Pak-MUSLIM
Voter (50+ posts)
BEST OF ALLAMA IQBAL
When I Go To The West I See Islam Without Muslims.
But
When I Come Back To The East I See Muslims Without Islam.............
Best of Allama Iqbal......An Eye Opener
- Thread starter Pak-MUSLIM
- Start date
BEST OF ALLAMA IQBAL
When I Go To The West I See Islam Without Muslims.
But
When I Come Back To The East I See Muslims Without Islam.............
Allama Iqbal
Citizen
BEST OF ALLAMA IQBAL
When I Go To The West I See Islam Without Muslims.
But
When I Come Back To The East I See Muslims Without Islam.............
NO , ITS NOT ALLAMA IQBAL'S POEM. IT IS WRONGLY ASSOCIATED WITH IQBAL
I CHALLENGE , TELL ME BOOK NAME FROM WHICH IT IS TAKEN?
If any body can't provide a reference , Please delete this post. Request to Moderators
PAINDO
Siasat.pk - Blogger
BEST OF ALLAMA IQBAL
When I Go To The West I See Islam Without Muslims.
But
When I Come Back To The East I See Muslims Without Islam.............
sirf qafia aor radeef mila leany say har koi Iqbal nahi ban jaata :angry_smile:
ahmadalikhan
MPA (400+ posts)
I agree with Allama Iqbal :) this is not Iqbals poetry. I can tell u even looking at few couplets. Its totally fake poem, trying to defame Iqbal by some of his enemies..
ahmadalikhan
MPA (400+ posts)
One thing more which people don't take notice, Allama Iqbal has more than 100 rejected poems, which Iqbal rejected himself and wrote better new ones in place of them, some poems he gave in Anjuman-e-Hamayat-e-Islam Fund.Like Nala-e-Yateem, which you will not find in any of his books. even those poems are extremely relevant to new one's. Iqbal Academy published a book of rejected poems published by Dir. Sohail Umer. Iqbal ki sirf 2, ya 3 poems hain jo kuch out of his standard hain... woh bhi bang-e-dra ke initial phase mein like '....ki gode mein bili dekh ker' ya 'naya shawala', etc. but Above one is not Allama Iqbal's poetry
Last edited:
fahid_asif
Senator (1k+ posts)
fake.................:dunno:
PAINDO
Siasat.pk - Blogger
ahmadalikhan
MPA (400+ posts)
or someone like Amir Liaqat [hilar][hilar][hilar]
Allama Iqbal
Citizen
janbazali
Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
i agree,...this is not Iqbal's
BEST OF ALLAMA IQBAL
When I Go To The West I See Islam Without Muslims.
But
When I Come Back To The East I See Muslims Without Islam.............
please provide reference or apologize for your cheap effort.................Islam me isi liaey beghare tehkeek k baat phelaney ko bura kaha gaya he.
Night_Hawk
Siasat.pk - Blogger
pathseeker
Politcal Worker (100+ posts)
Zamana-a predictive poem by allama iqbal
[h=3](Bal-e-Jibril-143)
[/h]
Zamana
Time
Jo Tha Nahin Hai, Jo Hai Na Ho Ga, Yehi Hai Ek Harf-e-Mehrmana
Qareeb Tar Hai Namood Jis Ki Ussi Ka Mushtaq Hai Zamana
What was, has faded: what is, is fading: but of these words few can tell the worth;
Time still is gaping with expectation of what is nearest its hour of birth.
]Meri Soorahi Se Qatra Qatra Naye Hawadis Tapak Rahe Hain
Main Apni Tasbeeh-e-Roz-o-Shab Ka Shumar Karta Hon Dana Dana
New tidings slowly come drop by drop from my pitcher gurgling of times new sights,
As I count over the beads strung out on my threaded rosary of days and nights.
Har Aik Se Ashna Hun, Lekin Juda Juda Rasme-o-Rah Meri
Kisi Ka Raakab, Kisi Ka Markab, Kisi Ko Ibrat Ka Taziyana
With each man friendly, with each I vary, and have a new part at my command:
To one the rider, to one the courser, to one the whiplash of reprimand.
Na Tha Agar Tu Shareek-e-Mehfil, Qasoor Mera Hai Ya Ke Tera
Mera Tareeka Nahin Ke Rakh Loon Kisi Ki Khatar Maiay Shabana
If in the circle you were not numbered, was it your own fault or mine?
To humor no‐one am I accustomed to keep untasted the midnight wine!
Mere Kham-o-Paich Ko Najoomi Ki Ankh Pehchanti Nahin Hai
Hadaf Se Baigana Teer Uss Ka, Nazar Nahin Jis Ki Arfana
No planet‐gazer can ever see through my winding mazes; for when the eye
That aims it sees by no lights from Heaven, the arrow wavers and glances by.
Shafaq Nahin Maghrabi Ufaq Par, Ye Jooye Khoon Hai, Ye Jooye Khoon Hai!
Tulu-e-Farda Ka Muntazir Reh Ke Dosh-o-Amroz Hai Fasana
That is no dawn at the Western skylineit is a bloodbath, that ruddy glow!
Await to‐morrow; our yesterday and to‐day are legends of long ago.
Woh Fikar-e-Ghustakh Ji Ne Uryaan Kiya Hai Fitrat Ki Taqaton Ko
Ussi Ki Betab Bijliyon Se Khatr Mein Hai Uss Ka Ashiyana
From Natures forces their reckless science has stripped the garments away, until
At last its own nesting‐place is scorched by the restless lightning it cannot still:
Hawaen Un Ki, Fazaen Un Ki, Sumundar Un Ke, Jahaz Un Ke
Girah Bhanwar Ki Khule To Kyunkar, Bhanwar Hai Taqeer Ka Bahana
To them the trade‐wind belongs, the sky‐way, to them the ocean, to them the ship
It shall not serve them to calm the whirlpool by which their fate holds them in its grip!
Jahan-e-Nau Ho Raha Hai Paida, Woh Alam-e-Peer Mar Raha Hai
Jise Farangi Muqamiron Ne Bana Diya Hai Qimar Khana
But now a new world is being born, while this old one sinks out of sight of men,
This world the gamblers of Europe turned into nothing else than a gambling‐den.
Hawa Hai Go Tund-o-Taiz Lekin Charagh Apna Jala Raha Hai
Woh Mard-e-Darvesh Jis Ko Haq Ne Diye Hain Andaz-e-Khusarwana
That man will still keep his lantern burning, however tempests blow strong and cold,
Whose soul is centred on high, whose temper the Lord has cast in the royal mould.
[h=3](Bal-e-Jibril-143)
[/h]
Time
Qareeb Tar Hai Namood Jis Ki Ussi Ka Mushtaq Hai Zamana
What was, has faded: what is, is fading: but of these words few can tell the worth;
Time still is gaping with expectation of what is nearest its hour of birth.
Main Apni Tasbeeh-e-Roz-o-Shab Ka Shumar Karta Hon Dana Dana
New tidings slowly come drop by drop from my pitcher gurgling of times new sights,
As I count over the beads strung out on my threaded rosary of days and nights.
Kisi Ka Raakab, Kisi Ka Markab, Kisi Ko Ibrat Ka Taziyana
With each man friendly, with each I vary, and have a new part at my command:
To one the rider, to one the courser, to one the whiplash of reprimand.
Mera Tareeka Nahin Ke Rakh Loon Kisi Ki Khatar Maiay Shabana
If in the circle you were not numbered, was it your own fault or mine?
To humor no‐one am I accustomed to keep untasted the midnight wine!
Hadaf Se Baigana Teer Uss Ka, Nazar Nahin Jis Ki Arfana
No planet‐gazer can ever see through my winding mazes; for when the eye
That aims it sees by no lights from Heaven, the arrow wavers and glances by.
Tulu-e-Farda Ka Muntazir Reh Ke Dosh-o-Amroz Hai Fasana
That is no dawn at the Western skylineit is a bloodbath, that ruddy glow!
Await to‐morrow; our yesterday and to‐day are legends of long ago.
Ussi Ki Betab Bijliyon Se Khatr Mein Hai Uss Ka Ashiyana
From Natures forces their reckless science has stripped the garments away, until
At last its own nesting‐place is scorched by the restless lightning it cannot still:
Girah Bhanwar Ki Khule To Kyunkar, Bhanwar Hai Taqeer Ka Bahana
To them the trade‐wind belongs, the sky‐way, to them the ocean, to them the ship
It shall not serve them to calm the whirlpool by which their fate holds them in its grip!
Jise Farangi Muqamiron Ne Bana Diya Hai Qimar Khana
But now a new world is being born, while this old one sinks out of sight of men,
This world the gamblers of Europe turned into nothing else than a gambling‐den.
Woh Mard-e-Darvesh Jis Ko Haq Ne Diye Hain Andaz-e-Khusarwana
That man will still keep his lantern burning, however tempests blow strong and cold,
Whose soul is centred on high, whose temper the Lord has cast in the royal mould.
rehansawal
Voter (50+ posts)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muhammad_Abduh
“ I went to the West and saw Islam, but no Muslims; I got back to the East and saw Muslims, but not Islam. ”
— Muhammad Abduh
these words were said by Muhammad Abduh and not by Allama Iqbal, dont just post anything u get, thori see tehkeek ki zehmat uthani chahiyay.
“ I went to the West and saw Islam, but no Muslims; I got back to the East and saw Muslims, but not Islam. ”
— Muhammad Abduh
these words were said by Muhammad Abduh and not by Allama Iqbal, dont just post anything u get, thori see tehkeek ki zehmat uthani chahiyay.
