Bro........ I am clear about my beliefs and I did not hide anything from the members of this forum
I am just giving arguments based on facts ........ Shirk is always in persons heart not in actions .... Amaal Ka Daroo Madaar Niyatoon Per Hai
I have a question to you.... Why people visit the Tomb of Prophet (PBUH) and of Hazrat Abu Bakar and Umer? Is it Shirk?
If Shirk then When u are going to ban the visitors from Prophet (PBUH) Tomb or going to declare them Mushrik ? Do u want to destroy the tomb of Prophet (PBUH)?
Man you mean is it okay if a person have no Shirk in heart but should worship idols because he can say that he has no Shirk in Heart...?
Islam and Sharia operates on Visible things not on hidden things and he/she will be treated or pubished as per his/her appearant deeds not whatever he/ thinks. Aa I have given the example above, one can claim on the day of judgement that though he was worshipping idols but actually he was believing in Allah. So in this case will Allah forgive him? And all relogions are doing the same things but in Islam, it is not allowed.
Going to grave is not haram but if one go there and start kissing the walls or tomb etc or doing Sajda there and ask the dead body for help, so is it allowed?
Prophet (PBUH) knew it that's why Hazrat Ayesha (RA) had stopped common people to visit there..
I am telling a story of Sheikh Ahmad Rafay (A common Buzarg of both Deoband and Brailvis) who had a visit to Raza-e-Rasool, SAW in somewhere 550 AD. Brailvis and Deobandi both in their books have attributed a story about him when he reached there, he had asked Prophet to bring out his hand from his grave, because Shaikh Sahib wanted to kiss it. Prophet did it (Nauzubillah) and the Sheikh kissed it. And this scene was watched by about 90 k people (Just imagine the lie) and Hazrat Abdul Qadir Jelani was also there among those 90 k. This is just one story.
And you don't know these Jahil People. Had Roza-e-Rasul left open for all, you would find more people there for 'Ibadat' than in Ka'aba.
Do you know how idle worshipping had started?
Let me tell you. In early ages when the relatives of dead body were crying. Shetan came to them that instead of crying for nothing, why you people not making a picture and then cry infront of it. People had started making pictures of dead peoples. After sometimes, Shetan came to them and had advised them that why noy make Idols of your relatives instead of just pictures and people had started this and which had ultimatily lead to Idol Worshopping.
If you want to understand this phenomenon, please try to understand the example above.
BTW for 1400 years the Prophet (PBUH) grave is there even after attack of Yazid on Madina, so what had brought this in your mind that it is actually the 'Plane' of destructiom of Prophet SAW Tomb?.
