Poll: Pakistan: secular, moderate Islamist or Islamic Modernist???

[atensari]

He talks about this quote during first two minutes. He did not present any quote explicit or implicit that contradicts the statement that I brought forward. On its face value it applies to Muslims and Non Muslims. Mr. Ahmed has tried to explain it. His position is that " Nizam" must be Islamic. If the law of the land is Islamic and people of the land Muslim and Non-Muslim must follow the law or face punishments than there is " Jabar " involved and the statement becomes irreverent. What he says is simply back door to " compulsion in religion ".

Law and Punishment are not "Jabar" at all. If it is then we are living under "Jabar" even in secular world.

 

[Unicorn]

I agree that law and punishment are not Jabar. But when you legislate religion as a state law than religion becomes a compulsion.

 

[atensari]

I agree that law and punishment are not Jabar. But when you legislate religion as a state law than religion becomes a compulsion.

Laws do not fall under compulsion. This is what explained in #18. System always enforced, no body want to pay bank interest, but system made it compulsory.

 

[justsomguy]

islam, islam, islam...any muslim who prefers another way of life needs to check himself