sacred now. They cannot be criticized for wrong policies, can Adeel confirm that this is now an Army Forum so we can decide whether to stay on this Forum or not. Naeem plz don't delete this thread it is something all the members would be interested in having an opinion. Thank you

rtabasum2

Expert​

Re: Shut up Mr Prime Minister I am Really Sorry

Can somebody say shut up too this butcher​

Last edited by Naeem; Today at 05:07 PM. Reason: no pak army bashing allowed please​

 

[alimohsan52]

​I support Rauf Tabasums right to free speech, he has every right to be critical of the army even if we do not agree with it.

PS I AM STILL UNSURE WHETHER RAUF IS A BOY OR A GIRL

 

[NohmnAli]

If his points were valid and criticism was constructive then I think every one siasat.pk should second this.

 

[desan]

Please avoid making these derogatory remarks against our patriotic dollar munching generals, else get ready for being called a traitor...

 

[rtabasum2]

​I support Rauf Tabasums right to free speech

I damn care abt ur support .

 

[Politcs]

Pakistan army is now trying to silent every voice. You will see more mass graves in Balochistan but media will call them that these graves are. 4000 years old.

 

[Usama Tayyab]

:PRauf chill out man, drink some water

See what happens when you show your kind concern and sympathies to other Pakistani. Hence proved apnay kam se kam rakha jaye.

 

[Wadaich]

@rtabasum U may get the constitution of Pakistan changed or declared void ab initio ........ and get all the people out of their graves and hanged for the crime they did against your wishes.

 

[handsome.ebi]

Pak army bashing is something very normel on this forum, i dont know how this moderator dared to commit such mistake

 

[Joker]

Please avoid making these derogatory remarks against our patriotic dollar munching generals, else get ready for being called a traitor...

بڑی بہن تو بڑی بہن ، چھوٹی بہن سبحان الله

 

[Zameen]

Moderators, Permanently BAN thread starter [hilar]

 

[jagga9]

Pakistan army is now trying to silent every voice. You will see more mass graves in Balochistan but media will call them that these graves are. 4000 years old.

General Zia's touts are not allowed to talk on this topic please ...

Only genuine political workers are allowed.

 

[jagga9]

بڑی بہن تو بڑی بہن ، چھوٹی بہن سبحان الله

جنرل ضیاء کی گود میں پلنے والے اسلامک جمہوری اتحاد والے یہاں بات کر کے اپنا منہ کالا نہکرں ...




اس ٹوپک پر بات صرف حقیقی سیاسی ورکر ہی کر سکتے ہیں ....

 

[aqeelpk12]

Language of rtabasum2 can be seen here in this post and people can read my replies to him :)

http://www.siasat.pk/forum/showthre...ameron-apologises/page3&p=2358618#post2358618

 

[pakikiwi]

See what happens when you show your kind concern and sympathies to other Pakistani. Hence proved apnay kam se kam rakha jaye.

hahah ! That's was classical, Phir Bewaja hamdardi nahi kare ga

 

[A_Yaseen]

There is a difference between right to be critical of the army and make routine to bash the army. Most of the people supported your stance against MQM but now if you are allowing the thread starter to express anything thing then you should allow Altaf Hussain to say any thing against any body. You can not make laws and rules as you wish. This forum is a Pakistani forum and it has to be under constitutions like it or not. I was against Altaf Hussain wording at that time and will be against anyone who uses such language as MQM chief did.

To answer rtabassum:
This forum is about Pakistani politics so like all people this forum are obliged to work under the constitution of Pakistan. Article 63 G of the constitution consider it treason to talk against Army. So if you want to talk against Army then first change the constitution and if you can then feel free to bash the Army. If not then feel free to join any other Indian or Anti Pakistani forum.

You asked the question that why can anyone talk against ministers, prime ministers. Then firstly you can not talk against Judiciary because if someone reported any post against Judiciary then the Admins can be under serious trouble. Talking against Judiciary is not clear in the constitution but it is defined by the judiciary itself. Secondly change the consititution and add the clause that no body can talk against prime minsters, president and ministers then no body will.

​I support Rauf Tabasums right to free speech, he has every right to be critical of the army even if we do not agree with it.

 

[Pak Falcon]

Dear Moderator Naeem, keep it up we are with you!

 

[kaalashaa]

Maybe because u ahould bash other wrong doers first, like noora etc. n then come to army which will always be the last standing entity with Pakistan!

 

[Pak Falcon]

Jisnay jitni b pak fouj par bakwas karni hai wo baraye meherbani Indians ya TTP k forums par jakay karay!

 

[A_Yaseen]

I also failed to understand the nature and attitude of few people. They are against Taliban and on the other side they are against Army. Army should be supported no matter what if the war against Taliban has to be won. So this a question to these people that do you know who are you with? You are with Taliban or Amy? If you say none then how this can be true and if it is true then then who have a choice? In war time you have to neglect many mistakes done by Army and have to wait for the right time. You all support political parties of your choice who appoint Army chiefs, ISI chiefs so if you have problem with these chiefs then why don't you grab your leaders from their neck. If they have appointed bad people then still the political leaders have to answer. I think this is the upper limit to the hypocrisy.