What happened to that little girl was horrible and wrong but
Those three in the studio (two women and one man) know nothing about the matter under discussion.
Sahi Muslim
'A'isha reported that Allah's Messenger (may peace be upon him) granted sanction to the members of a family of the Ansir for incantation (for removing the effects) of the poison of the scorpion. (Book #026, Hadith #5443)
and please check the definition of word incantation
And other from Sahi Muslim
Jabir b. 'Abdullah reported that Allah's Apostle (may peace be upon him) granted sanction to the family of Hazm for incantation (in mitigating the effect of the poison of) the snake, and, he said -to Asma' daughter of 'Umais: What is this that I see the children of my brother lean? Are they not fed properly? She said: No, but they fall under the influence of an evil eve. He said: Use incantation She recited (the words of incantation before him), whereupon he (by approving them) said: Yes, use this incantation for them. (Book #026, Hadith #5451)
Did you see "No, but they fall under the influence of an evil eve"
Sahi Muslim
....I heard Jabir b. 'Abdullah as saying that the scorpion stung one of us as we were sitting with Allah's Messenger (may peace upon him). A person said: Allah's Messenger, I use incantation (for curing the effect. of sting), whereupon he said: He who is competent amongst you to benefit his brother should do so. (Book #026, Hadith #5452)
Did you read "whereupon he said: He who is competent amongst you to benefit his brother should do so."
The list can be long from Sahi Hadith.
So I wonder on what basis those three were debating a thing they know not.
