Qouta system aik Zulm

[Qalandari1]

Quota System is a total injustice against the population of Urban Sindh. If it is justifiable then why on Urban Sindh ONLY? Why not on Urban Punjab, Urban KPK and Urban Baluchistan? This is the game against Pakistan because this is a deliberate effort to push back the most educated people of Pakistan who live in Urban Sindh and speak Urdu. This system is in place since 1973, and it was implemented because of rural Sindh was not meeting the requirement of quality education. Was rural areas of Punjab, Sarhad and Baluchistan were well educated in 1973 or are they now? If not then why this is not in everywhere in Pakistan. PTI and Imran Khan has to denounce this injustice loudly if they claim themselves tehreek-e-INSAF.

Quota system exists in all four provinces dumbo....

Provincial quota in jobs to remain intact for 20 more years

Provincial quota in jobs to remain intact for 20 more years - thenews.com.pk

 

[Aijazahmed]

Quota system exists in all four provinces dumbo....

Provincial quota in jobs to remain intact for 20 more years

Provincial quota in jobs to remain intact for 20 more years - thenews.com.pk

You are really either an stupid or an ignorant person. You are referring the bill that is for federal govt. jobs for different provinces. We are talking here quota system within the Sindh province that is divided based on Urban and rural Sindh. There is not such thing prevails in other 3 provinces. WHY????

 

[Chaudhry_1960]

کوٹہ سسٹم کی وجہ سے نکموں کو اوپر آنے کا موقع ملتا ہے اس بات میں کوئ شک نہیں اسی لئے سندھ کے کرپٹ حکمران کوٹہ سسٹم کی آڑ میں اپنے نالائقوں کی بھتری کا سوچتے ہیں اور ایم کیو ایم. بھی صرف اس معاملے کو اپنی سیاست چمکانے کے لئے استعمال کرتے ہیں مگر سب سے بڑا اور اصل مسئلہ یہ ہے کہ نقصان سندھ کا ہوتا ہے جہاں صرف نکمے, نالائق اور نکھٹو اوپر جارہے ہیں اور اپنے غلط فیصلوں سے سندھ کو نقصان پہنچا رہے ہیں

 

[Qalandari1]

You are really either an stupid or an ignorant person. You are referring the bill that is for federal govt. jobs for different provinces. We are talking here quota system within the Sindh province that is divided based on Urban and rural Sindh. There is not such thing prevails in other 3 provinces. WHY????

Huh ? Isn't the concept the same ? MQM wants to end the quota system in totality. In the 23rd amendment bill quota for South Punjab was considered.

For your info there are seats reserved for selective rural areas of Punjab for admission in Punjab educational institutions. The quota system exists for FR region, PATA of KP and also FATA students. Similarly for Baloch students in Balochistan.

 

[ifteeahmed]

جب تک پی پی پی سندہ پر قابض رہی گی ، سندھ میں تعلیم اور ترقی نہیں ھوگی۔ کیونکہ اگر یہ لوگ تعلیمِ یافتہ ھوگئے تو انکی سیاست ختم ھوجائے گے۔

ایم کیو ایم کو چائے کہ وہ اپنی جماعت کو پی ٹی آئی میں ضم کردے کیونکہ اب پی ٹی آئی ہی واحد بڑی قومی جاعمت ھے جسمیں ہر قومیت کے لوگ بڑی تعداد میں شامل ھیں اور عمران ہی واحد لیڈر ھے جو مشکل فیصلے کرسکتا اور یہ معاملہ بھی عمران ہی حل کرسکتا ھے۔

 

[FaisalKh]

There is one thing I do not understand. If there is merit requirement within a quota category, then how it is bad. For example, if there is one seat reserved for Jhudoo (Sindh) in an Engineering university and there are 20 contenders for that seat from Jhudoo then only that contender will get the seat who has the highest marks. So someone, please explain to me, how it is bad?

What IF out of those 20, 19 have got 33% marks and one has got 34%? Would it still make any sense to u to select the one with 34% and u for example got 80% marks but still was left behind?(serious)

 

[escalations]

In USA, there is something called Affirmative Action (mainly to assist African Americans) and also several seats and scholarships reserved for Native Americans. In Canada and Australia similar things exists.

In Sindh, unlike other provinces of Pakistan, a large immigrant population moved after the partition, effectively turning the locals or Natives to a minority in urban or developed Sindh. This minority was not as educated as migrants and was overtaken for all provincial jobs and opportunities. Even though there was migration in other parts of Pakistan also but not at such large scale. If 1 crore Mohajirs had moved to Quetta at time of partition, we would have seen similar quota there also.
There used to exist some seats in Punjab from backward area's, not sure if they are still there.

One thing wrong with this quota system implementation is its abuse. If someone has a domicile from Dadu but is going to a elite private school in Karachi or Hyderabad, he/she should not be allowed to use the quota. The quota should be given to a student who is actually studying in a school in rural Dadu. The idea of the quota is to give an opportunity to less privileged student or job seeker.
FYI: I am not from Sindhi but I do feel it is a unique situation, unlike other provinces because of how migration happened.

 

[atensari]

پی پی سندھیوں کو تعلیم دے کر کوٹہ سسٹم ایم کیو ایم کے منہ پر مارے - مرسوں مرسوں تعلیم نا دے سوںپی پی سندھیوں کو تعلیم دے کر کوٹہ سسٹم ایم کیو ایم کے منہ پر
مارے - مرسوں مرسوں تعلیم نا دے سوں

 

[jason]

What is the quota for city?

Share of Govt jobs are decreasing in overal job market.

For urdu speaking population there is no such restriction in Punjab and other provinces.So it compensates to some extent.

 

[jason]

Quota system should be restricted to educational institutes only.

for providing equal opportunity and that would be equitable.

 

[Exiled-Pakistani]

You have a valid point; I guess universities also need to set minimum standards to get admission. Just like 34% marks are ridiculus, then so are the people contesting with 98.1 % marks

What IF out of those 20, 19 have got 33% marks and one has got 34%? Would it still make any sense to u to select the one with 34% and u for example got 80% marks but still was left behind?(serious)