Zardari says we cannot afford to make new province it will increase expense but what about his deman

bisaat

Banned
when the hypocrite talks, he starts making many contradictions, Pakistani political parties have been exposed on their selfish agendas in persuing for a separate province. for instance PTI just for seeking votes in hazara region made promise for hazara province, PTI even passed resultion regarding hazara province just to show that the promise they made with hazarawals was not a hot air balloon. in reality Hazara province after passage of its resolution from KPK assembly never became reality. PMLN also passed resolution on south punjab bhawalpur province but that was also a face saving effort to show that they did follow their manifesto, in reality their resolution never became materialized, when ever it is discussed that why even after passage f separate province resolution PMLN failed to make one, PMLN produces counter argument that first Sindh should play its role in making Karachi province. all these hypocrite parties want to concentrate wealth and power in one hand, they don't want to distribute wealth and power among people evenly

Hazarawals and south Punjabi seraikis have a long history of deprivation. hazarawals complain that its their province but CM from KPK is never a hazarawal, it always from pashtun belt. they also complain that even though province earns more from hazara tourist areas, it is the other parts of the province who enjoy the money more. the similar is the story about seraikis who say that they don't get equal share for theor lands, as compared to noth and sentral, south Punjab lags behind. how can we overcome these grievances?

just yesterday i was listening to MR Zardari and he said in an interview that making more province is costly and we will have to bear extra expense for it, making more governments will incrase our expenses

MR Zardari have you forgotten how desperately you wanted to make south Punjab province and were pressurising Punjab government to make one? what happened to your logic than? now since a new demand of administrative units have come to light now a days, you have retreated from you stance of making more provinces? why? is it because in south Punjab you had the majority and you wanted to make it separate so that you can rule it? and since after 2013 election you filed to make majority in there, you retreated from your earlier demands?

MQM is not a hypocrite party, MQM supported your demand for separate south Punjab province then because MQM in principle demands more provinces for effective administration, MQM didn't have any self interest in South Punjab, but now PPP retracts from its earlier demand because it can cost themselves sindh province and the revenue engine Karachi.

as to the fact that making more provinces is a costly business, it is true that making more provinces may cost initially, but the benefits in long term out weight the initial expenses. the its like an investment which will bear a long time interest. making more provinces will mean that there will be more capital cities and which means that more cities of Pakistan will have important status and there will be more investment. more provinces mean that less number of Pakistanis will get more freedom to exercise their governance and improve it as they like. pakistanis will be able to make their own laws according to their needs and will get more power and importance. there will be infrastructural development, to seek justice one will not have to travel far away, and justice will be available at his door step. it will increase competition among the provinces as well. nobody will have monopoly on their earnings and they can use funds generated from their land for their own needs. powers will be distributed evently and will not remain concentrated in few hands.


 
Last edited:

miafridi

Prime Minister (20k+ posts)
New provinces will increase the performance of the country and the progress as well.

But they should be made on equal administrative, and equal resources both existing and the one a province is generating. So that when a province is made it is capable of raising money for itself. Because you don't want "a province with guns but no ammunition" or another example as a "Province with a Lake but with no boats or fishes in it for them to feed themselves.

Similarly Karachi shouldn't be made a province because it not only generates the majority of revenue for the whole Sindh province but for Pakistan as well. Making it a single province will boost karachi development, but other provinces revenue will be cut of then, so every province which doesn't have a considerable amount of revenue generating business should get a peace of Karachi. Note that its just my opinion which could either be wrong or right...
 
Last edited:

Pak1stani

Prime Minister (20k+ posts)
And for whole 5 years MQM was licking Zardari feet for sake of few ministries and to protect Altaf skin by not giving access to the killers of Dr. Imran Farooq
 

Galaxy

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
This man know very well that majority of Pakistanis are illiterate,poor and stupid.This kind of environment is a very fertile ground for Butt and Bhutto league type politicians.This makes it so easy to device people any way you like.
 

Mir Jaffer

Senator (1k+ posts)
The demand for Saraiki province is quite legitimate. They have been plundered by Punjbai establishment for 67 years. There is no Saraiki representation in federal or provincial, civil or military bureaucracy. NO funds by rcaist PMLN govt, all the funding is for LAhore and surroundings. Saraikistan's land is used to appease military bureaucracy to be divided maong them.Saraiki students are discriminated by the introduction of entry tests etc.
Saraikis are living at their land for centuries and Punjab is quite big to be controlled by MUghal KINg Shahbaz Sharif.
THe demand for Hzara province is just at basis of ethnic differences while the people of HAzara are economically dveeloped. Similalry urud speakers are enjoying all the economic benefits in Karachi, so there is no genuine demand for Mohajir or any thing such province. They only need local governments.
 

Okara

Prime Minister (20k+ posts)
And for whole 5 years MQM was licking Zardari feet for sake of few ministries and to protect Altaf skin by not giving access to the killers of Dr. Imran Farooq

Until few seconds ago they were part of the PPP Sindh goverment. Not sure if they are still in goverment or not while typing it.
 

midwayus

MPA (400+ posts)
pakistan can afford New Provinces Expense

but not AFFORD YOUR CORRUPTIONS

that's Y

you did not want new provinces
 

Altaf Lutfi

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
Our ruling elite has very clear priorities. Keep it all under thumb. If one stands forcefully, push it out of Pakistan. When everybody else gone, you can be assured of having Punjabi slaves going along for a few centuries more. When you see Punjabis ready to explode finally, pack up suit cases and move to the country you have nationality for and look after the business already doing well there.
 

Sniper

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
Tufff hai un logon per jinho nay zardari jaise chorrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr or jhotayyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy ki baat per yaqeen kia tha.
 

Omrkhan

Minister (2k+ posts)
Imran ke ankhe khol de he. All they want is fight and hatred among mazloms/ masses. At upper level they are all one.
Interior Sind ke laugo ke halat buhat kharab he. Only a few make millions and billions. If Khi become separate province Interior Sind will
Suffer. We must remain together and take care of our countrymen.

2nd option, Go Nawaz Go.
 

Omrkhan

Minister (2k+ posts)
GO NAWAZ GO. Why exchange one Elite Group with another one. It's like in tribal areas where one abductee is sold/exchanged to another
Kidnapper group.
 

Omrkhan

Minister (2k+ posts)
New provinces will increase the performance of the country and the progress as well.

But they should be made on equal administrative, and equal resources both existing and the one a province is generating. So that when a province is made it is capable of raising money for itself. Because you don't want "a province with guns but no ammunition" or another example as a "Province with a Lake but with no boats or fishes in it for them to feed themselves.

Similarly Karachi shouldn't be made a province because it not only generates the majority of revenue for the whole Sindh province but for Pakistan as well. Making it a single province will boost karachi development, but other provinces revenue will be cut of then, so every province which doesn't have a considerable amount of revenue generating business should get a peace of Karachi. Note that its just my opinion which could either be wrong or right...

Pakistan sub ka he. If oil fields are discovered in KPK all Pakistan should share in resources.
Khi generating 70 revenue is misnomer. If Punjab says water is ours only. Than what. All must share equally.