(Poll) Who do you think performed well and is responsible for recent stability of Pakistan?

[Lil'Genius]

Greetings,

I am creating a poll to understand the reason for our recent economic stability. I will not consider the past or any other political affiliations.
According to the constitution of Pakistan, it is safe to say that Pakistan have four distinct Pillars of Power* or Branches of State: Judiciary (Supreme Court), Legislative Government (under Prime Minister), Pakistan Arm Forces (whose supreme commander is President) and Electronic / Print Media.

With some amendments to this list, I am creating this poll to seek wisdom from masses.

Question:
Who do you think performed well and is responsible for recent stability of Pakistan?

Options:

• Judiciary
• Government (Ruling Party + Allies)
• Opposition (All parties in opposition)
• Pakistan Arm Forces
• Electronic / Print Media
• All above
• None

Regards,

*This is my interpretation. Any member with knowledge of Pakistan's constitution can guide.

 

[Galaxy]

Re: Pakistan's Recent Stability : Causes

​The fear of PTI.

 

[HORUS]

Re: Pakistan's Recent Stability : Causes

Economic stability is due to fall in global crude oil prices and also decrease in terrorism( thanks to rangers and Pak army ) which has greatly helped stabilise the country

 

[tz00007]

Re: Pakistan's Recent Stability : Causes

Army... plus fear of PTI...

 

[Talha Asif]

Re: Pakistan's Recent Stability : Causes

Pakistan Armed Forces

 

[PUNJABIMUNDANO1]

Re: Pakistan's Recent Stability : Causes

Income of agriculture community has decreased 50% in last 2 years in Punjab , remember 70% population of Pakistan is dependent on agriculture

Is this called economic stability ... your 70% population is more poorer than it was before

 

[Lil'Genius]

Re: Pakistan's Recent Stability : Causes

Income of agriculture community has decreased 50% in last 2 years in Punjab , remember 70% population of Pakistan is dependent on agriculture
Is this called economic stability ... your 70% population is more poorer than it was before

Well, I have no knowledge about that. What I know is that, all economic indicators are showing stability. Plus, are you sure the problems in agriculture sector is not because of climate change or floods etc?

 

[arafay]

Re: Pakistan's Recent Stability : Causes

there is no economic stability. i dont know where you are getting this idea from. all that has happened is inflation has gone down because oil prices went down and along with oil, all commodity prices came down. everything is the same for last 7-8 years

 

[PUNJABIMUNDANO1]

Re: Pakistan's Recent Stability : Causes

Well, I have no knowledge about that. What I know is that, all economic indicators are showing stability. Plus, are you sure the problems in agriculture sector is not because of climate change or floods etc?

Flood and diseases are also a factor .... but it is limited to some areas

Main factor is declining exports

When rice was being exported , a farmer was getting 2000 to 2500 price for 40 Kg of rice

Now , the rice export has fallen drastically ... Last year rice is still in Gudams and farmers are being paid just 1200 to 1300 price for 40 kg from last year

Rice is the main crop of central Punjab, Hence the income of entire region has fallen almost half

There could be two reasons

Failure in finding Export Markets

or

Rice Cartel is looting poor farmers with the support of government (almost all the big rice exporters are the ministers in Punjab or Federal Governments )

Anyway , Just google Pakistani exports in last 2 years ... Our exports are falling and imports are increasing ... Do u call it stability of Economy?

 

[Lil'Genius]

Re: Pakistan's Recent Stability : Causes

Flood and diseases are also a factor .... but it is limited to some areas
Main factor is declining exports
When rice was being exported , a farmer was getting 2000 to 2500 price for 40 Kg of rice
Now , the rice export has fallen drastically ... Last year rice is still in Gudams and farmers are being paid just 1200 to 1300 price for 40 kg from last year
Rice is the main crop of central Punjab, Hence the income of entire region has fallen almost half
There could be two reasons
Failure in finding Export Markets
or
Rice Cartel is looting poor farmers with the support of government (almost all the big rice exporters are the ministers in Punjab or Federal Governments )
Anyway , Just google Pakistani exports in last 2 years ... Our exports are falling and imports are increasing ... Do u call it stability of Economy?

I guess you have more precise knowledge about Rice Exports. I was more focusing on overall economic stability. In urban cities the businesses are booming, Dollar Rate and other factors. Don't you think the Pakistan after 2013 is more stable ?

 

[PUNJABIMUNDANO1]

Re: Pakistan's Recent Stability : Causes

I guess you have more precise knowledge about Rice Exports. I was more focusing on overall economic stability. In urban cities the businesses are booming, Dollar Rate and other factors. Don't you think the Pakistan after 2013 is more stable ?

Same situation is in cotton belt

Brother!

70% population is dependent on agriculture . 70% population is under stress and u are talking about economic boom

Urban Traders are also dependent on consumers and most of the consumers come from villages ... If villagers have no money then how come the urban economy be booming ?

I live in Lahore and trading business is also down only the salaried community is happy due to decline in inflation (because of declining oil prices)

How can u say people are Happy?

Two years ago I was receiving 8 to 10 thousand electricity bill now I am paying 20,000 rupees ... Electricity prices are almost double than 2013 and income is down

We are paying more indirect taxes than 2013 ... GST was increased ... Even we are paying more on a Mobile card than 2013

But after all these taxes People are getting nothing in return

 

[thinking]

Re: Pakistan's Recent Stability : Causes

Current ARMY leaderships and PTI..is the main thing for
Pakistan...others all are just Bullshit...

 

[PUNJABIMUNDANO1]

Re: Pakistan's Recent Stability : Causes

I guess you have more precise knowledge about Rice Exports. I was more focusing on overall economic stability. In urban cities the businesses are booming, Dollar Rate and other factors. Don't you think the Pakistan after 2013 is more stable ?

Dollar was at 97 two years ago or before May 11

Now it is almost 102

I think you are just following Non League propaganda which cannot be corroborated from the facts on ground

 

[Lil'Genius]

Re: Pakistan's Recent Stability : Causes

Dollar was at 97 two years ago or before May 11

Now it is almost 102

I think you are just following Non League propaganda which cannot be corroborated from the facts on ground

I am not. I am just comparing situation of Pakistan before and after 2013. TBH, from 2003 to 2007, Pakistan was more stable. Just my opinion...some will curse me now :)

 

[PUNJABIMUNDANO1]

Re: Pakistan's Recent Stability : Causes

I am not. I am just comparing situation of Pakistan before and after 2013. TBH, from 2003 to 2007, Pakistan was more stable. Just my opinion...some will curse me now :)

yes ...... Musharraf tenure was one of the best period of Pakistan history in economic terms in my memory

Agriculture economy was booming , so the urban , Even the poor people in villages became able to by fridge and tv

Mobile made its way into every hand

Middle class became able to by a car

Property business was booming too

And this prosperity led people to see the dream of an independent Judiciary and a Democratic country

But the judiciary and democratic governments that followed not only destroyed the strong economy of Pakistan but all the dreams of Pakistani Nation

 

[Lil'Genius]

Re: Pakistan's Recent Stability : Causes

yes ...... Musharraf tenure was one of the best period of Pakistan history in economic terms in my memory

Agriculture economy was booming , so the urban , Even the poor people in villages became able to by fridge and tv

Mobile made its way into every hand

Middle class became able to by a car

Property business was booming too

And this prosperity led people to see the dream of an independent Judiciary and a Democratic country

But the judiciary and democratic governments that followed not only destroyed the strong economy of Pakistan but all the dreams of Pakistani Nation

I am not here to defend Musharaf but he proved that his every decision was right.

1. Supporting world on war against terror....Time proved his decision was right !
2. Ending support of internal extremist wings....Time proved his decision was right !
3. Lal Masjid Operation....Time proved his decision was right !
4. Banning of Geo / Jhang....Time proved his decision was right !
5. Kicking Nawaz government....Time proved his decision was right !
6. Ch. Iftikhar....Time proved his decision was right !
7. Kashmir Issue resolution....Time proved his decision was right !
8. Allowing and revolutionising Education, Media and Telecom sector....Time proved his decision was right !


Surprisingly, he was so called dictator :)

 

[PUNJABIMUNDANO1]

Re: Pakistan's Recent Stability : Causes

I am not here to defend Musharaf but he proved that his every decision was right.

1. Supporting world on war against terror....Time proved his decision was right !
2. Ending support of internal extremist wings....Time proved his decision was right !
3. Lal Masjid Operation....Time proved his decision was right !
4. Banning of Geo / Jhang....Time proved his decision was right !
5. Kicking Nawaz government....Time proved his decision was right !
6. Ch. Iftikhar....Time proved his decision was right !
7. Kashmir Issue resolution....Time proved his decision was right !
8. Allowing and revolutionising Education, Media and Telecom sector....Time proved his decision was right !


Surprisingly, he was so called dictator :)

I agree with all this , his every decision proved right

but surprisingly he was a military dictator :)

 

[Lil'Genius]

Re: Pakistan's Recent Stability : Causes

I agree with all this , his every decision proved right

but surprisingly he was a military dictator :)

Surprisingly, this time Pakistan is stable due to the efforts of Gen. Raheel....Another General from Army :)

 

[Unorthodox]

Re: Pakistan's Recent Stability : Causes

 

[PUNJABIMUNDANO1]

Re: Pakistan's Recent Stability : Causes

Surprisingly, this time Pakistan is stable due to the efforts of Gen. Raheel....Another General from Army :)

Pakistan only became stable in terms of security .... Terrorist attacks receding

But economically the situation is becoming worse for general public ... May be government revenue increasing due to excessive indirect taxation