Sana Bucha caught stealing from The Economist Article - Geo Sack Sana Bucha

Pk_Qatar

MPA (400+ posts)
sana-bucha.JPG



Will the Geo show ‘some’ courage and suspend anchor Sana Bucha following in the footstep of the CNN on plagiarism charges.

The Geo/Jang group these days is propagating adopting the ‘Geo asool (principle)’ in journalism but practically doing against it.

The Time magazine and CNN has suspended an Indian-American journalist and author, Fareed Zakaria, for plagiarizing some sections of his column “The Case for Gun Control” from historian Jill Lepore’s work in the New Yorker. “He wrote a shorter blog post on CNN.com on the same issue which included similar unattributed excerpts.

Despite the findings of the inquiry committed of the organization (Geo) that Sana Bucha plagiarized an article of the Economist, no action has been taken against it so far. She also showed no ‘morality’ and stuck to the group albeit the charges were proved.
Bucha’s article published in The News on Sunday 17 July 2011. Her article is a word to word copy of the
article published in The Economist on July 14, 2011. Even some phrases in paragraphs are same.

http://www.thenews.com.pk/TodaysPrintDetail.aspx?ID=58127&Cat=9

http://www.economist.com/node/18959707

Source: Pakdesitny
 
Last edited by a moderator:

unique

MPA (400+ posts)
while editor time Fareed zakaria has paid heavily for plagiarizing only 1 paragraph in an article.
 

adeelch

New Member
Come on guys i don't like her either, but how do you know the economist article is not written by her????? economist doesn't have the author name most likely it is written by her. we should avoid levelling such accusations without proper proof.
 

Nice2MU

President (40k+ posts)
In those time there were no "Geo Usool" implement rather "Geo Bay-Usool" were prevailing. So your charges will be rejected. :)
 
G

gotti

Guest
First, Geo is not CNN. Second, copyrights don't exist Pakistan. Third, Fareed Zakaria is now being blamed for plagiarizing in his book as per an article in Washington Post. Fourth, you'll have to close Siasat.pk for posting TV Shows from Awaz that will also be closed. I lost count (pick any number), your agenda is anti-N league rather than ethics. Fifth, (I just saw "fourth", so this must be "fifth"), Fareed Zakaria is being punished for supporting Obama who is likely to lose his election due to a bad economy as per my prediction found here: http://www.siasat.pk/forum/showthread.php?73266-Predictions&p=942778&viewfull=1#post942778
 

gazoomartian

Prime Minister (20k+ posts)
First, Geo is not CNN. Second, copyrights don't exist Pakistan. Third, Fareed Zakaria is now being blamed for plagiarizing in his book as per an article in Washington Post. Fourth, you'll have to close Siasat.pk for posting TV Shows from Awaz that will also be closed. I lost count (pick any number), your agenda is anti-N league rather than ethics. Fifth, (I just saw "fourth", so this must be "fifth"), Fareed Zakaria is being punished for supporting Obama who is likely to lose his election due to a bad economy as per my prediction found here: http://www.siasat.pk/forum/showthread.php?73266-Predictions&p=942778&viewfull=1#post942778


Dear (John) Gotti!!!

That is the reason we are required by the moderators to always post the source. Such act vindicates the siasat.pk from plagiarism.

Posting any item w/o the link to the source could tantamount to theft of ideas with punishment in international laws.
 

xecutioner

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
First, Geo is not CNN. Second, copyrights don't exist Pakistan. Third, Fareed Zakaria is now being blamed for plagiarizing in his book as per an article in Washington Post. Fourth, you'll have to close Siasat.pk for posting TV Shows from Awaz that will also be closed. I lost count (pick any number), your agenda is anti-N league rather than ethics. Fifth, (I just saw "fourth", so this must be "fifth"), Fareed Zakaria is being punished for supporting Obama who is likely to lose his election due to a bad economy as per my prediction found here: http://www.siasat.pk/forum/showthread.php?73266-Predictions&p=942778&viewfull=1#post942778

Firstly ...gadhoon ka supporter gadha ... Secondly ... gadhoon ki khandaani rakheil sana bucha thirdly azaad media main ploton ki siasat lanay walay baRa gadha ... fourth .. hair transplant k baad aqal nahi aa jatti ..... fifth . .. you can buy few people but you can't buy youth .... now go and tell all this to bars gadha aur khaaooo hang group ..
 

rana_fahim

Voter (50+ posts)
aaj final ho he gaya k media he hamara khoon choosay ga..politician nay hamain itna dassa hy ya nahi but media itna gehra das raha hay jis ki koi had nahi hay.. koi bhi channel utha lo wahan aap bus disappointment he dekhain gay.. kion hay aysa ? hum may sy kitnay hain jo aaj bhi media pay bohat ziada rely kartay hain kis liye sirf is liye k ye ghareebon ki baat karta hay.. o mery ham watno ye ghareebon ki baat bhi apnay business k liye karta hay warna koi aysaa dekha hay jo ghareebon k saath beth kar un k ghar jaa kar iftaari karay.. nahi aysa ho he nahi sakta kion k inho nay itnay aali shaan set laga liye hain k.... (aagay aap khud saamgh daar hain..
kal 27 shab thi ibaadat ki raat (pata nahi laila-tul-qadar thi bhi ya nahi ) kion k hadees shareef may hay k taaq (odd) raaton mein laila-tul-qadar ki talash karo or hum.. kher baat jo mein nay karni hay wo ye hay k mein aap sb sy poochna chahta hon k kya sirf ibadat (naat shareef may reh gai hay) mery mu mein khaak mein ye nahi kehta k naat shareef nahi parhni chahiye magar ibadat sirf naat mein nahi hay.. ibadat nawafil mein hay, ibadat khud girya zaari mein hay magar hum aysy jahil hain k aik naat khawan naat parhta hay or hum "sirf suntay hain" naat to wo parh rahay hain humain kya mil raha hay.. think about it.. (mein phir ye baat clear karna chahta hon k na-oo-zu-billah mein Naaat shareef k khilaaf nahi hay, hargiz nahi magar is k ilawa bhi kuch hona chahiye infiraadi ibadat kitnay % hoti hay)

 
G

gotti

Guest
Dear (John) Gotti!!!

That is the reason we are required by the moderators to always post the source. Such act vindicates the siasat.pk from plagiarism.

Posting any item w/o the link to the source could tantamount to theft of ideas with punishment in international laws.

Bhai jaan...first of all...long time...second...plagiarism Pakistan main nahi exist kerti? log to PhD. main bhi plagiarism kertay hain.

What I am trying to say is that sirf iss waja say uski plagiarism yaad ayi kay woh anti-PTI hai?

Plagiarism ki baat kerni hai to hai to talk about aamir liaqat's degree or babar awan...is bichari ko maaf kero...no1 watches her show anyway
 
G

gotti

Guest
Firstly ...gadhoon ka supporter gadha ... Secondly ... gadhoon ki khandaani rakheil sana bucha thirdly azaad media main ploton ki siasat lanay walay baRa gadha ... fourth .. hair transplant k baad aqal nahi aa jatti ..... fifth . .. you can buy few people but you can't buy youth .... now go and tell all this to bars gadha aur khaaooo hang group ..

Yes, I support Nawaz but also Zardari and Altaf.


Gadhay ka supporter gadha...aur agar tum Imran khan kay supporter ho to phir Imran bhi gadha hai?
 

Back
Top