Professor Ahmad Rafiq Akhtar answering Imran khan's Question

[ishwaq]

I have never heard this man talking good about anybody...he always talk bad about others...

 

[Nice2MU]

khattaksahib
And please tell me how Imran khan was playing with your religious sentiments? Just by asking a simple question?
And it was a genuine question too. Why Pakistan has become the epic centre of all evil, corruption, rape, murder, kidnap,target killing and looting when a huge number of jamat people working to stop such things, and why it is not working. Heck you can't even find pure milk medicine, not even mirchi, and we are ready to collapse. Don't you think it was an honest question?
[HI]And your sentiments got hurt by a question. If any body was playing with your sentiments, it should be the professor with his answer, and not Imran with his question.
And who gave you the authority to call ullama juhala?
You say they are presenting the true picture of Islam. Do you know them that good? Did you spend some time with them, a week-end, 40 days,4months,a year?
Do you think they do what they tell others to do? Because if they don't, you should know who they could be,
[/HI]

Similar questions are replied differently by people based on their knowledge, experience and belief. If IMRAN KHAN ask the same question from Moulana Tariq Jameel, he will get completely different response. Additionally, it is said that 'if you want to judge someone intellectualness then concentrate on approach of asking question rather then approach of answering'. What was the need of asking such disputable question? What he wanted to listen from this professor? Every thing become clear, once you think positively. However,
1. If IMRAN was ignorant of this professor's mental approach, ideology etc etc then its IMRAN's mistake.
2. How can Tableeghi Jummat be held responsible for commitment of crimes in society. Its not tableegh, which teaches them to be thief, be corrupt etc etc. While I have already witnessed hundreds' of people, who left bad life after joining Tableegh. One of the tablighi Jummat motivated more than thousands non muslims to embrace Islam during their campaign in African country(I personally has met that Jummat members).

If you are aware of Islamic preachings then you must have read in books that "near Qayamat, these will be ullema, who will mislead the muslims towards path of Shaitann rather that that of Allah". If someone destroy my this world, I can forgive him but anyone who tries to destroy my Akherat, I can never.

And don't take so offensive about IMRAN KHAN. He is not only your leader, I also do respect him But the thing is that he should never indulge himself in those avenues, which don't belong to him. No one can justify his stance of asking question of this nature from person of that nature.

I had been with Tablighi Jumaat for quite some time and I have never listen any word from them against other like what this Professor A Rafiq Sahib is doing.

I agree with you if such question would ask from Tariq Jamil Sahib, he would answer with Hikma and wouldn't declare themselves only The Right and wouldn't talk against any sects.....

All the Islamic Groups are working for the preaching of Islam which shows their Love for Islam and Prophet (PBUH) but I like Tablighis because they don't talk against others. They just ask people to spend their lives according to Allah and Prophet (PBHU) teaching of Islam not the rest. Is it wrong?

 

[Reviver]

I have never heard this man talking good about anybody...he always talk bad about others...

Watch you mouth Sheikh Touseefur Rehman is true salafi muslim and lives in Jaddah

 

[NO FEAR]

People can read books and lecture of Prof Akhtar Rafique Ahmed at http://www.alamaat.com/

 

[Nice2MU]

Watch you mouth Sheikh Touseefur Rehman is true salafi muslim and lives in Jaddah

HAHAHA................Man what is mean by Salafi Muslim? Which Salafi Group he belongs to ? Why didn't you call him "The True Muslim"

Further Living in Jaddah doesn't mean that "He becomes True Muslim"

Dear True Muslims doesn't talk about others without any proof and this person talks against every Religious Group in Pakistan, which shows he doesn't consider anyone Right in Pakistan. Only he considers right himself.

 

[ishwaq]

HAHAHA................Man what is mean by Salafi Muslim? Which Salafi Group he belongs to ? Why didn't you call him "The True Muslim"

Further Living in Jaddah doesn't mean that "He becomes True Muslim"

Dear True Muslims doesn't talk about others without any proof and this person talks against every Religious Group in Pakistan, which shows he doesn't consider anyone Right in Pakistan. Only he considers right himself.

I agree with you 100%.:jazak:

 

[hassan.te]

I have not seen such a stupid person like this so called professor. First of all i also dont have any tag on me that i belong to tableegi jamat or some other....i am just a muslim, thats it. Tableegi jamat had never called themselves as any jamat. its the people who named them. Yes this is the fact when u r asking to a person to get into the way of Allah, its not like that he is an aalim. He is a student who is in the way of Allah to learn and correct himself. Every Muslim who get into the way of Allah to preach is infact also in search of ilm. I am a welleducated person as we see on the standards of this worldly education. I had been in search of the real soul of islam, visited many Ulama but i remeber the one illetrate person from sindh, who was moving in jamat and he made a speech in the masjid, he shaked me to the very root of every hair....so its necessary who is carrying khair for some 1...some aalim or just an ordinary man.... This guy is stupid who is saying that i will never be doing tableeg to some 1 and is denying completely the order of Quran in end of his speeech that KUNTUM KHAIR UMMATIN UHRIJAT LINNAS TAAMROONA BILMAARUFI WA TANHAUNA ANIL MUNKAR...

 

[Jaldikar]

 

[Adeel]

The guy makes a lot of sense

 

[Nice2MU]

The guy makes a lot of sense

I think you missed the "non", which would make the sentence as "The guy makes a lot of non-sense"

 

[Adeel]

I think you missed the "non", which would make the sentence as "The guy makes a lot of non-sense"

Elaborate please

 

[Jaldikar]

 

[Salik]

I think Professor was over board this time....so did the tableeghi brother while replying to him... ....

I wish we could learn to appreciate each other's good work rather than mocking each other....

 

[karachiwala]

khattaksahib
You have your sweat discussion trying to prove that you are less jahil than the professor
but why drag Imran Khan into this?

Imran Khan should be asking the question from Tablighi Jamaat and NOT an ignorant professor. This professor guy is a complete idiot. Imran Khan should also know that you ask questions from relevant people. This I think is the wrong approach of Imran Khan when it comes to Islam. I think he can only read English so he is dependent on Europeans for the interpretation of Islam as well.

 

[Saboo]

babadeena
Why you say those things which you do not do?
You found the problem right there. If we ever listen and try to solve
the problem. I guess not.
I have nothing more to add.

 

[Saboo]

Imran Khan should be asking the question from Tablighi Jamaat and NOT an ignorant professor. This professor guy is a complete idiot. Imran Khan should also know that you ask questions from relevant people. This I think is the wrong approach of Imran Khan when it comes to Islam. I think he can only read English so he is dependent on Europeans for the interpretation of Islam as well.

Oh my God!
How can you say such nasty things about others, without even knowing them properly?
I bet you, some of you will be dead by the time this discussion is over.

 

[alibaba222]

mojhye tu Imran khan per hansi a rahee he us nay sawal bhee kis insan say keya jisy Quran bhee sahee nahee perhna a raha ,Allah reham farmeye ham logo per

 

[pakistan_pak]

mojhye tu Imran khan per hansi a rahee he us nay sawal bhee kis insan say keya jisy Quran bhee sahee nahee perhna a raha ,Allah reham farmeye ham logo per

i dont find any difference between this so called prof and Rahman malik.

 

[abba-tera]

Tableghi Jamaat wale bohat naik log hain

 

[samar]

I had been with Tablighi Jumaat for quite some time and I have never listen any word from them against other like what this Professor A Rafiq Sahib is doing.

I agree with you if such question would ask from Tariq Jamil Sahib, he would answer with Hikma and wouldn't declare themselves only The Right and wouldn't talk against any sects.....

All the Islamic Groups are working for the preaching of Islam which shows their Love for Islam and Prophet (PBUH) but I like Tablighis because they don't talk against others. They just ask people to spend their lives according to Allah and Prophet (PBHU) teaching of Islam not the rest. Is it wrong?

Brother thats your observation but that does not counter the points raised by professor sahab.

baki achey burey log hr jaga paey jatey hain.