Jinnah's vision; A Pakistan nationalism not Provincialism

[mh.saghir]

I wish, everyone could understand this.

 

[Unicorn]

What you see today is precisely Jinnah's Vision, if not perhaps you should explain what happened to it.

 

[mh.saghir]

What you see today is precisely Jinnah's Vision, if not perhaps you should explain what happened to it.

can u plz elaborate???
to me, the problem is that provincialism. we will have to be a Muslim-Paki national rather than being a Punjabi, Sindhi, Balochi or Pakhtoon...

 

[Unicorn]

can u plz elaborate???
to me, the problem is that provincialism. we will have to be a Muslim-Paki national rather than being a Punjabi, Sindhi, Balochi or Pakhtoon...

Would you like Punjabi, Sindhi, Balochi, Pustoon, Hazara and others to abandon:

Their Language, culture, traditions?

After its abandoned what would be the second part Paki would be like.

Preciously what would you or Mr. Jinnah intend to adopt?

How can they all Adopt the correct MUSLIM part when non of you can agree what a MUSLIM should be. Read the religious posts on this forum and note their disagreements.

It is my position that politicians including Mr. Jinnah had fanned the insecurities, the weakest of the human emotions, of people for political power.

 

[mh.saghir]

Would you like Punjabi, Sindhi, Balochi, Pustoon, Hazara and others to abandon:

Their Language, culture, traditions?

After its abandoned what would be the second part Paki would be like.

Preciously what would you or Mr. Jinnah intend to adopt?

How can they all Adopt the correct MUSLIM part when non of you can agree what a MUSLIM should be. Read the religious posts on this forum and note their disagreements.

It is my position that politicians including Mr. Jinnah had fanned the insecurities, the weakest of the human emotions, of people for political power.

Yes, as long as they are Pakistanis and Pakistani Muslims because the base and essence of this country is Islam; otherwise in sub-continent Muslims and Hindus had the same culture, although their traditions and language were different.

And I think, mr. Jinnah's intentions are clear in this speech of his and I do have the same point of view; The Pakistani Nationalism.
Moreover, a Muslim is the one who believes in Allah and His Prophets and His angels and His Books and the day of judgement and the fate and the life after death. other than this believe, it's one's personal matter with Allah.

And and and, I don't want a comment on Jinnah's life and his career from a nation which killed their own leader of the nation. He fought and fought well and did well, or I must say the best, for this nation.

 

[adnan_younus]

exactly.. jinnah said all units represented in the center... he never visioned pakistan has a one unit which was done after his demise... the 23rd march resolution alsoa states the same.. autonomous units... had this been followed... the hatred towards punjab as a province wud never have creeped up... neither ethnicity pakistan wsa not a one unit administratively....