salmakh84
Politcal Worker (100+ posts)
People (esp Zaid Hamid etc) are trying to create rifts between mujahideen by claiming that all mujahideen are seperate.. raw agents etc.. this is totally untrue..
For some proofs see a old thread (I dont agree with Mehwish_ali's view but some points are valid: http://www.siasat.pk/forum/showthre...n-and-Pakistani-Talibans-are-the-one-and-same)
I am creating different thread due to differences in opinion and point of view and more concrete proofs
1: Ex CIA officer denies Pakistan helping Alqaeda (he was the one whose name was leaked in Pakistani newspapers and had to leave I think)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CpWcoTXQ7Rc&feature=player_embedded
2: CIA bomber in khost who killed many cia agents was under training from TTP (he also got help from aghani talibs)
Video: http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=9F-VO1MAoX0
&
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=d27_1263042354
3: An excerpt from Mullah Omer's letter. Yes, he doesn't directly take Pakistan's name, but than he doesnt say he is against it.. Original Pashtu letter is on Jamia Hafsa forum. He gives a message every Eid
"Wage Jihad (holy war) against America and its allies, and if one cannot fight he should quit his job and separate himself from them," the Pashtu-language letter stated.
The letter was faxed late on Sunday to the daily Wahdat newspaper in the north-west city of Peshawar, under the name of Mullah Omar, who has eluded the 10,000 strong US-led military coalition for 16 months. Peshawar lies 40 kilometres frrom the Afghan border.
The author referred to a fatwa issued in May "by 1,600 senior ulemas (Islamic scholars)."
"Infidels have encroached on Islam and today America is committing atrocities against Muslims, so jihad is absolutely compulsory for all Muslims.
"Anyone of you who helps infidels or serves them in any manner deserves to die."
The letter condemned Muslims who had "abandoned their duty to do jihad and joined savage America and its allies' armies." (for fatwa, see shamsheer bayniam, link at the end of post)
4: Many Alqaeda/TTP/Afghan mujahideen have been caught by Pakistani Agencies/Army (including many who were killed/tortured/sent to guantanamo etc). Pakistan agencies dont really differentiate, but YES, THEY KEEP A SLIGHTLY LIGHT HAND ON AFGHANIS due to strategic reasons
5: Recent attacks in Dir & Chitral. read the news. Our army claimed it was Afghani Talibans & Swati Talibans who attacked Pakistan...
also, see this:
(Afghani Taliban are helping Pakistani Extremists: Pak Army DG ISPR)
6: Pakistani Officials (PM, President etc) have repeatedly claimed that there is no difference in Talibans.
7: Some statement by Hizb Tahrir (I may not agree with all points with them, but they show HOW ISI is an american puppet: http://www.htmediapk.page.tl/PR-06-09-11.htm
8: More than 150 FLIGHTS DAILY by NATO Aircrafts from Pakistani Airspace. (Source: http://www.dawn.com/2011/09/07/pakistans-airspace-being-used-by-nato-flights-cable.html)
9: Pakistan Army fights the Taliban to get even the Debris of the drones they (taliban) destroy.
(http://www.siasat.pk/forum/showthread.php?80618-Pakistani-troops-Snatch-US-drone-debris-from-Taliban)
10: And most important, A video by the taliban proving they are one called Bunyan um Marsoos
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=968_1315256491
(low quality like youtube)
or you can download it from: (same video)
http://www.archive.org/download/bonian_marsos/mrs1.avi
or
http://www.archive.org/download/osod_mmzz43/mrs1.avi
(high quality, its 450MB. Please see video before commenting) Will post a smaller link of liveleak (video is longer than 10 minutes therefore not on YouTube)
11. Saleem Safi says Afghan Taliban & TTP are same: https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?v=195919213905278&set=vb.202307566569973&type=2&theater
12. Siraj-ud-din Haqqani (of the famous haqqani network) says TTP are our brothers! www.youtube.com/watch?v=LHELfc5jK94
13. Afghan Taliban's official website saying Hakimullah was "martyred" (shaheed) in American drone strike! http://shahamat-english.com/index.p...ing-the-martyrdom-of-mullah-hakimullah-mehsud (Quote: We consider the martyrdom of Mullah Hakimullah to be a great loss and offer our heartfelt condolences to his family, relatives and friends. Muslims consider martyrdom a lofty objective and we all strive to achieve this status. If America believes that by martyring Mujahideen they will somehow create a void and reach their selfish aims then they are greatly mistaken.)
14. Many Afghan Taliban are still in Pakistan prison. Many high profile Afghan Taliban were caught by ISI and handed over to USA (e.g Taliban Envoy (safeer) Mulla Abdul Salam Zaeef (Google for his video and how he was tortured by Pakistani and American agencies). Pakistan claimed they released Mullah Baradar but Afghan Taliban offical site said he is still under the prison of "infidels" and he has NOT been released!
15. Both want sharia. Both kill American agents and allies. Both kill local police and army.
16. Another big proof: See the book of Lt. Gen (ret) Shahid Aziz (who was on frontline in war on terror). He says it clearly, Pakistan Army helps kuffar and kills muslims!
17. Mullah Fazlullah (new ttp chief after Hakimulla) has Mullah Omer's backing! ( http://www.thenews.com.pk/Todays-News-13-26529-Fazlullah-has-Mulla-Omars-backing )
18. Even Sherry Rehman said in an interview that TTP was created by Afghan Taliban (mullah dadullah) after 2007! (Google for video)
19. See what "Good" Taliban Hafiz Gul Bahadur says to our Army: https://pbs.twimg.com/media/BX_NDMHCcAAIJWp.jpg
20. Afghan Taliban release a video called "Badari Lashkar Part 4" (https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?v=432962560171138) and pay big tribute to Nek Muhammed, Baitullah Mehsud and Hakimullah Mehsud of TTP, all martyred in US Drone Strikes!!
21. 17 Afgan and TTP members killed in drone strike in Kunar (8 April 2014): http://www.khaama.com/17-senior-pakistani-and-afghan-taliban-leaders-killed-in-kunar-airstrike-3543
22. Documentary by award winning Al-Jazeera Journalist shows Taliban attack on Afghan Army outpost, later views of afghan taliban regarding Pakistan Army.. (hint: no so good). lols
:Link:
http://www.dailymotion.com/video/x1o7bh7_fault-lines-on-the-front-lines-with-the-taliban_news or https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tt1yUx-MoNo
23. Whenever there is dispute in the TTP, their elders, Afghan Taliban settle it! Link: http://tribune.com.pk/story/700477/afghan-taliban-broker-ceasefire-between-rival-ttp-factions/
24. Recently (30 May 2014) released pamphlet by Hafiz Gul Bahadur, a known "Afghan Taliban" who has a deal with army says DONT SEND FIGHTERS TO AFGHANISTAN CAUSE WE GONNA FIGHT ARMY HERE!
All the taliban's are on board with that decision. Do you still think they are seperate? THINK AGAIN
There are many more!!
For those of you who want the detailed fatwa against pakistan army, search for the book "Shamsheer e Bayniam" (link: http://www.4shared.com/file/HG2AWxN0/Shamsheer_bay_nayam_sheikhAbuY.html)
For some proofs see a old thread (I dont agree with Mehwish_ali's view but some points are valid: http://www.siasat.pk/forum/showthre...n-and-Pakistani-Talibans-are-the-one-and-same)
I am creating different thread due to differences in opinion and point of view and more concrete proofs

1: Ex CIA officer denies Pakistan helping Alqaeda (he was the one whose name was leaked in Pakistani newspapers and had to leave I think)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CpWcoTXQ7Rc&feature=player_embedded
2: CIA bomber in khost who killed many cia agents was under training from TTP (he also got help from aghani talibs)
Video: http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=9F-VO1MAoX0
&
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=d27_1263042354
3: An excerpt from Mullah Omer's letter. Yes, he doesn't directly take Pakistan's name, but than he doesnt say he is against it.. Original Pashtu letter is on Jamia Hafsa forum. He gives a message every Eid
"Wage Jihad (holy war) against America and its allies, and if one cannot fight he should quit his job and separate himself from them," the Pashtu-language letter stated.
The letter was faxed late on Sunday to the daily Wahdat newspaper in the north-west city of Peshawar, under the name of Mullah Omar, who has eluded the 10,000 strong US-led military coalition for 16 months. Peshawar lies 40 kilometres frrom the Afghan border.
The author referred to a fatwa issued in May "by 1,600 senior ulemas (Islamic scholars)."
"Infidels have encroached on Islam and today America is committing atrocities against Muslims, so jihad is absolutely compulsory for all Muslims.
"Anyone of you who helps infidels or serves them in any manner deserves to die."
The letter condemned Muslims who had "abandoned their duty to do jihad and joined savage America and its allies' armies." (for fatwa, see shamsheer bayniam, link at the end of post)
4: Many Alqaeda/TTP/Afghan mujahideen have been caught by Pakistani Agencies/Army (including many who were killed/tortured/sent to guantanamo etc). Pakistan agencies dont really differentiate, but YES, THEY KEEP A SLIGHTLY LIGHT HAND ON AFGHANIS due to strategic reasons
5: Recent attacks in Dir & Chitral. read the news. Our army claimed it was Afghani Talibans & Swati Talibans who attacked Pakistan...
also, see this:

(Afghani Taliban are helping Pakistani Extremists: Pak Army DG ISPR)
6: Pakistani Officials (PM, President etc) have repeatedly claimed that there is no difference in Talibans.

7: Some statement by Hizb Tahrir (I may not agree with all points with them, but they show HOW ISI is an american puppet: http://www.htmediapk.page.tl/PR-06-09-11.htm
8: More than 150 FLIGHTS DAILY by NATO Aircrafts from Pakistani Airspace. (Source: http://www.dawn.com/2011/09/07/pakistans-airspace-being-used-by-nato-flights-cable.html)
9: Pakistan Army fights the Taliban to get even the Debris of the drones they (taliban) destroy.
(http://www.siasat.pk/forum/showthread.php?80618-Pakistani-troops-Snatch-US-drone-debris-from-Taliban)
10: And most important, A video by the taliban proving they are one called Bunyan um Marsoos
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=968_1315256491
(low quality like youtube)
or you can download it from: (same video)
http://www.archive.org/download/bonian_marsos/mrs1.avi
or
http://www.archive.org/download/osod_mmzz43/mrs1.avi
(high quality, its 450MB. Please see video before commenting) Will post a smaller link of liveleak (video is longer than 10 minutes therefore not on YouTube)
11. Saleem Safi says Afghan Taliban & TTP are same: https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?v=195919213905278&set=vb.202307566569973&type=2&theater
12. Siraj-ud-din Haqqani (of the famous haqqani network) says TTP are our brothers! www.youtube.com/watch?v=LHELfc5jK94
13. Afghan Taliban's official website saying Hakimullah was "martyred" (shaheed) in American drone strike! http://shahamat-english.com/index.p...ing-the-martyrdom-of-mullah-hakimullah-mehsud (Quote: We consider the martyrdom of Mullah Hakimullah to be a great loss and offer our heartfelt condolences to his family, relatives and friends. Muslims consider martyrdom a lofty objective and we all strive to achieve this status. If America believes that by martyring Mujahideen they will somehow create a void and reach their selfish aims then they are greatly mistaken.)
14. Many Afghan Taliban are still in Pakistan prison. Many high profile Afghan Taliban were caught by ISI and handed over to USA (e.g Taliban Envoy (safeer) Mulla Abdul Salam Zaeef (Google for his video and how he was tortured by Pakistani and American agencies). Pakistan claimed they released Mullah Baradar but Afghan Taliban offical site said he is still under the prison of "infidels" and he has NOT been released!
15. Both want sharia. Both kill American agents and allies. Both kill local police and army.
16. Another big proof: See the book of Lt. Gen (ret) Shahid Aziz (who was on frontline in war on terror). He says it clearly, Pakistan Army helps kuffar and kills muslims!
17. Mullah Fazlullah (new ttp chief after Hakimulla) has Mullah Omer's backing! ( http://www.thenews.com.pk/Todays-News-13-26529-Fazlullah-has-Mulla-Omars-backing )
18. Even Sherry Rehman said in an interview that TTP was created by Afghan Taliban (mullah dadullah) after 2007! (Google for video)
19. See what "Good" Taliban Hafiz Gul Bahadur says to our Army: https://pbs.twimg.com/media/BX_NDMHCcAAIJWp.jpg
20. Afghan Taliban release a video called "Badari Lashkar Part 4" (https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?v=432962560171138) and pay big tribute to Nek Muhammed, Baitullah Mehsud and Hakimullah Mehsud of TTP, all martyred in US Drone Strikes!!
21. 17 Afgan and TTP members killed in drone strike in Kunar (8 April 2014): http://www.khaama.com/17-senior-pakistani-and-afghan-taliban-leaders-killed-in-kunar-airstrike-3543
22. Documentary by award winning Al-Jazeera Journalist shows Taliban attack on Afghan Army outpost, later views of afghan taliban regarding Pakistan Army.. (hint: no so good). lols
:Link:
http://www.dailymotion.com/video/x1o7bh7_fault-lines-on-the-front-lines-with-the-taliban_news or https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tt1yUx-MoNo
23. Whenever there is dispute in the TTP, their elders, Afghan Taliban settle it! Link: http://tribune.com.pk/story/700477/afghan-taliban-broker-ceasefire-between-rival-ttp-factions/
24. Recently (30 May 2014) released pamphlet by Hafiz Gul Bahadur, a known "Afghan Taliban" who has a deal with army says DONT SEND FIGHTERS TO AFGHANISTAN CAUSE WE GONNA FIGHT ARMY HERE!

All the taliban's are on board with that decision. Do you still think they are seperate? THINK AGAIN
There are many more!!
For those of you who want the detailed fatwa against pakistan army, search for the book "Shamsheer e Bayniam" (link: http://www.4shared.com/file/HG2AWxN0/Shamsheer_bay_nayam_sheikhAbuY.html)
Last edited: