News Night- 26th December 2011 - Critical Analysis of Karachi Jalsa

[pak4242]

Kiya hum sab IMRAN KHAN sey ziyada akalmand hai....? yaqeenan nahi. Kiya ALLAH ney hum mei se kisi ko us maqam per faiz kiya hai jis per IMRAN KHAN 30saal se khara kaya hum pakistanies may se aksariyat ki tamana nahi hai ke hum bhi IMRAN KHAN ki terha koi bara kam kar ka mulk ki khidmat kare.........? Jab hum sab ye nahi kersaktey to pher har baat mei shak,tankeed ya IK ko beyakal samaghna mere samagh se bahar hai....?
IMRAN KHAN mai koi to baat hai jis ki waja se who IMRAN KHAN hai.
ALLAH IMRAN KHAN ki hifazat farmay AMEEN.

 

[BuTurabi]

خُوگرِ حمد سے تھوڑا سا گِلہ بھی سُن لے​

 

[zeshaan]

Talat sahib,
Buhat buhat shukrea,jalsay kee khubian aoor khamian ujagar karnay kaa,umeed hay keh PTI kay sarkarda loog aainda iss baat kaa khayal rakhain gay.

 

[MD Orackzai]

Kia javed hashmi nawaz sharif say zyada aqalmaand tha kion kay Allah nay nawaz sharif ko pichaly 30 saal say aik maqam par rkha hay

Kiya hum sab IMRAN KHAN sey ziyada akalmand hai....? yaqeenan nahi. Kiya ALLAH ney hum mei se kisi ko us maqam per faiz kiya hai jis per IMRAN KHAN 30saal se khara kaya hum pakistanies may se aksariyat ki tamana nahi hai ke hum bhi IMRAN KHAN ki terha koi bara kam kar ka mulk ki khidmat kare.........? Jab hum sab ye nahi kersaktey to pher har baat mei shak,tankeed ya IK ko beyakal samaghna mere samagh se bahar hai....?
IMRAN KHAN mai koi to baat hai jis ki waja se who IMRAN KHAN hai.
ALLAH IMRAN KHAN ki hifazat farmay AMEEN.

 

[hawkeyeblue]

We heard many times the respected intellectual (anchors) criticise Imran for not been able to give PLAN
As a very little educated person, with 2 masters and 22 years of professional life and just a student of political science. I studied at least 200 most prominent historical speeches of global leaders like Nelson Nandela, Desmond Tutu, Gandhi, Winston Churchill, Charles de Gaulle, Abraham Lincoln, Martin Luther King, Jr., Malcom X, few dictators like Adolf Hitler and Juan Jos Mosalini, Some revolutionaries like Mao Tse-Tung, Che Guevara and Fidel Castro quite a few American presidents and last and more relevant Qaid-e-Azam Mohammad Ali Jinnah and his companion. I was NOT ABLE TO FIND any so called PLAN laid out in their speeches one thing was common they gave policy guidelines and principles framework. Now is it not unfair of these respected intellectual (anchors) to criticise Imran for expectation of such thing merely because public speeches are not suppose to have the full PLAN (how to) details.

 

[Killthecorrupts]

Every anchor has become the so called intellectual. They think they change people's view with their rubbish theories. Time has changed & they have to say & show what people want to see and hear.

 

[saadkiakaray]

I have been observed talat since 2007 , now i relize that he is not as good as i thinked b4 ! He is biased against ik. He said there were 200000 or 250000 ! Although there were more than 500000 ! I was there ,every road was jam but talat didnt admited that it was most successful jalsa in pakistan history. He was just trying to find flaws in ik speech.note my words he wants n leage as next ruler.

 

[prolife]

I hope Mr Talat knows it was not a presidential debate but a public speech where in leaders only present an outline of their programes. But Yes, if Mr Talat expected from IK to have read each project report of PTI programes to the people then Mr Talat's analytical standards is something which needs a critical analysis. However, I agree Ik should have talked more about Karachi.

 

[prolife]

Mr Talat please try not to over exagirate your critical thinking to the point it becomes meaningless and discredible.

 

[saadkiakaray]

تا
talat was looking more cashier than analyst ! 3 times pti name,5 times said pakistan,5 time said karachi .....bla bla ! is he mad !

 

[k.a.kiani]

Thanks for replying to me...I should have made my statement more clearer. All I was trying to say is that he should do the same analysis of other politicians as well so that common people can compare them to Imran Khan and people would have a clear pic of the game.

As you can see the first thing I said was Good Analysis Talat saab.My post is still unedited.

hahaha... brother my answer is there is not comparison b/w IK and other politician so spare talat from wasting his precious time on others. he is too busy. people already know the difference. didn't you see in Lahore, Karachi and many other places. so there is already consensus that IK and PTI is above all corrupt leaders and parties

 

[k.a.kiani]

Good efforts in analysing but as often media is knit picking bit too much. No party can read out the whole manifesto in a jalsa. People will run away with bordem. We should not become perfectionist when expecting from a party. Take any other parties and compare with PTI. I am sure they can't even be declared 50% of what PTI success.

bhai jaan ye sirf analysis nahi tha. yeh "critical analysis" tha aur critical analysis mein weak point hi bata'ey jaatai hein. so dont worry Talat hussain is not an ordinary media man. He is most credible journalist and if he is wrong then you don't need to rely on any media man or woman.

 

[k.a.kiani]

تا
talat was looking more cashier than analyst ! 3 times pti name,5 times said pakistan,5 time said karachi .....bla bla ! is he mad !

o baba kaun bata'ey aapko aik important speech ka analysis issi tarha kia jata hai. you know how much PTI spent to make this speech. when you write your speech, especially when you know that this will become part of history, you have to give specific number of words to every issue. Ab meray bhai mein tumhein kya samjhaon politics mein leader ki taqreer bari important hoti hai. Ap eik taqreer se election jeet bhi saktai ho aur haar bhi.

 

[LovelyVirus]

bhai jaan ye sirf analysis nahi tha. yeh "critical analysis" tha aur critical analysis mein weak point hi bata'ey jaatai hein. so dont worry Talat hussain is not an ordinary media man. He is most credible journalist and if he is wrong then you don't need to rely on any media man or woman.

Talat is slightly better than other journalists but many of his knitpicking was just useless.

 

[IhsanIlahi]

good analysis