Re: The new proposed Map of New Middle East by Yahood-o-Nisara-o-Hanood
Some alternations in the Map are good for Muslim world..
1.... Kurdistan..... Kurd deserve a state
2.... Sunni Iraq.... if sunni think they cannot live in Iraq with Shia Majority
3....Arab Shia state.... It will be good for Saudi Arabian and Arab Iranian Shias to Join Iraqi Shias in Arab shias state
4... Idea of Islamic Sacred State is also a good one, Every Muslim should be allowed to enter this state without visa.
5... Joining Afghanistans Herat region with Persia is also a good Idea
Some Alternations which are not viable
1... If Balochs of Pakistan and Iran want a separate statehood they deserve it but the problem is the region is very thinly populated and backward if Pakistani and Iranian Armys start a Operation like Pakistani Army did in East Pakistan that will be catastrophic for Balochs to survive it as a people.
2... It is impossible for Tajiks, Hazaras and Pastuns to live in peace together in Afghanistan.
3....It will also impossible for Hazarawal, Kohistanis, Chatrilis ,Baltis, Hunzs and Shinas to join Pushtun dominated Afghanistan with there own free will.
4... It will be easy for the Pashtuns of Balochistan and Fata to Join their Pushtun tribesmen across Duradline. But it will be very difficult and catastrophic for the Pushtuns of KPK as their culture and traditions are different.
5... In some areas there is great intermixing of Pathans and Punjabies separation without bloodshed is impossible.
6... Sindhis will not like to live in projected Pakistan in this Map under overwhelming Punjabi domination