Urdu vs English: Are we ashamed of our language?

Geek

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
Most Pakistanis have been brought up speaking our national language Urdu and English. Instead of conversing in Urdu, many of us lapse into English during everyday conversation. Even people who do not speak English very well try their best to sneak in a sentence or two, considering it pertinent for their acceptance in the cooler crowd.

I wonder where the trend started, but unknowingly, unconsciously, somehow or the other we all get sucked into the trap. It was not until a few years ago while on a college trip to Turkey that I realized the misgivings of our innocent jabber.

A group of students of the LUMS Cultural Society trip went to Istanbul, Turkey to mark the 100th Anniversary of the famous Sufi poet Rumi. One day we were exploring the city when we stopped at a caf for lunch. The waiter took our orders, and continued to hover around our table during the meal. We barely noticed him until he came with the bill, and asked us:

Where are you from?

Pakistan

The waiter looked surprised, and then asked whether we had been brought up in England. We answered in the negative, telling him how Pakistan was where we all had grown up and spent out lives. The waiter genuinely looked perplexed now. Finally he blurted out:

Then why dont you speak in the Pakistani language?

The waiter went on to explain how Turkey, particularly Istanbul was a hot tourist location, luring millions of people of different nationalities from across the globe. However, when the Dutch would come visit, they would speak Dutch. When the French would come, they would speak French. When the Chinese would come visit, they would speak Chinese. Similarly everyone in Turkey spoke Turkish. He claimed he was very proud of his language and culture and failed to understand how someone would not speak the language of their country and choose instead a foreign tongue.

There were around ten of us there, and we were all at a loss of an answer. We had never thought of it that way. It was just something that you took up because of society. Even when people speak in Urdu, they tend to include a lot of English words in their sentences. Why is that? Is it because we are not proud of our national language? I am sure all of us are aware of how beautiful Urdu is, the poetry, grace and rhythm of our language is exceptional.

One excuse that springs to mind is the concept of westernisation due to the increased pace of globalization in todays world. Globalization is a factor, and yet the Japanese still speak Japanese, the Thai still speak Thai, the Greeks still speak Greek. China, a powerhouse on the global economic front, despite its many factories and western products production still speaks Chinese. In fact when the Chinese Olympics were held in 2008, the Chinese government actually had to ask its Chinese public to learn a few basic English words to help welcome the world.

I respect how these countries value their sense of identity, culture and language. I was deeply ashamed of what image I was unknowingly portraying of my country. I am very proud of Pakistan and Urdu, as I am sure we all are. No matter the problems, it is still our identity. I understand the irony of this article, since it is written in English. However, it is one way to reach those people who may unconsciously be making the same mistake as I was.

When living in the UK or travelling abroad, I make sure I use Urdu to converse with fellow Pakistanis. At home, I am also trying, though it is admittedly difficult since apparently there is a weird and honestly sad association of how cool, well brought-up and educated a person is with the amount of English he or she speaks. I write this article because it is high time we break such ignorant patterns in our society. Urdu is a beautiful and graceful language and we owe our country the respect it deserves by speaking and portraying our true roots.

Kiya khayal hai?

http://blogs.tribune.com.pk/story/6545/urdu-vs-english-are-we-ashamed-of-our-language/
 

gazoomartian

Prime Minister (20k+ posts)
Most Pakistanis have been brought up speaking our national language Urdu and English. Instead of conversing in Urdu, many of us lapse into English during everyday conversation. Even people who do not speak English very well try their best to sneak in a sentence or two, considering it pertinent for their acceptance in the cooler crowd.

I wonder where the trend started, but unknowingly, unconsciously, somehow or the other we all get sucked into the trap. It was not until a few years ago while on a college trip to Turkey that I realized the misgivings of our innocent jabber.

A group of students of the LUMS Cultural Society trip went to Istanbul, Turkey to mark the 100th Anniversary of the famous Sufi poet Rumi. One day we were exploring the city when we stopped at a caf for lunch. The waiter took our orders, and continued to hover around our table during the meal. We barely noticed him until he came with the bill, and asked us:

Where are you from?

Pakistan

The waiter looked surprised, and then asked whether we had been brought up in England. We answered in the negative, telling him how Pakistan was where we all had grown up and spent out lives. The waiter genuinely looked perplexed now. Finally he blurted out:

Then why dont you speak in the Pakistani language?

The waiter went on to explain how Turkey, particularly Istanbul was a hot tourist location, luring millions of people of different nationalities from across the globe. However, when the Dutch would come visit, they would speak Dutch. When the French would come, they would speak French. When the Chinese would come visit, they would speak Chinese. Similarly everyone in Turkey spoke Turkish. He claimed he was very proud of his language and culture and failed to understand how someone would not speak the language of their country and choose instead a foreign tongue.

There were around ten of us there, and we were all at a loss of an answer. We had never thought of it that way. It was just something that you took up because of society. Even when people speak in Urdu, they tend to include a lot of English words in their sentences. Why is that? Is it because we are not proud of our national language? I am sure all of us are aware of how beautiful Urdu is, the poetry, grace and rhythm of our language is exceptional.

One excuse that springs to mind is the concept of westernisation due to the increased pace of globalization in todays world. Globalization is a factor, and yet the Japanese still speak Japanese, the Thai still speak Thai, the Greeks still speak Greek. China, a powerhouse on the global economic front, despite its many factories and western products production still speaks Chinese. In fact when the Chinese Olympics were held in 2008, the Chinese government actually had to ask its Chinese public to learn a few basic English words to help welcome the world.

I respect how these countries value their sense of identity, culture and language. I was deeply ashamed of what image I was unknowingly portraying of my country. I am very proud of Pakistan and Urdu, as I am sure we all are. No matter the problems, it is still our identity. I understand the irony of this article, since it is written in English. However, it is one way to reach those people who may unconsciously be making the same mistake as I was.

When living in the UK or travelling abroad, I make sure I use Urdu to converse with fellow Pakistanis. At home, I am also trying, though it is admittedly difficult since apparently there is a weird and honestly sad association of how cool, well brought-up and educated a person is with the amount of English he or she speaks. I write this article because it is high time we break such ignorant patterns in our society. Urdu is a beautiful and graceful language and we owe our country the respect it deserves by speaking and portraying our true roots.

Kiya khayal hai?

http://blogs.tribune.com.pk/story/6545/urdu-vs-english-are-we-ashamed-of-our-language/

There is no doubt that the British dynasty has a lot to do with the way speak because of their undesired rules over us.

However, its equally our fault as well. The society has not offered Urdu environment, pure Urdu in media, TV Radio or print. The govt has not done anything to promote and develop the national language. The writers, authors have not kept up with the daily changing environment that spewing English whether its a video game or be it wrestling match, press conference by the politicians.

I personally seem to be at loss when I am looking for the alternative word for the technology. For example, I was looking for Urdu word for 'Click'. I went on sever sites but to no avail. Eventually I opted for something that does not require the word Click.

But it all boils down to one thing: INSTABILITY in the country.

There is no lack of talents in Pakistan. Our young generation, be it boys or girl, Muslim, non-Muslim, is very talented. Its the instability and corruption that is eating the country up. Even if some talented patriots want to do something, their talents are suppressed because the talent has to come out of the politician's family otherwise it will be allowed to go anywhere.

If Martial Laws weren't bad enough now we have free media that's more prone ton screwing up our culture.

But Urdu will be back when we progress and the west trails us, soon Inshallah
 
?? ???? ???????? ?? ?? ????? ?? ??? ???? ?? ??? ???? ?? ??? ??? ?? ????? ??????? ????? ???? ??? ??? ??? ?? ??? ???? ??? ???? ???? ?? ?? ?? ??? ????? ??? ?
 
Last edited:

ajeeba

MPA (400+ posts)
This is so true. I live in the UK and speak English, but my main language is pashto. whenever i meet someone from back home i speak pure pashto or pure urdu. i tend not to mix english in it. I love all Pakistani Languages. they are so beautiful. they all should be our national languages not only Urdu.
 

angryoldman

Minister (2k+ posts)
there are only two nations who care,love ,respect there mother toungs.
1) pathans
2) sikhs
they don't shy to speak there languages at any level.and also 1st they learn to their kids.and its really strong basics for new generations.
 

KhanHaripur

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
Most Pakistanis have been brought up speaking our national language Urdu and English. Instead of conversing in Urdu, many of us lapse into English during everyday conversation. Even people who do not speak English very well try their best to sneak in a sentence or two, considering it pertinent for their acceptance in the ‘cooler’ crowd.

I wonder where the trend started, but unknowingly, unconsciously, somehow or the other we all get sucked into the trap. It was not until a few years ago while on a college trip to Turkey that I realized the misgivings of our innocent jabber.

A group of students of the LUMS Cultural Society trip went to Istanbul, Turkey to mark the 100th Anniversary of the famous Sufi poet Rumi. One day we were exploring the city when we stopped at a caf for lunch. The waiter took our orders, and continued to hover around our table during the meal. We barely noticed him until he came with the bill, and asked us:

“Where are you from?”

“Pakistan”

The waiter looked surprised, and then asked whether we had been brought up in England. We answered in the negative, telling him how Pakistan was where we all had grown up and spent out lives. The waiter genuinely looked perplexed now. Finally he blurted out:

‘Then why don’t you speak in the Pakistani language?’

The waiter went on to explain how Turkey, particularly Istanbul was a hot tourist location, luring millions of people of different nationalities from across the globe. However, when the Dutch would come visit, they would speak Dutch. When the French would come, they would speak French. When the Chinese would come visit, they would speak Chinese. Similarly everyone in Turkey spoke Turkish. He claimed he was very proud of his language and culture and failed to understand how someone would not speak the language of their country and choose instead a foreign tongue.

There were around ten of us there, and we were all at a loss of an answer. We had never thought of it that way. It was just something that you took up because of society. Even when people speak in Urdu, they tend to include a lot of English words in their sentences. Why is that? Is it because we are not proud of our national language? I am sure all of us are aware of how beautiful Urdu is, the poetry, grace and rhythm of our language is exceptional.

One excuse that springs to mind is the concept of ‘ westernisation’ due to the increased pace of globalization in todays world. Globalization is a factor, and yet the Japanese still speak Japanese, the Thai still speak Thai, the Greeks still speak Greek. China, a powerhouse on the global economic front, despite its many factories and western products production still speaks Chinese. In fact when the Chinese Olympics were held in 2008, the Chinese government actually had to ask its Chinese public to learn a few basic English words to help welcome the world.

I respect how these countries value their sense of identity, culture and language. I was deeply ashamed of what image I was unknowingly portraying of my country. I am very proud of Pakistan and Urdu, as I am sure we all are. No matter the problems, it is still our identity. I understand the irony of this article, since it is written in English. However, it is one way to reach those people who may unconsciously be making the same mistake as I was.

When living in the UK or travelling abroad, I make sure I use Urdu to converse with fellow Pakistanis. At home, I am also trying, though it is admittedly difficult since apparently there is a weird and honestly ‘sad’ association of how ‘cool’, well brought-up and educated a person is with the amount of English he or she speaks. I write this article because it is high time we break such ignorant patterns in our society. Urdu is a beautiful and graceful language and we owe our country the respect it deserves by speaking and portraying our true roots.

Kiya khayal hai?

http://blogs.tribune.com.pk/story/6545/urdu-vs-english-are-we-ashamed-of-our-language/

 

farazkhii

MPA (400+ posts)
Kiya baat hai jigar, sahe kaha. Asal mein aaj tak hum angreezon ke ghulam hain, usi ki yeh aik nishani hai. English bol ke goron jaisa banna chahta hain laken phir bhi goray hamain apne pair ki jooti se ziada nahe samajhte.

urdu ke importnace aue poora column english main...wa wa,,,,phir kehtay ho main marta hun...
 

Bombaybuz

Minister (2k+ posts)
Geek now we all know ... few years back you were in turkey and your whole group is very good with speaking english... feeling any better??

2ndly ..jahan tak baat hai urdu ki tou urdu aur local languages he booli jatee hain bhai is mulk main 27% literacy rate ka baad aap aur kya expact kartey hoo?? i have no idea kis duniya main rahtey hain ya logh FB k elawa bhe duniya hai bhai ... aap ka graduate bhe do lines theek sai bool nahi pata english ki ... aur english bolna ya bolney ki koshish koe kamzori nahi hai ... aik must req hai for higher education, to understand all the ref: books, even to get better jobs.
 

Geek

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
[MENTION=7864]Bombaybuz[/MENTION]

Hey mate, first of all I dint not write this peace, it was written by amna khalid and is publish in express tribune I have mentioned it url under the blog.

2ndly in IMO in this piece she tried to address mostly the elite class of our country and also about the people who try to speak english or mix english with urdu just to look literate, and for those people only jahils speak urdu. she has tried to emphasize on the importance of our national language. it was an important issue that's why I shared it here .
 

Bombaybuz

Minister (2k+ posts)
[MENTION=7864]Bombaybuz[/MENTION]

Hey mate, first of all I dint not write this peace, it was written by amna khalid and is it was an important issue that's why I shared it here .

I may not question your intentions while submitting this thread ...but emphasizing on the importance of our national language in a foreign language is itself a joke... but as i said with 27% literacy one can hardly change anything... 3/4 different education systems are working simultaneously in this country... same 12th from diff systems brings in diff cattle of fish. but your defense budget is 400% times to your education budget which tells the whole story i guess.
 

Imranpak

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
Most Pakistanis love their culture and heritage but the third expat generation mostly only speak and understand English. This is because mostly their parents were born and raised abroad so ties with Pakistan/iat have weakened, it's for parents to educate kids on who they are together with values and customs.

We are not ashamed whatsoever but much of our current generation is ignorant of our traditions and culture.