Khan Sab
MPA (400+ posts)
- Featured Thumbs
- https://i.ytimg.com/vi/tPjdlCIoHF4/hqdefault.jpg
Maulana Tariq Jameel Addressing Need Of Time Issue Regarding Moon-Sighting Controversy & Youth Misco
- Thread starter Khan Sab
- Start date
Khan Sab
MPA (400+ posts)
Jesa k MTJ ne shuru men hi kaha k Ye Masail Ullama k Itefaq,Soch o Fiqr kerne R ek Dosre se Mashwara kerne se Hal ho sakte han.
Chand K bare men to meri Apni Raey ye ha k Sab Mil k Ikhate Chand Dekhen,Gawahiyan lene ka koi Ek Mayar banaen R Siasat na karen to ye masla hi khatam ho jaey ga. Its Simple Not So Complicated
Last edited:
LOL everyone talks the same thing. Nothing new. Where's the solution ?
Khan Sab
MPA (400+ posts)
Maulana ne Talqeen o Targheeb ker di ha Itefaq peda kerne ki baqi Ap apne Zehn pe Itna bojh na len, Solution nikalne wale nikal len ge Ager nikalna chahen to. Don't worry Ap bas Rozon ki tayari karen
LOL don't waste my time.
Zindabad4u
Senator (1k+ posts)
we are living 2017 we can check online the position on the moon and we see live streaming of the moon but we can't agree start of the moon ???
https://www.moonsighting.com/1438rmd.html
this web site will show you in which country you will see the moon with optical aid, or naked eye etc...
we are using very thing with science but not using science for moonsighting ??? why ???
clock,TV,Mobile,Laptop, Cars, motorbikes, Ship, Planes etc all using science and Internet ? why can't we use technology for moonsighting ?? why mullah like Tariq Jamil come with Questions not with answer ? everyone knows the questions.... umah is going toward botton bcoz all the mullahs just busy making money.
https://www.moonsighting.com/1438rmd.html
this web site will show you in which country you will see the moon with optical aid, or naked eye etc...
we are using very thing with science but not using science for moonsighting ??? why ???
clock,TV,Mobile,Laptop, Cars, motorbikes, Ship, Planes etc all using science and Internet ? why can't we use technology for moonsighting ?? why mullah like Tariq Jamil come with Questions not with answer ? everyone knows the questions.... umah is going toward botton bcoz all the mullahs just busy making money.
riz100blue
Voter (50+ posts)
Mainly Jamat people are overseas for ages and they are the main who create FITNA and now doing drama bazi to show that they are innocent and they have nothing to do with it...they are the one who create isolation in all overseas countrries....they use prado mobile and all other technologies and when it comes to Moon rather use technology, start narrating self made hadiths .....also these all maulana alim should stay in pakistan and feed poor kids and orphans rather spending millions on their Airtickets, Umra Hajj thats more important.
riz100blue
Voter (50+ posts)
Maulana Tariq Jameel himself use landcruisers and all techonoligies, also he should use moon technology, people are sitting on Moon and they cant see moon yet, if sighting moon is sunnah with naked eyes, then driving camels and livestock is all sunnah , they all must drive then....spend 40 days 4 months on camels and donkeys ....why not ....its allowed in pakistan
Khan Sab
MPA (400+ posts)
Ap logon ko koi Mullah Phobia ha kia? K jo bhi Mullah ho ga wo Science ka munkar hi hoga? Maulana ne Science ka inkar kia na Science k khilaf koi bat ki r Ap Science Science chilana shuru ho gaey ho. Maulana bhi yai keh rahe han k is Ikhtelaf ka solution nikalo R Isi bat ki request ki ha Ullama se k Apne Differences khatam karen r Ek page pe aen r is issue ko resolve karen, koi bhi solotion tab nikle ga jab Niyat Sai ho k ikhtelaf khatam kerna ha R ek mechanism bnana ha.
Yahi Ikhtelaf ha k Kuch Ullama sirf Moon Sighting pe rely kerte han r kuch Totally Science pe rely kerne ka kehte han R Sab k Apne Apne Followers han. Ab is Ka Solution Men ne bhi oper yai dia k sab Ikhate Moon Sighting bhi karen R ek Mechanism bhi bnaen jis men Science ki bhi help li jaey to dono taraf ki Raey pori ho jaey gi, Ye mujhe R Apko pata ha To Maulana ko bhi pata ha but is issue men Siasat,Badniyatee r Kam ilmi involve ha, Us k liye Maulana ne Thori si Targheeb di ha R ap log appreciate kerne k bajaey bila wajah Tanqeed pe Shuru ho gaey ho. Pehle Ikhtelaf Khatam kerne R Solution nikalne ki Niyat bane gi to Kisi Solution pe Ittefaq bhi ho jaey ga.
Is Article r Is Video Se kafi Help mil jaey gi
The conflict
A section of Islamic scholars believe that seeing the moon with the naked eye should be the criterion for declaring the start of a new month. A smaller section advocates that we can rely solely on the calculations, and there is no need to visually see the moon.
Without endorsing one view over the other, I will simply point out that as far as sighting the moon goes, we could acquire great deal of help from science.
We could use calculations and modern simulations for knowing where and when to look for the moon, how high it will be in the sky, and what are the chances of its visibility. It is now possible to calculate the exact window of the moon’s visibility after sunset and even generate simulated images of the moon beforehand.
The official and unofficial moon sighting committees ask people to testify if they have seen the moon. This is where these simulated images can be use: anyone who claims to have seen the moon can be asked questions like what time they saw it, how high it was, whether it was near or close to the sun, whether the cusps were upward or sideways, whether it was on the left side or right side of the moon, etc.
These questions are enough to filter out false claims of sighting.
This rejection is attributed to genuine misjudgment, which does not diminish the person’s uprightness and acceptability as a witness. Numerous renowned as well as recent and contemporary scholars support this view.
That is how the Central Ruet-i-Hilal Committee filters out testimonies, but the Masjid Qasim Ali Khan gives no value to these calculations, and relies solely on the piousness of a person as evidence of correct sighting.
Full Article : https://www.google.com.pk/amp/s/www.dawn.com/news/amp/1188758
Video :
Last edited:
