Was Jinnah a British Agent?

[TalibEilm]

Muhammad Ali Jinnah is criticised from certain quarters in Pakistan in the name of religion that he was secular, liberal and so and so and had lived in England and he partitioned the subcontinent which was a great sin. According to them Jinnah divided Muslims of India into 3 sections i.e West Pakistani Muslims, Indian Muslims and East Pakistani (now Bangladeshi) Muslims.

Let's examine these allegations and investigate the charges.

1. Jinnah was not the son of a Chaudhry, or Nawabzada. He was from a middle class family and was sent to England for work (apprenticeship) by his father. He wasn't sent to England for studies, as his father was not a Sindhi or Punjabi loyal of the British. Jinnah Poonja had not betrayed Muslims by assisting the British in 1857's war of independence. It means Jinnah had a very clean background. His veins didn't have blood of traitors like Mir Jafar, Mir Sadiq, Chaudharys or Maliks.

2. Jinnah was not accepted as a leader in Punjab, NWFP (KP), Balochistan and Sindh until 1947. Punjab was under Sikander Hayat Khan and Khizar Hayat Tiwana, the Unionists who were British loyals. Punjab had to recognise Jinnah only when it saw partition was imminent and communal violence had followed the Direct Action campaign. Punjabis now had no choice but to support Quaid e Azam and Pakistan. NWFP was under Bacha Khan and Congress and they also had no choice but to recognise Jinnah.

Now if Jinnah was a British agent then why Punjabi Unionists (British loyalists) hadn't supported All India Muslim League?

 

[TalibEilm]

First Kashmir War

This war itself is an evidence that Jinnah was so anti-British. He went to war with India over Kashmir when Indian troops were commanded by India's first Gov. General, Mountbatten, and when Pakistan's British military chiefs were also blocking Quaid's order of military intervention in Kashmir.

 

[atensari]

کیبنٹ مشن کی سفارشات کی منظوری کے بعد قائد اعظم عملا قیام پاکستان سے دستبردار ہو چکے تھے. جس کے مطابق برطانیہ غیر منقسم ہندوستان چھوڑ کر جائے گا. دونوں فریق دس سال بعد فیصلہ کریں گے کے انہیں اکھٹا رہنا ہے یا نہیں. نہرو کا بغض باطن اس کی زبان پر آگیا. "دس سال بعد کون الگ ہونے دے گا". اس بیان کے بعد قائد اعظم نے علیحدہ ریاست سے کم کوئی مطالبہ نہیں کیا​

 

[jaanmark]

study more more moooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooore NAWAZ group

 

[TalibEilm]

Illegal occupation of Pakistan by Punjabi British agents

Punjabis who did not support the creation of Pakistan by majority by not accepting the leadership of Quaid e Azam, had always lived under feudal lords, their condition is still the same. These Punjabi feudals could not tolerate a Mohajir Prime Minister, Liaquat Ali Khan and a Bengali Governor General, Khwaja Nazimuddin. So Liaquat was assassinated in Punjab (Company Bagh Rawalpindi) by calling him from Karachi. The Pathan, Major Gen. Akbar Khan had earlier been arrested on account of Rawalpindi Conspiracy and another Pathan, Ayub Khan (a British / American loyalist) had taken over Pakistan's military by that time. The Pathan-Punjabi conspiracy into the assassination of Pakistan's first Prime Minister did not allow any investigation to the crime. We still don't know the actual motives and details of this assassination.

After this assassination, the British King George appointed a Punjabi loyal, Malik Ghulam Muhammad (with a Pathan background) as Governor General of Pakistan. And that was the beginning of illegal occupation of Pakistan by Punjabis and Pathans who had no sacrifices and services in the making of Pakistan.

 

[TalibEilm]

Ayub Khan, the Pathan Traitor gave his backing to the Punjabi Gov. General Ghulam Muhammad for dismissing the Bengali Prime Minister, Khwaja Nazimuddin which was an illegal and unconstitutional act. This nexus used another Bengali, Muhammad Ali Bogra as a puppet and then was thrown away. The Punjabi Chief Justice Munir issued his unpopular and dubious decision to support the actions of Punjabi Governor General against Bengali Speaker (Tamizuddin Case), legislators etc in 1955.

Great grandson of Mir Jafar, Iskander Mirza was used by the British Queen as Gov. General of Pakistan to support the Punjabi-Pathan occupation of Pakistan until Ayub the Traitor directly occupied this nation illegally and worked to break Pakistan in 1971.

Now who are the British / American agents?

 

[TalibEilm]

Would Pakistan be created if there was no Jinnah?

No, never. Indians also accept this fact that Pakistan would never be created if there was no Jinnah. The making of Pakistan is due to this one man by the help of God.

Jinnah never accepted knighthood from the British the way Iqbal and other leaders did. He was one of the richest men in India by 1940. All his wealth was earned by his profession, no funding from the British or Hindus could be proved. He was considered an arrogant person by the British, what an irony!

He parted his ways from Hindus when he saw their true colours and when he believed that Hindu mindset is permanently natural. He started believing in partition of India following the tyrannical Congress Rule of 1937 - 39. He had not had a strange dream like Iqbal who never saw Bengal and Kashmir as part of Pakistan.

 

[TalibEilm]

Did Jinnah divide Indian Muslims through partition?

No he didn't. Muslims were already naturally, geographically, ethnically divided across India. Bengali Muslims (present Bangladesh), North Eastern Muslims (present Pakistan) and North-Central-Southern Indian Muslim minority already existed. Jinnah only liberated the first two sections of Muslims using international law, and by the grace of God these two sections of Muslims are still liberated and independent from the narrow-minded Hindu domination.

Salam to Jinnah!

 

[hasehm]

Its simple if he was agent what he got in return ? Answer is pakistan

 

[Aliimran1]

I think that the people in charge here should take swift and strict action against whom are writing nonsense about Qaid e Azam and Army and Baluchistan and trying to create hatred on this forum---- by finding their original country and report this to appropriate authorities and put some sort of filter so they can not infiltrate and spread hatred against our founding father and defame our Army and especially against Balochistan and distorted facts and history ------ If you will not take action against these elements they will keep coming with different names and IDs and propogate against Pakistan ----- I hope that you will take action ASP

 

[kkkkk]

Only a Hindu agent or an stupid would raise such a question. In reality the Congress supported Ulama and Mullas had damaged Muslim League initially but thanks God, the 1937 Congress rule had completely blown the facade of Congress of any soft corner for Muslims. In 21 November, 1945 elections, Muslim League had won all the 30 reserved seats of the Muslims in center and 440 out of 495 seats in the provinces. Unfortunately, it seems that Islam and Muslims have greatly been damaged by Mullahs, as religion becomes their profession and passion.

 

[kkkkk]

Some time it seems that suspicion against the Geo tv, this website may also have some patronage of Indian intelligence agency RAW.
We all need to be watchful of traitors inside, open and clear enemies are not an issue even if they be hundred time more than what they are today.

 

[j1234]

world powers wanted to divide sub continent.

 

[shami11]

Where ever Jinnah went, Muslims followed him, how can you say he did not have any support in Punjab, Sindh, KPK, and Balochistan?

 

[TalibEilm]

Where ever Jinnah went, Muslims followed him, how can you say he did not have any support in Punjab, Sindh, KPK, and Balochistan?

Historical facts say that they didn't.

 

[rtabasum2]

Endian alert.........

 

[Night_Hawk]

Endian alert.........

I agree, the Mods should stop this.

 

[Hawk in the Sky]

I agree, the Mods should stop this.

mods suto pi ker sojatay hain on these posts..
I expected more from Anie.. anyway seems all become alike after assuming powers...

 

[TalibEilm]

Propaganda aur brainwashing kay ventilator mein paida honay walon ko tareekhi haqayeq sazish nazar aatay hain.

 

[Night_Hawk]

mods suto pi ker sojatay hain on these posts..
I expected more from Anie.. anyway seems all become alike after assuming powers...

@Annie
@Maahir
@AbdulRehman
We should report these threads and posts for their prompt action.