Awam Ki Adalat - 13th Mayl 2012 - Dr. Qadir Magsi - سندھو دیش کا نعرہ کیوں؟
- Thread starter Awam Ki Adalat
- Start date
Qadir Magsi is a reknown racist. I am not supporting MQM despite being an Urdu Speaking but how will any average Urdu Speaking going to react after watching words and demands of people like Magsi?I can't take responsibility of others. Woh tau tension,ghusse aur ghabrahat mein MQM ke ilawa aur kahaan jayeinge aur MQM tau chahegi key uske supporters aur voters mein sense of insecurity jun ki tun rahe.
I support creation of new provinces in Pakistan including division of Sindh but on administrative basis not ethnic as Karachi was never inhabited by Sindhi feudals and remained a separate entitity amidst feudal culture of rural Sindh...maybe then we can cope with certain diseases such a Punjabphobia. Aur yeh cheez notice keejiye key yeh episode Islamabad mein hua lekin humare mulk ki youth is qadar educated aur tolerant hai key wahaan bhi majority ne Magsi se yehi poocha key woh kis basis per Muhajiroun ko itna alien samajhta hai and you can tell from their accents that almost none of them was from Karachi.Isse MQM ke phelai hui ghalat fehmiyaan bhi shayad kum ho key baqi ke Pakisyan mein loog jahil aur tasubi waghera hain.
Aur yeh questions bhi kiye gaye key Magsi kyun Punjab ko itna bura bhala bolta hai? Lagta hai key isne South Punjab aur Bahawalpur province ki news nahi suni.
Mera Sindhis se koi shikwa nahi as my parents spent their respective childhood and adolescence with friends hailing from different backgrounds especially my mother who had Sindhi and Punjabi friends and classmates too.I respect their culture and 5000 year old civilization.
I support creation of new provinces in Pakistan including division of Sindh but on administrative basis not ethnic as Karachi was never inhabited by Sindhi feudals and remained a separate entitity amidst feudal culture of rural Sindh...maybe then we can cope with certain diseases such a Punjabphobia. Aur yeh cheez notice keejiye key yeh episode Islamabad mein hua lekin humare mulk ki youth is qadar educated aur tolerant hai key wahaan bhi majority ne Magsi se yehi poocha key woh kis basis per Muhajiroun ko itna alien samajhta hai and you can tell from their accents that almost none of them was from Karachi.Isse MQM ke phelai hui ghalat fehmiyaan bhi shayad kum ho key baqi ke Pakisyan mein loog jahil aur tasubi waghera hain.
Aur yeh questions bhi kiye gaye key Magsi kyun Punjab ko itna bura bhala bolta hai? Lagta hai key isne South Punjab aur Bahawalpur province ki news nahi suni.
Mera Sindhis se koi shikwa nahi as my parents spent their respective childhood and adolescence with friends hailing from different backgrounds especially my mother who had Sindhi and Punjabi friends and classmates too.I respect their culture and 5000 year old civilization.
I support new province but main apni tasobana soch ki waja say mqm ky haq main nahee ho. What is the same thing mqm is saying.
Qadir Magsi is not a racist. He is person who stands for the rights of his people. MQM is a racist party which utilizes racism and terrorism to support its agenda. PPP and MQM are not the most favored parties of people in Sindh. Even then they are the ruling parties because of the Feudal and Terrorist mentality of both the parties. Its about time that Sindhis should come out and elect the Nationalist parties to truly represent them.
mohibbewatan
Senator (1k+ posts)
I totally hate MQM but Magsi is most definitely a racist, you have no right to ask why people are coming to your province because you don't own it so shut up and admit that Urdu speaking are as much Pakistanis as anyone.
Why do people confuse MQM with Urdu speaking. MQM does not equal to all Urdu speaking. Secondly for sure Urdu speaking are pakistanis and as much Sindhis as the aboriginals but this does not give any one right to make a fascist group out of it and disturb the law and order. What hurt Sindhi Speaking people the most is to see the Killings and Bhatakhori brought about to the land of their forefathers by a fascist party which claims to represent the Nation whom they gave places in their hearts and lands. This is actually difficult to comprehend for the people who live in other provinces. My mother has always told me stories of the time when people migrated from India to Sindh my grandfather had a few houses and he gave it to the people who came and same was happening all over Hyderabad. The people who did not have other houses broke the lockes of the Hindus that have left and presented them to the Immigrants. So no Sindhis and for that sake any party in Sindh though Nationalist or Seperatist is not racist, they just want their resources to be spent on them and they don't want to see facist parties disturbing law and order or wanting to divide Sindh. Period!
What's tasubana here? I am also from an Urdu Speaking background as mentioned earlier.MQM doesn't have a clear stand on division of Sindh...sometimes they talk about Urban-Rural divide and their workers are seen in Muhajir Suba Tehreek rallies but Altaf Hussain calls himself a son of Sindh Dharti and denies anything to do with division of Sindh. Plus, there are many other non-Sindhis too such as Memons and Kutchis who have cultural origins in Indian states of Rajasthan,Gujarat and Maharashtra...and they've been living in karachi and suburbs since before 1947. So it's all about the distinct environment of Karachi for past 100-150 years.
