Thanks for appreciation.Thanks for uploading. Informative.!!!...!!!
Very sad that he is kept out of main stream!
munkar e hadith43 surah az Zukhruf Ayah 19 To 25
43 Surah az Zukhruf Ayah 26 To 32
43 Surah az Zukhruf Ayah 33 To 56
43 Surah az Zukhruf Ayah 63 To 80
43 Surah az Zukhruf Ayah 81 To End
44 Surah ad Dukhan Ayah 01 To 16
44 Surah ad Dukhan Ayah 17 To 37
44 Surah ad Dukhan Ayah 38 To End
45 Sura Al Jathiyah Ayah 01 To 27
45 Sura Al Jathiyah Ayah 27 To End
46 Surah al Ahqaf Ayah 01 To 09
Surah al Ahqaf Ayah 10 To 14
Surah al Ahqaf Ayah 15 To 16
Surah al Ahqaf Ayah 17 To 23
Surah al Ahqaf Ayah 24 To 26
Surah al Ahqaf Ayah 27 To End
those in my family and friends who follow this guy never pray, never pay zakat, are supporter of nudity in the name of fashion and drink alcohol. what kind of influence is this so called allama?
Dear brother siddique, the real question is, can anyone prove that tafseer can be anything other than personal opinion of a person? No matter what it is that you read or hear about you cannot have but your own opinion about it. If one has no idea of this very fact then one is not educated enough to understand the concept or the rule of interpretation. Comments by such people therefore carry no weight because they are based on ignorance.munkar e hadith or quran ke man mane tafseer karany wala allah is k fitnay say sub ko mahfooz rakhay ameen
Dear brother simple_and_peacefull, I do not have any problem with any scholar of islam but that whatever anyone says about islam must be based upon evidence that can be clearly proven. Otherwise anyone is human and can make mistake. It is because according to the quran people are born without knowing anything but they are given brain, senses and bodies to find out things for themselves for the good of themselves and others. We have the universe before us as well as divine guidance. It is up to ourselves to explore them both for our own benefits. If we fail anywhere then consequences follow us.Dear brother mughal,
what about your view on dr israr ahmad...
Ask him the views about Mirza Manhoos Mauood...Dear brother mughal,
what about your view on dr israr ahmad...
Dear brother simple_and_peacefull, I do not have any problem with any scholar of islam but that whatever anyone says about islam must be based upon evidence that can be clearly proven. Otherwise anyone is human and can make mistake. It is because according to the quran people are born without knowing anything but they are given brain, senses and bodies to find out things for themselves for the good of themselves and others. We have the universe before us as well as divine guidance. It is up to ourselves to explore them both for our own benefits. If we fail anywhere then consequences follow us.
Dr israr sb marhoom was influenced by his back ground just like dr tahir al qardi sb is influenced by his back ground. Comparing them to their own backgrounds they made big jumps forward showing they have been using their own brains. Likewise if we compare alaama parwez marhoom his back ground is brelavi same as mine and dr tahir sb but he made a jump much bigger than anyone else of his time. The only people who did greater were people like sir seyyid, iqbal and jinnah etc.
My problem is mostly with mullahs and by that I mean those who condemn each other with their fatwa baazi. Despite this I respect their part in preserving islamic information. It will be dishonesty on part of anyone who does not give mullahs the credit that they rightfully deserve.
Overall all kinds of muslims have done something good for islam here and there for which it will not be right to not to give them credit.
I do not call in to question sincerity of people to their cause. All I can do is disagree with their opinion or understanding of things. Even with mullahs I disagree only here and there and not completely. It is mostly due to the fact that I have bigger picture in my mind which helps me understand thing in proper context.
I do not go around cursing and condemning people for their difference of opinions instead I try to explain things for better understanding so that people may learn from that. Even when I started on this forum I began by explaining things and hopefully I have helped people look at things on a wider scale. Still it will take some more time before some of our brethren realise their own errors of judgement. All because as a society or community we are not used to critical study of islam and muslims.
Hope this explains my stance on islamic scholarship. I have learned from all scholars and advise the same for all of us. Sticking to sectarian bias is not a good thing instead we all must follow evidence and show we are using our own brains. So long as we are sincere to ourselves and consistent with advice of Allah as we understand it and have good will towards humanity at large we are fine.
Thanks for the opportunity to explains things, regards and all the best.
ask him the views about mirza manhoos mauood...
Must be his relative , both are mughal. And he may be qadyani too... Posting here light version of qadyaniet...
Your Daleel and your Aqal is upto yor Hud Hud , this GGanja Hud Hud...Raaz bhai jo baat bhi mabni bar daleel ho us baat ki sanad wohi baat hoti hai koi shakhsiyat nahin. aap ki sanad bekaar hai agar aap ki baat mabni bar daleel nahin hai.
kia aap ne kabhi ghor farmaya keh daleel hoti kia hai? hamari qaom ke liye daleel mehz aik lafz hai is se aage kuch bhi nahin. unhen yeh maloom hi nahin keh daleel hoti hi mabni bar aqal hai. jo log aqal ki ehmiyat hi se inkaar karte hen woh daleel ki bunyaad hi ka inkaar kar dete hen is liye aise log sahibe ilm nahin hote. unki kisi bhi baat ka ehtbaar nahin hota agarche keh woh kisi alaa madarasa ke sanad yaafta hun.
agar mere paas koi ilm hai to us ka andaaza meri baatun se bakhoobi lagaya jaa sakta hai magar agar main kahoon keh main intaai taleem yaafta hun magar meri baatoon main na koi nsar ho na per to aap ko khud hi pata chal jaaye ga keh mere dawe main kitni haqeeqat hai ya sadaaqat hai.
Albatta is nateeje par ponchne ke liye aap ke paas bhi ilm ka hona usi qadar zaroori hai jise aap ko baat ke saheeh tor par pata chal sake. warna aik bache ki tarha aap apni kahen ge bila doosre ki baat ko samjhe.
rahee hudhud ki baat to lagta hai hudhud abhi tak aap ke gale main atka hua hai. bhai ab ningal bhi lo warna aap ko ulta latkaana pade ga.:lol: