Open Letter to IMRAN KHAN

[PakistaniFirst]

March 22, 2011

Dear Imran Khan,

Your telephone call to Altaf Hussain has taken everyone by surprise and most of your admirers and followers have failed to understand the exact motive behind the contact.
At the same time, it hardly surprised anyone after listening to Altaf Hussain on issue of welcoming Taliban, bringing back Aafia Siddiqui, injustice of Raymond Davis, or any other major issue because everyone knows that these Altaf’s statements are meaningless only used for political point scoring.
For example, this nation enjoys the daily jokes of Altaf Hussain that he is against feudal and corruption, while practically Altaf Hussain has been supporting and enjoying every government since 2 decades.

The press release from PTI states that you and Altaf Hussain have found common ground on the following three national issues:

1- Raymond Davis
2- Aafia Siddiqui
3- Drone Attacks

Although I might be unable to completely understand your latest move based on my inexperience, I still believe that these 3 issues are just symptoms of deeper problems for which Altaf Hussain is directly responsible, and I don’t think you will achieve anything productive unless you find common ground on those deeper issues.

You might want think about few of these core questions before finding common ground on surface issues:

- Will Altaf Hussain ever support military rule or intervention in future? This is the core issue as all these three problems are direct result of Military-US partnership and decided outside the parliament.

- Will Altaf Hussain ever support sacking of judiciary and take part in the process directly through his governor and parliamentarians? This is also very important as the name of your political party is “Tehreek-e-Insaaf”.

- Will Altaf Hussain stop the crimes in Karachi and allow peace to take place? More people have been killed in Karachi than by terrorism in rest of Pakistan. Killing is a much bigger crime religiously and legally than corruption and you have been very vocal against killings by Altaf Hussain since 12th May. Do you think it is wise to support someone you accuse of murders against someone you accuse of corruption?
There can be a couple of more questions on core issues, but I would like to highlight Altaf’s current stance on the 3 issues where you found common ground:

1- Raymond Davis – Most of the statements from Altaf Hussain came after Raymond was released, which shows that basis of AH stance is political point scoring rather than principles. Secondly, AH is currently supporting PPP government, most notably Rehman Malik who has allowed hundreds of Raymond Davis to exist in Pakistan. Can you ask AH to quit partnership with PPP and demand RM to get rid of these CIA contractors to prove that AH is really serious on RD issue? Secondly, if AH can hold weekly sermons in presence of healthy audience, why didn’t he bring a huge protest against release of RD?

2- Aafia Siddiqui – She was kidnapped by Pakistani officials along with her 3 kids under government of MQM in both Sindh and Federal, and General Musharraf was empowered by Altaf Hussain, which makes AH hugely responsible for this kidnap, and hundreds of other kidnaps that were sold to the Americans against dollars. While AH was fully involved in worst form of human rights abuse, what makes you think AH really cares about bringing Dr. Aafia Siddiqui back to Pakistan?

3- Drone Attacks – Everyone knows that your stance on War of Terror is totally opposite to that of Altaf Hussain, where you have been vocal advocate of dialogue and stopping american terrorism, while AH mostly supported use of force. What makes you think that you can just corporate on issue of “Drone Attacks” alone while the core issue is the unjust war of terror where your policies are conflicting?

Finally, let me share a short dialogue I recently had with a taxi driver from Khyber-Pakhtoonkhuwa in Dubai:

I asked the driver why people in his province support ANP?
He answered that Pakhtoons of KP like Imran Khan not ANP, but they love ANP because they are the only party in Karachi that can fight back against AH and protect Pakhtoon residents and workers.

I wonder what that taxi driver and other similar minded people from KP thinking now after knowing any possibility of IK and AH alliance.

 

[lovely_pk]

Trust me it didn't surprise me at all as i already know he is even bigger hypocrite then this!!!!!

 

[malikbhai]

Here is my reply on this issue.

 

[Dr Z Khan]

I totally agree with lovely_pk

 

[Lawangeen]

I am totally disagree with you and one more thing i am not a supporter of Imran khan but he is a great leader and i respect him. You should be thinking out of the box, don't think like every other person and about Pukhtoon khwa ppl... i am from there, and Imran khan will be the next elected leader from our province. And about ANP no one likes ANP they are corrupt to the core, they came into power coz of their elder's name. But thats it No more ANP in khyber puktoon khwa...

 

[arslan4u]

A reply to your letter from a PTI supporter:

Your telephone call to Altaf Hussain has taken everyone by surprise and most of your admirers and followers have failed to understand the exact motive behind the contact.

NO, there is absolutely nothing confusing about it. Imran wants to develop a national concensus on drone attacks and Aafia's case. If we agree on certain issues than there is no harm in working together on THOSE ISSUES i.e. During the Chief Justice Movement all parties worked together and set their differences aside. Similarly, during Gunj's rule opposition parties worked together.

At the same time, it hardly surprised anyone after listening to Altaf Hussain on issue of welcoming Taliban, bringing back Aafia Siddiqui, injustice of Raymond Davis, or any other major issue because everyone knows that these Altaf’s statements are meaningless only used for political point scoring.

Again, a baseless assumption, it in fact took everyone by surprise, blogosphere and Pakistani political circles were all buzzing with this news. PTI should be credited for this as Imran set these precedents to speaking with Altaf on the PHONE and surprisingly Altaf complied. Political statements are always issued for political point scoring, the fundamental law of politics is to sway public opinion towards you by issuing statements that attract people, not sure what's so illegal about it. But you can ask MQM instead of Imran because Imran is not a leader of MQM, why are you asking Imran about Altaf's ambitions?

For example, this nation enjoys the daily jokes of Altaf Hussain that he is against feudal and corruption, while practically Altaf Hussain has been supporting and enjoying every government since 2 decades.

Again, MQM should answer this and it has nothing to do with Raymond Davis case or Aafia's case.

The press release from PTI states that you and Altaf Hussain have found common ground on the following three national issues:
1- Raymond Davis
2- Aafia Siddiqui
3- Drone Attacks
Although I might be unable to completely understand your latest move based on my inexperience, I still believe that these 3 issues are just symptoms of deeper problems for which Altaf Hussain is directly responsible, and I don’t think you will achieve anything productive unless you find common ground on those deeper issues.

Again, nothing so complicated in that,
RAYMOND - whoever is responsible for his release must be exposed i.e. Shahbaz Sharif and PMLN!!
AAFIA - must be released
DRONES - must stop

You might want think about few of these core questions before finding common ground on surface issues:

PTI doesn't need a friendly advice from a PMLN toady. As Imran says, he doesn't accept free advice; you have to donate to PTI party fund first.

- Will Altaf Hussain ever support military rule or intervention in future? This is the core issue as all these three problems are direct result of Military-US partnership and decided outside the parliament.

You can ask Altaf if he will or won't support a military dictatorship. It has nothing to do with PTI. It's not the military-US relationship only but Pakistan's civilian governments have been a staunch supporters as well including PMLN who really went above and beyond in the Raymond Davis case to please their masters. PTI opposes all those who support US drone attacks whether it's military or a civilian government but under the current circumstances since we a have "democratically" elected government, it's their responsibility to control the military and agencies and if they can't than they must resign.
Pakistan Tehreek e Insaf wants to work with those who are against drone attacks and Aafia's case, it's as simple as that!!

- Will Altaf Hussain ever support sacking of judiciary and take part in the process directly through his governor and parliamentarians? This is also very important as the name of your political party is “Tehreek-e-Insaaf”.

Pakistan Tehreek e Insaf does not base its decisions on assumptions. Again, what Altaf will do and won't do in the future is none of any concern to PTI. A separate letter should be send to Altaf asking him about his future strategy.
In politics, parties agree and disagree on issues, in the case of Drone attacks PTI and MQM agree and in other issues they disagree. We cannot link one issue to the other issue and shut all our doors on our opponents.

- Will Altaf Hussain stop the crimes in Karachi and allow peace to take place? More people have been killed in Karachi than by terrorism in rest of Pakistan. Killing is a much bigger crime religiously and legally than corruption and you have been very vocal against killings by Altaf Hussain since 12th May. Do you think it is wise to support someone you accuse of murders against someone you accuse of corruption?

Again, MQM should answer these questions/allegations. 32000 Pakistanis have been killed in FATA KPK because of this illegal war and as a direct result of drone attack in Pakistan.
PTI acknowledges MQM stance on drones but also vehemently opposes and condemns terror techniques used by MQM in Karachi, credit and condemnation must be granted where it's due.

There can be a couple of more questions on core issues, but I would like to highlight Altaf’s current stance on the 3 issues where you found common ground:
1- Raymond Davis – Most of the statements from Altaf Hussain came after Raymond was released, which shows that basis of AH stance is political point scoring rather than principles. Secondly, AH is currently supporting PPP government, most notably Rehman Malik who has allowed hundreds of Raymond Davis to exist in Pakistan. Can you ask AH to quit partnership with PPP and demand RM to get rid of these CIA contractors to prove that AH is really serious on RD issue? Secondly, if AH can hold weekly sermons in presence of healthy audience, why didn’t he bring a huge protest against release of RD?

Why Altaf did what he did is not PTI's responsibility. This should be directed to MQM. The only issues that were discussed in less than 10 minute conversation were Raymond, Aafia and Drone Attacks. Again, PTI acknowledged MQM's stance on Drone attacks and Aafia. They are not our ally, or strategic partner.

2- Aafia Siddiqui – She was kidnapped by Pakistani officials along with her 3 kids under government of MQM in both Sindh and Federal, and General Musharraf was empowered by Altaf Hussain, which makes AH hugely responsible for this kidnap, and hundreds of other kidnaps that were sold to the Americans against dollars. While AH was fully involved in worst form of human rights abuse, what makes you think AH really cares about bringing Dr. Aafia Siddiqui back to Pakistan?

Altaf Hussain held huge rallies in Karachi supporting Aafia's case and Fouzia Siddiqi went to 9/0 to personally thank MQM's leadership during a press conference.
PTI acknowledges these attempts by MQM.
Why MQM didn't help Aafia before is not PTI's responsibility. Ask MQM!!

3- Drone Attacks – Everyone knows that your stance on War of Terror is totally opposite to that of Altaf Hussain, where you have been vocal advocate of dialogue and stopping american terrorism, while AH mostly supported use of force. What makes you think that you can just corporate on issue of “Drone Attacks” alone while the core issue is the unjust war of terror where your policies are conflicting?

Drone attacks on PAKISTANI soil are an issue of our sovereignty and as a result of these many innocent Pakistanis have lost their lives.
Drone attacks are an extension of War on terror and they are not separate issues.
Again, we have acknowledged MQM's stance against drone attacks and that is all that was discussed in a telephonic conversation between Altaf and Imran. A broad detailed discussion including War on terror did not take place.

Finally, let me share a short dialogue I recently had with a taxi driver from Khyber-Pakhtoonkhuwa in Dubai:
I asked the driver why people in his province support ANP?
He answered that Pakhtoons of KP like Imran Khan not ANP, but they love ANP because they are the only party in Karachi that can fight back against AH and protect Pakhtoon residents and workers.
I wonder what that taxi driver and other similar minded people from KP thinking now after knowing any possibility of IK and AH alliance.

Nice anecdote, but flawed logic!!
ANP support killing of innocent Pushtuns by drone attacks but opposes killing of Pushtuns in Karachi??
Pushtuns of KPK are more concerned with what's happening in their own backyard. There is a staunch opposition to drone attacks in KPK.
By the way, every letter is usually signed by the writer; it would be nice to see who wrote this letter. I would appreciate if I know who I am addressing in my reply.
I think I should consult PMLN's media cell (owner of PKP) dedicated to Imran Khan and PTI.


Source: http://pkpolitics.com/discuss/topic/answer-to-pkpolitics-despicable-attempt-of-maligning-pti

 

[pak4242]

Forgive your enemies, but never forget their names.
MAY ALLAH KEEP YOU AWAY FROM BAD POLITICS.

IMRAN KHAN IS ONLY HOPE FOR PAKISTAN

 

[syediqbal]

I think we should not make "TOUFAN IN CHAI KI PIALEE MAIN" give some time and then judge.....wait and see!

 

[abbasiali]

Here is my reply on this issue.

Great Quote,

PTI-MQM Great partners,

Imran Khan & Altaf Hussain two great leaders, both are going to change whole face of Pakistan, cuz now our great leader Imran Khan have discovered few resemblence in few things, soon after lot will start match, and then happy ending.........lolzzzzzzzzzzz

Altaf Hussain President of Pakistan

Imran Khan Prime Minister of Pakistan.

Establishment is now looking new combination. I believe.

 

[Aijazahmed]

great quote,

pti-mqm great partners,

imran khan & altaf hussain two great leaders, both are going to change whole face of pakistan, cuz now our great leader imran khan have discovered few resemblence in few things, soon after lot will start match, and then happy ending.........lolzzzzzzzzzzz

altaf hussain president of pakistan

imran khan prime minister of pakistan.

Establishment is now looking new combination. I believe.

but for me, only imran is a looser in this new move.

Who are the winners then? Only pmln.

Recently pmln came up with two big blunders:
1- supported lotacracy
2- gave safe passage to raymond davis etc...

People in punjab especially pmln supporters were going apart of pmln, and they have started to look for alternate force in punjab, and imran was the ideal for them.
But imran did a big mistake to call altaf bhai. Now people have again gone back to pmln.

Imran once again missed the train. He had a golden chance to fill the gap in punjab. But calling ah he has pushed himself back to square one.

Imran needs a good vice captain in politics also.....he needs javed miandad in pti.

New life to pmln.

 

[gazoomartian]

here is my $0.02 before I head to bed

I do not support IK because he is some sorta pious man or a farishta sifat insaan - its just a matter of lack of alternative.

Find me a better person, I will dump IK. I have seen them all.

The nation should give PTI a chance, like the commercial says:

You have seen the rest, now see the best

Current party geedars are not an alternative. Give PTI a chance, try him out

zara pata to chaley key bhai saheb kitney paani mein hain

DO NOT WASTE YOUR VOTES on the current govt leaders
​

 

[ALI ARYAN]

سب حضرات کی رائے پڑھنے کے بعد صرف ایک بات میری سمجھ میں آتی ہی کے عمران خان اور الطاف حسین کے درمیان رابطے سے صرف وہ عناصر خوش نہیں ہیں جو کے تعصب اور بغض سے بھرے ہوے دل رکھتے ہیں. ملکی حالت کے پیش ا نظر اس وقت کو ملک کو تیرے آپش کی ضرورت ہے اور وہ تیسرا آپشن عوام کو صرف متحدہ اور عمران خان دے سکتے ہیں. نہیں تو ووہی ہو گا جو ہمیشہ سے ہوتا آ رہا ہی پہلے تیری پھر میری باری.

 

[Nice2MU]

I totally agree with lovely_pk

You both are the Idiot Most peoples in this forum rather in this world. So it's better to ignore you

Every Good peoples even Prophets had many opponents because Satan must have some supporters so keep going on Mr Fake , hypocrite and Lier Doctor

 

[Nice2MU]

but for me, only imran is a looser in this new move.

Who are the winners then? Only pmln.

Recently pmln came up with two big blunders:
1- supported lotacracy
2- gave safe passage to raymond davis etc...

People in punjab especially pmln supporters were going apart of pmln, and they have started to look for alternate force in punjab, and imran was the ideal for them.
But imran did a big mistake to call altaf bhai. Now people have again gone back to pmln.

Imran once again missed the train. He had a golden chance to fill the gap in punjab. But calling ah he has pushed himself back to square one.

Imran needs a good vice captain in politics also.....he needs javed miandad in pti.

New life to pmln.

Every news or story has a Shelf life. This whole debate of Imran-Altaf Phone Call will finish in 7-10 days and peoples would discussing some other Raymond Davis type things.

I disagree with you that PML (N) go new life because:

1: Their 45 % Fake votes have been deducted from Voter lists on which PML and PPP used to win

2. Peoples now want change and PML & PPP have nothing new to give or people don't trust them now.

 

[lovely_pk]

You both are the Idiot Most peoples in this forum rather in this world. So it's better to ignore you

Every Good peoples even Prophets had many opponents because Satan must have some supporters so keep going on Mr Fake , hypocrite and Lier Doctor

>>>> You both are the Idiot Most peoples in this forum rather in this world. So it's better to ignore you <<<

No wonder man, you are getting smart!!!!!!!!! you are doing good in keeping yourself out of trouble.

 

[NisarMalik]

The paid online media propaganda brigade of Imran Khan maintains a track record of u-turns ever since he has jumped into politics with the slogan “Next Prime Minister”….

All Pakistanis remember Imran Khan's comments on May 12, 2007

when he said MQM is different because they first attack and then project themselves as aggrieved.

He blamed MQM for terrorizing Edhi’s son:

he promised that no “reconciliation” will be done until justice is done with the blood of 50 people killed by MQM on May 12, 2007.
On May 27, 2007 Imran Khan said that MQM is a mafia, whose “don” is Altaf Hussain sitting in London. They rely on blackmailing and harassment. They are extortionists.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5CqiyXm5afc&feature=related

Similarly, Imran Khan was also thrashed by MQM:

This lumpoon was once beaten and stranded by Jamiat (Jamat Islami students wing) at Punjab University in 2007. Yes JI is the same party in whose lap this person is now sitting.

Imran Khan's direct question to Altaf Hussain: http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=ApIdn_Oe5Uw

However, it seems that the "establishment" has started playing a new game through PoTI + MQM when Altaf Hussain seeks help from Imran Khan in Punjab:

http://ummat.com.pk/2011/03/20/news.php?p=news-02.gif

Every word written in this news item, written over 15 months ago, seems very true. http://www.columnpk.com/secret-deal-between-imran-khan-and-mqm-chief-altan-hussain/
Burying the hatchet: http://tribune.com.pk/story/135283/burying-the-hatchet-imran-calls-up-altaf-agrees-to-work-together/
Imran’s dictator mindset is pretty clear when he takes another U-turn on MQM
http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=cWweAvO33fU

No wonder the real workers of PTI are frustrated and the PoTI party is left with paid online media brigade http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v=VZJP0KGd6fI


He visited all the power brokers to seek their help. But he has subsequently been lying about his visit to None-Zero http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=ZQa9QReLgew

With the advent of media, the world has changed considerably. Every word that you utter or any action that you do is tracked to show you a mirror! This mirror shows that Imran Khan has been taking considerable u-turns on the direction of his masters.