Salik
Senator (1k+ posts)
What a silly example!!! Will the doctor's community also agree on the treatment of stomachache by operating knee?
Why isnt it silly when your so Ulema differ with each other on major issues of today...
اسماءالرجال is the study of the narrators....On the credibility or non-credibility of any Hadith there exist agreements of Ulema and if I am not mistaken this knowledge or technique is called Asma ur rijal.
while something youre' referring to is called جرح و تعديل
Remember!!! reading something does not mean that you understood that. If it had been the case then there had had never been the need of prophets.
Dont compare your Ghulaman e Nafs with the Holy Prophets.... عليهم السلام
Your comment show that you want something that pleases you that is the reason that you did not read the links.
Why should I read the links you provided... Why should I not read the links of the Ulema who are not hate and Fatwa mongers...
(while I have no problem with Darse Quran.com.... and I listen to Moulana Aslam Sheikhupuri...)
rom your comment that layman like you can find out the hole in their fatwa, a famous story comes to the mind in which a graduated person was humiliated by illiterate persons in his village because the graduated person told his fellow villagers that he had B.A. And one of the stupid villager cut joke that he spent so many years and learned two words which are wrong i.e. in reverse order.
Silly example ... does not apply here... How can you compare common people with 16-24 years of formal education and basic or may be basic+ understanding of Deen with a Villager???
I learn from whereever I get knowledge... unless it is not hatemongering... or telling people that you should just be blind followers...As far as defining credible Ulemas are concerned I went one step further and gave you their websites. So spend some time listening to them, reading the material if you really want the right path.
Yes one must understand the Quran and Hadith but how? with which interpretations? Your own? Your own understanding? or the understanding which are handed over to us by Prophet Muhammad () through his Sahab (), Tabe'en, Taba Tabe'en and the following Ulemas of Ahl e Sunnat of Jammat.
Who make fatwas against each other... calling each other kafir... Rest of them are the source of the Deen... You cant equalize them...
You did research, fine. Why do you ask me? I did not issue the Fatwa. I am satisfied with their (who gave this fatwa) education & research. You are not satisfied so ask them (those who issued it) the question/challenge them so that you get satisfactory answers. I have already provided you with the corresponding links. (If I had direct connection with these Ulemas I could have given you the answer by now. But you live in Karachi, Pakistan so you can meet them.).
I gave you a single example in a single fatwa... and asked a simple question to bring the proof of Asnaad's being Sahih as stated in your farwa ... and asked you ... why your trustworthy Ulemas are lying blatantly about the Hadith's asnaad... IF you still consider these so called Ulema authentic... May Allah help you...
True Ulema never make any Halal thing Haram or Haram thing Halal. I would highly recommend (instead of the fact that you would not listen) you that you listen to the following bayan to have some understanding.
Thats what they did in the concerned fatwa??? Did nt they???
There is no point in listening to Bayan for the purpose of talking to u... because if I disagree with something .... I cant question it.. So I only listen to those... who I trust...
@all
By the way.. The explanation of Sarfaraz Shah Sb about Tawakkal and Sabr on his website is excellent... He also tells about how to increase your tawakkal on Allah SWT... would recommend to all...
Last edited: