Adil Raja sold out?

BlackBirdSSG

Voter (50+ posts)
Fair point, bro, skepticism is valid, especially when it comes to media optics. But we also need to understand who Adil Raja is and why he ended up on a platform like that. He’s not just a YouTuber or an ex-army officer giving spicy takes, he’s a dissident. He’s been openly critical of Pak military’s deep-rooted interference in politics, judiciary, media, basically, the whole system. That’s why he had to run for his life and seek asylum in UK. The guy didn’t leave because he got bored of Islamabad, he left because there was a serious threat to his life and liberty. That alone changes the entire context of what he’s doing abroad.

Now, yes, he did say before that he wouldn't appear on Indian channels. And now he has. That’s a U-turn, no doubt. But people evolve. Those who don't take U-turns in their life have 0 scope of improving themselves. When you’re in exile, media doors open 2 you are going to be international, including India’s. That doesn’t automatically mean he's on someone’s payroll. If you actually watch the show, he didn’t give them what they were fishing for. Host clearly tried to pin the blame of Pahalgam attack on Pakistan, but Raja didn’t bite. He didn’t confirm anything, didn’t bash Pakistan as a country, & didn’t parrot Indian narrative. Instead, he used the opportunity to speak about civil-military imbalance and the need for true democracy in Pakistan, things many of us discuss here on this very forum.

Let’s not confuse critique of Army with hate for Pakistan. He may be flawed, may be opportunistic at times, but so far, there’s no evidence he’s “sold out” - at least not through this video. If he starts leaking actual classified stuff or echoing Indian state propaganda word-for-word, we’ll have every right to call him out. But until then, let’s judge what was actually said, not just where it was said.
Also worth pointing out, this isn’t the first time an Indian platform hosted a Pakistani figure, and it didn’t go the way they hoped. Remember Moeed Yusuf’s one-on-one with Karan Thapar? That was a masterclass in composure and clarity. Despite being constantly interrupted, Moeed didn’t lose his cool, stayed on point, and defended Pakistan’s position like a statesman. Even the Indian comment section was full of praise for how he handled himself, while many slammed Karan for being aggressive and interruptive.
So the idea that appearing on Indian media = selling out is just lazy thinking. It depends on what you say, not where you say it. Moeed Yusuf didn’t become a traitor by going on Karan Thapar’s show, he became more respected for standing his ground. The same yardstick should apply to Adil Raja too - regardless of that he said earlier & due to evolving war dynamics. If he starts echoing Indian propaganda, sure, call him out. But if he uses the platform to push uncomfortable truths without crossing national red lines, maybe we should look at what’s being said, not just the channel’s logo in the corner.
 

ProPakistanii

Senator (1k+ posts)
On numerous occasions AJ proudly doing chest thumping that he has refused to appear on Indian channels despite "sweet offers".

His appearance on Indian TV now and accusing Pak of being behind Pahalgam attack has seriously undermined his credibility.
Where in the video has he accused pak being behind pahalgam attack?
 

Back
Top