Moeed Pirzada on Islamabad Drama

[Darik]

News media persons are only interested in TV ratings.Excellent analysis.

 

[Rizwan2009]

اس سارے ڈرامے کا ايک ہي مقصد تھا وہ کہ سرحدي علاقوں پر بھارتي جارحيت کے واقعے کو پس پشت ڈال کر لوگوں کي توجہ اس طرف سے ہٹادي جائے تاکہ بھارت سے اس کي اپني شرائط پر مزاکرات کئے جاسکيں سارا امريکہ کا پريشر ہے مزاکرات کے لئے
​

 

[mrk123]

excellent analysis

Analysis is right on the money except for the point that incidents like these bring us closer as a nation. I think it divides us more and more since people entrench themselves on either side. Some would claim that the guy was right, as proclaimed by the hacks known as TV anchors, and some would rightly consider him a lunatic. Some would think that Zamarrud Khan was a hero where in fact what he did was absolutely idiotic. Some would say that media played it so well and some would rightly berate them for fishing around for anything to increase their ratings. Some would commend the commandos/rangers/police for injuring the guy and taking him into custody and some rightly would bemoan the fact that this incident exposed the authorities and showed how incompetent and inefficient they are.

There is nothing in this incident that will unite the nation. It was a deranged man and his equally deranged wife trying to garner some attention and the stupid media providing them exactly what they were craving for and to top it all off the whole drama was ably facilitated by the law enforcement authorities and finally as it happens in episodes like this an idiot was declared a hero in the end.

Oh well - all is well that ends well.

 

[mrk123]

meri to ab yeh dua hai ke is Qaum se mazeed sikandar bhi niklain

Allah he khair karay!

Kyoon bhai aik he kaafi nahin?

Waisay sikander say ziyada tu kanwal bibi chahee howee theen puri situation per aur woh bhi baghair red-bull kay :-)

 

[Lil'Genius]

Very nice and sensible brief analysis. Well Done Moeed (clap)

 

[aamir_uetn]

Us ne woh baat kahi jo majority karti hai , us k liye DJ ISI hona na hona zaroori nahi

Baat mayaari tafreeh ki nahi , Baat aik Pakistani hone k naate Ghairat khane ki hai , aaj se kuch din pehle issi forum par aik Kashmeeri naujawan ka khat share kia gaya tha jo ke bohut naraaz tha , Wahan Indian hamari behnon ki izzatain loot rahain hoon Kashmir main aur yahan hum Pakistan ke cinema main un ki movies dekh rahe hoon to phir aap hi batao ke aik Kashmiri k Dil pe kia guzray gi

to majority apne andazey he lagati hain na info nai hoti uskey paas, sikandar ki baat sahi thi laikin tareeqa sahi nai tha, khuda na khaasta khud bhi mara jata aur uske bv bachay bhi to ??

baqi rahi filmon ki to film dekhne se mera nahi khyal azadi-e-kashmeer ko koi nuqsan puhnch sakta hai

 

[Khurpainch]

ﮐﯿﺴﯽ ﺍﻧﻮﮐﮭﯽ ﺩﺍﺳﺘﺎﻥ ﺳﺐ ﮐﻮ ﺳﻨﺎ ﮔﯿﺎ..... ﺍﮎ ﺷﺨﺺ ﺍﺳﻼﻡ ﺁﺑﺎﺩ ﮐﯽ ﺑﯿﻨﮉ ﺑﺠﺎﮔﯿﺎ
​

 

[monh zorr]

;)جن دونوں کو آپ بھائی سمجھ کر رپلائی کر رہے ہیں یہ دونوں صنف نازک ہیں ​

اب کچھ نہیں ہوسکتا دوست
بھائی کہہ دیا تو کہہ دیا،،اب انکے ہاتھ ہے ،صنف بدل کر بھائی چارہ کا ثبوت دیں،یا اپنی روش پر قائم رہیں،،
منہ زور تو زبان سے کہہ کر بدل نہیں سکتا،، نو،،نیور
​

 

[Sohraab]

Allah he khair karay!

Kyoon bhai aik he kaafi nahin?

Waisay sikander say ziyada tu kanwal bibi chahee howee theen puri situation per aur woh bhi baghair red-bull kay :-)

aap mujhe aik baat batain

Javed Ch k show main jo baat Sikandar ne ISI ke bare main ki .. kia woh ghalat hai ????? ............ us ne kaha ke Pakistan main hone wali har dehshat gardi ka Ilzam musalmanon par daal diya jata hai , kia yeh baat Sikandar ne ghalat kahi ???????

Media per bataya ja raha tha ke Sikandar Sharabi hai , Paaagal hai , zehni mareez hai

Mere bhai , yeh kaisa sharabi , Paaagal aur zehni mareez tha , jo baatain bilkul theek kar raha tha

Kia is mulk ki secret agencies ki yeh responsibilty nahi banti ke jo loog electronic media per Indianization ko last 12 years se promote kar rahe hain , Yeh un ko Rookain , chahay rookne k liye jo tareeqa bhi ikhtiyar karna pare

aap mujhe batain , aik aam Pakistan LIKE SIKANDAR , yeh baat achi tarha janta hai ke TTP ke peechay anti Pakistan mulk hain , Lekin kia in baaton ko kabhi Pakistani channels ne highlite kia hai ?????

 

[mrk123]

aap mujhe aik baat batain

Javed Ch k show main jo baat Sikandar ne ISI ke bare main ki .. kia woh ghalat hai ????? ............ us ne kaha ke Pakistan main hone wali har dehshat gardi ka Ilzam musalmanon par daal diya jata hai , kia yeh baat Sikandar ne ghalat kahi ???????

Media per bataya ja raha tha ke Sikandar Sharabi hai , Paaagal hai , zehni mareez hai

Mere bhai , yeh kaisa sharabi , Paaagal aur zehni mareez tha , jo baatain bilkul theek kar raha tha

Kia is mulk ki secret agencies ki yeh responsibilty nahi banti ke jo loog electronic media per Indianization ko last 12 years se promote kar rahe hain , Yeh un ko Rookain , chahay rookne k liye jo tareeqa bhi ikhtiyar karna pare

aap mujhe batain , aik aam Pakistan LIKE SIKANDAR , yeh baat achi tarha janta hai ke TTP ke peechay anti Pakistan mulk hain , Lekin kia in baaton ko kabhi Pakistani channels ne highlite kia hai ?????

O meray pyaray Sohrab bhai, yaar agar aik ***** batain sahee kar raha ho tu kiya woh zee aqal kahlai ga?

Bhai jaan yeah kaunsa tareeqa hai sahee baatain karnay ka? Apnay biwi aur bachoon ki jaanoon ko iss tarah khatray mein daalna shahadat aur aqalmandi nahin balkay sareehan baywaqoofi hai.

Her kaam aur her baat ka aik tareeqa hota hai.

Aap aisay paish kar rahay hain kay medis iss aadmee kay khilaaf thaa - meray bhai kitnay he anchors nay uss say bola kay aap kay saaray mutalibaat durust hain. Anchors uss ki iltija kar rahay thay.

Aik aur baat yeah kay saaray media house commercial idaaray hain. Unka maqsad sirif aik he hai aur woh hai munafay ka husool. Iss say ziyada kuch nahin. Woh koe qaumi khidmat saranjaam nahin day rahay.

Media kitna he bura kiyoon na ho magar jiss tarah media MQM say darrtaa hai ussee tarah ya uss say thora kam military establishment aur TTP say bhi darrta hai.

Aik aur baat yeah kay TTP kisi ki support say chal rahi hai - yeah bhi pakistani establishment ki aik tactic hai kay ilzaam namaaloom beirooni taqatoon per daal do. O bhai, agar koee beiruni taqat hai bhi tu unkay aalaa'e kaar tu pakistani he hain na. Jitnay dahshatgardee Pakistan mein ho rahee hai uss kay zimmaydaar pakistani he hain - ilzaam kisi aur per daalnay shutur murgh ki tarah rait mein sir daalnay kay mutradif hai.

Aaj yeah aik aadmee aayaa tha kal ko 2 dozen loog aa jain gay aur phir 100 aur phir 1000. Yeah baywaqoofi hai aur agar aainda bhi hoee tu woh baywaqoof he ho gi. period! na iss say kuch badla hai aur na badlay ga.

Hamein ijtamaee taur per apnay aap ko badalna hai. HUM SUB KO. establishment, siyasatdaan, mazhabi leaders, aur sub say barrh kar aam aadmee ko. Iss episode nay hum sub ki ijtimaee kamzooriyoon aur kohtaiyoon ko expose kar kay rakh diya hai aur dunya ko nazar aa gaya hai kay hum aik failed state hain.

 

[Sohraab]

O meray pyaray Sohrab bhai, yaar agar aik ***** batain sahee kar raha ho tu kiya woh zee aqal kahlai ga?

Bhai jaan yeah kaunsa tareeqa hai sahee baatain karnay ka? Apnay biwi aur bachoon ki jaanoon ko iss tarah khatray mein daalna shahadat aur aqalmandi nahin balkay sareehan baywaqoofi hai.

Her kaam aur her baat ka aik tareeqa hota hai.

Aap aisay paish kar rahay hain kay medis iss aadmee kay khilaaf thaa - meray bhai kitnay he anchors nay uss say bola kay aap kay saaray mutalibaat durust hain. Anchors uss ki iltija kar rahay thay.

Aik aur baat yeah kay saaray media house commercial idaaray hain. Unka maqsad sirif aik he hai aur woh hai munafay ka husool. Iss say ziyada kuch nahin. Woh koe qaumi khidmat saranjaam nahin day rahay.

Media kitna he bura kiyoon na ho magar jiss tarah media MQM say darrtaa hai ussee tarah ya uss say thora kam military establishment aur TTP say bhi darrta hai.

Aik aur baat yeah kay TTP kisi ki support say chal rahi hai - yeah bhi pakistani establishment ki aik tactic hai kay ilzaam namaaloom beirooni taqatoon per daal do. O bhai, agar koee beiruni taqat hai bhi tu unkay aalaa'e kaar tu pakistani he hain na. Jitnay dahshatgardee Pakistan mein ho rahee hai uss kay zimmaydaar pakistani he hain - ilzaam kisi aur per daalnay shutur murgh ki tarah rait mein sir daalnay kay mutradif hai.

Aaj yeah aik aadmee aayaa tha kal ko 2 dozen loog aa jain gay aur phir 100 aur phir 1000. Yeah baywaqoofi hai aur agar aainda bhi hoee tu woh baywaqoof he ho gi. period! na iss say kuch badla hai aur na badlay ga.

Hamein ijtamaee taur per apnay aap ko badalna hai. HUM SUB KO. establishment, siyasatdaan, mazhabi leaders, aur sub say barrh kar aam aadmee ko. Iss episode nay hum sub ki ijtimaee kamzooriyoon aur kohtaiyoon ko expose kar kay rakh diya hai aur dunya ko nazar aa gaya hai kay hum aik failed state hain.

to phir is sab ka solution kia hai aik commen Pakistani k liye , woh kis tarha apni aawaz uthai ke Pakistan main govt , courts aur fauj ko ahsaas ho ke media Indianization phela raha hai , Pakistani cinema main Indian movies chal rahi hain aur jab TTP ka naam liya jata hai to saath main Islam ko joor kar tanqeed ki jati hai lekin koi baironi qywatton ka naam nahi leta , aap ki nazar main kia karna chahiye aik commen pakistani ko ?

 

[kashoo]

well said Moeed...gud analysis...why dont some gud analyst including talat moeed and doc shahid start their own channel.?

 

[monh zorr]

yeh aik aam pakistani ki andar ki frustration hai , jo sikandar ne is tarha se nikali hai , Qanoon haath main lena to har tarha se ghalat hai lekin jab aap ke saath na Hakumat ho , na fauj ho , na adalat ho aur aap na insafi hoti dekh rahe hoon apne mulk k saath to phir yehi hota hai

For example , main chahta hoon ke Pakistan k cinema gharon main Indian movies band hoon aur Pakistani channels par Indian Content , to bhai mere kia mera yeh mutalba Hakumat , fauj , courts , pemra accept kare ga ????

Kabhi bhi nahi kare ga

aur agar main kisi din yeh decide karta hoon ke k main khud hathyaar uthaon ga , To phir main Mujrim ban jaoon ga ?????

Yaar yeh kaisa Insaf hai aur yeh kaise Andheer nagri hai hai k mere Jazbaat ki tarjumani meri hakumat bhi na kare , fauj bhi na kare , courts bhi na kare , Aur agar main kisi din khud Hathyaar utha loon to phir main Mujrim hoon , Yeh kaisa Insaf hai bhai

ہتھیار ہاتھ میں لیکر مطالبہ کرنے والا، اگر پکڑا جائے تو مجرم کہلاتا ہے،
اور اگر نہ پکڑا جائے تو،،،
قوم کا نجات دہندہ، وطن کا رکھوالا،اور مملکت کا سربراہ(مالک) کہلاتا ہے،
اسی کا نام انصاف ہے بھائی
تم ہتھیار اٹھانے کے بات نہ کرو، تمہارے خوبصورت ہاتھ دعا کیلئے اٹھنے چاہیئں
​

 

[Sohraab]

ہتھیار ہاتھ میں لیکر مطالبہ کرنے والا، اگر پکڑا جائے تو مجرم کہلاتا ہے،
اور اگر نہ پکڑا جائے تو،،،
قوم کا نجات دہندہ، وطن کا رکھوالا،اور مملکت کا سربراہ(مالک) کہلاتا ہے،
اسی کا نام انصاف ہے بھائی
تم ہتھیار اٹھانے کے بات نہ کرو، تمہارے خوبصورت ہاتھ دعا کیلئے اٹھنے چاہیئں
​

main to hathyar uthanay ki baat nahi karta , kuin ke main itna taqatwar nahi hoon

Lekin har hathyar uthanay wale ko main ghalat sirf is liye nahi keh sakta ke us ne Qanoon ko haath main Liya

Bohut si cheezon ko dekhna partahai bhai , kisi bhi muamle main satuation ko samajh kar hi aap apni Rai qaim kar sakte hain

Yeh Sikandar chahay koi staged drama hai yah phir jo bhi hai ALLAH BEHTAR JANAY , Lekin jo baatain us ne Javed Ch ke saath ki woh meri nazar main 100 % theek hain