Lal masjid operation, and musharaf per ilzam

[Khan.paki]

I have started this new thread so people can fairly, and honestly discuss this myth of lal masjid operation. Guys be honest and be fair not just because you dont like musharraf, and you start abusing him and write against him.

hum log ghalat ko ghalat nahi kehtay, dartey hain, kabhi in mazhabi inteha pasando se, kabhi in elehdgi pasandoo se, jiss ka result aj sab log apni aankho se karachi aur balochistan main dekh rahey hain.

now as far as lal masjid is concern, every one knows and every single day of this operation coverage is availbel on media as proof of what i am saying,

i will ask few questions?

kiya wo armed nahi thay?
kiya us ko enough time nHi diya gaya?
kiya un se mazakray nahi kiye gaye?
kiya IMAM e KABA ne un se request nahi ki? Ke yeh sab kuch chor do aur mazakrat kar lo?
kiya un logo ne armed forces ka muqabla nahi kiya?
kiya hamre commados shaheed nahi hue?
kiya us masjid main weapen nahi thay?


there are million of other questions which you can ask yourself, and then doscuss and tell people that what is true. Guys aik cheez main janta hoo,musharaf use to make decions a the right time, i also agree few of his decision are not very good anyways he is also a human like us.

Lal masjid operation 100% justified i support him on that, if iwere him i woukd do same even wrost to deal with these people who threaten my country.

please healthy and fair discussion. No abusing. Talk with daleel

 

[shtudent]

i kno.media ny u turn lia.kuch bura b hoa.bt one thing i kno..khan.paki tmhy galia dy log .is py.sorry to say

 

[shtudent]

sincerely (clap)nice thread

 

[hassanattique]

Answer to your questions are fairly simple. This operation cannot be justified. First thing if you dont know then let me tell you that still there are army persons who refuse to do the operation the way their officers are ordering and still in Army prisons. I am telling this because the person who met those people in Army prison told me. That is another story how he end up in Army Prison. Second kia ap ki army itni farig hy ky they cant do commando operation and try to arrest the people inside. Cant they use weapons jo unn ko bayhoos krr daitay instead of using Bombs that can only kill. There were small childrens and girls They may be wrong but as a state its your duty to not to kill them but try to arrest them so that after some time some of them can get to right path you have to give chance. The other method they can use was to cut all the electricity water sources and just wait aik na aik din unhoo ny haar manani hee thee. They opted a wrong way for the operation. Personnely i am very much pro Pak army but in this matter i cant agree with them how they carried out the operation.

 

[Khansaber]

HOW YOU GUYS FORGOT MILLION MARCH DONE TO SAVE LAL MASJID OPERATION BY Mr Qadri ....ik wasn`t that politically powerful so i`ll give him break for not stepping up and enjoying democratic convention and PMLN wasn`t in power .

 

[zhohaq]

Please start by putting up what you think actually happened, so we get an idea how deluded you are.

Just the basics the background how did it start, who were the ,players, the negotiations, the breakdown and the operation.And finally the casualties.

 

[Pure_pakistani]

​muasharraf did absolutely well

 

[zee4zubair]

EVEN THOUGH, WHATEVER HE DID NOBODY CAN JUSTIFY THIS ACT OF TERROR/WAR ON HIS OWN CITIZENS. :angry_smile::angry_smile:

 

[insaf-seeker]

Musharraf iss dunya say jaye ga nahin iss jurm ki saza paye baghair (In Sha Allah)

 

[FaisalKh]

[TUNEDOTPK][/TUNEDOTPK]There is also a scholar's video who was negotiating nd he was crying nd begging to stop this operation. I also heard in same video or another that the major general sahab asked the negotiator to finish as no matter wat happens they have to do operation. What is the truth, only ALLAH paak knows but my heart does not want me to believe that a person who has only one son can sacrifice his son just for power nd a man will sacrifice his mother for the same cause. I m also army supporter but i do not support this act becoz there were other peaceful options available. By the way lal masjid is just by police station nd ISI headquarter as i heard one of the reporter mentioning this. Nd the credibility would be that they should have left the common people nd journallists to go straightaway after they proclaimed victory rather than waiting for two days and "planting" everything. ALLAH paak hi insaf karega chahe wo ghazi rasheed hai ya army ya wo ranger or commando jinhon ne apni jaanain dee is tareek incident mai. U should listen to ghazi rasheed's last telephonic interview with tv channel nd be neutral nd think deep nd then decide urself nd also the tone of his voice nd that a person who knows will be killed any soon can tell lie????

 

[Wiki_]

Only answer to your question is: All terrorism, suicide bombing and TTP is the result of this operation!!!
Electricity cut, food and water supply cut, tear gas usage and many other tactics could have saved many lives .. Army got angry and therevenge of one Ranger's death was the beginning of this CHAOS we are living in today.

 

[saqi81]

Very good thread and this was a 100% correct decision. Every 1 was on same page even media, Hamid Mir told Musharif he ill not say anything against this operation. Imam of Kabbalah talked to them and Edhi as well . They deserved to be treated lyk dat.

 

[Believer12]

That operation was right and no doubt enemies of Pakistan were sitting inside under the protection of Burqa sarkar moulvis. They kidnapped foreigners and insult our citizens particularly women.they occupied govt property such as public liberary and school for girls.
This operation was necessary and history will appreciat Pervaiz Musharaf over this brave decision.
Today courts are under the fear of terrorists and not a single person got penality from courts. But in near future courts will appreciate Musharaf action.

 

[saqi81]

Answer to your questions are fairly simple. This operation cannot be justified. First thing if you dont know then let me tell you that still there are army persons who refuse to do the operation the way their officers are ordering and still in Army prisons. I am telling this because the person who met those people in Army prison told me. That is another story how he end up in Army Prison. Second kia ap ki army itni farig hy ky they cant do commando operation and try to arrest the people inside. Cant they use weapons jo unn ko bayhoos krr daitay instead of using Bombs that can only kill. There were small childrens and girls They may be wrong but as a state its your duty to not to kill them but try to arrest them so that after some time some of them can get to right path you have to give chance. The other method they can use was to cut all the electricity water sources and just wait aik na aik din unhoo ny haar manani hee thee. They opted a wrong way for the operation. Personnely i am very much pro Pak army but in this matter i cant agree with them how they carried out the operation.

There is one in prison my uncle took part in operation and he knows all detail. They gave them all the safe passages and only problem was foreigners Uzbek , chachan and afghani. They knew if they got safe passage then how they ill hide these Foreigners dats y Mullah did not accept this and kill our army man. Now tell me if some one kill our army want they suppose to deserve?

 

[saqi81]

EVEN THOUGH, WHATEVER HE DID NOBODY CAN JUSTIFY THIS ACT OF TERROR/WAR ON HIS OWN CITIZENS. :angry_smile::angry_smile:

They killed our army man it means they were enemy of Pakistan.

 

[Babatank]

Lal Masjid was located in the federal capital. The people were sought out the Lal Masjid were very dominant. They have been terrorizing the neighbourhood. Have ignored many requirements of the authorities arbitrarily. As a religious person they had to be exemplary instead they took the law into their own hands. They are terrorist...you can't allow these terrorist to humiliate you in front of the whole world. I followed the whole scenario live on TV and how all the Media person shouted at Musharaf Gov. to launch bone hard operation on these culprits. They had enough time to show the "white flag", but they refused to co-operate with all different authorities. After all, I think Musharaf did the right thing.

If anyone should receive any compensation, then only the relatives of the brave soldiers and the police officers. Until now not a single terrorist was hanged and now this...stop glorifying these criminals and killers

 

[Sohraab]

baat jab zaatiaat aur ana tak pohnch jati ha to aisa he hota ha.patience aur tadbeer se bachat ho sakti thi..
Lekin hmaray haan ka jo molvi ha wo akheer he ziddi ha.akhlaq,tadbeer,sabr aur maslehat nahe ha.
Ek govt ko wohi karna chahye tha jo kia gia.kuch sabr kia ja sakta tha..lekin media ne double game ki.

SubHan Allah

Kia Be ghairrraton wali Post ki hai

 

[shaheer]

SubHan Allah

Kia Be ghairrraton wali Post ki hai

JAZAKALLAH khair janab.apko bura laga ma ne delete kr dia,i am sorry k apka dil dukha.

 

[Sohraab]

JAZAKALLAH khair janab.apko bura laga ma ne delete kr dia,i am sorry k apka dil dukha.

post delete hone se kia aap ki woh soch delete ho sakti hai jis se aik musalman ki dil aazari hui hai , yani ke meri dil aazari hui hai ???????????????

 

[Sohraab]

Musharraf iss dunya say jaye ga nahin iss jurm ki saza paye baghair (In Sha Allah)

kia khubsurat baat kahi hai (clap)

dil karta hai aap ke haath choom loon jin haaton se aap ne yeh post likhi hai (clap)