Citizen X
President (40k+ posts)
Yeh to ek school ki ek class ka ek teacher jis ka video ban gaya, naa janay kitnay hazaron schoolon mein asay teacher yeh jahalat pardha rahe houngay.
Yeh to ek school ki ek class ka ek teacher jis ka video ban gaya, naa janay kitnay hazaron schoolon mein asay teacher yeh jahalat pardha rahe houngay.
There I fixed it for you.Bubber Shair ne source ka poocha hai.
Meri guzarish hai ke aap yeh kaam ker lain
1- Read Quran with translation 2-3 times
2- Read Sahih Bukhari, Tabqat e Ibn e Saad, Mota Imam Malik, Tarikh e Ibn Khaldoon, Tarikh e Tibri (all these are available in urdu translation) and if you could find urdu translation of Izala tul Khifa by Imam Shafe'i
Insha Allah you will not need these Mullah's anymore to guide or misguide you.
آپ کا سورس آف نالج کیا ہے؟
اس لئے پوچھ رہا ہوں کہ اسطرح اصل ریفرینس تک جاکر اس کی تفصیل ہر کوی نہیں وہی بیان کرسکتا ہے جو کافی سال اسی کام میں لگا چکا ہو میں نے بھی تھوڑا بہت پڑھنے کی کوشش کی تھی مگر حدیث کا میدان بہت وسیع ہے کتابیں بہت زیادہ اور مطالعہ کیلئے وقت بہت کم
Yeh to ek school ki ek class ka ek teacher jis ka video ban gaya, naa janay kitnay hazaron schoolon mein asay teacher yeh jahalat pardha rahe houngay.
hadith (sahih) se hi quran ko samajhne main aasani hoti hai. Main ne aik kitab ka mention kiya hai Imam Shafi'i ki woh agar aap parh lain to yeh baat samajh aa jae gi. Yeh forum nahin is behes ka aur na main koi aisi baat kehna chahta hoon jo kisi ki dil azari ka sabab bane. Koun theek hai aur kaun ghalat yeh to Allah SWT jaanta hai main kaun hoon koi hukam lagane wala. Duaon main yaad rakheenThere I fixed it for you.
Jub Quran hai to ulat pulat haditon ka beech mein kya lena dena
So you disagree with Allah s.w.t when he himself sayshadith (sahih) se hi quran ko samajhne main aasani hoti hai.
Any forum is a good forum as any. Agar such ke kissi ki dil azari ho, to hone do.Yeh forum nahin is behes ka aur na main koi aisi baat kehna chahta hoon jo kisi ki dil azari ka sabab bane.
it is in quran that the "life of Rasool Allah (PBUH) is best example (uswa e Husna) for you, take what he gives (allows) you and refrain from what he ask you to refrain" How can that happen without Hadith - But I take your point that most illetrate mullahs say whatever comes to their mind by saying "Hadith shareef main aaya hai" without any sanad.So you disagree with Allah s.w.t when he himself says
54:17 : And We have indeed made the Qur'an easy to understand and remember: then is there any that will receive admonition?
This whole notion of we need hadith to understand the Quran is a mullah made notion just like many mullahs today even say, Quran tarjumay ke saath nahi pardo, gunnah millay ga.
Any forum is a good forum as any. Agar such ke kissi ki dil azari ho, to hone do.
First of all I am not 100% exactly sure which verse you are quoting since you did not provide a reference, is it Surah Hashar Verse 7? So before I say anything I would like to be sure in order to avoid any misunderstanding.it is in quran that the "life of Rasool Allah (PBUH) is best example (uswa e Husna) for you, take what he gives (allows) you and refrain from what he ask you to refrain" How can that happen without Hadith - But I take your point that most illetrate mullahs say whatever comes to their mind by saying "Hadith shareef main aaya hai" without any sanad.
Again read about what 7 aloom Imam Shafi'i said are essential for anyone to do tafseer e quran. How many people in these days have them?