Debate between Fawad Chaudhry & Mufti Naeem on moon sighting

[Siasi Jasoos]

https://www.facebook.com/video.php?v=367922417154668

 

[insouciant]

Fawad's suggestion is right, but approach is wrong! He needs to make someone from majlis e shura as a stakeholder in the comittee too to ensure islamic conditionalities are met and mullahs dont get a chance to object!

 

[Iconoclast]

No need for a science committee and no need for royat e halal committee. Does the moon show up a day later in Pakistan? The whole issue is moronic. Start fasting along with the rest of the world when Ramadan is announced in Saudi Arabia.

 

[Dream Seller]

Dono parties aese baat kar rahi hein jese koee zaati issue...even this learned molvi possesses very threatening tone...kar k dekhao rather than saying let’s sit together and come up with the best outcome...

 

[Zinda_Rood]

مولوی کو سائنس اور ٹیکنالوجی نہیں چاہیے، مولوی کو جہالت چاہیے۔۔ مولوی کے پیٹ کا مسئلہ ہے۔۔۔​

 

[Khan125]

Ye FAWADEY gandey ka issue hi nhi.
Ministry of religious affairs agar madad mangey tb science ki ministry koi rae de sakti hey vo b technical log, ye dabbu saab nhi.

 

[Zinda_Rood]

مولوی چودہ سو سال پرانی جنگل سے نکلی ہوئی پتھر دور کی مخلوق ہے،آج کے دور میں مولوی ایلین لگتا ہے، مولوی چاہتا ہے اس کہ ساتھ باقی لوگ بھی جہالت کے سمندر میں ڈبکیاں لگاتے رہیں۔۔​

 

[Notpersonal]

Fawad 100% right

 

[Heisenberg007]

Fawad is 100% right here. Some of these moulvis (not all, but some of them) just want to stay relevant, and they will oppose every scientific help even at the cost of dividing the nation.

 

[Zubair Panwala]

Fawad has no powers to form any type of body in this matter

 

[Zubair Panwala]

Fawad is interfaring in other minstery. PM must take notice of this.

 

[Boota101]

With due respect, These Molvis declared Loud speaker Haraam, they said printing press was against Islam, they were against the Printing of Quran on printing press. These Molvis were of the view that TV was Haraam. Now they are always on TV. They said Telephone was Haraam. Now they use a phone made by Jews. They say it is Haraam to pray where there is a picture of anybody. Now they keep the notes in their pockets with the photos of Jeorge Washington and Jefferson and also they keep pounds in their pocket while praying which bears a photo of Queen without even Scarf.
Lastly in all over Pakistan why these molvis follow the NAMAZ CHART which shows time for the whole century. Why don’t they pray by guessing time from the shadow of the sun, which was actually the practice at the time of our PROPHET MOHAMMAD PBUH.
My dear molvis be a bit sensible.

 

[c'estmoi]

Gosh I hate such molvis

 

[Zubair Panwala]

Strange! Fawad don't know latest sciencètific luminar calenders areailable, then for what purpose he is forming a new body

 

[Zubair Panwala]

Misleading about Saudi Arabia, they are not following any type of luminar calendar for announcing the start of the new Islamic moñths

 

[Aslan]

Molvis will always object to any sensible solution be it minimum age for marriage,start of Ramadan or Eid.The government should come up with a registration system. No molvi should be able run any religious institution without a licence.To get a licence the molvis should have to pass a rigorous examination.

 

[Zubair Panwala]

It is an open secret that how much Fawad knows about both Islam and Science

 

[Urdu speaking]

Yaa Karachi ka molvi ghunda Javed Ahmed Ghamdi kee jotee ky barabar bhee nahi Hy....

 

[WatanDost]

رویت کا مطلب ہے دیکھنا .... اب اگر پورے ملک کا موسم ابر آلود ہو تو چاند نظر نہیں آئے گا
بیشک سائنس کے اعداد و شمار کے حساب سے موجود ہو بھی تو رویت چاند نہیں ہو گا اور شرعا
یہی طریقہ سنّت ہے ...... لہذا فواد صاحب اپنی آخرت تباہ نہ کریں کہ کروڑوں روزے آپ کے گلے
کا پھندا بن جائیں گے

 

[drkhan22]

Fawad is an extremist liberal. It os kot even few days and he has created another controvercy. Rooyat is prerequisite to start n f8nish Ramadhan. His interference is going to be disasterous. What a pathetic person to be in this position. Ghamidi is always an excuse for these liberals. Poor Ghamidi