MQMs coming of age?
Beautiful article Posted by Murtaza Razvi in Featured Articles Section of the Daily Dawn, Pakistan, Politics on 12 10th, 2009 | 161 responses
Of late, the Muttahida Qaumi Movement (MQM) is the only political party that has been making all the right noises on national issues, starting from its unequivocal condemnation of extremism to the considered stance on the controversial National Reconciliation Ordinance. The mourning day observed this week across urban Sindh on the call of the MQM for the victims of the Lahore Moon Market terrorist attacks was but a call for unity against a common enemy so opposed to the Pakistani majoritys way of life.
A transformation seems to be afoot in the partys maturing political orientation. It is fanning out of its stronghold of urban Sindh to reach out to the people everywhere, be it in Gilgit-Baltistan or the huge swathes of the middle class in Punjab. If it continues on this path of widening its public appeal by raising issues that affect the citizens in their everyday lives, the party can truly come of age and broaden its public appeal.
There is a growing awareness of the dreadful gap left in national politics by the PPP and the PML-N, the two largest parties, which seem only to retreat into their entrenched positions to the detriment of public interest and good governance. This gap needs to be filled by a third force seeking wider public support based on doing politics that reflects the peoples needs and aspirations.
It was in 1967 when such a gap between the ruling and the ruled first came to the fore in what was then West Pakistan: Zulfikar Ali Bhuttos Pakistan Peoples Party sought to bridge that gap by transforming the social contract, and with it the political lexicon. Lets not forget that Mr Bhutto, too, was groomed in the lap of the military establishment, but when his calling beckoned he rose to the occasion. His party became the voice of the silent majority that had not been heard. The Bhutto magic lingers to this day, though the spell cast by the party has considerably weakened as it was diluted over time in the hurly burly that characterised the partys every stint in power.
If the MQM can succeed in widening its public appeal on issue-based politics today, it could rekindle the hope for better governance than we have seen in the past many decades. The party can do it because it has, over the past seven years, acquired the wherewithal for such a role. It has been a ruling coalition partner at the centre and in Sindh, besides having effectively run city district governments in urban Sindh. This has helped the party break out of the ghetto mentality which went into its genesis.
A new sensibility, coupled with responsibility and the subtleties of being on the other side of the fence that is, on the ruling side while continuing to voice the concerns of the underdog, is just the right mix that a party claiming to represent the middle class needs. Despite many misgivings that exist against the MQM today, and for which the party too has to foot some blame, the people are so desperate right now that they would be willing to give the MQM a chance to deliver where all others have failed. And on the delivery front, the party is standing on firm ground given the good job it has done in Karachi over the past few years.
But even before that, the political vacuum that has existed for over two decades now is one that has left many middle-class people detached from politics. The people are just waiting to give anyone a chance having an agenda that resonates with their own wishes, as in hoping against hope. It should be recalled that under the devolution of power plan promulgated by General Musharraf in 2001, the MQM was able to secure over 100 nazims slots in Punjab alone.
This was because there was a big disconnect between the Muslim League headed by the Sharifs, who had been thrown out of power in the 1999 coup, and the peoples expectations of a representative government. But later it was the Muslim League of the Chaudhries that became Musharrafs new surrogate. The ruling cliques feudal mindset and the MQMs pro-establishment stance at the time culminating in the mayhem of May 12, 2007, in Karachi, when the then defunct chief justice was not allowed to enter the city hurt the MQMs popularity in Punjab.
However, the people of Punjab have a short memory; if the post-1970 election results are anything to go by, they, more than Pakistanis elsewhere, have voted across party lines. This makes the electorate there a potent force, one that can be won over provided your politics remains relevant to popular sentiment which, in turn, a party committed to its convictions can steer in the right direction. Isnt that what democracy is all about?
Consider, for instance, the MQMs popular demand to continue the local government system after making necessary changes to the laws that administer it, rather than scrapping the representative system at the grassroots level altogether. The stance resonates with public sentiment not only in Karachi but across the board.
At a recent conference held in the high security zone of Islamabad, some 500 supporters of the local government system, including many nazims from across the four provinces, braved the odds of reaching the capital to push the government for not derailing the local government system. The PPP and PML-Ns stance on the issue is highly controversial if not outright unpopular. It is seen by the people as an attempt to strengthen the provincial governments traditional, feudal-minded approach to amassing all power in their big-brotherly hand.
As for the MQMs position on local governments, it is this brick-by-brick laying of the social and political edifice from the ground up that can win the party wider public support. But a prerequisite for garnering a broad-based backing will have to be MQMs credentials as a political force that is inclusive and national in its appeal, as opposed to parochial or regional.
In the months ahead, if the MQM continues to throw its weight behind the right gut feel that can give way to a wider public consensus on a given issue, like on terrorism and the NRO, it can enjoy national leadership in a fairly good time.
Murtaza Razvi is the Editor, Magazines, at Dawn.
The following reader comments do not necessarily reflect the views and policies of the Dawn Media Group.
161 Comments
Tanzeel says: December 12th, 2009 at 17:26 Altaf doesnt need MQM, its MQM that needs Altaf.
Slashing Altaf from MQM and suggesting Mustafa Kamal or Sattar instead would be unfair, you need to understand that running a city or department is a different thing than running a party. Infact you people should praise Altaf for picking a gem out of nowhere and made him work like that.
I wonder why at time we become so selfish and limit our thinking to short term only.
Tomorrow someone else would come and do more than Kamal you guys would start suggesting his name for party leadership. Not a sane approach I would say.
Tanzeel says: December 12th, 2009 at 17:11 Reason for not being popular through out Pakistan is the restrictions agencies had put on MQM. If you remember the military operations against MQM in a bid to break party structure you would not call MQM a single province party.
Now nation is witnessing true face of MQM. All image building and wonders MQM has done in Karachi and stances they have taken in assemblies are under the leadership of Altaf which are being appreciated nationwide.
One should understand that Farooq Sattar, Mustafa Kamal or any MQM representative is working under Altafs leadership. MQM wont have been the third largest party of Pakistan had Altaf not led MQM.
I would also like to clarify that expenses incurred by Intl Secretariat and over all party funding take places through MQMs-fund contributed by its party members by allocating certain percentage of their monthly income.
ark abbot says: December 12th, 2009 at 16:36 Come on give us a break! MQM the party behind the 12th may carnage and responsible for spreading terror in Karachi city is today being given the credit of going against terrorism.
Action speaks louder than words.
Natasha says: December 12th, 2009 at 16:05 It is important to be aware of todays politics instead of HISTORY.
Im not calling MQM unbiased.Im talking about the critics.
Natasha says: December 12th, 2009 at 15:52 Ali,
And since your comparing the man with the Shareefs , kindly let me know what does he do for a living.
jk says: December 12th, 2009 at 12:32 Absolutely right again naveed, the MQM is only party, who has condemned terrorism and extremists. It has become a brave and visionary party, with the thoughts of the masses on its mind.
Other parties have same rhetoric and why no other leaders brave enough to condemn terrorism?
Naved Haider says: December 12th, 2009 at 10:36 In case some one is determined to oppose MQM, its not difficult to find faults and reject it. Most of the MQM critics are living 1980s and 90s, they are not able see a positive change in the party in the last decade.
For me two reasons are enough to support the party.
1- MQMs commitment to root out religious extremism from Pakistan and their loud and clear stance on this matter.
2- MQMs performance in the development work of Karachi in the recent past.
I am least bothered why Altaf Hussain is living in England & and from where he is getting funds to run the party.
Syed Ali says: December 12th, 2009 at 10:17 The people of Pakistan are sick of the two big political parties namely PPP and Muslim Nawaz group, the blogger has mentioned all the pros and cons of MQM, I believe if there is any leadership to be trusted in coming days that would be only MQM, they are not industrialists, bureaucrats neither tycoons, but they have showed in Karachi and Hyderabad, they are the worker of Peoples of Pakistan.
MQM has shown it leadership by taking stance on the three very sensitive national issues NRO, terrorism and military action in swat and South Waziristan. The only party who came out on the street against terrorism and Taliban is MQM. They are the only one who is behaving as a true national and mature political party.
MQM is truly a party of the poor and downtrodden people of Pakistan. All MQM need is cautious and sensible political moves. The future is waiting for them. My suggestion is to keep the accountability process within the party and very soon we will see MQM as a national party on the horizon of Pakistani Politics.
Kabeer Faruqui says: December 12th, 2009 at 10:02 Every political party in the world get funds through donations from Business houses, private firms/companies, members and sympathizers and MQM is no different in this regard. When people put such questions only for MQM, it clearly indicates the biased approach towards the party.
aLi says: December 12th, 2009 at 10:02 Natasha and Malik,
Thank you,
ALi
Saad says: December 12th, 2009 at 9:56 It seriously hurts me how can someone write a favoring article for MQM.
They always tried to make a state into a state.
hasjams says: December 12th, 2009 at 9:49 Well, apart from some of the bitter facts mentioned above regarding MQM and the leadership, it becomes an undeniable fact that MQM has made a turn around in terms of its vision and tolerance.
Secondly, there is a well known saying actions speak louder then words so the kind of development we had seen for last few years is matchless to the previous ones.
Last but not the least, what other option the natives of Karachi have besides MQM; I think no one.
So Jamal says: December 12th, 2009 at 4:27 MQM will never come to age until it transitions from a mafia style to democratic norms. Can the party make any decisions with the great Bhai. Is there any succession mechanism in place? Are office holders elected to their roles by inside votes or just selected by Bhai?
ABG says: December 12th, 2009 at 3:15 At least this party has the most literates than any other party in Pakistan.
There are always bad eggs in every party but the weight age of such eggs in MQM is low.
Guys: Were almost on the verge of extinction. Lets get united. We cant afford any divisions anymore. Get good education, provide good education and rise as one great/developed nation, and rise as one voice! Thats all we need
jK says: December 12th, 2009 at 2:07 Some interesting points made by all. But the bottom line is this MQM deserve the chance, people are sick and tired of other parties like PPP and of Sharif party. Lets try some change and these days what you hear coming from the MQM camp makes a lot of sense. The condemnation of terrorism, the importance of local governance, etc.
Yes it would help the MQM cause now for Altaf Hussein to go back to Pakistan and yes it would be unifying for the party to have the Pakistani flag as their party flag. How ever the bottom line is we need change.
The party has its faults but I think is the best bet at the moment and believe me if I can see the virtues of the MQM in the current climate, Im sure others can as Well.
Tanzeel says: December 12th, 2009 at 2:06 And those who want Altafs removal from MQM leadership should go back and read some history books to know how much struggle he has done for the party. Its so easy to demand his removal just because couple of teenagers dont like him but there should be some sense behind passing such statements.
Altaf is the founder of MQM and he will remain so forever. Just the way we cant take away Jinnahs status of Quaid from Pakistan, we cannot remove Altaf from MQM chairmanship.
MQM works on professional lines, Altaf doesnt do micromanagement like other party leaders. MQM has a management hierarchy and all party workers including its leader follow it.
Zafar Hussain says: December 12th, 2009 at 1:50 MQM has potential to be a national party provided it leaves Altaf Hussain, introduces internal party democracy, disband armed mafia type activities, and etc.
saifullah says: December 12th, 2009 at 1:20 Can MQM shun its ethnic base, and can it stop treating Mr. Altaf hussain as savior and treat him as a human being. Thus, letting party decision making done through an institutional process and not on the decisions of Mr. Hussain (single man cannot hold all the wisdom). Let the Rabta committee to be a decision-making forum.
Citizens want political parties to practice democracy within their parties.
Sayyid Shamsi says: December 12th, 2009 at 1:11 As I read the 116 comments over this article. Some of the people raised this question Why Altaf hussain is sitting in Uk and running his party from uk. I will not go in detail but I will ask the question to those who raised this question. Why Mr. Zardari is sitting in President House, Nawaz sharif he is sitting in Rewand with a lots of security. What happened to the Pakistan Most secure place which is GHQ. I think you will find the answer. About Altaf hussain will he several time ask this thing to his party workers to come back to Pakistan. Do you think what party workers said? We need your guidance without your physical presence at this current situation. MQM party workers and leader have a very close relationship. Here in MQM most of issues decided by Rabita committee. About Party fund I can assure you MQM is not lotting Pakistani nation money as other parties did. We dont have any bank accounts in Switzerland. Party fund is generated by MQM workers where they contribute from their salary a reasonable amount every month and as every knows how many MQM workers all over the Pakistan. Guess 10,000 worker * 50 Rest = 500000 this is just an example. Thats called unity among the party and relationship.
Farooque Ali says: December 12th, 2009 at 1:00 Everyone has right to say, because we all are living in independent state.
One thing I would like to say that a person who is living in the Non-Muslim State and governing from there and giving the orders from there, then how is it possible that they are patriot?
Why dont MQM change its main office from London to any Muslim State?
They believe on Non-Muslim rather than Muslims!!
ali hassan says: December 12th, 2009 at 0:57 Despite my disliking for MQM in past years due to its mysterious activities, I have come to like the way it has raised voice on important national issues.
I think MQM can be an alternative.
Sayyid Shamsi says: December 12th, 2009 at 0:39 A very good analysis by writer. Yes MQM is gaining the public support all over the country and as a Pakistani nation we have to give chance to MQM and bring MQM in National politics. Although they did some wrong decision in the past but the current situation MQM is showing mature politics which is people politics. In my personal opinion although I am from Punjab we have to welcome MQM and see how they can do more for Pakistan as they did in Karachi, Hyderabad without the support of Federal Government and Establishment. I have a hope that MQM can change the system of Pakistan and bring Pakistan as an independent state where people can enjoy with full rights with no discrimination over sex, religion, cast etc.
Watan Dost says: December 11th, 2009 at 23:29 Answer:
Altaf Hussain does not come to Pakistan because the people who assassinated Liaqat Ali Khan & Benazir are still around.
Tanzeel says: December 11th, 2009 at 23:14 MQMs funding take place through a systematic procedure involving internal audit. The party has established a fund call MQF (Muttahida Qaumi Fund) where party workers allocate 1% of their income to MQM. KKF(Khidmat-e-Khalak foundation) also utilizes the same sort of funding, though they earn through charity as well.
Sindhi says: December 11th, 2009 at 23:09 After reading the comments I can pick out two things from those who are against MQM :
1) Altaf Hussain lives in London.
2) MQM terrorizes its people It is a ethnic party.
Hmmm, if MQM terrorized its people, why would it be fastest growing party in Pakistan? Why would it receive accolades from many in Karachi and Hyderabad? Do you think most of the people in Karachi and Hyderabad are racist, anti-Pakistani and dumb? Lately, media is not giving anyone any room to breathe, they pounce on anyone who seems to not have their act straight. So why are their accolades from Lahore based media personalities and columnist for MQM?
Altaf is never going to be Pm President Mayor Parliamentarian. He is going to remain figure head so him being here or in London is irrelevant. Look at others in the party who are so apt to do this task like Haider Abbas Rizvi and Dr. Farooq Sattar. As a Sindhi I can tell you this much, next time I vote, it will be for MQM.
Rauf says: December 11th, 2009 at 22:40 @Natasha
Because they are rational. When you are rational you tend to be less biased
MQM Less biased? Are you sure about that Natasha? If I remember correctly, there were few MQM supporters waving the MQM flag in the stadium during cricket match 2009 Pak/Aus match (in South Africa). This was even reported on few cricket websites.
I Shahid says: December 11th, 2009 at 22:06 Barooq, rational people support MQM because irrational people like you are not open to any discussions and will not change their mind whatever evidence contrary to your opinion is brought up.
Ammar Baloch says: December 11th, 2009 at 22:04 Those who are asking question about MQM earning, probably they dont know well the supporters of MQM, Go to any MQM gathering, pick a bucket and collect money, you will get it fill in no times. Secondly, MQM is well supported by many of the eminent industrialists. But the most important thing unarguably is that they run the ministries quite well and none of the MQM minister involved in any corruption scandal.
Islam Shah says: December 11th, 2009 at 22:01 Belonging to middle class is not the yardstick of judging people. To be a middle class man does not mean to be Mr. clean. Rather middle class people are more prone to corruption and extremism. MQM leaders and workers accuses feudal and industrialists for current situations of the country but they forget that Pakistan was ruled for thirty years by army dictators who all belonged to middle class and who threw the country twice in wars with India, twice in wars of Afghanistan and encouraged extremism, factionalism and sectarianism. Most of our bureaucrats belong to middle class. Police personnel mostly belong to middle class. Are they honest?
Shahid says: December 11th, 2009 at 21:52 Mqm has made many mistakes in the past but it has to be seen in the context of survival. Their were powers/elements which tried every thing to prevent MQM take off the ground because their own interest was threatened. In any case MQM has traveled a long journey since their inception in eighties and nineties and has now matured into a true national political party. One thing to remember is that it always had the support of people inspite of all the allegations and propaganda against them. I believe we ought to give them a chance on national scale to challange them and test their potentials.
.
Soomro says: December 11th, 2009 at 21:27 MQM and Imran Khan are the only two entities who have some idea about how to save Pakistan. I think if they leave their anger for each other and form a coalition they both will be very successful. MQM can do well in whole Pakistan (not only Karachi) if and only if they leave their violent ways. I hope and pray that day will come soon. If their reputation changes I dont think any party will stand in their way to come in power. Only then we can have a PM from MQM.
Sarwar Shah says: December 11th, 2009 at 21:26 Yes MQM is a true representative of working class of the Pakistan, All people (98%) belonging to middle class should stride hard to up bring MQM.
zainab says: December 11th, 2009 at 21:22 I would suggest that MQM should be merged in PML Quaid-e-azam group to please the soul of Jinnah and to join the main stream. This party will never be acceptable to people of other places of Pakistan except Karachi with the brand names of MQM and Altaf hussain. I further suggest if the merger with PLMQ is not viable, at least its name and leadership should be changed. Then I hope people will forget and forgive its past.
Nasir Habib says: December 11th, 2009 at 20:47 @ Natasha, MQM has a very big donor base in Karachi. I still remember standing in lines with my parents to donate.
How many city nazims were/ are living in rented houses? Mustafa Kamal still does.
Mr. Altaf can not be taken seriously. MQM is a party that goes with the flow.
Rehan says: December 11th, 2009 at 19:47 Regardless of what is said by the detractors, the MQM of 2010 is not the MQM of 1999. It is a middle class party that is focused on social justice and moderation. This it self is a tremendous hope for our nation. Nobody here is going to shed any tears for Mr. Altaf Hussain, we all dislike him, even MQM members, but you play the game that you have to play.
If our brothers in Punjab ever get past their prejudices, they would find the MQM to be a very good platform that shares their ideals.
manjhi khan says: December 11th, 2009 at 18:48 Dear writer,
MQM may have done good works but only in Urdu speakers areas, it is unfortunate that genetically biased Urdu media has been projecting MQM as only good thing that has happened in land of pure Urdu media doesnt show the Sindhi colonies which under the city government are facing all hell and bias. If its party of middle class how its leader is managing huge mansion in London?
Barooq says: December 11th, 2009 at 18:17 Natasha
I made a case of rationality before asking how come rational people think what they think.
And simply put, supporting MQM is supporting Altaf Hussain.
Which rational mind would support a crying and screaming drama queen of a leader.
Natasha says: December 11th, 2009 at 17:58 Jamil,
Brian says: December 11th, 2009 at 17:16 Spot on Mr. Rizvi, the MQM has certainly proved itself this time around. The MQM represents the Middle Class therefore I believe it is the only party which can unify the nation.
One suggestion for my MQM brothers; lets do away with the current Flag, let the PAKISTAN FLAG represent the MQM; I am sure it will work wonders in unifying the nation.
Until or unless the multicolored flags are banished, our nation can never unite.
Common MQM, lets unite the nation with the Green and White.
Natasha says: December 11th, 2009 at 17:14 //It pains me to see rational people supporting MQM and I would love to see why?//
Because they are rational. When you are rational you tend to be less biased. We need to be more flexible. MQM is as bad as any other party. They have shown improvement over the years. Lets just have the guts to appreciate what is good and condemn what is wrong without being prejudiced. MQM has done wonders for Karachi. They are not angels but are definitely turning out to be a good party. Their hypocrisy aside, they have played a positive role in some important issues.
Natasha says: December 11th, 2009 at 17:10 //MQM is democratic?
Thats a joke right?
There is one entity in MQM. I remember when people tried to break away from Altaf, the violence that followed.
I mean seriously? People here are delusional.//
-
MQM is not democratic just like any other party. PMLQ cant think beyond Chaudhrys, PMLN is nothing without Shareefs and our darling PPP has always been the property of the Bhuttos and now the Zardaris cum Bhuttos. Theres no point in singling out MQM .They are no different.
P.S. I am in favor of MQM changing its leadership. They need an awami leader not some someone saving his life in England talking dramatically about his agony over the sufferings of people here every other day.
Natasha says: December 11th, 2009 at 17:05 Well- written article. I agree with most of the things mentioned. I would like to add that Altafs removal as the partys supreme commander would help improve the image of the party especially in Punjab but unfortunately MQMs not willing to take any such step for the sake of the country. If not his removal, his return to the country would help improve the partys image. People at large are irritated by his telephonic addresses. Hes perceived as a dramay baaz by the masses. He should prove his patriotism by coming back ignoring all the security concerns like other leaders. It is easy to express pain for the awam while sitting abroad. Come and serve them here. There life is as precious as yours.
saad ahmed says: December 11th, 2009 at 17:01 MQM could be better option in the coming days they have demonstrated good governance in Karachi and Hyderabad. Mustafa Kamal, mayor of Karachi has done tremendous job and made significant changes in short tenure of 4 years. Last month He was invited by Harvard University and Columbia university of New York to deliver lecture. I wonder how many of our politicians might be invited or capable of delivering lecture in top notch educational institutions.
Secondly, it is the beauty of MQM to give tickets to ordinary people from middle class. Mustafa Kamal himself was an ordinary MQM activist. And now they are trying to come in to mainstream politics to wash the stain of ethnic party. Having seat in Gilgit, I believe MQM might be good option for us.
As salam o Alikum
Shahab Uddin Ahmed says: December 11th, 2009 at 16:56 Indeed an article of substance and a true reflection of public opinion. MQM has shown maturity which reflects from the historic decisions it took through this decade.
In my opinion MQM in the past was never given a fair chance to prove its worth. In the past decade or so MQM was allowed to play its role in national politics, the result has been very encouraging.
MQM is the only political party which comes from the 98% unprivileged class of Pakistan. No one better then them can understand the plights of the downtrodden and I totally agree with the writer when he says, If the MQM can succeed in widening its public appeal on issue-based politics today, it could rekindle the hope for better governance than we have seen in the past many decades. The CDGK in Karachi and Hyderabad has released equal funds to all the towns irrespective of political affiliations which not only shows justice but also shows commitment to their just cause.
My praise to MQM for coming up to the expectations of their voters and pray to almighty Allah for their success to save this country and image in the world as a progressive and peaceful nation.
Zamarrud khan says: December 11th, 2009 at 16:27 One wonders some TV channels are projecting MQM to the best of their efforts. Dont know the consideration whether it is money or terror.
Jamil Niazi says: December 11th, 2009 at 16:12 MQM was first supporting NRO and had even assured PPP to pass it through parliament but after sensing medias reaction to the NRO when presented in Parliament MQM took a somersault and started portraying itself as an enemy of NRO from day one.
Ammar A. Qureshi says: December 11th, 2009 at 15:52 A youth revolution is what can save Pakistan. All these feudalistic and thug parties are playing power-game.
Ammar A. Qureshi says: December 11th, 2009 at 15:50 We have become such a desperate nation that we just could not differ between real concern of having peoples best interests at heart and a fake one just to win peoples heart for getting them to vote. Tell me why should we settle for the best of the worst? Why shouldnt we get best of the best in our assemblies? Most of the karachites are afraid of MQM as we experience its fascism in everyday life. It is fascism behind the veil of democracy.
Mudassir Hussain says: December 11th, 2009 at 15:49 I am really appalled after reading a comment by one MR who still thinks that MQM stands for Muhajir Qaumi Movement.
Most of the people who are commenting about MQMs atrocities and terror would not have seen it from their own eyes!! It is just word of mouth but on the other hand. I am not advocating that only all the right things have been done till now.
We need to keep in mind that MQM originated and is existing in Pakistan. Where a lot of things had gone by under the name of politics and political parties!!
If they have realized and are mending their ways, then wait and see what happens instead of beating our backs!
Barooq says: December 11th, 2009 at 15:41 MQM is democratic?
Imran Khan a failed politician?
I guess he is a failed politician because he did not become Musharrafs ilk like Altaf bhai did for 8 years. Atleast Imran Khan LIVES in Pakistan and knows whats going on instead of screaming into a phone every few days from his London residence.
Furqan says: December 11th, 2009 at 14:21 Any unbiased reader would have extracted the major problem of Pakistan from the public views I witnessed after the article. This is what we want to think, MQM may or may not be involved in the thing you talking about but what now. The only party which is practically doing some thing. The promises made by other parties is only followed by MQM to implement on ground. Think again and Think twice.
GHAZAN KHAN says: December 11th, 2009 at 14:07 Isnt it good if some one is changing himself for the better? MQM is such one.
For other political parties I can say they going from bad to worse. I shall be pleased if other parties also adopt MQM policies and take interest in common mans issues, adopt a clear policy against terrorism, religious extremism and mullahism. BRAVO
Irfan Rizvi says: December 11th, 2009 at 14:06 MQM political polices and agenda has evolved over the time and are the only party in our country that has done so and are not based on slogans such as Roti Kapra & Makaan for last 40 years. Although they used ethnicity to establish themselves but I think that is the only way to go in this country as people consider themselves Punjabi, Pathan, Sindhi, Maharjir, Balochi first and Pakistani afterwards. They still have a lot to do in order to improve their image as their history of 90s is not hidden to anyone and they have a leader sitting in UK who declines to return to the country. But its good to give the credit where its due and the writer should be applauded for that. MQMs recent politics has started a trend of issue based politics which only MQM & PTI are doing, and should be followed by all the other parties
Barooq says: December 11th, 2009 at 13:47 And how easily you forgot to mention MQMs relentless support of Musharraf, the carnage of May 12th, and how the middle class Altaf Hussain, without a job is living in UK and refuses to return?
Few private news channels have been on MQM bandwagon for quite a while and its a shame that people working for Newspapers are doing that too.
Why dont you just You tube Mr.Altaf and just try to sit through his 10 minute address? The guy is a actor. He shouts and screams and cries and one of the biggest drama queens of all time. And nobody actually can make fun of him on mainstream media. Can you tell me why?
You want to talk about how good MQM has been, you can. But do you actually think it would change the perception of people like me who have seen what they have done?
Aamnah Khan says: December 11th, 2009 at 13:27 Mustafa Kamals work is indeed commendable when you drive all over the city and the way MQM is spreading its wings is exemplary but not much because the armed political phenomena based in the very core of this popular party is the most alarming factor which I am very against, in any unwanted case MQMs leadership wants to use it they use it and we face strikes and horrors all over the city. Their way of armed politics is unexpected and inevitable whenever they intend to force it. If thats also a part of politics I am not ready to second the opinion of the author.
.
MQM is a progressing party and it should set firm rules in areas where people like me are questioning its credibility.
Barooq says: December 11th, 2009 at 13:14 I dont want to be governed by a leader who cries every three days on telephone. And screams.
And it was not morally because of MQM but others political parties who every time after coming into power tried to knock MQM down which eventually resulted in problems.
While commenting on the darker sides of MQM during past 2 decades it would be fair if we also keep in mind the atrocities and tough situation, citizens of Karachi and Hyderabad had to face Qasba Colony, Aligarh Colony, Pakka Qilla are few places/events.
I will also endorse the view of Reality Bites regarding the absent leadership. That is an important aspect missing from MQMs operational capabilities here in Pakistan. But reasons given by others in this regard are also very obvious.
A lot of expectations have been tied around MQM now. They need to struggle even harder to live up to it.
Omar Khattab says: December 11th, 2009 at 11:42 Observer in his/her comments says, Anyone who has lived in Karachi from 1985 1995 and watched the political scene would be a witness to their dark sides.
I am a living witness to their dark sides.
gholam says: December 11th, 2009 at 11:37 Thats true. But I think MQM of 1990s is long gone and they have transformed from a regional ethnic party to a mainstream party with nationalist, moderate and development minded anti feudal, strong anti terrorist agenda, They have done very well in Karachi and Hyderabad and I feel they must work hard to enlarge their constituency not through mere slogan, but through action in all the Provinces of this great Nation. God bless Pakistan. May we shine and stand strong and united. Ameen.
Regards from Peshawar
Observer says: December 11th, 2009 at 10:54 Good piece of writing and I respect the authors point of views. I dont have confidence on a party whose leadership literally prides in being a foreign national, and standing away from the masses and the country. They perceive to represent. Hippocratic kind off right?
The party may have potential but the leadership needs to change in order to improve the partys brand image. Anyone who has lived in Karachi from 1985 1995 and watched the political scene would be a witness to their dark sides.
Hassan says: December 11th, 2009 at 10:52 Well I wish that what the writer has said about MQM turns into truth. MQM needs to turn into such a party rather than a party that relies more on street power. Yes if they do get rid of such things and show more political maturity they sure can be a good political force which can gain better respect. A writer here is saying they have no corruption records and maybe they do have some terror and horrible allegations such as torture and rape but I wont go into that, I would just tell you one thing yes there are good people in MQM and there are very few in other parties but MQM is not having clean hands either. Corruption has become an integral part of our society whether political parties or other govt. officials etc.
Umair Majeed says: December 11th, 2009 at 10:40 MQM has taken right steps in connection with terrorism. This shows their good will for Pakistan. If we work on Altaf Bhaia strategy against terrorism we will surly be getting rid of it. Every individual should protect Pakistan.
Ghazanfar says: December 11th, 2009 at 10:15 Finally people of Pakistan are realizing the fact that they are being ruled by feudals for 62 years. MQM is the only political force with no such background. Time is up for change in Pakistan and we are waiting to see that.
razak says: December 11th, 2009 at 10:13 Indeed MQM is the reality in politics who always won the side of ruling party, but compare with other two largest parties like PPP & PML-N is still not justified by the work and attitudes of MQM.
I would say that this is the only party who exist in few areas of urban Karachi, there is no such presence of MQM is rural areas of Sindh.
kamal khan says: December 11th, 2009 at 10:09 I completely agree with the writer. However, I would like to clarify the understandings of Reality Bites that Pakistan is country where prediction can be made about the unpredictable. Reality Bites should be aware of the fact that Mir Murtaza Bhutto, Bughti and many like others were killed in day light. Especially Mir Sahab was killed when his sister was sitting prime minister. How come Mr. Altaf Hussain will be spared?
Danish Khan says: December 11th, 2009 at 10:07 Ill vote for Mustafa Kamal for PM any day. Hats of to Altaf Hussains leadership skills and yes they are true representatives for middle class Pakistan and they also care about Pakistan Alot. By the way this is the only party which is also well organized in Pakistan.
Badar says: December 11th, 2009 at 10:03 There are pros and cons with MQM like any other party.
Shairani says: December 11th, 2009 at 9:45 @ Reality bites, doesnt the assassination of Shaheed Benazir Bhutto answer your question?
Sajjad says: December 11th, 2009 at 9:33 This is the only political party in Pakistan now, which talks about social changes. Many political pundits only talks, MQM delivers the benefits of middle class governance to 98% of Pakistan, Development of Karachi is a proof of it. Hopefully 1 day MQM can have Prime Minister from the party, that day will start a new era in Pakistan history Inshallah, Good, clean, authoritative Governance to eliminate, terrorism, making Pakistan more secure and economically sound. Internationally MQM definitely has a better face then any other Corrupt or plunder parties, and in long-term people of other provinces will realize the ideologies of party is as simple as to deliver which no other claims or take pride off. Writer has put the facts in place, Mash Allah Karachi is more secure then any other Pakistan city, it surely is due to Strong opposition of MQM, hats off MQM, may we see MQM leaders back safely to Pakistan and lead the party to spread the message of new era to all over Pakistan.
Zarghun says: December 11th, 2009 at 9:19 MQM has two faces. One is extremely good which has been discussed in the blog and the other face which it has been hiding for the last two years is too ugly to be watched. But I would appreciate if MQM has got rid of that fascist character of it.
MK says: December 11th, 2009 at 9:18 MQM still has to go quiet a far way, show maturity and further cleanse its cadre from hoolum but you are right, Thanks to Mustafa Kamal, Haider Abbas Rizvi and Khush Bakht Shujaat are faces people will like to listen and see more.
Let us hope and monitor, this is perhaps the last hope.
AHK says: December 11th, 2009 at 8:40 I think this article is nothing but scary. The writer does have a point there when he says there is a vacuum left open by PPP and PML types. If that vacuum if filled by MQM than I must say good bye Pakistan.
Shahzad says: December 11th, 2009 at 7:42 I am very pleased to read this blog. Every political party has its misfortunes and shady sides its the axiom of politics. However, where other parties have failed miserably, MQM has truly delivered not only in the development sector but also at multiple levels in Karachi, especially healthcare and education. For that I commend our honorary mayor Mustafa Kamal, as well as Altaf bhai for being the true leader of MQM. As long as a party delivers, all the talks in my opinion about where the leader is, is useless and will not impact any common man daily life chores.
Good luck MQM
tmf says: December 11th, 2009 at 7:23 I like how you play down the violence perpetuated by this party (and that it continues to do so in Karachi). You seem to be oblivious to the fact that this party sets the bar when it comes to violence in urban Pakistan.
Faisal says: December 11th, 2009 at 6:47 I totally agree with you, I think they are very progressive and party of educated people.
zafar Hussain says: December 11th, 2009 at 6:46 May be MQM is making right noises but it is not a democratic party. MQM must institute democracy and transparency in its party affairs, and only then it will able to represent people.
Alamsher K. Wzir says: December 11th, 2009 at 6:41 Noises MQM can make. The party is good at it. Every time noises are made, there is a motive behind it. How much more party can get from Zardaris govenment. 8 years MQM supported army dictator Musharraf. Now party is making right noises You must be joking.
Ali says: December 11th, 2009 at 6:40 I wonder, how can you make such comments about the very elements responsible for May 12 Massacre.
I am speechless!
Absar says: December 11th, 2009 at 6:04 MQM is yet another party like PPP or PML-N. I dont agree with the blogger.
There was an article in Dawn sometime back the title of which is The road to Punjab and author was Kunwar Idris. That article completely defines MQM being another ethnic party following the traditional demagoguery politics.
Blotting out ones hypocrisies under the development work in Karachi and raising voice against NRO doesnt warrant MQM as an all-good political party in Pakistan. Its perhaps the worst political party in the history of Pakistan with no principles; who believes in a leader living a peaceful life outside Pakistan while his countrymen are suffering for years. Imagine Khomani ruling Iran from Cuba, Gordon Brown ruling England from Thailand, Obama ruling US from Antarctica. I cant hold my laughs. MQM is one and only singular gift, for sure!
manawer hasan says: December 11th, 2009 at 6:00 I am still confused why people want to bring Altaf Hussain Back to Pakistan, if he is managing his stuff from England then their is no point in asking him to come back to Pakistan until and unless their is a peace and security in Pakistan. People forget that BB came to Pakistan and how brutally she was assassinated by their own country mens. In my opinion this is satellite age and you can run the country by living anywhere, its not compulsory to bring Leaders in Home country.
KBK says: December 11th, 2009 at 5:50 MQM observed mourning for Lahore victims, it was good thing but why they are not observing mourning for those who were killed and burnt alive by this group on May 12 and April 09 at Karachi. Were they not human being? Will MQM supporters have any reply?
02. On NRO first time President Zardari has done good job and released the list of beneficiaries of NRO which was sufficient proof that MQM was a corrupt organization as evident from cases.
khayal says: December 11th, 2009 at 5:45 Until MQM gets Non-Mohajir/Non-Karachite people in its ranks on prominent positions, it cant shed its ethnic image and get broader national support.
Syed K. Nawaz says: December 11th, 2009 at 5:26 I appreciate authors attempt to write such a unique piece of its own kind.
Brother Reality Bites may be you are right in your argument regarding a dream life of Quaid-e-Tehreek Altaf Hussain in London, but as a matter of fact its not 100% correct, as he is living a simple life and he is out there not on his own wish!
We the workers and Supporters of MQM consider it better to wait till any suitable time rather to Call him to the country and give a chance to any bad wisher to attempt any bad move against him.
We the Pakistani Nation needs a Great Leader like him, who truly can deliver to the People of Pakistan!
While writing these line, I have in my mind Mir Murtuza Bhutto, Ms. Benazir Bhutto, Hakeem Muhammad Saeed, Muhammad Salahuddin, Moulana Ludhyanvi, Saleem Qadri, Dr. Ghulam Murtuza Malik, Nawab Akbar Bugti, Azeem Ahmed Tariq, and thousand others who are not with us now!!!
I will appreciate your understanding in this regard bro!!!
Akil Akhtar says: December 11th, 2009 at 5:12 The problem with MQM is its roots are in its popular leaders are from a single city.
It will remain as Mohajir Qaumi Movement in our minds for a long time I guess. We do not want a lounge politician telling us from London what is good for us.
Ali says: December 11th, 2009 at 4:30 Sitting outside the country, it does seem to me as if MQM is currently making all the right moves as far as national issues go. However, I feel that it has not detached itself completely from its militant roots. I was hoping for a really changed MQM in the Musharraf era but the events of May 12 were an eye-opener that showed that militancy is still very much a part of the fabric of this party. I feel that this party needs much more time and maturity, and in all honesty some major overhaul of its leadership before it can claim national popularity.
ken says: December 11th, 2009 at 4:15 MQM needs to remove Altaf bhai as their leader, Once Altaf bhai is out of picture then MQM will become the number one party.
Pakistan Zinda Abaad
TRUE FAN OF MQM says: December 11th, 2009 at 3:43 Had the MQM opportunities to explore with honesty back to decades, Sindh Prince would have had no problems and developed but unfortunately, MQM is the victim due to our own Pakistani greedy political leaders.
Shayan says: December 11th, 2009 at 3:01 Astonishing! Have you people already forgotten last years Pakhtun-Muhajir riots in Karachi or even May 12, 2007? Mr Razvi and those posting here may have extremely short memories but rest assured that the rest of Pakistan does not.
The landscape of Pakistani politics is clear for MQM since feudal dominated PML(N) and PPP have miserably failed to deliver any thing for the poor and downtrodden people of Pakistan. All MQM need is cautious and sensible political moves. The future is waiting for them. Who knows Mustafa Kamal could be the future Prime Minister of Pakistan.
Watan dost says: December 11th, 2009 at 1:45 We have tried the ones who have traded the blood sweat & tears of our nation for
62 years. MQM should team up with the middle class of Punjab and give our nation what we deserve. An educated leadership loyal to Pakistan. They need to reduce their militant image though. Mustafa Kamal is the leadership we need. All power to the people.
N. Mirza says: December 11th, 2009 at 1:43 It is about time that Pakistan should leave its feudal past behind. We are 170-200 million citizens on the mercy of few landlords, oligarchs, and mullahs.
Long live the local governments and grassroots movements!
javed jadoon says: December 11th, 2009 at 1:39 It amazes me to see all the same people who runs the Pakistan are same faces comes again just with different party and agenda. All of or most of them are so corrupt that makes us sick. They are not afraid of god, or any thing.
We do need help from developed country to monitor our system and punish them who are hurting our country.
Thank you
Jadoon
desihungama says: December 11th, 2009 at 1:12 On a second note, Ill vote for MQM any day and twice on Sunday.
desihungama says: December 11th, 2009 at 1:10 The future belongs to the likes of Imran Khan and MQM.
Rizwan Nasar says: December 11th, 2009 at 0:35 Very interesting blog MQM has come off age! It had started on grass root level but I think its leadership had lost its ways. They have come back a cycle. It is the only political party today that has its roots in the people. It has taken them years but we see now there is a genuine leader in Mustafa Kamal who is concerned about the people and the city. I think it is time for MQM to become a force of change for Pakistan. As for the London leadership let them be there and do their lip service. We need a few more Mustafa Kamals to do the work in Pakistan and change it for the better. Let the revolution begin!
roshan zameer says: December 11th, 2009 at 0:23 Can any one answer who is paying for the comfortable living of MQM leadership in UK for over 17 years?
Nuzaira Azam says: December 10th, 2009 at 23:45 MQM Goes national!
After more than two decades diligent political work, Muttahida Qaumi Movement crossed the borders of a regional identity, and got onto main stream national political highway. It all happened when the party won a seat in the recent Gilgit-Baltistan Legislative Assemblys first-ever election.
Whether one agrees or not, the fact remains that MQM leader Altaf Hussain has led the party to the national level without any patronage or through political dynasty. The party has established a transparent political culture by tolerating political dissent, appreciating hard work and elevating the middle class people to decision-making positionsa phenomenon that is alien to Pakistans politics.
It is alleged that MQMthe only organized political party in the countryis more regimental than democratic and no party member dares to dissent with the supreme leader Altaf Hussain. However, many perceive it differently and believe that democracy means more responsibilities and to accomplish fundamental tenets and mechanics of democracy, strict rules and laws are indispensable.
There is a ray of hope, albeit a small one. Hussain, being a visionary leading a party that claims to be based on principles, could play a role in uniting other political forces and help establishing a somewhat more stable political system. It is about time to start a new beginning; the political parties should start organizing themselves and welcome new blood to empower the democracy, and to prevent running the political parties and politics as family businesses. They must unite together so no force dare to plunge them from the democratic path.
Nuzaira Azam
Washington, DC
N Karim says: December 10th, 2009 at 23:42 Dear Munib,
Why it is difficult for you to understand that Altaf is not coming to Pakistan. The assassination of Benazir Bhutoo is a good answer. In our country it is very hard to survive when you speak truth and make efforts for rights. I do not belong to MQM but surely suggest Mr. Altaf Hussain to remain in London to raise voice for the rights to 98% population of the people of Pakistan.
I salute the writer of article and very much agree with his opinion. One day MQM will be the ultimate voice of middle and lower middle class people of Pakistan.
umar tosheeb says: December 10th, 2009 at 23:32 MQM has great chance in Punjab especially after PPPs sure demise in the province. PPP has become intolerable and too controversial. I cant see it getting more than 10 seats in Punjab. If MQM stays out of controversial issues, it can pose a challenge for PML(N), but it will take time.
Remember Recent History says: December 10th, 2009 at 23:02 @Reality Bites
I think your concern is definitely legitimate, however Benazir was running her party from Dubai/London since 1999 in self exile (thats 9 years) and Nawaz Sharif was running his party from Saudi Arab for 9 years as well. I believe Altaf Hussein hasnt been in Pakistan since 1993-94?; give or take 13 years. If you are willing to discount 9 years for PPP and PML (N), then 13 shouldnt be a big issue for you for MQM.
I would assume that if MQM truly wants to become a national party though, it would need to have a complete change of guard at the top including Altaf Hussein.
Iqbal khan says: December 10th, 2009 at 22:59 This article is a reflection of peoples inspiration for a change in the political and power structure of the country. It is no doubt that peoples are looking to MQM for a change. MQM is able to change the feudal politic but the leadership must also put brake to the emerging party activists who are quickly establishing a new system of choudrys/voderas and Khans in the rural areas.
In the feudal system peoples are safe from their enemies so long they surrender their freedom to the khans.
Iqbal
Abbas Mastaan says: December 10th, 2009 at 22:44 that is, on the ruling side while continuing to voice the concerns of the underdog;
Strongly agree with the writer. The MQM has shown the right way to raise your concerns without derailing democracy lesson to be learnt for all other political forces of the country. Bravo MQM!!
Rahma says: December 10th, 2009 at 22:40 The MQM boycotted the 2001 local body elections.
mustafa says: December 10th, 2009 at 22:29 MQM is the true representative of poor and middle class citizens of Pakistan; if Altaf bhai is removed from this party. He is just like an army dictator for the party and people want democracy.
Canadian says: December 10th, 2009 at 21:51 The way they are working for past few years, I think they are far better than the options we got right now and they definitely deserve a chance to run the show.
Atta H khoso says: December 10th, 2009 at 21:41 MQM should never think for national issues because it has achieved no success over provincial issues as we know that the nation in SINDH province, since inception has denied MQMs existence and are not showing their soft corner to this nontraditional party and this unique attitude of Sindhi Nation is attributed to the uncomprehending policies of MQM. therefore, I will advice MQM leaders to show their proximity towards Sindh and then start worrying for other national issues.
Sajjad says: December 10th, 2009 at 21:39 MQM being anti-terrorist? This has to be the joke of the century. Noise-making, whether of the right type or the wrong type, has always been a hallmark of this party. Looking beyond the noise-making, you will find plenty of evidence of bad things they have done and the list goes on. I think people in the rest of Pakistan will do fine without this party in their areas.
Nicky says: December 10th, 2009 at 21:02 If the MQM comes to power in Pak then peace will prevail in the sub-continent.
Ambreen says: December 10th, 2009 at 20:40 I have never been a supporter of MQM. But after being disappointed repeatedly by the rest of the leadership I am willing to give them a chance. They are slowly proving themselves. The work in Karachi speaks for itself.
Ga says: December 10th, 2009 at 20:33 I just dont understand how a fascist party like the MQM can bring up the likes of Mustafa Kamal. Then again, to survive and to be respected as a political force in any country there has to be a militant streak. So despite the violent past I think MQM can have a good future considering it is not a party of feudal.
Atif says: December 10th, 2009 at 20:20 Very well done MQM is the only and last hope for all Pakistanis as it has the potential to deliver and has more literate and energetic people in it who can bring the change in Pakistan and also have the potential to fill the political gap as well. MQM have already shown it in Karachi and can prove it throughout Pakistan as well and to those who are saying the Altaf Bhai is sitting outside Altaf Bhai is sitting out side just because of his workers they dont want him to come to Pakistan and also he is not in comfort there he works day and night for the party and this is also a big reason of MQMs success and also another strong reason to support MQM is not a single case is registered against them of corruption anywhere in Pakistan. MQM is committed to deliver and MQMs stand on certain issues of Pakistan will also make MQM more powerful in Pakistan
Adnan says: December 10th, 2009 at 20:07 I agree with much of what the MQM stands for as far as their secular ethos is concerned. But how will they ever convince anyone outside of Karachi that they are anything other then an ethnic party which serves the interest of Karachites Urdu speaking? Are Punjabis going to be convinced that their interests will be served by such a party?! Seems unlikely.
Zafar Malik says: December 10th, 2009 at 20:03 I agree with the writer, there is a huge political vacuum in Pakistan, which needs to be filled and very soon, if country has to survive. Over the past six decades there have been huge demographic changes in Pakistan. A large, mostly urban based middle class has emerged and needs a political voice of its own. Power of traditional Zimindars, feudals, khans, sardars and bradaris has declined.
Now who will fill this vacuum, remains to be seen. MQM has a good chance, but overcoming the stigmas of its past will not be easy.
Abdul haleem says: December 10th, 2009 at 19:58 MQM past policies were wrong. Labeling them as ethnic party. But they are doing much better. They have to convince others people that what they will do what for common people of Pakistan. Common people are fed up with other parties and with Taliban.
Ansar says: December 10th, 2009 at 19:46 Long live Pakistan and Long Live MQM
Tanzeel says: December 10th, 2009 at 19:33 As far as Altafs arrival in country is concerned, hes simply not allowed by the party followers because of the insecure countrys environment.
Question regarding why party is still strengthened and masses still follow him religiously thats because of MQMs Work and manifesto. MQM is the only organized political party of Pakistan and its leader is connected with every single worker.
Arsalan Kh says: December 10th, 2009 at 19:15 Nice article, I believe on each and every issue, MQM has taken a bold stance. Whether its Talibanization, Swat deal, NRO etc. No buddy can deny that MQM doesnt represent the lower middle class masses of Sindh infact now the whole Pakistan. The way, they have been working despite of facing heavy criticism and opponents who dont let them do the work some time but they dont stop their selves. They are working always for the people. I wish, MQM can grow in whole Pakistan and we would see some one working for Pakistan instead for their personal benefits.
Arsalan.
Pakistani says: December 10th, 2009 at 19:09 Well see after the NRO ruling who has really come of age.
Beautiful article Posted by Murtaza Razvi in Featured Articles Section of the Daily Dawn, Pakistan, Politics on 12 10th, 2009 | 161 responses
Of late, the Muttahida Qaumi Movement (MQM) is the only political party that has been making all the right noises on national issues, starting from its unequivocal condemnation of extremism to the considered stance on the controversial National Reconciliation Ordinance. The mourning day observed this week across urban Sindh on the call of the MQM for the victims of the Lahore Moon Market terrorist attacks was but a call for unity against a common enemy so opposed to the Pakistani majoritys way of life.
A transformation seems to be afoot in the partys maturing political orientation. It is fanning out of its stronghold of urban Sindh to reach out to the people everywhere, be it in Gilgit-Baltistan or the huge swathes of the middle class in Punjab. If it continues on this path of widening its public appeal by raising issues that affect the citizens in their everyday lives, the party can truly come of age and broaden its public appeal.
There is a growing awareness of the dreadful gap left in national politics by the PPP and the PML-N, the two largest parties, which seem only to retreat into their entrenched positions to the detriment of public interest and good governance. This gap needs to be filled by a third force seeking wider public support based on doing politics that reflects the peoples needs and aspirations.
It was in 1967 when such a gap between the ruling and the ruled first came to the fore in what was then West Pakistan: Zulfikar Ali Bhuttos Pakistan Peoples Party sought to bridge that gap by transforming the social contract, and with it the political lexicon. Lets not forget that Mr Bhutto, too, was groomed in the lap of the military establishment, but when his calling beckoned he rose to the occasion. His party became the voice of the silent majority that had not been heard. The Bhutto magic lingers to this day, though the spell cast by the party has considerably weakened as it was diluted over time in the hurly burly that characterised the partys every stint in power.
If the MQM can succeed in widening its public appeal on issue-based politics today, it could rekindle the hope for better governance than we have seen in the past many decades. The party can do it because it has, over the past seven years, acquired the wherewithal for such a role. It has been a ruling coalition partner at the centre and in Sindh, besides having effectively run city district governments in urban Sindh. This has helped the party break out of the ghetto mentality which went into its genesis.
A new sensibility, coupled with responsibility and the subtleties of being on the other side of the fence that is, on the ruling side while continuing to voice the concerns of the underdog, is just the right mix that a party claiming to represent the middle class needs. Despite many misgivings that exist against the MQM today, and for which the party too has to foot some blame, the people are so desperate right now that they would be willing to give the MQM a chance to deliver where all others have failed. And on the delivery front, the party is standing on firm ground given the good job it has done in Karachi over the past few years.
But even before that, the political vacuum that has existed for over two decades now is one that has left many middle-class people detached from politics. The people are just waiting to give anyone a chance having an agenda that resonates with their own wishes, as in hoping against hope. It should be recalled that under the devolution of power plan promulgated by General Musharraf in 2001, the MQM was able to secure over 100 nazims slots in Punjab alone.
This was because there was a big disconnect between the Muslim League headed by the Sharifs, who had been thrown out of power in the 1999 coup, and the peoples expectations of a representative government. But later it was the Muslim League of the Chaudhries that became Musharrafs new surrogate. The ruling cliques feudal mindset and the MQMs pro-establishment stance at the time culminating in the mayhem of May 12, 2007, in Karachi, when the then defunct chief justice was not allowed to enter the city hurt the MQMs popularity in Punjab.
However, the people of Punjab have a short memory; if the post-1970 election results are anything to go by, they, more than Pakistanis elsewhere, have voted across party lines. This makes the electorate there a potent force, one that can be won over provided your politics remains relevant to popular sentiment which, in turn, a party committed to its convictions can steer in the right direction. Isnt that what democracy is all about?
Consider, for instance, the MQMs popular demand to continue the local government system after making necessary changes to the laws that administer it, rather than scrapping the representative system at the grassroots level altogether. The stance resonates with public sentiment not only in Karachi but across the board.
At a recent conference held in the high security zone of Islamabad, some 500 supporters of the local government system, including many nazims from across the four provinces, braved the odds of reaching the capital to push the government for not derailing the local government system. The PPP and PML-Ns stance on the issue is highly controversial if not outright unpopular. It is seen by the people as an attempt to strengthen the provincial governments traditional, feudal-minded approach to amassing all power in their big-brotherly hand.
As for the MQMs position on local governments, it is this brick-by-brick laying of the social and political edifice from the ground up that can win the party wider public support. But a prerequisite for garnering a broad-based backing will have to be MQMs credentials as a political force that is inclusive and national in its appeal, as opposed to parochial or regional.
In the months ahead, if the MQM continues to throw its weight behind the right gut feel that can give way to a wider public consensus on a given issue, like on terrorism and the NRO, it can enjoy national leadership in a fairly good time.
Murtaza Razvi is the Editor, Magazines, at Dawn.
The following reader comments do not necessarily reflect the views and policies of the Dawn Media Group.
161 Comments
Tanzeel says: December 12th, 2009 at 17:26 Altaf doesnt need MQM, its MQM that needs Altaf.
Slashing Altaf from MQM and suggesting Mustafa Kamal or Sattar instead would be unfair, you need to understand that running a city or department is a different thing than running a party. Infact you people should praise Altaf for picking a gem out of nowhere and made him work like that.
I wonder why at time we become so selfish and limit our thinking to short term only.
Tomorrow someone else would come and do more than Kamal you guys would start suggesting his name for party leadership. Not a sane approach I would say.
Tanzeel says: December 12th, 2009 at 17:11 Reason for not being popular through out Pakistan is the restrictions agencies had put on MQM. If you remember the military operations against MQM in a bid to break party structure you would not call MQM a single province party.
Now nation is witnessing true face of MQM. All image building and wonders MQM has done in Karachi and stances they have taken in assemblies are under the leadership of Altaf which are being appreciated nationwide.
One should understand that Farooq Sattar, Mustafa Kamal or any MQM representative is working under Altafs leadership. MQM wont have been the third largest party of Pakistan had Altaf not led MQM.
I would also like to clarify that expenses incurred by Intl Secretariat and over all party funding take places through MQMs-fund contributed by its party members by allocating certain percentage of their monthly income.
ark abbot says: December 12th, 2009 at 16:36 Come on give us a break! MQM the party behind the 12th may carnage and responsible for spreading terror in Karachi city is today being given the credit of going against terrorism.
Action speaks louder than words.
Natasha says: December 12th, 2009 at 16:05 It is important to be aware of todays politics instead of HISTORY.
Im not calling MQM unbiased.Im talking about the critics.
Natasha says: December 12th, 2009 at 15:52 Ali,
And since your comparing the man with the Shareefs , kindly let me know what does he do for a living.
jk says: December 12th, 2009 at 12:32 Absolutely right again naveed, the MQM is only party, who has condemned terrorism and extremists. It has become a brave and visionary party, with the thoughts of the masses on its mind.
Other parties have same rhetoric and why no other leaders brave enough to condemn terrorism?
Naved Haider says: December 12th, 2009 at 10:36 In case some one is determined to oppose MQM, its not difficult to find faults and reject it. Most of the MQM critics are living 1980s and 90s, they are not able see a positive change in the party in the last decade.
For me two reasons are enough to support the party.
1- MQMs commitment to root out religious extremism from Pakistan and their loud and clear stance on this matter.
2- MQMs performance in the development work of Karachi in the recent past.
I am least bothered why Altaf Hussain is living in England & and from where he is getting funds to run the party.
Syed Ali says: December 12th, 2009 at 10:17 The people of Pakistan are sick of the two big political parties namely PPP and Muslim Nawaz group, the blogger has mentioned all the pros and cons of MQM, I believe if there is any leadership to be trusted in coming days that would be only MQM, they are not industrialists, bureaucrats neither tycoons, but they have showed in Karachi and Hyderabad, they are the worker of Peoples of Pakistan.
MQM has shown it leadership by taking stance on the three very sensitive national issues NRO, terrorism and military action in swat and South Waziristan. The only party who came out on the street against terrorism and Taliban is MQM. They are the only one who is behaving as a true national and mature political party.
MQM is truly a party of the poor and downtrodden people of Pakistan. All MQM need is cautious and sensible political moves. The future is waiting for them. My suggestion is to keep the accountability process within the party and very soon we will see MQM as a national party on the horizon of Pakistani Politics.
Kabeer Faruqui says: December 12th, 2009 at 10:02 Every political party in the world get funds through donations from Business houses, private firms/companies, members and sympathizers and MQM is no different in this regard. When people put such questions only for MQM, it clearly indicates the biased approach towards the party.
aLi says: December 12th, 2009 at 10:02 Natasha and Malik,
Thank you,
ALi
Saad says: December 12th, 2009 at 9:56 It seriously hurts me how can someone write a favoring article for MQM.
They always tried to make a state into a state.
hasjams says: December 12th, 2009 at 9:49 Well, apart from some of the bitter facts mentioned above regarding MQM and the leadership, it becomes an undeniable fact that MQM has made a turn around in terms of its vision and tolerance.
Secondly, there is a well known saying actions speak louder then words so the kind of development we had seen for last few years is matchless to the previous ones.
Last but not the least, what other option the natives of Karachi have besides MQM; I think no one.
So Jamal says: December 12th, 2009 at 4:27 MQM will never come to age until it transitions from a mafia style to democratic norms. Can the party make any decisions with the great Bhai. Is there any succession mechanism in place? Are office holders elected to their roles by inside votes or just selected by Bhai?
ABG says: December 12th, 2009 at 3:15 At least this party has the most literates than any other party in Pakistan.
There are always bad eggs in every party but the weight age of such eggs in MQM is low.
Guys: Were almost on the verge of extinction. Lets get united. We cant afford any divisions anymore. Get good education, provide good education and rise as one great/developed nation, and rise as one voice! Thats all we need
jK says: December 12th, 2009 at 2:07 Some interesting points made by all. But the bottom line is this MQM deserve the chance, people are sick and tired of other parties like PPP and of Sharif party. Lets try some change and these days what you hear coming from the MQM camp makes a lot of sense. The condemnation of terrorism, the importance of local governance, etc.
Yes it would help the MQM cause now for Altaf Hussein to go back to Pakistan and yes it would be unifying for the party to have the Pakistani flag as their party flag. How ever the bottom line is we need change.
The party has its faults but I think is the best bet at the moment and believe me if I can see the virtues of the MQM in the current climate, Im sure others can as Well.
Tanzeel says: December 12th, 2009 at 2:06 And those who want Altafs removal from MQM leadership should go back and read some history books to know how much struggle he has done for the party. Its so easy to demand his removal just because couple of teenagers dont like him but there should be some sense behind passing such statements.
Altaf is the founder of MQM and he will remain so forever. Just the way we cant take away Jinnahs status of Quaid from Pakistan, we cannot remove Altaf from MQM chairmanship.
MQM works on professional lines, Altaf doesnt do micromanagement like other party leaders. MQM has a management hierarchy and all party workers including its leader follow it.
Zafar Hussain says: December 12th, 2009 at 1:50 MQM has potential to be a national party provided it leaves Altaf Hussain, introduces internal party democracy, disband armed mafia type activities, and etc.
saifullah says: December 12th, 2009 at 1:20 Can MQM shun its ethnic base, and can it stop treating Mr. Altaf hussain as savior and treat him as a human being. Thus, letting party decision making done through an institutional process and not on the decisions of Mr. Hussain (single man cannot hold all the wisdom). Let the Rabta committee to be a decision-making forum.
Citizens want political parties to practice democracy within their parties.
Sayyid Shamsi says: December 12th, 2009 at 1:11 As I read the 116 comments over this article. Some of the people raised this question Why Altaf hussain is sitting in Uk and running his party from uk. I will not go in detail but I will ask the question to those who raised this question. Why Mr. Zardari is sitting in President House, Nawaz sharif he is sitting in Rewand with a lots of security. What happened to the Pakistan Most secure place which is GHQ. I think you will find the answer. About Altaf hussain will he several time ask this thing to his party workers to come back to Pakistan. Do you think what party workers said? We need your guidance without your physical presence at this current situation. MQM party workers and leader have a very close relationship. Here in MQM most of issues decided by Rabita committee. About Party fund I can assure you MQM is not lotting Pakistani nation money as other parties did. We dont have any bank accounts in Switzerland. Party fund is generated by MQM workers where they contribute from their salary a reasonable amount every month and as every knows how many MQM workers all over the Pakistan. Guess 10,000 worker * 50 Rest = 500000 this is just an example. Thats called unity among the party and relationship.
Farooque Ali says: December 12th, 2009 at 1:00 Everyone has right to say, because we all are living in independent state.
One thing I would like to say that a person who is living in the Non-Muslim State and governing from there and giving the orders from there, then how is it possible that they are patriot?
Why dont MQM change its main office from London to any Muslim State?
They believe on Non-Muslim rather than Muslims!!
ali hassan says: December 12th, 2009 at 0:57 Despite my disliking for MQM in past years due to its mysterious activities, I have come to like the way it has raised voice on important national issues.
I think MQM can be an alternative.
Sayyid Shamsi says: December 12th, 2009 at 0:39 A very good analysis by writer. Yes MQM is gaining the public support all over the country and as a Pakistani nation we have to give chance to MQM and bring MQM in National politics. Although they did some wrong decision in the past but the current situation MQM is showing mature politics which is people politics. In my personal opinion although I am from Punjab we have to welcome MQM and see how they can do more for Pakistan as they did in Karachi, Hyderabad without the support of Federal Government and Establishment. I have a hope that MQM can change the system of Pakistan and bring Pakistan as an independent state where people can enjoy with full rights with no discrimination over sex, religion, cast etc.
Watan Dost says: December 11th, 2009 at 23:29 Answer:
Altaf Hussain does not come to Pakistan because the people who assassinated Liaqat Ali Khan & Benazir are still around.
Tanzeel says: December 11th, 2009 at 23:14 MQMs funding take place through a systematic procedure involving internal audit. The party has established a fund call MQF (Muttahida Qaumi Fund) where party workers allocate 1% of their income to MQM. KKF(Khidmat-e-Khalak foundation) also utilizes the same sort of funding, though they earn through charity as well.
Sindhi says: December 11th, 2009 at 23:09 After reading the comments I can pick out two things from those who are against MQM :
1) Altaf Hussain lives in London.
2) MQM terrorizes its people It is a ethnic party.
Hmmm, if MQM terrorized its people, why would it be fastest growing party in Pakistan? Why would it receive accolades from many in Karachi and Hyderabad? Do you think most of the people in Karachi and Hyderabad are racist, anti-Pakistani and dumb? Lately, media is not giving anyone any room to breathe, they pounce on anyone who seems to not have their act straight. So why are their accolades from Lahore based media personalities and columnist for MQM?
Altaf is never going to be Pm President Mayor Parliamentarian. He is going to remain figure head so him being here or in London is irrelevant. Look at others in the party who are so apt to do this task like Haider Abbas Rizvi and Dr. Farooq Sattar. As a Sindhi I can tell you this much, next time I vote, it will be for MQM.
Rauf says: December 11th, 2009 at 22:40 @Natasha
Because they are rational. When you are rational you tend to be less biased
MQM Less biased? Are you sure about that Natasha? If I remember correctly, there were few MQM supporters waving the MQM flag in the stadium during cricket match 2009 Pak/Aus match (in South Africa). This was even reported on few cricket websites.
I Shahid says: December 11th, 2009 at 22:06 Barooq, rational people support MQM because irrational people like you are not open to any discussions and will not change their mind whatever evidence contrary to your opinion is brought up.
Ammar Baloch says: December 11th, 2009 at 22:04 Those who are asking question about MQM earning, probably they dont know well the supporters of MQM, Go to any MQM gathering, pick a bucket and collect money, you will get it fill in no times. Secondly, MQM is well supported by many of the eminent industrialists. But the most important thing unarguably is that they run the ministries quite well and none of the MQM minister involved in any corruption scandal.
Islam Shah says: December 11th, 2009 at 22:01 Belonging to middle class is not the yardstick of judging people. To be a middle class man does not mean to be Mr. clean. Rather middle class people are more prone to corruption and extremism. MQM leaders and workers accuses feudal and industrialists for current situations of the country but they forget that Pakistan was ruled for thirty years by army dictators who all belonged to middle class and who threw the country twice in wars with India, twice in wars of Afghanistan and encouraged extremism, factionalism and sectarianism. Most of our bureaucrats belong to middle class. Police personnel mostly belong to middle class. Are they honest?
Shahid says: December 11th, 2009 at 21:52 Mqm has made many mistakes in the past but it has to be seen in the context of survival. Their were powers/elements which tried every thing to prevent MQM take off the ground because their own interest was threatened. In any case MQM has traveled a long journey since their inception in eighties and nineties and has now matured into a true national political party. One thing to remember is that it always had the support of people inspite of all the allegations and propaganda against them. I believe we ought to give them a chance on national scale to challange them and test their potentials.
.
Soomro says: December 11th, 2009 at 21:27 MQM and Imran Khan are the only two entities who have some idea about how to save Pakistan. I think if they leave their anger for each other and form a coalition they both will be very successful. MQM can do well in whole Pakistan (not only Karachi) if and only if they leave their violent ways. I hope and pray that day will come soon. If their reputation changes I dont think any party will stand in their way to come in power. Only then we can have a PM from MQM.
Sarwar Shah says: December 11th, 2009 at 21:26 Yes MQM is a true representative of working class of the Pakistan, All people (98%) belonging to middle class should stride hard to up bring MQM.
zainab says: December 11th, 2009 at 21:22 I would suggest that MQM should be merged in PML Quaid-e-azam group to please the soul of Jinnah and to join the main stream. This party will never be acceptable to people of other places of Pakistan except Karachi with the brand names of MQM and Altaf hussain. I further suggest if the merger with PLMQ is not viable, at least its name and leadership should be changed. Then I hope people will forget and forgive its past.
Nasir Habib says: December 11th, 2009 at 20:47 @ Natasha, MQM has a very big donor base in Karachi. I still remember standing in lines with my parents to donate.
How many city nazims were/ are living in rented houses? Mustafa Kamal still does.
Mr. Altaf can not be taken seriously. MQM is a party that goes with the flow.
Rehan says: December 11th, 2009 at 19:47 Regardless of what is said by the detractors, the MQM of 2010 is not the MQM of 1999. It is a middle class party that is focused on social justice and moderation. This it self is a tremendous hope for our nation. Nobody here is going to shed any tears for Mr. Altaf Hussain, we all dislike him, even MQM members, but you play the game that you have to play.
If our brothers in Punjab ever get past their prejudices, they would find the MQM to be a very good platform that shares their ideals.
manjhi khan says: December 11th, 2009 at 18:48 Dear writer,
MQM may have done good works but only in Urdu speakers areas, it is unfortunate that genetically biased Urdu media has been projecting MQM as only good thing that has happened in land of pure Urdu media doesnt show the Sindhi colonies which under the city government are facing all hell and bias. If its party of middle class how its leader is managing huge mansion in London?
Barooq says: December 11th, 2009 at 18:17 Natasha
I made a case of rationality before asking how come rational people think what they think.
And simply put, supporting MQM is supporting Altaf Hussain.
Which rational mind would support a crying and screaming drama queen of a leader.
Natasha says: December 11th, 2009 at 17:58 Jamil,
Brian says: December 11th, 2009 at 17:16 Spot on Mr. Rizvi, the MQM has certainly proved itself this time around. The MQM represents the Middle Class therefore I believe it is the only party which can unify the nation.
One suggestion for my MQM brothers; lets do away with the current Flag, let the PAKISTAN FLAG represent the MQM; I am sure it will work wonders in unifying the nation.
Until or unless the multicolored flags are banished, our nation can never unite.
Common MQM, lets unite the nation with the Green and White.
Natasha says: December 11th, 2009 at 17:14 //It pains me to see rational people supporting MQM and I would love to see why?//
Because they are rational. When you are rational you tend to be less biased. We need to be more flexible. MQM is as bad as any other party. They have shown improvement over the years. Lets just have the guts to appreciate what is good and condemn what is wrong without being prejudiced. MQM has done wonders for Karachi. They are not angels but are definitely turning out to be a good party. Their hypocrisy aside, they have played a positive role in some important issues.
Natasha says: December 11th, 2009 at 17:10 //MQM is democratic?
Thats a joke right?
There is one entity in MQM. I remember when people tried to break away from Altaf, the violence that followed.
I mean seriously? People here are delusional.//
-
MQM is not democratic just like any other party. PMLQ cant think beyond Chaudhrys, PMLN is nothing without Shareefs and our darling PPP has always been the property of the Bhuttos and now the Zardaris cum Bhuttos. Theres no point in singling out MQM .They are no different.
P.S. I am in favor of MQM changing its leadership. They need an awami leader not some someone saving his life in England talking dramatically about his agony over the sufferings of people here every other day.
Natasha says: December 11th, 2009 at 17:05 Well- written article. I agree with most of the things mentioned. I would like to add that Altafs removal as the partys supreme commander would help improve the image of the party especially in Punjab but unfortunately MQMs not willing to take any such step for the sake of the country. If not his removal, his return to the country would help improve the partys image. People at large are irritated by his telephonic addresses. Hes perceived as a dramay baaz by the masses. He should prove his patriotism by coming back ignoring all the security concerns like other leaders. It is easy to express pain for the awam while sitting abroad. Come and serve them here. There life is as precious as yours.
saad ahmed says: December 11th, 2009 at 17:01 MQM could be better option in the coming days they have demonstrated good governance in Karachi and Hyderabad. Mustafa Kamal, mayor of Karachi has done tremendous job and made significant changes in short tenure of 4 years. Last month He was invited by Harvard University and Columbia university of New York to deliver lecture. I wonder how many of our politicians might be invited or capable of delivering lecture in top notch educational institutions.
Secondly, it is the beauty of MQM to give tickets to ordinary people from middle class. Mustafa Kamal himself was an ordinary MQM activist. And now they are trying to come in to mainstream politics to wash the stain of ethnic party. Having seat in Gilgit, I believe MQM might be good option for us.
As salam o Alikum
Shahab Uddin Ahmed says: December 11th, 2009 at 16:56 Indeed an article of substance and a true reflection of public opinion. MQM has shown maturity which reflects from the historic decisions it took through this decade.
In my opinion MQM in the past was never given a fair chance to prove its worth. In the past decade or so MQM was allowed to play its role in national politics, the result has been very encouraging.
MQM is the only political party which comes from the 98% unprivileged class of Pakistan. No one better then them can understand the plights of the downtrodden and I totally agree with the writer when he says, If the MQM can succeed in widening its public appeal on issue-based politics today, it could rekindle the hope for better governance than we have seen in the past many decades. The CDGK in Karachi and Hyderabad has released equal funds to all the towns irrespective of political affiliations which not only shows justice but also shows commitment to their just cause.
My praise to MQM for coming up to the expectations of their voters and pray to almighty Allah for their success to save this country and image in the world as a progressive and peaceful nation.
Zamarrud khan says: December 11th, 2009 at 16:27 One wonders some TV channels are projecting MQM to the best of their efforts. Dont know the consideration whether it is money or terror.
Jamil Niazi says: December 11th, 2009 at 16:12 MQM was first supporting NRO and had even assured PPP to pass it through parliament but after sensing medias reaction to the NRO when presented in Parliament MQM took a somersault and started portraying itself as an enemy of NRO from day one.
Ammar A. Qureshi says: December 11th, 2009 at 15:52 A youth revolution is what can save Pakistan. All these feudalistic and thug parties are playing power-game.
Ammar A. Qureshi says: December 11th, 2009 at 15:50 We have become such a desperate nation that we just could not differ between real concern of having peoples best interests at heart and a fake one just to win peoples heart for getting them to vote. Tell me why should we settle for the best of the worst? Why shouldnt we get best of the best in our assemblies? Most of the karachites are afraid of MQM as we experience its fascism in everyday life. It is fascism behind the veil of democracy.
Mudassir Hussain says: December 11th, 2009 at 15:49 I am really appalled after reading a comment by one MR who still thinks that MQM stands for Muhajir Qaumi Movement.
Most of the people who are commenting about MQMs atrocities and terror would not have seen it from their own eyes!! It is just word of mouth but on the other hand. I am not advocating that only all the right things have been done till now.
We need to keep in mind that MQM originated and is existing in Pakistan. Where a lot of things had gone by under the name of politics and political parties!!
If they have realized and are mending their ways, then wait and see what happens instead of beating our backs!
Barooq says: December 11th, 2009 at 15:41 MQM is democratic?
Imran Khan a failed politician?
I guess he is a failed politician because he did not become Musharrafs ilk like Altaf bhai did for 8 years. Atleast Imran Khan LIVES in Pakistan and knows whats going on instead of screaming into a phone every few days from his London residence.
Furqan says: December 11th, 2009 at 14:21 Any unbiased reader would have extracted the major problem of Pakistan from the public views I witnessed after the article. This is what we want to think, MQM may or may not be involved in the thing you talking about but what now. The only party which is practically doing some thing. The promises made by other parties is only followed by MQM to implement on ground. Think again and Think twice.
GHAZAN KHAN says: December 11th, 2009 at 14:07 Isnt it good if some one is changing himself for the better? MQM is such one.
For other political parties I can say they going from bad to worse. I shall be pleased if other parties also adopt MQM policies and take interest in common mans issues, adopt a clear policy against terrorism, religious extremism and mullahism. BRAVO
Irfan Rizvi says: December 11th, 2009 at 14:06 MQM political polices and agenda has evolved over the time and are the only party in our country that has done so and are not based on slogans such as Roti Kapra & Makaan for last 40 years. Although they used ethnicity to establish themselves but I think that is the only way to go in this country as people consider themselves Punjabi, Pathan, Sindhi, Maharjir, Balochi first and Pakistani afterwards. They still have a lot to do in order to improve their image as their history of 90s is not hidden to anyone and they have a leader sitting in UK who declines to return to the country. But its good to give the credit where its due and the writer should be applauded for that. MQMs recent politics has started a trend of issue based politics which only MQM & PTI are doing, and should be followed by all the other parties
Barooq says: December 11th, 2009 at 13:47 And how easily you forgot to mention MQMs relentless support of Musharraf, the carnage of May 12th, and how the middle class Altaf Hussain, without a job is living in UK and refuses to return?
Few private news channels have been on MQM bandwagon for quite a while and its a shame that people working for Newspapers are doing that too.
Why dont you just You tube Mr.Altaf and just try to sit through his 10 minute address? The guy is a actor. He shouts and screams and cries and one of the biggest drama queens of all time. And nobody actually can make fun of him on mainstream media. Can you tell me why?
You want to talk about how good MQM has been, you can. But do you actually think it would change the perception of people like me who have seen what they have done?
Aamnah Khan says: December 11th, 2009 at 13:27 Mustafa Kamals work is indeed commendable when you drive all over the city and the way MQM is spreading its wings is exemplary but not much because the armed political phenomena based in the very core of this popular party is the most alarming factor which I am very against, in any unwanted case MQMs leadership wants to use it they use it and we face strikes and horrors all over the city. Their way of armed politics is unexpected and inevitable whenever they intend to force it. If thats also a part of politics I am not ready to second the opinion of the author.
.
MQM is a progressing party and it should set firm rules in areas where people like me are questioning its credibility.
Barooq says: December 11th, 2009 at 13:14 I dont want to be governed by a leader who cries every three days on telephone. And screams.
And it was not morally because of MQM but others political parties who every time after coming into power tried to knock MQM down which eventually resulted in problems.
While commenting on the darker sides of MQM during past 2 decades it would be fair if we also keep in mind the atrocities and tough situation, citizens of Karachi and Hyderabad had to face Qasba Colony, Aligarh Colony, Pakka Qilla are few places/events.
I will also endorse the view of Reality Bites regarding the absent leadership. That is an important aspect missing from MQMs operational capabilities here in Pakistan. But reasons given by others in this regard are also very obvious.
A lot of expectations have been tied around MQM now. They need to struggle even harder to live up to it.
Omar Khattab says: December 11th, 2009 at 11:42 Observer in his/her comments says, Anyone who has lived in Karachi from 1985 1995 and watched the political scene would be a witness to their dark sides.
I am a living witness to their dark sides.
gholam says: December 11th, 2009 at 11:37 Thats true. But I think MQM of 1990s is long gone and they have transformed from a regional ethnic party to a mainstream party with nationalist, moderate and development minded anti feudal, strong anti terrorist agenda, They have done very well in Karachi and Hyderabad and I feel they must work hard to enlarge their constituency not through mere slogan, but through action in all the Provinces of this great Nation. God bless Pakistan. May we shine and stand strong and united. Ameen.
Regards from Peshawar
Observer says: December 11th, 2009 at 10:54 Good piece of writing and I respect the authors point of views. I dont have confidence on a party whose leadership literally prides in being a foreign national, and standing away from the masses and the country. They perceive to represent. Hippocratic kind off right?
The party may have potential but the leadership needs to change in order to improve the partys brand image. Anyone who has lived in Karachi from 1985 1995 and watched the political scene would be a witness to their dark sides.
Hassan says: December 11th, 2009 at 10:52 Well I wish that what the writer has said about MQM turns into truth. MQM needs to turn into such a party rather than a party that relies more on street power. Yes if they do get rid of such things and show more political maturity they sure can be a good political force which can gain better respect. A writer here is saying they have no corruption records and maybe they do have some terror and horrible allegations such as torture and rape but I wont go into that, I would just tell you one thing yes there are good people in MQM and there are very few in other parties but MQM is not having clean hands either. Corruption has become an integral part of our society whether political parties or other govt. officials etc.
Umair Majeed says: December 11th, 2009 at 10:40 MQM has taken right steps in connection with terrorism. This shows their good will for Pakistan. If we work on Altaf Bhaia strategy against terrorism we will surly be getting rid of it. Every individual should protect Pakistan.
Ghazanfar says: December 11th, 2009 at 10:15 Finally people of Pakistan are realizing the fact that they are being ruled by feudals for 62 years. MQM is the only political force with no such background. Time is up for change in Pakistan and we are waiting to see that.
razak says: December 11th, 2009 at 10:13 Indeed MQM is the reality in politics who always won the side of ruling party, but compare with other two largest parties like PPP & PML-N is still not justified by the work and attitudes of MQM.
I would say that this is the only party who exist in few areas of urban Karachi, there is no such presence of MQM is rural areas of Sindh.
kamal khan says: December 11th, 2009 at 10:09 I completely agree with the writer. However, I would like to clarify the understandings of Reality Bites that Pakistan is country where prediction can be made about the unpredictable. Reality Bites should be aware of the fact that Mir Murtaza Bhutto, Bughti and many like others were killed in day light. Especially Mir Sahab was killed when his sister was sitting prime minister. How come Mr. Altaf Hussain will be spared?
Danish Khan says: December 11th, 2009 at 10:07 Ill vote for Mustafa Kamal for PM any day. Hats of to Altaf Hussains leadership skills and yes they are true representatives for middle class Pakistan and they also care about Pakistan Alot. By the way this is the only party which is also well organized in Pakistan.
Badar says: December 11th, 2009 at 10:03 There are pros and cons with MQM like any other party.
Shairani says: December 11th, 2009 at 9:45 @ Reality bites, doesnt the assassination of Shaheed Benazir Bhutto answer your question?
Sajjad says: December 11th, 2009 at 9:33 This is the only political party in Pakistan now, which talks about social changes. Many political pundits only talks, MQM delivers the benefits of middle class governance to 98% of Pakistan, Development of Karachi is a proof of it. Hopefully 1 day MQM can have Prime Minister from the party, that day will start a new era in Pakistan history Inshallah, Good, clean, authoritative Governance to eliminate, terrorism, making Pakistan more secure and economically sound. Internationally MQM definitely has a better face then any other Corrupt or plunder parties, and in long-term people of other provinces will realize the ideologies of party is as simple as to deliver which no other claims or take pride off. Writer has put the facts in place, Mash Allah Karachi is more secure then any other Pakistan city, it surely is due to Strong opposition of MQM, hats off MQM, may we see MQM leaders back safely to Pakistan and lead the party to spread the message of new era to all over Pakistan.
Zarghun says: December 11th, 2009 at 9:19 MQM has two faces. One is extremely good which has been discussed in the blog and the other face which it has been hiding for the last two years is too ugly to be watched. But I would appreciate if MQM has got rid of that fascist character of it.
MK says: December 11th, 2009 at 9:18 MQM still has to go quiet a far way, show maturity and further cleanse its cadre from hoolum but you are right, Thanks to Mustafa Kamal, Haider Abbas Rizvi and Khush Bakht Shujaat are faces people will like to listen and see more.
Let us hope and monitor, this is perhaps the last hope.
AHK says: December 11th, 2009 at 8:40 I think this article is nothing but scary. The writer does have a point there when he says there is a vacuum left open by PPP and PML types. If that vacuum if filled by MQM than I must say good bye Pakistan.
Shahzad says: December 11th, 2009 at 7:42 I am very pleased to read this blog. Every political party has its misfortunes and shady sides its the axiom of politics. However, where other parties have failed miserably, MQM has truly delivered not only in the development sector but also at multiple levels in Karachi, especially healthcare and education. For that I commend our honorary mayor Mustafa Kamal, as well as Altaf bhai for being the true leader of MQM. As long as a party delivers, all the talks in my opinion about where the leader is, is useless and will not impact any common man daily life chores.
Good luck MQM
tmf says: December 11th, 2009 at 7:23 I like how you play down the violence perpetuated by this party (and that it continues to do so in Karachi). You seem to be oblivious to the fact that this party sets the bar when it comes to violence in urban Pakistan.
Faisal says: December 11th, 2009 at 6:47 I totally agree with you, I think they are very progressive and party of educated people.
zafar Hussain says: December 11th, 2009 at 6:46 May be MQM is making right noises but it is not a democratic party. MQM must institute democracy and transparency in its party affairs, and only then it will able to represent people.
Alamsher K. Wzir says: December 11th, 2009 at 6:41 Noises MQM can make. The party is good at it. Every time noises are made, there is a motive behind it. How much more party can get from Zardaris govenment. 8 years MQM supported army dictator Musharraf. Now party is making right noises You must be joking.
Ali says: December 11th, 2009 at 6:40 I wonder, how can you make such comments about the very elements responsible for May 12 Massacre.
I am speechless!
Absar says: December 11th, 2009 at 6:04 MQM is yet another party like PPP or PML-N. I dont agree with the blogger.
There was an article in Dawn sometime back the title of which is The road to Punjab and author was Kunwar Idris. That article completely defines MQM being another ethnic party following the traditional demagoguery politics.
Blotting out ones hypocrisies under the development work in Karachi and raising voice against NRO doesnt warrant MQM as an all-good political party in Pakistan. Its perhaps the worst political party in the history of Pakistan with no principles; who believes in a leader living a peaceful life outside Pakistan while his countrymen are suffering for years. Imagine Khomani ruling Iran from Cuba, Gordon Brown ruling England from Thailand, Obama ruling US from Antarctica. I cant hold my laughs. MQM is one and only singular gift, for sure!
manawer hasan says: December 11th, 2009 at 6:00 I am still confused why people want to bring Altaf Hussain Back to Pakistan, if he is managing his stuff from England then their is no point in asking him to come back to Pakistan until and unless their is a peace and security in Pakistan. People forget that BB came to Pakistan and how brutally she was assassinated by their own country mens. In my opinion this is satellite age and you can run the country by living anywhere, its not compulsory to bring Leaders in Home country.
KBK says: December 11th, 2009 at 5:50 MQM observed mourning for Lahore victims, it was good thing but why they are not observing mourning for those who were killed and burnt alive by this group on May 12 and April 09 at Karachi. Were they not human being? Will MQM supporters have any reply?
02. On NRO first time President Zardari has done good job and released the list of beneficiaries of NRO which was sufficient proof that MQM was a corrupt organization as evident from cases.
khayal says: December 11th, 2009 at 5:45 Until MQM gets Non-Mohajir/Non-Karachite people in its ranks on prominent positions, it cant shed its ethnic image and get broader national support.
Syed K. Nawaz says: December 11th, 2009 at 5:26 I appreciate authors attempt to write such a unique piece of its own kind.
Brother Reality Bites may be you are right in your argument regarding a dream life of Quaid-e-Tehreek Altaf Hussain in London, but as a matter of fact its not 100% correct, as he is living a simple life and he is out there not on his own wish!
We the workers and Supporters of MQM consider it better to wait till any suitable time rather to Call him to the country and give a chance to any bad wisher to attempt any bad move against him.
We the Pakistani Nation needs a Great Leader like him, who truly can deliver to the People of Pakistan!
While writing these line, I have in my mind Mir Murtuza Bhutto, Ms. Benazir Bhutto, Hakeem Muhammad Saeed, Muhammad Salahuddin, Moulana Ludhyanvi, Saleem Qadri, Dr. Ghulam Murtuza Malik, Nawab Akbar Bugti, Azeem Ahmed Tariq, and thousand others who are not with us now!!!
I will appreciate your understanding in this regard bro!!!
Akil Akhtar says: December 11th, 2009 at 5:12 The problem with MQM is its roots are in its popular leaders are from a single city.
It will remain as Mohajir Qaumi Movement in our minds for a long time I guess. We do not want a lounge politician telling us from London what is good for us.
Ali says: December 11th, 2009 at 4:30 Sitting outside the country, it does seem to me as if MQM is currently making all the right moves as far as national issues go. However, I feel that it has not detached itself completely from its militant roots. I was hoping for a really changed MQM in the Musharraf era but the events of May 12 were an eye-opener that showed that militancy is still very much a part of the fabric of this party. I feel that this party needs much more time and maturity, and in all honesty some major overhaul of its leadership before it can claim national popularity.
ken says: December 11th, 2009 at 4:15 MQM needs to remove Altaf bhai as their leader, Once Altaf bhai is out of picture then MQM will become the number one party.
Pakistan Zinda Abaad
TRUE FAN OF MQM says: December 11th, 2009 at 3:43 Had the MQM opportunities to explore with honesty back to decades, Sindh Prince would have had no problems and developed but unfortunately, MQM is the victim due to our own Pakistani greedy political leaders.
Shayan says: December 11th, 2009 at 3:01 Astonishing! Have you people already forgotten last years Pakhtun-Muhajir riots in Karachi or even May 12, 2007? Mr Razvi and those posting here may have extremely short memories but rest assured that the rest of Pakistan does not.
The landscape of Pakistani politics is clear for MQM since feudal dominated PML(N) and PPP have miserably failed to deliver any thing for the poor and downtrodden people of Pakistan. All MQM need is cautious and sensible political moves. The future is waiting for them. Who knows Mustafa Kamal could be the future Prime Minister of Pakistan.
Watan dost says: December 11th, 2009 at 1:45 We have tried the ones who have traded the blood sweat & tears of our nation for
62 years. MQM should team up with the middle class of Punjab and give our nation what we deserve. An educated leadership loyal to Pakistan. They need to reduce their militant image though. Mustafa Kamal is the leadership we need. All power to the people.
N. Mirza says: December 11th, 2009 at 1:43 It is about time that Pakistan should leave its feudal past behind. We are 170-200 million citizens on the mercy of few landlords, oligarchs, and mullahs.
Long live the local governments and grassroots movements!
javed jadoon says: December 11th, 2009 at 1:39 It amazes me to see all the same people who runs the Pakistan are same faces comes again just with different party and agenda. All of or most of them are so corrupt that makes us sick. They are not afraid of god, or any thing.
We do need help from developed country to monitor our system and punish them who are hurting our country.
Thank you
Jadoon
desihungama says: December 11th, 2009 at 1:12 On a second note, Ill vote for MQM any day and twice on Sunday.
desihungama says: December 11th, 2009 at 1:10 The future belongs to the likes of Imran Khan and MQM.
Rizwan Nasar says: December 11th, 2009 at 0:35 Very interesting blog MQM has come off age! It had started on grass root level but I think its leadership had lost its ways. They have come back a cycle. It is the only political party today that has its roots in the people. It has taken them years but we see now there is a genuine leader in Mustafa Kamal who is concerned about the people and the city. I think it is time for MQM to become a force of change for Pakistan. As for the London leadership let them be there and do their lip service. We need a few more Mustafa Kamals to do the work in Pakistan and change it for the better. Let the revolution begin!
roshan zameer says: December 11th, 2009 at 0:23 Can any one answer who is paying for the comfortable living of MQM leadership in UK for over 17 years?
Nuzaira Azam says: December 10th, 2009 at 23:45 MQM Goes national!
After more than two decades diligent political work, Muttahida Qaumi Movement crossed the borders of a regional identity, and got onto main stream national political highway. It all happened when the party won a seat in the recent Gilgit-Baltistan Legislative Assemblys first-ever election.
Whether one agrees or not, the fact remains that MQM leader Altaf Hussain has led the party to the national level without any patronage or through political dynasty. The party has established a transparent political culture by tolerating political dissent, appreciating hard work and elevating the middle class people to decision-making positionsa phenomenon that is alien to Pakistans politics.
It is alleged that MQMthe only organized political party in the countryis more regimental than democratic and no party member dares to dissent with the supreme leader Altaf Hussain. However, many perceive it differently and believe that democracy means more responsibilities and to accomplish fundamental tenets and mechanics of democracy, strict rules and laws are indispensable.
There is a ray of hope, albeit a small one. Hussain, being a visionary leading a party that claims to be based on principles, could play a role in uniting other political forces and help establishing a somewhat more stable political system. It is about time to start a new beginning; the political parties should start organizing themselves and welcome new blood to empower the democracy, and to prevent running the political parties and politics as family businesses. They must unite together so no force dare to plunge them from the democratic path.
Nuzaira Azam
Washington, DC
N Karim says: December 10th, 2009 at 23:42 Dear Munib,
Why it is difficult for you to understand that Altaf is not coming to Pakistan. The assassination of Benazir Bhutoo is a good answer. In our country it is very hard to survive when you speak truth and make efforts for rights. I do not belong to MQM but surely suggest Mr. Altaf Hussain to remain in London to raise voice for the rights to 98% population of the people of Pakistan.
I salute the writer of article and very much agree with his opinion. One day MQM will be the ultimate voice of middle and lower middle class people of Pakistan.
umar tosheeb says: December 10th, 2009 at 23:32 MQM has great chance in Punjab especially after PPPs sure demise in the province. PPP has become intolerable and too controversial. I cant see it getting more than 10 seats in Punjab. If MQM stays out of controversial issues, it can pose a challenge for PML(N), but it will take time.
Remember Recent History says: December 10th, 2009 at 23:02 @Reality Bites
I think your concern is definitely legitimate, however Benazir was running her party from Dubai/London since 1999 in self exile (thats 9 years) and Nawaz Sharif was running his party from Saudi Arab for 9 years as well. I believe Altaf Hussein hasnt been in Pakistan since 1993-94?; give or take 13 years. If you are willing to discount 9 years for PPP and PML (N), then 13 shouldnt be a big issue for you for MQM.
I would assume that if MQM truly wants to become a national party though, it would need to have a complete change of guard at the top including Altaf Hussein.
Iqbal khan says: December 10th, 2009 at 22:59 This article is a reflection of peoples inspiration for a change in the political and power structure of the country. It is no doubt that peoples are looking to MQM for a change. MQM is able to change the feudal politic but the leadership must also put brake to the emerging party activists who are quickly establishing a new system of choudrys/voderas and Khans in the rural areas.
In the feudal system peoples are safe from their enemies so long they surrender their freedom to the khans.
Iqbal
Abbas Mastaan says: December 10th, 2009 at 22:44 that is, on the ruling side while continuing to voice the concerns of the underdog;
Strongly agree with the writer. The MQM has shown the right way to raise your concerns without derailing democracy lesson to be learnt for all other political forces of the country. Bravo MQM!!
Rahma says: December 10th, 2009 at 22:40 The MQM boycotted the 2001 local body elections.
mustafa says: December 10th, 2009 at 22:29 MQM is the true representative of poor and middle class citizens of Pakistan; if Altaf bhai is removed from this party. He is just like an army dictator for the party and people want democracy.
Canadian says: December 10th, 2009 at 21:51 The way they are working for past few years, I think they are far better than the options we got right now and they definitely deserve a chance to run the show.
Atta H khoso says: December 10th, 2009 at 21:41 MQM should never think for national issues because it has achieved no success over provincial issues as we know that the nation in SINDH province, since inception has denied MQMs existence and are not showing their soft corner to this nontraditional party and this unique attitude of Sindhi Nation is attributed to the uncomprehending policies of MQM. therefore, I will advice MQM leaders to show their proximity towards Sindh and then start worrying for other national issues.
Sajjad says: December 10th, 2009 at 21:39 MQM being anti-terrorist? This has to be the joke of the century. Noise-making, whether of the right type or the wrong type, has always been a hallmark of this party. Looking beyond the noise-making, you will find plenty of evidence of bad things they have done and the list goes on. I think people in the rest of Pakistan will do fine without this party in their areas.
Nicky says: December 10th, 2009 at 21:02 If the MQM comes to power in Pak then peace will prevail in the sub-continent.
Ambreen says: December 10th, 2009 at 20:40 I have never been a supporter of MQM. But after being disappointed repeatedly by the rest of the leadership I am willing to give them a chance. They are slowly proving themselves. The work in Karachi speaks for itself.
Ga says: December 10th, 2009 at 20:33 I just dont understand how a fascist party like the MQM can bring up the likes of Mustafa Kamal. Then again, to survive and to be respected as a political force in any country there has to be a militant streak. So despite the violent past I think MQM can have a good future considering it is not a party of feudal.
Atif says: December 10th, 2009 at 20:20 Very well done MQM is the only and last hope for all Pakistanis as it has the potential to deliver and has more literate and energetic people in it who can bring the change in Pakistan and also have the potential to fill the political gap as well. MQM have already shown it in Karachi and can prove it throughout Pakistan as well and to those who are saying the Altaf Bhai is sitting outside Altaf Bhai is sitting out side just because of his workers they dont want him to come to Pakistan and also he is not in comfort there he works day and night for the party and this is also a big reason of MQMs success and also another strong reason to support MQM is not a single case is registered against them of corruption anywhere in Pakistan. MQM is committed to deliver and MQMs stand on certain issues of Pakistan will also make MQM more powerful in Pakistan
Adnan says: December 10th, 2009 at 20:07 I agree with much of what the MQM stands for as far as their secular ethos is concerned. But how will they ever convince anyone outside of Karachi that they are anything other then an ethnic party which serves the interest of Karachites Urdu speaking? Are Punjabis going to be convinced that their interests will be served by such a party?! Seems unlikely.
Zafar Malik says: December 10th, 2009 at 20:03 I agree with the writer, there is a huge political vacuum in Pakistan, which needs to be filled and very soon, if country has to survive. Over the past six decades there have been huge demographic changes in Pakistan. A large, mostly urban based middle class has emerged and needs a political voice of its own. Power of traditional Zimindars, feudals, khans, sardars and bradaris has declined.
Now who will fill this vacuum, remains to be seen. MQM has a good chance, but overcoming the stigmas of its past will not be easy.
Abdul haleem says: December 10th, 2009 at 19:58 MQM past policies were wrong. Labeling them as ethnic party. But they are doing much better. They have to convince others people that what they will do what for common people of Pakistan. Common people are fed up with other parties and with Taliban.
Ansar says: December 10th, 2009 at 19:46 Long live Pakistan and Long Live MQM
Tanzeel says: December 10th, 2009 at 19:33 As far as Altafs arrival in country is concerned, hes simply not allowed by the party followers because of the insecure countrys environment.
Question regarding why party is still strengthened and masses still follow him religiously thats because of MQMs Work and manifesto. MQM is the only organized political party of Pakistan and its leader is connected with every single worker.
Arsalan Kh says: December 10th, 2009 at 19:15 Nice article, I believe on each and every issue, MQM has taken a bold stance. Whether its Talibanization, Swat deal, NRO etc. No buddy can deny that MQM doesnt represent the lower middle class masses of Sindh infact now the whole Pakistan. The way, they have been working despite of facing heavy criticism and opponents who dont let them do the work some time but they dont stop their selves. They are working always for the people. I wish, MQM can grow in whole Pakistan and we would see some one working for Pakistan instead for their personal benefits.
Arsalan.
Pakistani says: December 10th, 2009 at 19:09 Well see after the NRO ruling who has really come of age.
