رؤیت ہلال اور اسلامک کلینڈر - مفتی حنیف قریشی

mirror777

Senator (1k+ posts)
عید کب ہو گی رویت ہلال کمیٹی کے اعلان پر؟یا قمری کلینڈر کی تاریخ پر؟


فواد چوہدری کے جاہلانہ بیان پر مناظر اسلام مفتی حنیف قریشی صاحب کا زبردست تبصرہ۔۔۔۔۔شریعت کے مسئلے اب ٹیکنالوجی حل کرے کرے گی۔۔۔؟

جب اوقاتِ نماز کے لیے کلینڈر تیار ہوسکتا ہے، تو چاند دیکھنے کے لیے کیوں نہیں۔
اس وقت سب زیادہ زیرِ بحث آنے والا مسئلہ۔ ضرور دیکھیں اور دوسروں تک بھی اس ویڈیو کو پہنچائیں
 

nayapakistanzindabad

Senator (1k+ posts)
Officially saudia ke sath manawo .masla hi muk jayega. Dunya kahan se kahan phonch gayee hamare gadhe chand ke masla pe lar rahe hein. Yeh to shahadatein bhi apni marzi ke logoon se accept karte hein .yehi jahelayet hae !
 

socrates khan

Councller (250+ posts)
اونٹوں اور خچروں سے ٹیوٹا اور ہونڈا کا فاسٹ اینڈ فیوریس اجتہادی سفرکرتے ہوئے تو ملائیت کو جدیدت سے جپھی ڈالنے میں کوئی مضائقہ نہیں لیکن زندگی کی دیگر ضروریات کیلئے آسانی اور وقت سے ہم آہنگ ہونے سے ان کے ٹِڈّؤں میں مروڑ اٹھنے لگتے ہیں۔۔
 

Cape Kahloon

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
Yeh theek ha chand dekhna Afzal treen kam ha.
Leken ager chand apnay city main nazar na aay tu kesse dossray city sey chand dekhnay ke atlaha per Eid ke ja sakti ha.
Ab cleander sey agr Yeh atlaha mil jay chand
Talou hu geya ha tu pher ess ko man ker eid kernay main Keya problem ha?
 

knowledge88

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
I have a question. I hope someone could help me for the information.
When I saw the video at 1:47. I found a Hadees read by the Mufti that if the sky is cloudy on the night of 29th of the month then assume the month has 30 days.
What if people go out to sight the moon for Ramadan at the end of Shaban 29 days. What if it is cloudy and people assume the Shaban month has 30 days. Although moon did appear but could not be sighted because of the cloudy sky so people according to the Hadees did not follow the calendar and assumed the Shaban has 30 days.
Here is the problem. Now the Eid moon can be sighted after only 28 days because the month of Ramadan erroneously started one day late because of the cloudy sky.
So what should Muslims do then?
Should they celebrate the Eid after just 28 days of Ramadan? Doesn't that also mean people worshipped on the even nights instead of odd nights of the last ashra? Is it permissable to have a month of 28 days if the moon has been sighted ?
 
Last edited:

mirror777

Senator (1k+ posts)
I have a question. I hope someone could help me for the information.
When I saw the video at 1:47. I found a Hadees read by the Mufti that if the sky is cloudy on the night of 29th of the month then assume the month has 30 days.
What if people go out to sight the moon for Ramadan at the end of Shaban 29 days. What if it is cloudy and people assume the Shaban month has 30 days. Although moon did appear but could not be sighted because of the cloudy sky so people according to the Hadees did not follow the calendar and assumed the Shaban has 30 days.
Here is the problem. Now the Eid moon can be sighted after only 28 days because the month of Ramadan erroneously started one day late because of the cloudy sky.
So what should Muslims do then?
Should they celebrate the Eid after just 28 days of Ramadan? Doesn't that also mean people worshipped on the even nights instead of odd nights of the last ashra? Is it permissable to have a month of 28 days if the moon has been sighted ?
Two consecutive months can't come of 29 days.
This is the major flaw in a lunar calendar that if only Karachi people could watch at that day for 15 minutes only, and on that day there would be clouds in Karachi.Lunar calendar would declare it Eid, but its actually ramadan. In that way roza of 200 million people could be lost.
 
Last edited:

Dantheman

MPA (400+ posts)
اونٹوں اور خچروں سے ٹیوٹا اور ہونڈا کا فاسٹ اینڈ فیوریس اجتہادی سفرکرتے ہوئے تو ملائیت کو جدیدت سے جپھی ڈالنے میں کوئی مضائقہ نہیں لیکن زندگی کی دیگر ضروریات کیلئے آسانی اور وقت سے ہم آہنگ ہونے سے ان کے ٹِڈّؤں میں مروڑ اٹھنے لگتے ہیں۔۔
Beautifully summarized!!