P
pakstar
Guest
I recently joined Siasat.pk forum as inactive member but soon I realised that there is alot to contribute after seeing active participation of different users.
First of all I would like to start with a small piece of advice for everyone on this forum (Including myself) to respect each other as brother and sister in order to make our points with decency and pride. We are all coupled with two relations, one is being Muslim and other being Pakistani and therefore we should never forget that the person we are talking to is also one of Us. We can differentiate from each other we can think differently but we should never be divide. We are one Nation Pakistani and we will remain brothers always. Lets start having love and respect for others. End of the day whoever we are , our objective and goals are for good of Pakistan. Life goes on!
Coming back to the point, I thought to pick up this point in debate that who can run Pakistan in better way. First of all in my opinion there are two aspects of Pakistan Politics one is Micro Politics and other in Macro Politics. Micro Politics is the one where actions are motivated or addressed from one party to other, person to another person etc; in other words we can call it Party politics. I am least bothered about it because it is wastage of time. I am interested in MACRO politics as whatever happens in Micro Politics would reflect in MACRO politics. MACRO politics is that who cares or damages the interests of Pakistan.
I will not go too far as the scope of my debate would remain in radius of current affairs. I start with the point that we as Pakistani are very naive people and we can easily be distracted. In Pakistan we had two type of rulers, Army Generals and Politicians. What we always and mostly discuss in debate is Politians who only get 20 to 30% of budget to spend for good of Pakistan, rest 70 to 80% Budget goes to Pak Army which is accountable to no one. So lets have a look at Pakistan army role in building Pakistan.
There are/have been two key players in Ruling of Pakistan, ARMY and Politicians. Let’s take Army First.
Role of Pakistan Army.
ARMY TAKES 70 to 80% of our budget / tax payer money and what they have returned to Pakistan?
Army ruled Pakistan 30+ years nearly half of Pakistan’s life and each term of Army was 4 times
Longer than our normal prime ministers term. So an army gernal had 4 times more chances to do good for Pakistan which they FAILED ALWAYS, and in result we
Lost East Pakistan where army failed ton control the situation and Pakistan broke into two.
Army always bypassed Constitution and removed elected Prime Ministors of Pakistan, without any right from consitituion or without a single vote from Pakistani nation. Their job is to protect nation not to rule but they still rule as they are ABOVE LAW.
Army has occoupid most of our building, land, play grounds in Cantt areas. My play ground (station ground) next to Islamabad Airport has now become Army flats. IN short they are biggest Land mafia (no accountability).
Army Killed our brothers and sisters in LAL Masjid, Regardless they were right or wrong but the excissve force used (SSG Commonados) against ordinary civial of Paksitan can never be justified. This was not enemy but our brothers and sisters.
Army did political viticimization, e.g Hanged GREAT Leader Zulfiqar Bhutto, also Akbar Bughti, kept alot of PMLN leaders in jails during exile of Nawaz Sharif.
Army schools are only for children of servicemen, Such a shame, if you are a hard working civilian your children do not have right to be educated in Pakistan.
List could be long but I take some important areas in debate therefore the above proves the sincerity of Army. Besides its propaganda of Pakistan army to tell us about PMLN was corrupt or PPP was/is corrupt, So that we can keep on fighting between us as supporter of one or other. They do not want us to think about corruption of Army or blunders of army. They are more than happy seeing us here fighting between PPP, PMLN, MQM and other parties. That is what they want so they keep on ruling Pakistani nation by taking all resources of Pakistan for Pakistan Army.
Therefore First of all wheever we critise that who is respoinsbile for this situation in Pakistan, 70-80% it is done by army which ruled Pakistan more than any one else and which takes resources of Pakistan more than anyone else.
Next is now Politicians.
The PPP from Benazir Bhutto!
NFC award
Benazir Income support
18th amendment
IF YOU KNOW MORE PLEASE ADD IN THE LIST
The PMLN
o Yellow Cab Scheme (one can criticize anything but I still see yellow cabs on
road, and people feeding their families using those yellow cabs)
o Telephone Privatization ( I rem booking calls to uk 300rs for 3 mins, its fruit of his privatization of telecom that we can make calls to UK , USA and other countries for just one or two rupee per minute)
o Motorway (Thanks to nawaz Sharif who gave us gift of Motorway in Pakistan)
o Roads (Roadwork were at peak in his term, including domestic and Highways)
o Schools and colleges (In Rawalpindi alone, sheikh rasheed worked very hard and alot of new schools and colleges were built when he was minister under Nawaz Sharif Govt). Same Sheikh rasheed did nothing in Mushraaf Govt.
o Price stability (prices were stable in his term and even if there was increase it was minor)
o Loans (affordable and interest free loans scheme for students and small businesses helped many to progress themselves)
o Nuc. Test (despite the pressure of international community he made his decision in the interest of Pakistan)
o and roadmap to prosperous Pakistan.
o Sasti Rooti
o IF YOU KNOW MORE PLEASE ADD IN THE LIST
Having seen a short analysis, it clarifies that 70-80% Pak Army damaged interest of Pakistan, we have to debate their wrong doings and we have to question them past and future, otherwise Pak Army will keep on stealing Pakistan resources and will keep us fighting between PMLN , PPP, PTI and MQM. In contrast to Pak Army damages, Politicians did great job for Pakistan. PMLN regardless of micro politics but they played a vital role in construction and building of Pakistan, as the long list above explains.
Therefore I may be wrong but in my opinon PML N is only way forward, Imran Khan is very sincere person but he does not have competitive team. He should join PMLN for better of Pakistan along with Zaid Hamid.
Long Live Pakistan
You are welcome to post comments and feedback but with intellect not with disrepsct.
First of all I would like to start with a small piece of advice for everyone on this forum (Including myself) to respect each other as brother and sister in order to make our points with decency and pride. We are all coupled with two relations, one is being Muslim and other being Pakistani and therefore we should never forget that the person we are talking to is also one of Us. We can differentiate from each other we can think differently but we should never be divide. We are one Nation Pakistani and we will remain brothers always. Lets start having love and respect for others. End of the day whoever we are , our objective and goals are for good of Pakistan. Life goes on!
Coming back to the point, I thought to pick up this point in debate that who can run Pakistan in better way. First of all in my opinion there are two aspects of Pakistan Politics one is Micro Politics and other in Macro Politics. Micro Politics is the one where actions are motivated or addressed from one party to other, person to another person etc; in other words we can call it Party politics. I am least bothered about it because it is wastage of time. I am interested in MACRO politics as whatever happens in Micro Politics would reflect in MACRO politics. MACRO politics is that who cares or damages the interests of Pakistan.
I will not go too far as the scope of my debate would remain in radius of current affairs. I start with the point that we as Pakistani are very naive people and we can easily be distracted. In Pakistan we had two type of rulers, Army Generals and Politicians. What we always and mostly discuss in debate is Politians who only get 20 to 30% of budget to spend for good of Pakistan, rest 70 to 80% Budget goes to Pak Army which is accountable to no one. So lets have a look at Pakistan army role in building Pakistan.
There are/have been two key players in Ruling of Pakistan, ARMY and Politicians. Let’s take Army First.
Role of Pakistan Army.
ARMY TAKES 70 to 80% of our budget / tax payer money and what they have returned to Pakistan?
Army ruled Pakistan 30+ years nearly half of Pakistan’s life and each term of Army was 4 times
Longer than our normal prime ministers term. So an army gernal had 4 times more chances to do good for Pakistan which they FAILED ALWAYS, and in result we
Lost East Pakistan where army failed ton control the situation and Pakistan broke into two.
Army always bypassed Constitution and removed elected Prime Ministors of Pakistan, without any right from consitituion or without a single vote from Pakistani nation. Their job is to protect nation not to rule but they still rule as they are ABOVE LAW.
Army has occoupid most of our building, land, play grounds in Cantt areas. My play ground (station ground) next to Islamabad Airport has now become Army flats. IN short they are biggest Land mafia (no accountability).
Army Killed our brothers and sisters in LAL Masjid, Regardless they were right or wrong but the excissve force used (SSG Commonados) against ordinary civial of Paksitan can never be justified. This was not enemy but our brothers and sisters.
Army did political viticimization, e.g Hanged GREAT Leader Zulfiqar Bhutto, also Akbar Bughti, kept alot of PMLN leaders in jails during exile of Nawaz Sharif.
Army schools are only for children of servicemen, Such a shame, if you are a hard working civilian your children do not have right to be educated in Pakistan.
List could be long but I take some important areas in debate therefore the above proves the sincerity of Army. Besides its propaganda of Pakistan army to tell us about PMLN was corrupt or PPP was/is corrupt, So that we can keep on fighting between us as supporter of one or other. They do not want us to think about corruption of Army or blunders of army. They are more than happy seeing us here fighting between PPP, PMLN, MQM and other parties. That is what they want so they keep on ruling Pakistani nation by taking all resources of Pakistan for Pakistan Army.
Therefore First of all wheever we critise that who is respoinsbile for this situation in Pakistan, 70-80% it is done by army which ruled Pakistan more than any one else and which takes resources of Pakistan more than anyone else.
Next is now Politicians.
The PPP from Benazir Bhutto!
NFC award
Benazir Income support
18th amendment
IF YOU KNOW MORE PLEASE ADD IN THE LIST
The PMLN
o Yellow Cab Scheme (one can criticize anything but I still see yellow cabs on
road, and people feeding their families using those yellow cabs)
o Telephone Privatization ( I rem booking calls to uk 300rs for 3 mins, its fruit of his privatization of telecom that we can make calls to UK , USA and other countries for just one or two rupee per minute)
o Motorway (Thanks to nawaz Sharif who gave us gift of Motorway in Pakistan)
o Roads (Roadwork were at peak in his term, including domestic and Highways)
o Schools and colleges (In Rawalpindi alone, sheikh rasheed worked very hard and alot of new schools and colleges were built when he was minister under Nawaz Sharif Govt). Same Sheikh rasheed did nothing in Mushraaf Govt.
o Price stability (prices were stable in his term and even if there was increase it was minor)
o Loans (affordable and interest free loans scheme for students and small businesses helped many to progress themselves)
o Nuc. Test (despite the pressure of international community he made his decision in the interest of Pakistan)
o and roadmap to prosperous Pakistan.
o Sasti Rooti
o IF YOU KNOW MORE PLEASE ADD IN THE LIST
Having seen a short analysis, it clarifies that 70-80% Pak Army damaged interest of Pakistan, we have to debate their wrong doings and we have to question them past and future, otherwise Pak Army will keep on stealing Pakistan resources and will keep us fighting between PMLN , PPP, PTI and MQM. In contrast to Pak Army damages, Politicians did great job for Pakistan. PMLN regardless of micro politics but they played a vital role in construction and building of Pakistan, as the long list above explains.
Therefore I may be wrong but in my opinon PML N is only way forward, Imran Khan is very sincere person but he does not have competitive team. He should join PMLN for better of Pakistan along with Zaid Hamid.
Long Live Pakistan
You are welcome to post comments and feedback but with intellect not with disrepsct.
Last edited by a moderator:
