Adeelsaleem
Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
Last edited:
Hazrat Ayesha RA marriage age - Mufti Menk amazing and logical explanation
- Thread starter Adeelsaleem
- Start date
- Status
Raaz
(50k+ posts) بابائے فورم
ان بے غیرتوں کو حضرت عائشہ رضی اللہ عنہ کی فکر کھا گئی
کوئی اور کام نہی ہے ان لوگوں کو
کوئی قران کی بات کرو جو کہتا ہے کہ ہر چیز پر تحقیق کرو
جس حکم کو مان کر لوگ خلا میں بیٹھ کر مسلمانوں کو گھور رہے ہیں
اور یہ برقہ پہن کر حضرت آئشہ کی عمر پر تحقیق کر رہا ہے جن کو فوت ہوے بھی چودہ سو سال گزر گئے ہیں
What is not sufficient to understand is: explanation is coming from a muslim scholar about more than 14 centuries after the prophet SAW.
Why not from a tradition of the Prophet SAW or a verse of Quraan.
Can somebody describe at what age of Hazrat Ayesha RA consummation take place, if marriage took place at the age of 6 or 7?
As we go back into the older ages of history, people used to live longer life than todate e.g. Haztar Adam was 1000 years old, Hazrat Noh WAS 900 years old, Hazrat Mosis was 125 years old.
May be Hazrat Ayesha's age is not being quoted correctly.
The scholar appears to be incorrect to proving that in that age girls could reach puberty at the age of 6 or 7.
Examples he gave relates to mental growth and not physical growth as there can be a disparity between two factors but reaching puberty is a physical phenomenon which can be generalised and in vary rare cases is subject to exceptions.
This seems to be a mis-information regarding the Prophet SAW otherwise the impossible would have been explained by him and not by a scholar of the current era.
What a strange phenomenon - something relating to "the followed or the Prophet of Allah Almighty" being explained by "the follower" which cannot be held more than a fake or a concocted argument.
However, it is undeniable - customs vary from one to the other culture.
Why not from a tradition of the Prophet SAW or a verse of Quraan.
Can somebody describe at what age of Hazrat Ayesha RA consummation take place, if marriage took place at the age of 6 or 7?
As we go back into the older ages of history, people used to live longer life than todate e.g. Haztar Adam was 1000 years old, Hazrat Noh WAS 900 years old, Hazrat Mosis was 125 years old.
May be Hazrat Ayesha's age is not being quoted correctly.
The scholar appears to be incorrect to proving that in that age girls could reach puberty at the age of 6 or 7.
Examples he gave relates to mental growth and not physical growth as there can be a disparity between two factors but reaching puberty is a physical phenomenon which can be generalised and in vary rare cases is subject to exceptions.
This seems to be a mis-information regarding the Prophet SAW otherwise the impossible would have been explained by him and not by a scholar of the current era.
What a strange phenomenon - something relating to "the followed or the Prophet of Allah Almighty" being explained by "the follower" which cannot be held more than a fake or a concocted argument.
However, it is undeniable - customs vary from one to the other culture.
Last edited:
BrotherKantu
Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
prophet Mohammad (pbuh) married more than once. Out of all marriages had only one child. Most of these marriages were to unite tribes and bring peace among them. Please some one who is knowledgeable do me a favor and explain it . thanks
wamufti
Senator (1k+ posts)
O bhai ... Prophet SAW had 3 daughters from Amma Khadija RA . Bibi Zainab RA, Ruqayyah RA, Umm Kulthum RA and Fatima RA . He also had 2 sons who died in childhood.
Thanks bro.
Pakistani1947
Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
Last edited:
This explanation is not satisfactory. The best explanation is that perhaps it was acceptable at the time in that society to be married off at practically ANY age. You don't have to try explanations like, "Oh.. at the time people used to mature fast." "Oh.. she was married but the consummation was at a much later age." Another plausible line of explanation would be that perhaps the Age is wrongfully quoted. All other lines of explanations look like they are trying to catch at straws.
My own personal view is related to the first point I made, that perhaps this was acceptable in that particular society at the time. Because had their been any issue, Aysha(ra) would've said so herself and/or history from that time would've said so itself. Instead we hear absolutely no issue about it reading from that time frame.
My own personal view is related to the first point I made, that perhaps this was acceptable in that particular society at the time. Because had their been any issue, Aysha(ra) would've said so herself and/or history from that time would've said so itself. Instead we hear absolutely no issue about it reading from that time frame.
ali-raj
Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
Boss 3 daughters and 2 sons.
ali-raj
Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
I won't go deep into the subject, it has been discussed several times, and only when you piece together lots of information, then you get the exact date.
But there are pointers,which indicate that She was not 6, nor 9 , but above 15 yrs (16,19 perhaps) when she got married (consumated).
Her age difference with Hazrat Fatima R.A , Age diff of Hazrat Fatima R.A and Hazrat Ali R.A, then Time of Hijrah, Her Sister Asma (10 yrs older)
The thing is, Islamic scholars are hell bent on reducing the age to 9 for their own benefits, Thats why there is confusion. Same goes for other things in Islam as well. When there is a difference, it is due to benefit of someone, not for Islam.
And don't just google it. Read saha Sitta, and some other authentic books, cross reference them and you'll get the picture.
But there are pointers,which indicate that She was not 6, nor 9 , but above 15 yrs (16,19 perhaps) when she got married (consumated).
Her age difference with Hazrat Fatima R.A , Age diff of Hazrat Fatima R.A and Hazrat Ali R.A, then Time of Hijrah, Her Sister Asma (10 yrs older)
The thing is, Islamic scholars are hell bent on reducing the age to 9 for their own benefits, Thats why there is confusion. Same goes for other things in Islam as well. When there is a difference, it is due to benefit of someone, not for Islam.
And don't just google it. Read saha Sitta, and some other authentic books, cross reference them and you'll get the picture.
devoid feast
Senator (1k+ posts)
Re: Age of Ayesha (RTA) عائشہ (رضی اللہ عنہا) کی عمر
Iss qoom ka kya hoga...:(
Iss qoom ka kya hoga...:(
Ahad Khalid
Banned
Re: Age of Ayesha (RTA) عائشہ (رضی اللہ عنہا) کی عمر
great politician! mis(hazrat) Aysha.
great politician! mis(hazrat) Aysha.
BeingHuman
Politcal Worker (100+ posts)
Re: Age of Ayesha (RTA) عائشہ (رضی اللہ عنہا) کی عمر
[h=4]SAHIH INTERNATIONAL[/h][h=2]The Prophet is more worthy of the believers than themselves, and his wives are [in the position of] their mothers. And those of [blood] relationship are more entitled [to inheritance] in the decree of Allah than the [other] believers and the emigrants, except that you may do to your close associates a kindness [through bequest]. That was in the Book inscribed. Quran 33.6[/h]Ab jo marzi kaho
MashraQi Larka
Minister (2k+ posts)
Re: Age of Ayesha (RTA) عائشہ (رضی اللہ عنہا) کی عمر
ایک اور بات وہ یہ کہ پہلے لوگ جلدی شادی کردیا کرتے تھے۔ اِسکے لئے 1400 سال پیچھے نہ جائیں، صِرف 100 سال پیچھے چلے جائیں، یہ بالکل عام سی بات تھی۔
اور دوسری بات یہ کہ آج سے 1400 سال پہلے لوگ زیادہ صحتمند ہوتے تھے۔ جلدی قد کاٹھ نِکال لیا کرتے تھے۔ شائد اِسیلئے اِسلام میں شادی /نِکاح کیلئے ایک خاص عمر کی شرط نئی ہے، بلکہ بلوغت کی عمر میں پہنچنے کی شرط ہے۔
ایک اور بات وہ یہ کہ پہلے لوگ جلدی شادی کردیا کرتے تھے۔ اِسکے لئے 1400 سال پیچھے نہ جائیں، صِرف 100 سال پیچھے چلے جائیں، یہ بالکل عام سی بات تھی۔
اور دوسری بات یہ کہ آج سے 1400 سال پہلے لوگ زیادہ صحتمند ہوتے تھے۔ جلدی قد کاٹھ نِکال لیا کرتے تھے۔ شائد اِسیلئے اِسلام میں شادی /نِکاح کیلئے ایک خاص عمر کی شرط نئی ہے، بلکہ بلوغت کی عمر میں پہنچنے کی شرط ہے۔
- Status
