The Decision Of Hanging Mumtaz Qadri Was Right Or Wrong ?

[paki_]

Re: کیا ممتاز قادری کی پھانسی درست تھی؟؟؟

model town ke qatil wazir e azam or ala bannay phir rahay hai .. rabia imran bhi dandanati phirti hai .qadri ka jurm qatal nahi ghareeb hona tha . or iss say khatra blashphemy law ke ghalt istamal ko nahi on ashrafia ko tha jo yeh baat koam ko batana chatay hain ham tum say oper hai anida easi harkat maat karna cheye ham din diharay model town kartay phirain

I disagree with some of your points. Mumtaz Qadri took the law into his own hand and killed a man who wasn't convicted. but you are right the law should be the same for every Pakistani, rich or poor. the perpetrators of model town massacre should also be hanged

 

[Anonymous Paki]

The decision was absolutely spot on....BUT I am happy to see NOORAS getting thrashed!

 

[zahidmajid]

1000% right

 

[atensari]

Re: کیا ممتاز قادری کی پھانسی درست تھی؟؟؟

اس پھانسی پر عوام کی واضخ اکثریت دو حصوں میں تقسیم ہے ، بہتر ہوتا اس کو عمر قید میں تبدیل کر دیا جاتا .. قادری سے جانے انجانے میں جرم سرزد ہوا اور ایک خون کیا جس کی سزا لازم تھی ، لیکن سزا کیا ہونی چاہئیے تھی ، اس پر بحث ہو سکتی ہے

قانون تحفظ ناموس رسالت اور سزائے موت کی مخالفت کرنے والے اس سزا پر واضح طور تقسیم نظر نہیں آ رہے

 

[Wicked]

PPL how justify that Qadri killing wasnt right should think in this what if everyone start taking law into their own hands. what would happen to the society ?

 

[Talwar Gujjar]

Lets not bring Iman into this.

There were Muslim soldiers in British Indian Army who fought against Turks and participated in the siege of Makkah in 1916. Some of them even shot at Kaabah during that siege. They were following orders and abiding by their contract of duty. Does this mean their Iman was solid?

On the other hand, 1857 war of independence started when some Muslim soldiers refused to use cartridges made of pig skin. So by not abiding by their contract, their Iman became doubtful?

Reality is that personal beliefs often win out when they are considered in conflict with contract of duty.

No, don't agree. There was no compulsion on Qadri. His crime was grave and immense: And whoever kills a believer intentionally, his punishment is Hell; he shall abide in it, and Allah will send His wrath on him and curse him and prepare for him a painful chastisement.(Surah an-Nisā 4:93)

 

[amir_ali]

Keeping aside the religious or legal aspects of the issue, in terms of pure politics PM Nawaz Sharif has taken a huge risk. Muslim League's vote bank is mostly Pakistani nationalist-cum- conservative traditionalist which had been getting uncomfortable with Nawaz Sharif's persistent apparent efforts to appease liberal-conservative segments of society. This latest incident seems to be the final straw on camel's back.

A random survey of a sample of PMLN voters done immediately after Mumtaz Qadri's hanging has shown almost 50% of these voters vowing not to vote for PMLN again under Nawaz Sharif. If this reflects the wider feelings and these feelings persist, Nawaz Sharif may be in real trouble come next elections.

I personally was expecting hue and cry on much greater level, some thing like what happened after BB assassination, but obviously that didnt happen.

People will forget this qadri within months, may be sooner.

 

[amir_ali]

زندہ لکھ کا اور مردہ سوا لاکھ کا،میں گزشتہ ٣ سالوں سے اس فورم پر ہمیشہ ممتاز قادری کی پھانسی کی مذمت کی ہے ،سزا لازمی ہونی چا ے تھی مگر موت کی نہیں ،دس پندرہ سال جیل میں رہتا تو لوگ استہ استہ بھول جاتے ،مگر اس پھانسی نے اس کو اگلے ١٠٠. سال کے لئے زندہ کر دیا ہے ،اب ایسے واقیات میں اضافہ ہو گا نہ کے کمی .جتنی کم عقلی سلمان تاثیر ،ممتاز قادری نے دکھائی اتنی ہی حکومت اور عدالت بھی نکلی .

Nip the evil in the bud.

Kal koi aap ko ya aap kae ghar walon ko ye ilzam laga kar mar de kae us kae khyal main aap nae koi blasphemy ki hae, to phir???

 

[Porus]

I personally was expecting hue and cry on much greater level, some thing like what happened after BB assassination, but obviously that didnt happen.

People will forget this qadri within months, may be sooner.

Based on what I've heard from PMLN supporters, they are not likely to forget this when the election time comes. They have a deep feeling of anger and betrayal. Whatever he does, Nawaz Sharif is not likely to get votes from secular circles, which are not in significant number in any case. But losing a solid chunk of his traditional vote bank will cost him dearly in elections.

 

[tz00007]

if qadri is right then taliban r right too...lolz


im a PTI supporter but i commend PMLN govt on this.. they took a very brave decision.. qadri jese logo ka yahi anjaam hona chahiye..

 

[I Love Muhammad (PBUH)]

100% right decision .

no one has right to kill an other person, Qadri committed a crime , proudly confessed and was rightly hanged .

Now once he has been hanged , he has paid the price for his crime and its up to Allah to decide his fate so stop sending him to hell or heaven , leave it to Allah as he knows best

 

[stranger]

qadri ko sahi saza mili.... faisla 100% sahih hai

kuch log saza na dene ka mutalba iss tarah paish ker rehe hain ke agar kisi or ko saza nahi mili to qadri ko bhi nahi milni chahiay.... wohi PPP wali baat ke kia corruption per hamara haq nahi????

per asal haqeeqat ye keh jaisay qadri ko saza hui..... waisay hi baki sub ko bhi saza do.... jo ziada behter insaaf ho ga



mujhay aaj tak aik baat samajh nahi aai... bachpan main aik wakia perha tha school ki kitab main keh makkah ki aik aurat Nabi pak per koora phainka kerti thi.... aik din jab oos ne koora na phainka to aap oos ke ghar chalay giay or pata kia ke wo aaj kion na aai...... shaid ye waqia sacha hi ho ga.... Nabi pak ne kia saza di oos burhia ko??? shaid qatal ker dia tha na???

phir tayef walay wakia main bhi sab ko qatal ker dia tha na??? shaid or bhi bohat se waqiat hain aisay jab sab ko qatal ker dia gia....

or to or fath-e-makkah per bhi sub ko qatal ker dia or hinda (Nabi ke chacha ki qatil) ko bhi qatal ker dia balke zinda hi gala dia tha


issi liay hum aaj bas issi sunnat ki pairvi kerte huay issi tak main rehte hain ke koi gustakhi kere or bus tha ker ke maar dain

kash koi mujhay samjha sakay ke hum aisa kion kerte hain?????

 

[Jalil Malik]

Os ka ghalt faisla tha magar Qadri ka ishq-e- rasool be sabit hot hai. بہتر ہوتا اس کو عمر قید میں تبدیل کر دیا جاتا

 

[MAwan]

Nip the evil in the bud.

Kal koi aap ko ya aap kae ghar walon ko ye ilzam laga kar mar de kae us kae khyal main aap nae koi blasphemy ki hae, to phir???

Janab her waqia ke peechay kuch na kuch sachai zaroor hoti ha, agar blasphemy ka ilzam itna aasaan hota tu yahan her roz kai hazar lashein gir rehi hoti,
baqi muje samjh nehin aayi ap kis tanazer mein baat ker rehy hain , agar ap salman taseer ki baat ker rehy hain tu us ka profile hi aisa tha aur uper se sab media ke samney uss ne jo aur jaisey alfaaz boley tu obviously kuch log tu offended ho gye they aur unn mein se aik mumtaz qadri bhi tha.

 

[MAwan]

جتنی کم عقلی سلمان تاثیر ،ممتاز قادری نے دکھائی اتنی ہی کم عقل ملا برادری نکلی

یہ ملا برادری کی رسم تاجپوشی ہوئی ہے
جنہوں نے اس قوم کو صرف خود کش بمبار اورجہالت دی ہے

بجاۓ ٹھیک طریقے سے آگے لے کر جانے کے ، ہر الٹا کام کیا ہے
حتی کہ امریکہ کی جنگوں میں مشرف حکومت کی مدد بھی کی ہے ، لیکن مانتے نہی ، چھوٹے ہیں

sir ye kaam hakomat ke kerne ke hotey hain ke unn ke kisi amal ki weja se log kaise react ker saktey hain aur rehi baat mulla ki tu woh tu hamesha hi aise muqey ki talash mein hotey hain jis se woh apni dukaandari chamaka sakein.loha garam dekh ker her shakhs meedan mein uter aya aut log hamesha ki terah bewaqoof ban gye, is loey mulla ko blame dene ka faida nehin he woh muqa prest hain jider tarazoo bhari hua uder jhook gye .hakomat aur adalat ne boht immaturity dekhai ha.

 

[Aliimran1]

If it was not under the influence of some domestic or foreign power and if the law took all its correct measures then We have to accept it and leave the burdan of conscious to the judges to deal with ---------- ?

 

[Mojo-jojo]

Re: کیا ممتاز قادری کی پھانسی درست تھی؟؟؟

All political party heads & army should come together & send a clear message to these mobs who are trying to challenge the writ of the govt same as Qadri. This is also an important decision in the course of fight against terrorism. Most of the ppl in these mobs are uneducated so in the long run education is the only answer.

لیکن میاں صاحب تو میٹرو اور اورنج لائن کے چکر میں پڑے ہوئے ہیں قوم کو تعلیم کون دے گا؟

 

[ISIKHAN]

if Qadri hanging was right then what happened to these ******** .... also qadri hanging clearly show that money and elite works in justice system

 

[Pakistanian]

100% Agreed.

 

[Sarfraz1122]

holy prophet was very kind to those who abused and tried to kill them...
But extremists only get haidiths of that time when
Waar between good and bad, justice and cruilty was fought so that hadith or ayats are for that scienrio
Because it was time when kings also used to kill others who abused them..so in today world has better ways to fight religiois and political waars by by power of words and pen.

But i think this is a need of time that army should take over and deal with these buniad parsat mullahs...
So it has two benefits...
Nawas sharif sahib time will be over....
Mullah time will.be over
Then real change at all levela wil begin