Pakistan's floods have left a country that's too difficult to rule The government in Islamabad is floundering and ripe for a coup if anyone wanted to launch one, says Con Coughlin. Con Coughlin By Con Coughlin Published: 6:33AM BST 25 Aug 2010 179 Comments Flood survivors at Muzaffargarh, in central Pakistan, on August 19 Photo: Khalid Tanveer If ever a country were ripe for a coup, it is Pakistan. The besieged government of President Asif Ali Zardari is assailed on all fronts by man-made conflict and natural disaster and there is a palpable sense in Islamabad that the return of the generals to the presidential palace would come as something of a relief. As if fighting a war against a determined enemy like the Taliban wasn't a difficult enough challenge, Mr Zardari now finds himself struggling to restore his credibility after a less-than-convincing response to the catastrophe of the flooding. To grasp the scale of the task facing the President, you need look no further than the American drone strikes that are being launched against suspected Taliban militants, at the same time as relief workers are struggling to save millions of homeless and hungry Pakistanis. Related Articles * Indian election: India is now a world power, and it must remember to behave like one * Barack Obama's charm offensive needs to be followed up with military action * Former Pakistani president Pervez Musharraf offers to return to power in Pakistan * If we win the war in Afghanistan, we could lose a battle in Pakistan * Hillary Clinton lures Pakistan with $500m new aid package * Taliban gunmen shooting couple dead for adultery caught on camera Before the monsoon waters broke, Mr Zardari was under intense pressure from his allies to do more to counter the militant Islamist groups that pose as great a threat to Pakistan's government as they do to the security of the West. A measure of the challenge involved in restoring security in this cricket-mad country is that the national team is obliged to play its international fixtures overseas following last year's brutal attack on the Sri Lankan team in Lahore, which killed eight people, including six policemen. David Cameron's blunt declaration that Pakistan was looking both ways in the fight against Islamist terrorism may not have won him many friends in the Zardari government. But it certainly articulated the deeply held view of many Western policy-makers that it could do more to tackle extremism. Now, following the widespread devastation unleashed by the floods, the President finds himself the subject of bitter criticism at home as well. It began with his ill-considered decision to continue with his tour of France and Britain earlier this month as the crisis deepened, when he visited his elegant chateau and made arrangements to launch the political career of his 21-year-old son, Bilawal Zardari Bhutto. Now his opponents are directing their ire at the government's inept response to the wider crisis caused by the floods. In a country where most of the agricultural wealth is concentrated in the hands of a few feudal landlords, the misery being experienced by millions of dispossessed and impoverished citizens is inevitably going to stoke the fires of dissent. Atlaf Hussain, the exiled leader of the Muttahuda Quami Movement, articulated the suspicions of many Pakistanis when he accused some landlords of deliberately diverting the waters to neighbouring villages in order to protect their own crops and livestock. He is now demanding a French Revolution-style redistribution of land among the masses, and has issued a call to "patriotic generals" to fulfil their duty by establishing martial law. However, what is different about this crisis is that, for once, the generals don't appear at all interested in taking responsibility for a country that is teetering on the verge of collapse. Pakistan has a history of military coups, many initiated to tackle the corruption and ineptitude of civilian administrations. The country's most recent military dictatorship, under General Pervez Musharraf. was instigated in 1999, in part due to allegations of corruption against the government of Nawaz Sharif, the current leader of the opposition. He, in turn, had replaced Benazir Bhutto, Mr Zardari's murdered wife, who had been dismissed over allegations of corruption. Since winning independence in 1947, Pakistan has endured more years of military dictatorship than civilian rule. Yet on this occasion, the military appears disinclined to enter the political fray. This is partly because it is still recovering from the bruising experience of Gen Musharraf's nine-year rule. It is just two years since he departed his homeland to live in exile in London. But even though he worked stoically to hold the country together, particularly during the tumult that followed the September 11 attacks, his tenure ended in opprobrium, as he was accused of excessive pro-Americanism and trying to destroy the independence of the judiciary. Many of those now running Pakistan's military, such as General Ashfaq Kayani, the army chief, and Lt Gen Ahmed Pasha, the head of the ISI intelligence service, are Gen Musharraf's protgs, and have little desire to suffer the humiliation heaped on the former dictator by the current civilian administration, which has threatened to prosecute him for alleged abuse of power. They also have their hands full fighting a bitter counter-insurgency campaign against the Taliban and its allies, as well as supporting Nato's effort to bring stability to Afghanistan. Of course, if they felt the country's very survival were in jeopardy because of the political fallout from the flooding crisis, even the most apolitical military officers might feel obliged to involve themselves. That is certainly what happened the last time the country faced a disaster on this scale: in 1970, the Pakistani government's totally inadequate response to the cyclone that devastated the coast of what was then East Pakistan, killing between 300,000 and 500,000 people, ultimately caused the civil war that resulted in the creation of Bangladesh. The death toll from this month's flood is for the moment, at least only a fraction of that figure. But the government's handling of the crisis has revived perceptions that the country's political elite is interested only in taking care of its own interests, rather than those of the people its members have been elected to serve. Nowhere is this sense of alienation more keenly felt than in the newly-created province of Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa, the Pashtun-dominated region formerly known as the North West Frontier Provine. As the crisis has unfolded, the provincial government has consistently accused Islamabad of ignoring the plight of the Pashtuns, claiming that insufficient numbers of rescue helicopters were dispatched as the crisis developed and that vital foreign aid was diverted to the less needy province of Punjab, for political reasons. Pashtun anger at Islamabad's perceived indifference is unlikely to result in a Bangladesh-style campaign for secession. But it does illustrate the damage that the floods have inflicted on the government's reputation for competence, as well as on the country at large. Extreme measures will be required to rebuild large swathes of the country once the waters have receded but building the effective and inclusive government that Pakistan deserves will be an even greater challenge. * * * * * * * * * * * * * Email * Print * Share * | * * * * Email * | * Print Text Size click here to increase the text size click here to decrease the text size http://www.telegraph.co.uk/comment/...ft-a-country-thats-too-difficult-to-rule.html TelegraphNews Con Coughlin Get feed updates Pakistan Get feed updates Comment Get feed updates Personal View Get feed updates Advertisement Ads by Google * Alternative Energy * Clean Energy * Clean Energy Sources * Clean Energy Options * Energy Independence Advertisement Ads by Google * 58" Plasma TV for $13.21? New Kind of Auction Site Has High Priced Items Going for Just Pennies SwipeBids.com * Killer Blues Guitar Wanna See How I Play A Great Blues Solo With Only 4 Notes? Watch Video BluesGuitarUnleashed.com * Is Your Bank In Trouble? Free list Of Banks Doomed To Fail. The Banks and Brokers X List. Free! www.MoneyAndMarkets.com More on Con Coughlin Get feed updates Pakistan Get feed updates Comment Get feed updates Personal View Get feed updates Loading comments... Problems loading Disqus? blog comments powered by Disqus Advertisement MORE Columnists * Boris Johnson | Jeff Randall * Simon Heffer | Christopher Booker * Benedict Brogan | Janet Daley * Terry Wogan | Geoffrey Lean * Mary Riddell | Bryony Gordon * Charles Moore | Jenny McCartney * Jemima Lewis | Tracy Corrigan * Rowan Pelling | Matthew d'Ancona * Alan Cochrane | Robert Webb * Alasdair Palmer | Con Coughlin * Philip Johnston | Vicki Woods * Nigel Farndale | Christopher Howse * Michael Deacon | Celia Walden Blogs * Damian Thompson * Benedict Brogan * Norman Tebbit * Toby Young * James Delingpole Cartoons * Garland | Adams | Tobias Grubbe * Matt | Alex Comment Most Viewed * TODAY * PAST WEEK * PAST MONTH 1. Pakistan's floods have left a country that's too difficult to rule 2. Only the hard mutts should feel the force of a new law 3. Public libraries: A pint of best bitter and a Cider with Rosie 4. Supporters of Climate Camp action are 'useful idiots' 5. Since when did self-service mean bullying by machine? 1. Keep up the good work, weatherman Tomasz Schafernaker - and the finger, too 2. Arrested for defending the red squirrel 3. Despised Clegg could become Labour's unwilling kingmaker 4. I thought going camping would be wonderful - and then I tried it 5. Libya has made fools of us all over Lockerbie bomber Megrahi, and much else besides 1. If President Obama carries on like this, he will turn into a lame duck 2. Desperate days for the warmists 3. Keep up the good work, weatherman Tomasz Schafernaker - and the finger, too 4. Arrested for defending the red squirrel 5. The shameful stories that can't be told Sponsored Features Dell laptops Stunning savings on Dell laptops Find the right deal for you across Dell's full range of laptops, notebooks and desktop PCs. Southern Energy smart kit Save on energy bills with a free kit Track and reduce your energy with Southern Electric's smart kit. Be the first to sign up. Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement MORE FROM TELEGRAPH.CO.UK